10 ms·
I'm making what I would think to be an upper middle class salary and I can't afford a home in a modestly decent neighborhood in L.A. It seems to me that there
by colordrops 10y ago
I'm making what I would think to be an upper middle class salary and I can't afford a home in a modestly decent neighborhood in L.A. It seems to me that there is definitely a problem and I support loosening development restrictions.
It's not only restrictions though. Of the people I know who own property, many, if not the majority, own more than one property, some of them empty. I also know many remote Chinese that own a property in L.A. It's super frustrating.
- umanwizard 10y ago> afford a home Can you afford rent, though? Isn't a bit extreme to expect to be able to own property -- like some sort of medieval lord -- in a major city?
- alexbecker 10y agoIt didn't used to be. We should be asking why things seem to have regressed, shouldn't we?
- umanwizard 10y agoDidn't it? Were individuals ever commonly buying houses (EDIT: any property) in Manhattan, for example? I don't have any hard numbers, but I suspect LA simply having become more urban and desirable is a big part of it. It's certainly still possible to buy houses in suburban flyover country very cheaply.
- colordrops 10y agoNot a fair comparison. Manhattan is a very dense small area. More comparable to L.A. would be the greater NY metropolitan region.
- panzer_wyrm 10y agoPlease do not change the goalposts. You were talking about property not houses. Condos are property and are easier to obtain.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- beering 10y agoWouldn't rent and a monthly mortgage end up being about the same? The value provided by one unit of housing to its tenants should be about the same as the value to an owner living there, so an investor buying a unit shouldn't expect to reap huge returns relative to someone buying a unit with a X0-year mortgage, right? I think owning property would be much more expensive than renting in the case where the value is based on future appreciation, vs actual value that it provides as a living area. I admit I'm not an expert on real estate, so please explain to me whether this makes sense or not.
- sbov 10y agoIn the last housing bubble rents and mortgages disconnected pretty severely. My friends and I were renting a million dollar house in Los Gatos for just $2400/month. Not sure how things are nowadays though.
- linkregister 10y agoIn the overall Bay Area, rents are moving up with house prices. Median rent in Los Gatos is $5.5k per month.
- mythrwy 10y agoWell given the number of houses in a major city obviously SOMEONE is affording them. Unless they are all owned by a handful of people (not really what we are shooting for here I'd think). Point being, its not unreasonable at all to expect to be able to afford a home.
- colordrops 10y agoWhy would affording to purchase a property in a large diverse city like L.A. with a high salary be unreasonable? I really don't understand your stance.
- sjg007 10y agoIt should be.. basic subdivision would work but it's nimbys that prevent it.
- panzer_wyrm 10y agoNot at all. Renting with no road to purchase turns you into serf. Owning your dwelling is the most basic form a security a human needs. I own a condo that I rent and live renting in other part of my city. The rents cancel each other. It works very nice for me. I definitely wish more people own their homes. I also love highrises.
- abalashov 10y agoI'm not sure this rather dated precept is compatible with the exigencies of 21st century economics, and the flexibility, mobility and long hours demanded. For one thing, houses are cash sinks. It doesn't make sense for highly paid professionals to spend enormous amounts of time or money reshingling roofs, painting, mowing lawns, treating weeds, trimming hedges, repairing plumbing, etc. The deep specialisation and constant attention that the professional economy asks are orthogonal to all those things. It's prudent to upload those demands to the cloud (aka your landlord, at scale) so to speak. I know far more urban professionals that were hindered by the ballast of owning real estate than those empowered by this "most basic form of security". Here in the sprawling metro Atlanta area, taking another job will very likely take you to a wholly different part of this vast agglomeration and doom you to a punishing commute unless you sell your house and relocate. The uncertainty, transaction costs and other friction kept a number of people I know in dead-end jobs until they were finally laid off. As a personal anecdote, I bought a condo in May 2007. I was drinking the very same Kool-Aid about basic form of security and whatnot. I finally let my home go to foreclosure in summer 2015. I financed at $160K, and in summer 2015 it appraised at $85K. I still owed $140K. One of the lenders sued me for a $29K deficiency and got a judgment, and I'll be paying them $250/mo for the next six years. Some security. I grant that my effort at partaking of the most basic form of security a human needs was exceptionally disastrous, but I think the housing crash educated a lot of people about just how much security it really offers. A senseless push to ownership for ownership's sake threatens to discard those valuable lessons. The real argument for owning vs. renting is the mortgage interest deduction, and that's an artifice of government tax policy that hugely distorts the market and the incentives.
- panzer_wyrm 10y ago
- posixplz 10y agoYou have hit the nail on the head. Unfortunately, i fear that any sufficiently strong measures to restrict empty homes or foreign investment (see: empty home taxes in British Columbia) will be met with strong resistance from Democrats. As a resident of the Pacific Northwest, the same property squeeze is happening here on a similarly massive scale, also driven by foreign "investment". In my experience, advocating for strong countermeasures is a great way to get one's self labeled as a Trump-er or anti-immigrant.
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>i fear that any sufficiently strong measures to restrict empty homes or foreign investment (see: empty home taxes in British Columbia) will be met with strong resistance from Democrats. Uh, I'm not sure why Democrats would be against this, especially considering Prop 13 was passed by Reagan.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoI know people like to blame Reagan for lots of things, but Prop 13 was passed by voter initiative in 1978, Reagan was Governor from 1967 to 1975. He probably voted for it though.
- icantdrive55 10y ago"I'm mad as Hell" Howard Jarvis. My father was madder. He would watch those property taxes go up every year, cringe, and gulp his Mickey's Big Mouth Beer. (My father died of liver cancer years later. My father drank for many reasons, but all adults were furious over what politicians were doing with all that money. It wasen't pretty.) Politicians used the money on pet projects. I was a kid, but I knew something was very wrong. Everyone knew--Republicans, and Democrats, even the hippies were furious. The waste/borderline fraud was on the front pages of newspapers monthly. The Bay Area is a disaster. Rents are atrocious. Traffic is worse than ever. Sewer systems were built, but their was just never enough to enlarge them? They always had money to hire a new relative though? But--your Founders just have to live here, and set up shop in the high rise, with the hand finished wood tables. I don't quite get it. Yes--I do get it. It's they can buy the nice house in the nice neighborhood, and "Oh well?". But they always blame it on the Investors. "Investors need to be close to their money?" It's getting old. But blaming prop 13 in any way is just projecting. Take away prop 13. Within weeks REIT's, your Founders, Every DINK with money will be chasing those units. I give it a year, and the widows would be gone, and the 1 percenter's will be Landlords. Get ready for New York City rents.
- iamacynic 10y agothe recent ballot measure that uncorks development passed; it will get better in LA. the NIMBYs reigned supreme here for a while but they are being beaten.
- tomcam 10y ago> I also know many remote Chinese Hey, they're not all remote. Some of them are outgoing, a few even garrulous!
- tehlike 10y agoThe other side of the coin is this is akin to what employees from bay area are doing in, say, Texas. They buy properties and propping up the prices elsewhere.