4 ms·
Why does she need to shadow a student to learn what it's like to be a student? Wasn't she a student once herself? These things are pretty obvious. I always jus
by jstanley 10y ago
Why does she need to shadow a student to learn what it's like to be a student? Wasn't she a student once herself?
These things are pretty obvious. I always just assumed teachers didn't care.
- ramy_d 10y agoBecause we're old and the slow transition through accumulation of new experience have made us forget what it's like to be on the other side. *Edit: words
- yequalsx 10y agoI was a student of calculus once. But it was long ago and I no longer remember what it was like. Human memory is bad and we are prone to hyperbole when it comes to recalling struggles/good times. A reminder is not a bad idea from time to time. I suppose there are past experiences that you have forgotten what it was really like.
- bighi 10y agoYou might not remember a lot of the specifics. But I am sure you remember that you did a lot of sitting and a lot of listening (2 of the 3 surprising findings of the article).
- rhino369 10y agoI remember class being boring, but I didn't have these two hour long block classes that seem in vogue now. Well, I did in college and grad school, but you could skip class. Or during grad school it was common to just surf the web when you got truly bored. After reading this I remembered sitting in some really boring high school classes boiling with almost rage at how boring it was. Sitting and looking at the clock. I wouldn't have remembered that without the help of the article. I can easily see how a teacher would lose this prospective.
- nradov 10y agoMy father was a high school teacher. When his school shifted to long block classes it was great for lab and shop classes because they lost much less time on setup and cleanup, but terrible for lecture classes because many students couldn't pay attention that long.
- Consultant32452 10y agoMan, I have vivid memories of AP calculus. And that was... almost 20 years ago. At my school each class had 2 PCs: one for the teacher and one for the students. Our student PC was broken and the school apparently didn't have the resources to fix it. My calc teacher let us fix it for her, so we did. Then we started playing Grand Theft Auto (the original). In the game there's this chain of like 8 joggers we called the "school children" (meh, it was pixelated). We'd take turns trying to get a flame thrower and then finding the school children. Then you'd announce you were ready. The teacher would stop the lecture and we'd all go back to the computer to watch you try to flame thrower all the school children in a single go to get some giant bonus points. Then you rotated out. A couple weeks before the AP exam we all decided we should learn calculus so we started cramming. Most of us passed.
- jameskilton 10y agoNever attribute to malice what can be explained through ignorance.
- threatofrain 10y ago-- if you wish to promote a specific vision of gentle relations. However, if you're after information, then you should choose whatever is best for scientific economy. Maybe that takes you down a gentle path, and maybe it doesn't.
- rpenm 10y agoIt's just a heuristic along the lines of Occam's Razor. Competent malice is less likely than incompetence, all else being equal. Normative motivations are irrelevant.
- glibgil 10y ago> ignorance Indifference in this case. Anyone could have remembered or imagined what the day of a student is. They just didn't care
- water42 10y agoThis article is nothing more than low effort clickbait. People love hearing about "shocking" revelations.
- pmoriarty 10y agoAgreed. This is a super obvious fluff article. Not worthy of HN, except to the extent it might spark discussion on the subject.
- dsmithatx 10y agoYeah I agree, I mean, I realized all this stuff around 8 years old. Even after reading this I don't think any other teachers actually care or will ever care. This teacher is just getting old and forgetting how much being in school sucks. Thankfully I can just work on computers and make tons of money and love it. I now learn more every single week than I probably learned in a few months of school and, I graduated. That isn't from work though as I'm over 40. It's just because I love to read and learn. I was doing Autocad in 1988 in 8th grade. I was learning Unix/Slackware inside out in 1993 after I graduated. School barely gave me basics in 13 years and I could of learned all of that in less than a year. If my wife wasn't a stay at home mom I'd probably home school my kids. Sadly though I have to work all the time so, they go to a boring school and only learn how to take tests.
- hourislate 10y ago+1000
- ivanche 10y ago> School barely gave me basics in 13 years and I could of learned all of that in less than a year. Oh the irony...
- alunchbox 10y agowhat's the irony here ? asking for a friend.
- sdabdoub 10y agoI'm guessing it's the "could of" instead of the correct "could have" in the GP.
- glibgil 10y ago13 years in a designated place of learning is worth less than 1 year in unstructured freedom, according to OP. It's ironic because for OP a place where you are suppose to learn is not a good place to learn
- lr4444lr 10y agoTo be fair, your perspective changes when you're on the other side of the desk. Teacher training in the U.S. is pretty abysmal. The research they're exposed to is largely theoretical or specialized, because that's what your professors have to focus on in a publish or perish world. Good training would identify the misconceptions teachers are prone to, and the practical application of adolescent psych. There's also an appalling lack of guidance through the states' regulatory framework.
- Allower 10y agoThe three key points outlined by this piece are not difficult to grasp, or even realize. Its common sense. Bottom line, teachers are incentivized to sabotage real learning opportunities. the sad thing is, no one is trying to change it.
- cirgue 10y agoAdults forgetting what it is like to be young has been a foible of teachers and parents for all of recorded history. People are way worse at making connections between past experiences and present ones than we like to admit.