12 ms·
YouTube Stars Feel an Advertising Pinch
- minimaxir 10y agoThe article underplays the success of Patreon in solving this problem; almost every video creator I follow has set up one. It's a win-win for both content creators and consumers. I'm actually surprised more programmers/engineers have not set up a Patreon. (in disclosure, I have one set up, but have zero expectation of it replacing a full-time salary.)
- falcolas 10y agoIt's unfortunate that viewers have to pay twice for content - once via Patreon, the second while watching ads.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoOne pays the content, one pays the hosting.
- falcolas 10y agoShould that matter, to the viewer?
- tapoxi 10y agoMy cousin is a YouTuber, and for him (and a few others) they follow a "Premium Content" model. Their YouTube channel has free, ad supported content to develop an audience, and Patreon subscribers get that content ad-free, as well as extra content. It's a decent model, but as I find myself watching more YouTube than Netflix/Hulu these days, I really wish this concept was supported by YouTube itself. They have YouTube Red, but that doesn't directly support my favorite YouTubers.
- jasonlotito 10y agoYouTube Red does directly support the YouTubers you watch.
- jrockway 10y agoI think he's saying that he wants $X per month to be delivered directly to the content creator's bank account regardless of how many of that content creator's videos he watches. That's what Patreon does. Twitch has a clearer subscriber model, I think. When you "subscribe", you're actually giving your actual real money to the channel. I'm not sure why YouTube doesn't have that. (Different horses for different courses, I guess. YouTube is more about the "1 billion people will watch this and some people will see an ad", versus "I know I like you, here's some money." Both can be profitable for everyone involved, but the models are very different. Scale vs. curation, or something.)
- rtkwe 10y agoOnly somewhat. As far as anyone can tell, because afaik Google hasn't come out and said precisely, all the money goes into a large pot and then the whole pot is split by the portion of minutes watched with Red that for each channel. ie in a simple case with two channels and 2 Red viewers if person A watches 20 minutes of channel A and person B watches 10 minutes of channel B in a month: A gets 2/3 of the pot and B gets 1/3. At least that's what seems to be happening as far as I can see from the various articles written about it.
- falcolas 10y agoGiven how a video has to be monitized by the creator (i.e. set up with ads) to get Red dollars as well, I'm curious if the changes to ad placement will have a knock-on effect for Red dollars as well... I'd hope not, but stranger things have happened.
- rtkwe 10y agoI'm not clear on what you're saying.
- deelowe 10y agoIt's honestly bizarre to me that more YTer's aren't promoting red for this very reason.
- tyfon 10y agoYoutube red is only available in * Australia * Korea * Mexico * New Zealand * The United States I'd buy it in an instant (in fact, I already have all access which is bundled with red) but it's just not available in most of the world.
- EA 10y agoIt is worse with ESPN. I buy the ESPN Magazine. I buy ESPN Insider. And I still have to watch ads on ESPN videos.
- Buge 10y agoYoutubers can disable ads on their videos if they don't want any ad revenue.
- placeybordeaux 10y agoOne of my favorite OSS contributors in scala was recently asking on twitter if any companies would be interested in sponsoring him to spend a couple months working full time on issues on his OSS stuff. Lots of people responded asking for his patreon, enough that he went ahead and set one up[1]. It'll be interesting to see if this kind of thing continues. [1]: https://www.patreon.com/lihaoyi https://www.patreon.com/lihaoyi
- jdietrich 10y agoIn 2008, Kevin Kelly theorised that a successful creative person only needs a few thousand true fans to have a successful career. If that small group of fans are willing to throw you $20 for a book or a t-shirt or a CD every year, you can make a middle-class income. You don't need to be a star, you don't need the backing of a record label or a publisher or a movie studio. While initially promising, this theory didn't seem to bear out in practice. Many creative people replied that the numbers just didn't add up. Margins are too thin, expenses are too high, promotion is too difficult. Unless you're absurdly lucky, you can't make a decent living without access to a mass audience via the traditional media. Patreon seems to be the technology that brings this theory to life. A huge variety of creative people now have a regular, sustainable income thanks to their Patreon subscribers. If you can find 1000 people willing to throw you an average of $5 a month, you're earning more than the median US household. With those subscribers paying your bills, your merch sales and ad revenue and whatever else are just gravy. It's SaaS for creatives - recurring revenue always trumps one-off sales. http://kk.org/thetechnium/1000-true-fans/ http://kk.org/thetechnium/1000-true-fans/
- Mikushi 10y ago> Last week, the company announced a slate of new ad-supported shows on YouTube, including projects with Ellen DeGeneres and Kevin Hart. Gotta support "well behaved" brands and cut the small man out of the picture. Insipid low brow content that'll please advertiser is all these will be. Sadly it seems certain parts of the internet are turning into cable... Let's not even get started on the appalling support YouTube offers content creators when things go wrong. If you are not Coca Cola I guess you basically don't exists. Shame bandwidth is such an expensive part of the video market, because Youtube deserves to have some stiff competition thrown at it. Things like Patreon help offer alternatives but it could help with being better integrated into the platform.
- themagician 10y agoYou aren't entitled to money just because you post stuff on YouTube. Brands want to advertise on "insipid low brow content" specifically because it has mass appeal and caters to advertising. Nothing stops you, as a content creator, from finding your own advertisers. There is a very strange mentality among YouTube creators that they are somehow "entitled" to have advertisers run ads on their channel and pay them. Like you said, bandwidth is expensive. YouTube is already giving you something for free. I really don't get it.
- falcolas 10y agoWhen a creator's videos go from making $700 per video to $150 per video, without being caused by any action on the creator's part, and without any kind of transparency from YouTube's part... I think they are absolutely justified to be concerned. And that's what this article shows - concern. Concern about laying people off. Concern about having to find another job. Nobody's is acting like they're entitled to money, just concerned about the sudden changes they have no control or visibility into.
- sfifs 10y agoThe content likely was not attractive for an advertisers to put an ad on in the first place and so revenues dropped the minute ad controls for advertisers were added. Google didn't really have a choice but to do this given the billions that were pulled. Will be interesting to see impact on AMJ quarter results.
- jszymborski 10y agoThere is going to be a huge push for invite-only creator-centric platforms like LinusTechTips' Float Plane. YouTube should have developed something like this instead of YouTube Red ages ago.
- johnnydoe9 10y agoYeah Float Plane Club is already working and they're trying to make a proper website and have some friends partner with them. Youtube made a tip jar where people (from a select list of countries) could tip a creator whatever they liked but they scrapped it before ever making the feature international.
- geppeto 10y agoyou make it sound like they have a chance
- jszymborski 10y agoThere is no lose scenario for LTT re:Float Plane, just a less monumental one. They've released early-access subscription-based material before through the defunct Vessel platform (which exited successfully via buy-out). Now they're building that platform themselves for their audience. Whether they can expand it successfully to other creators is another question, but I see no reason why they wouldn't...
- SadWebDeveloper 10y agoEveryone hopes they do well but that project its going to crash and burn big time or stay as another patreon, because what makes YouTube great is the huge device compatibility it already has with several platforms, i can't be the only one watching YouTube on my TV rather than my smartphone, tablet or PC.
- mangodrunk 10y agoI exclusively watch it on my TV. I find it funny when they will talk about information at the bottom, or click the links on the video which assumes a less passive device than the TV. I've been subscribed to You Tube Red for quite some time now as well.
- LeonM 10y agoYouTube creators are highly undervalued. Many of them are highly influential amongst their viewers and have more views than your average mid-tier TV show. Youtube also offers much better insight in the audience than TV channels ever can achieve. And yet, the content creators need to rely on Patreon and selling merchandise to pay for their expenses. I'm not saying all of them are struggling, in some niches (for example cosmetics) YouTube creators are known to make a pretty hefty buck in sponsorship deals, but the majority is highly undervalued. Alejandro Salomon recently talked about this in his podcast [1], since this phenomenon is especially true in the automotive sector. [1] https://youtu.be/fcIgvYzSFm4?t=1936 https://youtu.be/fcIgvYzSFm4?t=1936 edit: typo
- komali2 10y ago>undervalued I think this is arguable based on the meaning of "value." For example, what I would say are the "highest value" channels, i.e. educational, review, informational etc are not getting as much payout as "Spiderman and Elsa Sit On Eachother's Heads" or "man blows out his microphone screaming at minecraft" videos. I mean, capitalism, yea, I get it, people like Spiderman and Elsa more than learning about stuff.
- kbenson 10y agoI think it's fairly obvious that in a discussion about advertising, and how they are feeling the pinch of advertisers leaving youtube, in this discussion value is based on advertisers, since they are the ones paying. This interpretation seems to be supported by the supporting statements included. Their value to you might be entirely different.
- Namrog84 10y agoTrue but there are likely a few channels or videos that bring new users to the platform and then view other content and yet that creator only gets what that user viewed on their video. Not the fact that they likely brought a lot of views to the platform (rise in water lifts all hosts scenario) I highly suspect if you look at what all the content creators and people receive via ads. Plus overhead of running YouTube. They are likely making tons more money in profit when main content creators are getting the short stick.
- soared 10y agoClassic HN comment. Only education-focused content is of value. There is no value in entertainment, especially when it is for children and plebs. When they get off work, why don't they view the science videos instead of lowly clickbait? There are reasons those videos exist, get off your god damn high horse komali2.
- tw04 10y agoThere's also a reason why we've got a president who blatantly lies and yet half the country can't be bothered to do a simple fact check. So no, don't get off your high horse. Encourage everyone you know to spend more time educating themselves for entertainment and less time wasting away watching pointless drivel - whether it's on YouTube or broadcast tv.
- self-diversity 10y agoMostly off-topic, but I'm curious, do you believe "fake news" is both new and also a real problem?
- sillyquiet 10y agoYou are encouraging proselytization, which is just as intrusive and annoying in non-religious contexts.
- tw04 10y agoIf you find people encouraging you to better yourself through scientific education "intrusive and annoying", you need to take a long hard look in the mirror. Quite frankly I'm not even sure why you'd participate on this site other than to troll.
- sillyquiet 10y agoyep, definitely intrusive and annoying - I don't need other people telling me how, in their opinion, I need to better myself. What an incredibly dumb comment.
- thejohnhenry 10y agoIt's crazy to me how nobody, even the (usually remarkably candid) Youtube stars themselves, acknowledge that this story is mostly about ad fraud. I would expect people to be hush-hush about this in a normal industry, but Youtube creators are usually really good about incisive analysis and being open with their audience. Do they themselves not know?
- EnFinlay 10y agoWhat fraud are you referring to? The type where ads are reported as clicked, but advertisers don't see the user come to their site, or the type where influencers don't tag when they've been paid to promote a product?
- thejohnhenry 10y agoThe first kind. Is the second kind also a big problem? I'm unaware of it.
- Buge 10y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8fU2QG-lV0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8fU2QG-lV0
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Analemma_ 10y agoAd rates on the internet go in only one direction: down. They're OK to bootstrap your "brand" but you'd better start looking for alternate revenue sources immediately, whether that's merch, Patreon, whatever.
- digitalneal 10y agoThe classic "Musicians make money touring, not selling records." This is why the automotive Youtube "celebs" are launching GTCon a convention for car enthusiasts to get fans to meet them IRL and buy merch!
- boiu 10y agoI can attest to this as I have a youtube channel that deals with some controversial and sensitive topics like pushing for reformation of Islam, secularism and alternative spirituality and my channel was decimated by youtube's decision to cut advertising revenues to the channel. I also failed to raise enough funds from Patreon to support the channel and therefore my cultural initiative is totally dead for now. Shame because I thought that this work is important in these turbulent times. This is my channel https://www.youtube.com/c/BoxofIslam https://www.youtube.com/c/BoxofIslam
- pc86 10y agoYou mean YouTube's decision to allow advertisers not to be on your channel if they didn't want to? Surely advertisers should have that choice, right? That's what caused you to lose money, not any executive decision by YouTube. And this comment is probably dead because of the out of context advertisement for your channel.
- boiu 10y agoWhat dead comment? I am not following...
- nimos 10y agoA lot of the videos being demonetized don't seem any worse than what's on daytime TV. It will be interesting to see if Twitch can capitalize on this and start offering more options for non-live content. There already seems to be some youtubers moving to streaming on there to try and diversify. Youtube in general seems very poorly run lately. The app on my phone right now won't play videos unless I update or wait 30 seconds. Who okayed that? You might as well just tell me to fuck off. I'd happily use something worse out of spite at this point. "Don't be evil, but really annoying is ok"
- darksim905 10y agoWhere are people getting that youtubers are undevalued? There are some really dumb channels out there where people are making $10k a month, easy from a few million views, with maybe one person helping them. There are many, many salty people out there that they are losing money because they don't know how to adjust to YouTube's algorithm changes. Sure, there may be some changes to advertising & some people may claim to 'leave' the platform, but the reality is, they make money. People just don't realize how much, even if many people out there have adblockers enabled.
- pc86 10y agoTo be clear this isn't an algorithm change, it's giving advertisers a choice on where their ads show up.
- angry-hacker 10y agoLet's not forget YouTube relies on these people too. Yes, YouTube has near monopoly in the area right now, but there can always be changes. These influencers can bring a new site overnight 500k new users if they want to. And the whole advertisers don't like that content is stupid and complicated. I can't remember the name but some popular guy made series about serial killers, no NSFW pictures but probably something you wouldn't your kids watch. Most of his videos were banned completely. Yet we have a shitload of rap music that sings literally about killing people making money with big brands. Go figure. This song gives me nice Amazon.com ads: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJwKKKd2ZYE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJwKKKd2ZYE
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 10y agoI'm really hoping for YouTube (Google) vs. Twitch (Amazon) competition. YouTube is clearly moving into Twitch's market, and there are signs that Twitch is looking to expand into non-streaming content.
- sotojuan 10y agoA channel I watch recently mentioned the reason it has been posting more often (at expense of quality) is that YT algorithm heavily punishes infrequent uploads. You have to post frequently and build a community to be successful now.
- ramy_d 10y agoAs a consumer this is what irks me the most. YouTube is forcing indie creators to make content at a scale and rate they just can't live up to leaving larger productions (from tv) to migrate into this "new market" and the end-game is that if youtube is just TV, then this discussion is a resounding "no thanks"
- djhworld 10y ago> His firm recently conducted a survey of 100 YouTube creators and said that channels focused on comedy and gaming experienced the sharpest drops in revenue last month compared with February. At the same time, creators in food, beauty and fashion, and family and parenting had increases. YouTube shares ad revenue with creators, who keep more than half. I'm wondering it this is just a coincidence, or whether Youtube are trying to shift advertisers to these "family friendly" channels, and away from anything that might cause controversy.
- hasbot 10y agoA paranormal-focused channel with 470,000 subscribers used to earn $6000 per month!? Wow! I had no idea there was that much money to be made.
- socrates1998 10y agoYouTube is really weird, the whole reason I go there is to watch people who don't have TV shows. If YouTube turns into Jimmy Fallon clips, then why even have the website? YouTube is being tempted by corporate money to turn it into another TV channel. But as soon as the only good content you can get is made by NBC or CBS, then why would people go to YouTube? It's amazing that they seem to promote these TV shows when their own creators get pushed to the side. I mean, talk about bad business. They should have the Jimmy Fallons on youtube, but why wouldn't you push your own creators? That's what makes youtube unique. The small Youtube creators are the ones that should be protector and promoted by Youtube and it seems like it is the opposite. They are ones hurt the most by these changes to youtube's systems. It's like youtube just wants them to leave. Look at how they treated their #1 overall channel. He freaking left for Twitch. Are you kidding me?
- bigtunacan 10y ago"Look at how they treated their #1 overall channel. He freaking left for Twitch. Are you kidding me?" I'm a bit ignorant of both the YouTube and Twitch scenes. Who are you referring to?
- ramy_d 10y agoPewdiepie
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 10y agoPresumably Pewdiepie (the largest channel by subscribers), but he's very much still posting to YouTube. Not sure what that's about. Twitch, incidentally, banned IcePoseidon because he was doing IRL streams and attracting too much attention (getting threatened with guns) who moved to YouTube's streaming format. Twitch and YouTube are looking more and more like a little proxy war for Google and Amazon.
- ben_jones 10y agoWhy hasn't "Twitch but for {food, cars, cosmetics, etc.}" cannibalized youtube yet? Twitch was basically a row boat that cut off Google's battleship by firing a nerf gun across its bow. And they won. And they got acquired for billions. Their product is great, I've learned a fair bit of design and function just by looking at it. I suppose gaming has a large user base that is quick to download and try new tech. It also has a way of slow "dopamine dripping" its audience into spending countless hours of viewership. Does this not exist in other genres?
- sp332 10y agoYouTube specifically didn't like dealing with copyright complaints from video game makers. People posting game streams got sick of their videos being taken down from YouTube, and moved to Twitch. I don't see food or cosmetics having similar pain points on the platform that would make room for a competitor.
- andrewclunn 10y agoGoogle allowed ads on terrorist videos. Advertisers complain. Google enables advertiser controls to save their revenue. Advertisers favor sanitary corprorate media, similar to what's on TV. Google launches YouTubeTV and embraces the new model, after having a virtual lock on user created video. Of course, anyone who saw the cultivated (see dishonest) YouTube trending filter and what it had become already knew that this day was coming. Embrace, extend and extinguish, it works for "cool" and culture too apparently.
- nannePOPI 10y agoBig advertisers don't want to give money to indipendent content creators, because they are a lot of people and much more difficult to control since they own themselves and are not owned by corporations. Think about the reaction pewdiepie had after being dropped by disney. If he was a tv star it would have meant the end of his career. Instead it was just a big "meh" and moving on. Tv networks are easy to control. Networks are often owned indirectly/in part by the very same people who ask for the ad space. It is not about the value of the ad, it's about not giving too much power to normal people and risk too much decentralization. Having so much voices it's bad, globalist billionaires and corporations risk losing an amount of control over population they don't want to lose, also because they often crave total domination, both in politics and in the markets. I know this could be difficult to understand, because many of us are sane people and don't crave that kind of power. It's difficult to put ourselves in the shoes of the people with the very big money, but they really do think in term of having absolute power and control (in fact they did get there). They think "okay, those people have an audience, they make people I can easily control lose the audience, I need a solution", and they do it immediately. Instead it's difficult to us to imagine being so big and rich, and yet feeling treatened by some kids on youtube. It looks crazy to us, but that's really how they think. Yet that's how corps and billionaires often thinks, because they have a complete different mindset from normal people. Of course I could be completely wrong, it's just an opinion, no math involved so can't really prove it. Use your gut.
- wshaef 10y agoNo matter what kind of business you’re in, it’s wise to diversify your sources of revenue. YT’s ad-focused monetization model disservices a variety of creators for a variety of reasons, many of which are mentioned in this NYTimes article. Fan patronage in the likes of what Vidme (disclaimer: I’m a co-founder) and Patreon are offering help creators diversify their revenue streams and make content for their fans, rather than to please advertisers. Google and Facebook aren’t well incentivized to offer this kind of model on platform because they can make considerably more money allocating resources towards optimizing ad revenue. Hunter Walk, an ex YT employee turned investor, writes about this in this blog post: https://hunterwalk.com/2017/03/26/why-were-paying-for-content-these-days/ https://hunterwalk.com/2017/03/26/why-were-paying-for-conten...
- profalseidol 10y agoTime for SingularDTV
- profalseidol 10y agoTime for Brave and BAT
- thr0waway1239 10y agoThese creators are very smart and very good at what they do. But they lack the most basic understanding of why it is such a bad idea to create an entire business around something you cannot control. Yes, there is that risk with anything you do (including your own website and your own email list), but surely by now they have heard enough people complain online that it is very unwise to build a tall building on a shaky foundation. Aside: why don't they use competitors such as Vimeo and post the videos on Vimeo [1] first, and then post those same videos on YouTube after two weeks? If their audience is really that engaged, shouldn't they be following them to Vimeo also? It would be a two in one deal - the creators create competition between two online video services (which is usually good for them), and if more creators move away from YouTube the consumer also benefits from greater choice and is more likely to go check out Vimeo, leading to a possible virtuous cycle. A third and unexpected side benefit - less data collection about your online practices by an internet behemoth. [1] From what I can see, Vimeo also has options to monetize your videos. https://vimeo.com/blog/post/learn-how-vimeo-on-demand-helps-creators-earn-more https://vimeo.com/blog/post/learn-how-vimeo-on-demand-helps-...
- fiatpandas 10y agoEasy to say you shouldn't put all your eggs in one basket, and who would disagree with you? But I think it is not saying very much. E.g. someone loses their job: "see, I told you it would have been better to work 2-3 jobs. You relied too much on your only job." At some point you spread yourself too thin and it's better to concentrate on an ecosystem with a critical mass that actually cares about your content. Do I feel bad about someone who built up a ghost hunting video empire on YouTube see their castle crumble as advertisering industry pivots on standards? Abstractly, no. But just compare the trending content on YouTube to Vimeo and try to imagine the likelyhood of the majority of your users inconveniencing themselves by introducing a rift in their YouTube subscription consumption flow. It's a stretch.
- ehnto 10y agoThere are certainly other baskets, but none have been as nice and profitable, with as large a user base, as YouTube. So to say they should be using other platforms is great in theory, in reality they would just lose their followers. There are other platforms just as technically competent as YouTube. But I don't believe there is a replacement for the community and the brand YouTube has just yet. It also stands to reason that if there were competition, and say half the users used one platform and half the other, that you would get half the viewers on each, the possibility for massive growth on either is smaller as more channels compete over fewer users. Even if you were on both, it would be harder. This is one of those situations where as a creator and a user, it would be nice if one monolithic platform just worked out well for everyone.
- xcopy 10y agoI think they want to take their smaller competitors out
- hxta98596 10y agoI wonder if the opacity and significantly less money coming from YouTube (YT) here is a bit of "Headline bad - Bottom line pad" i.e. When a business encounters a major problem like this, fix the problem ASAP but also use these opportunities to try to add new profits (another example of how this works: when Uber faced criticism about driver background checks they used the negative publicity to add a $1.50 "safe ride fee" to every ride) Q: Could enough YT stars with 7 and 8 figure subscriber counts band together and move to a different platform or get staked by a well-funded new startup to create a YT competitor site?...In theory sure anyone can try to compete with a google product...but how realistic is this here? And if it's not realistic then YT can cut the % it has been paying content creators and get away with it. I have no clue if ad revenue $ will return to previous levels for YT content creators. I hope so. But I wouldn't be surprised if YT used this opportunity to change how it has been doing things and grab a bigger piece of the ad money profit pie at stake. Either way this is a fascinating story: on one hand YT has almost a monopoly when it comes to this kind of monetized online video content. On the other hand, YT is dependent on a pyramid of quite powerful content creators to maintain the very monopoly they are subject to.