8 ms·
Luther's World: Understanding the man who was the powerhouse of the Reformation
- pionar 10y agoI really liked Dan Carlin's podcast on Luther and the aftermath of his posting of the theses: http://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-48-prophets-of-doom/ http://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-48-prophet...
- geff82 10y agoCan we stop talking about Luther (at least Germany is so full of it now)? I am glad we live in a humanist, secular world in the West at least and we can be joyful that we overcame the catholic rule as well as the protestant.
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoNo, it's the basis of the ruling discourse.
- mason240 10y agoProtestantism was a phase we needed to get from Catholicism to secular humanism.
- coldtea 10y agoI (and several thinkers, Nietzsche for one) find it was rather the inverse: while catholicism was more relativistic, open, and even carnal, protestantism brought a fundamentalist look at the Bible that was a regression to even stricter interpretation and zealotry. Which is why modern protestant denominations in the US for example are even more Old Testament and wacko than catholics. And of course the same strictness has been inherited by atheists that grew in a protestant culture, contrary to classical humanism.
- mason240 10y agoPeople believe all kinds of crazy things, but it's undisputed that Protestantism has been generations ahead of Catholicism in social change. Even today, protestants have been accepting of same sex marriages, female clergy, birth control, and even abortions than the monolithic Catholic church, and that's not about to change anytime soon.
- jcranmer 10y agoOne of the main accusations the Protestants levied against the Catholic Church was that Catholic Church was too liberal and too willing to be flexible in its theology. The Counter-Reformation (a reaction to these accusations) did prompt the Catholic Church to become much more conservative, but this was not the state of the church prior to the Protestant Reformation.
- mason240 10y ago>One of the main accusations the Protestants levied against the Catholic Church was that Catholic Church was too liberal and too willing to be flexible in its theology. Some did yes. For others the appeal of Protestantism was flexibility.
- coldtea 10y ago>People believe all kinds of crazy things, but it's undisputed that Protestantism has been generations ahead of Catholicism in social change. That's only superficial, as protestant countries (and especially calvinist ones) transcribed into everyday non-religious morals all kinds of religious tenets, from the "protestant work ethic" to modern versions of puritanism like "political correctness".
- mason240 10y agoSome did yes. Protestantism was a very diverse collection of sub-theologies. Based on these replies, I'm wondering if there wasn't pop-history hit-piece on Protestantism that I'm not aware of. Just for for the record, I'm an atheist myself.
- Hermel 10y agoAlso relevant in this context is Jean Calvin, who had an enormous influence on what today is considered "protestant work ethics" and on the well-known related theories by Max Weber. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Calvin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Calvin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Weber https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Weber
- forvelin 10y ago"With the sole exception of Jesus Christ, more books have been written about Luther than about any other person who has ever lived." Is there any basis for this claim or did writer forget that there are other religions and their characters ?
- oblio 10y agoAgreed. I'd expect Confucius to be top 5, at least.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- danesparza 10y agoEven a cursory examination of other sources will show this to be false. Here is a great list from the Guardian publication in 2014: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2014/jan/30/whos-most-significant-historical-figure https://www.theguardian.com/books/2014/jan/30/whos-most-sign... Spoiler: Martin Luther is number 17 on their list
- Nokinside 10y agoSeeing history trough individuals can be misleading. There would have been reformation even without Luther. There were several reformations before Luther. Bible was translated into German and other languages before Luther. Mentel Bible was on it's second printing when Luther started his reformation. Several other successful reform movements started at the same time or little later. Question is why reformations started at that particular time and why Luther was so successful and several reformations before him failed. The answer is technology. Printing press revolution had exploded. There was over 1000 printing presses throughout Western Europe when Luther started his reformation. Germany and Italy were the main centers. Pamphlets from reformists spread around like wildfire and the movement was able to grow much faster among common people. https://blogs.qub.ac.uk/medievalforum/2015/08/19/literacy-and-print-in-early-modern-germany-and-england/ https://blogs.qub.ac.uk/medievalforum/2015/08/19/literacy-an... >Between 1516 and 1546, 3.1 million copies of Martin Luther’s works were sold in Germany (excluding whole and partial Bible translations). Considering that each reprint had around 1,000 copies, that equates to 3,100 editions of his work alone. Over this period, 1,057 editions were published in Wittenberg, 490 in Augsburg, and in comparison, Basel produced 131 editions. On a shorter time-scale, the number of pamphlet editions produced from 1518 to 1529 is as follows: 181 in Wittenberg, 140 in Augsburg and 61 in Basel. What is more remarkable is that Luther also authored 20% of the 7,500 cheap broadsheets printed between 1520 and 1526. Besides preaching, the Protestant reformers clearly published a large amount of material to disseminate their ideologies to a wider audience.
- wyclif 10y agoDon't forget Wycliffe translating the New Testament into English back in 1382.
- irrational 10y agoI wish I could upvote you 1000 times. Wycliffe and Tyndale were hugely instrumental.
- baldfat 10y ago> Question is why reformations started at that particular time and why Luther was so successful and several reformations before him failed. I think the reason why Luther was successful is he was the first to die of natural causes. Also it was the wood cutting. Most people were illiterate but the pictures could tell you who the good guys vs the bad guys very easily. Also these and illustrations were EPIC. Sadly my favorite isn't easily findable. He has the Pope with a trumpet up his arse. This one will do http://blogs.thegospelcoalition.org/justintaylor/files/2014/10/Papal_Belvedere-300x388.jpg http://blogs.thegospelcoalition.org/justintaylor/files/2014/... As someone that was on track for a PhD in Historical Theology (Yes that is an actual actual discipline). So this is right up my ally! I LOVE Martin Luther and most Christians today would have hated good old Martin. If you can read his writings they are actually pretty amazing good reads if he isn't on full tilt rage on the Pope, hatred and lies on the Jews or the horrible Peasant Revolt. We certainly can condemn all people of history with 21st Century eyes but Martin Luther did many other things extremely well. Here is a great quote: “You say, “What comes out of our mouth must be kept!” I hear it – which mouth do you mean? The one from which the farts come? (You can keep that yourself!)” From Against the Roman Papacy, an Institution of the Devil, pg. 281 of Luther’s Works, Vol. 41 Also Johann Bugenhagen's funeral sermon for Martin Luther is normally not written with his opening of asking forgiveness for his coarse use of language and potty mouth.
- TallGuyShort 10y agoIs this worth reading past page 1? After all that it's barely talked about Luther himself, and just about a bunch of authors and how great their books are and and minor opinions they have about Luther.
- muninn_ 10y agoObligatory Dan Carlin mention here: http://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-48-prophets-of-doom/ http://www.dancarlin.com/product/hardcore-history-48-prophet... It's very entertaining and interesting (I'm not making a case for historical accuracy here).