7 ms·
Capsules aren't inferior. In fact they can land on planets and moons without atmospheres, unlike space planes. And once propulsive landing of capsules is impl
by colordrops 10y ago
Capsules aren't inferior. In fact they can land on planets and moons without atmospheres, unlike space planes. And once propulsive landing of capsules is implemented, they can land on Earth without a landing strip, and even on boats.
- jessriedel 10y agoYea, wings on spacecraft are about as elegant as parachutes. They can make sense for certain uses, but, as a rule of thumb, they are inelegant and not futuristic.
- blackguardx 10y agoTechnically, the space shuttle and this space plane are lifting bodies, which I think is pretty cool and elegant.
- theoh 10y ago... there's something particularly evocative about this image taken during early lifting body research: https://www.nasa.gov/centers/dryden/multimedia/imagegallery/HL-10/ECN-2203.html https://www.nasa.gov/centers/dryden/multimedia/imagegallery/...
- dotancohen 10y agoThank you! I've never seen that photo, but it is obviously the inspiration for the Dynasoar poster: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_X-20_Dyna-Soar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_X-20_Dyna-Soar
- schiffern 10y agoCapsules are lifting bodies too. Apollo had a L/D of 0.368 and "steered" by rotating. Dragon uses the same technique (albeit with a slightly lower L/D), and Dragon 2 will have a tungsten ballast sled so it can change its angle of attack dynamically during re-entry. Even simple cylinders can be lifting bodies. Shuttle and Falcon 9 both have a L/D of 1.[1] On Falcon 9 the first stage acts as a lifting body, using the grid fins to "trim" the big cylindrical body making it act like a wing. In the SpaceX landing videos you can see the stage pitch up on reentry. This is no accident. Upward lift = more atmosphere traveled through = more drag = less landing fuel needed = more payload to orbit. A nice optimization by the SpaceX team! >you don't actually need wings by the way, it's kind of a common misconception around, you just need some lift over drag number, or lift vector - and steer back to the launch pad --- Elon Musk[2] [1] https://spaceflightnow.com/2017/04/04/musk-previews-busy-year-ahead-for-spacex/ https://spaceflightnow.com/2017/04/04/musk-previews-busy-yea... [2] http://shitelonsays.com/transcript/npc-luncheon-with-elon-musk-2011-09-29 http://shitelonsays.com/transcript/npc-luncheon-with-elon-mu...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jessriedel 10y agoThere isn't really a sharp distinction, is there? The primary method of generating lift for both wings and lifting bodies is simply the fact that it's an inclined plane moving through a fluid with positive angle of attack.
- blackguardx 10y agoThey each have some length of wing, but get a lot of lift from the shape of the fuselage. These craft wouldn't exist without lifting body research. This space plane and the shuttle shouldn't be derided for gliding into landing. Not using fuel while landing saves precious cargo capacity. If the main argument against them is that they can't land on the moon, I don't understand why a future craft couldn't both glide into an atmosphere and use thrusters in a vacuum in to land.
- jessriedel 10y ago> Not using fuel while landing saves precious cargo capacity Those wings are also a lot of mass, and hence take away from payload. In fact, propulsive landing always takes less mass than wings in the limit of large craft size. (You can see this by taking an equivalent limit, the limit of thin atmosphere; for sufficiently thin atmosphere, the amount of surface area you need to brake diverges but the amount of fuel to stop propulsively is fixed.) In this sense, propulsive landings naturally succeed wings as crafts get larger.
- blackguardx 10y agoI won't argue with that, but that isn't true in the case of the X-37, which is why it glides into landing. Elegance in engineering is fulfilling the requirements in the simplest, cheapest way possible.
- njarboe 10y agoFollowing this principle I sometimes think the new east span of the Bay Bridge is/was a $6 billion boondoggle. The historical (and I thought, beautiful) original span was not retrofitted because Caltrans said they could build a new span for less that would have a longer lifespan. The simple, cost effective viaduct design was rejected as not grand enough for a Bay Area bridge and a short decorative, self-anchored suspension bridge was added to the viaduct for an extra $5 billion. It would sure have been nice if that money had been spent on a couple of additional bridges across the bay. One from the 101/380 to the 880 near the Oakland airport would sure help the traffic problems some. With interest rates near zero, I'm sure the finances for a toll bridge would work out. Just need the political will.
- bjd2385 10y agoWay I see it is, if we can land a rover the size of a minivan on a different planet, we should be able to do this without much more effort. Money, perhaps, yes; but, we've already done it.
- nradov 10y agoYou might think so, but the difficulty doesn't scale linearly with size and weight. For example there's a practical upper bound on airbags to absorb landing shock; we can't just build larger ones for a capsule carrying humans.
- hawkesnest 10y agoI would imagine that the airbag solution would be rather unpleasant for humans, even if it were possible/practical.
- bjd2385 10y agoNot at all what I was referring to in my comment. But, yes, you're entirely accurate regarding the airbags. (:
- godelski 10y agoNot to mention that when you add fuel you now need more fuel for the added mass of that fuel. And....
- robotresearcher 10y agoCapsules like Soyuz can't land without an atmosphere. They use aerobraking and parachutes. You need a big rocket to slow down and land. At which point it's a very different machine.
- ceejayoz 10y agoI'd imagine the grandparent is thinking more SpaceX than Soyuz.
- dogma1138 10y agoSpaceX Dragon capsule can't land without atmosphere either it needs it to aerobreak it doesn't carry nearly enough fuel to come to a rest from orbital reentry speeds using propulsion alone.
- ceejayoz 10y agohttps://www.quora.com/Can-the-Dragon-V2-land-on-the-moon https://www.quora.com/Can-the-Dragon-V2-land-on-the-moon > The Dragon-2 has enough power and fuel to land and ascend back to lunar orbit. The Dragon's SuperDraco has higher performance than the Apollo Lunar Module. Apollo LM descent engines has 10,000 lbf thrust, and 3,500 lbf thrust for ascent (the lander part is left behind). The Dragon's SuperDraco has 16,000 lbf thrust. The Dragon also uses computers to control throttle and land (much more fuel efficient). Hence, the Dragon-2 has enough power and fuel to land and ascend back to lunar orbit even if it carries all it's parts during ascent. However, it may need to cut crew from 7 to 3 to loose more weight for fuel. (Plus, I said "more SpaceX" as in "capsules with powered descent", not "SpaceX's exact current models as already implemented"...)
- dogma1138 10y agoLunar orbit isn't earth reentry tho, even the SuperDraco doesn't seem to carry enough fuel nor have the specific impulse for an earth landing when you remove the aerobreaking.
- Retric 10y agoThese things would fit inside the shuttle which creates a very different design with much lower thermal stresses. Remember, the initial shuttle design was actually viewed as an improvement by real rockets scientists even if the project ballooned into ridiculous territory there really is a lot of value in those short stubby wings.
- coredog64 10y agoDynasoar was a contemporary of the Mercury capsule.
- sandworm101 10y agoThere are a few things that wings can do that capsules cannot. Shuttle's wing were never actually used for their intended purpose. Wings allow for "once over and return" flights. Shuttle's creators envisioned it launching into a polar orbit, overflying the USSR to [redacted] then land back home without a second orbit. That requires the ability to 'fly' through the atmosphere to make up for the earth's rotation during your orbit. For a vehicle doing multiple orbits, such wings would allow it greater latitude on return. It wouldn't have to wait for its orbit to line up as perfectly with the intended landing site. "The militarily specified 1,085 nmi (2,009 km; 1,249 mi) cross range requirement was one of the primary reasons for the Shuttle's large wings, compared to modern commercial designs with very minimal control surfaces and glide capability." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle
- mapt 10y agoThe driving requirement of the Shuttle was that it should be feasible to steal a Soviet satellite sporting unknown new orbital technology, before the Soviets had the opportunity to intervene, and that it be prepared to fly fairly quickly whatever its faults to be ready for potential Soviet expansions into spaceflight as an area of competition. There were a lot of other requirements and stakeholders that were part of the planning process, and any of them who didn't understand that espionage was a critical component were left wondering why anyone would design such an expensive, impractical failure; Why every stage of the process where it seemed to be unworkable, someone said "Yeah, don't worry about that" and poured money on the problem. Aside from direct requirements, we also encouraged the Soviet Union to spend lavishly copying our design. By the time the USSR unexpectedly broke up, Energia had just (unsuccessfully) flown a test run with a giant Polyus laser weapon. Mission accomplished, right? But we didn't then want all of the Soviet scientists to spread to the winds and start building ICBMs for anyone who could pay. We needed them to stay in Russia until Russia could become a solvent, stable state. So we said "What sort of international cooperative effort could we use a whole bunch of Shuttle AND Soyuz flights for?" and designed (or adapted) a space station around that requirement. We decided to revamp Reagan's ill-fated "Space Station Freedom" program into the ISS. That's the only reason we didn't retire the Space Shuttle long before the Columbia.
- exabrial 10y agoClearly you've never needed to plant a nuclear bomb on an asteroid hurtling towards the Earth.
- raverbashing 10y agoLanding on celestial bodies lacking atmosphere seems to be a case by case problem, which we will most likely need to solve for one case only: the moon