4 ms·
Its full of principles like that, and _for an economic discussion_ makes an average amount of sense -- which is one of the reasons economics isn't actually scie
by ilaksh 10y ago
Its full of principles like that, and _for an economic discussion_ makes an average amount of sense -- which is one of the reasons economics isn't actually science.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoIt's story telling with no scientific basis - fairy tales for grown ups. Pareto is valid, but getting from Pareto to "You only have to be a little bit better to win everything" is first-order nonsense. Still - the author has books to sell. So there's that.
- Brotkrumen 10y agoIt's not a natural science. If you restrict sciences to whatever you believe a natural science is, you'll kick out some useful, predictive and fruitful subsets of the natural sciences out too. So maybe we should let that old meme "if it's not done in white lab coats, it's not a science" die.
- 1_2__3 10y agoSure that's fine. Economics still isn't science, even by the relaxed definition.
- Brotkrumen 10y agoBy what relaxed definition? I didn't give a definition of "science" as that's kind of a hard problem smarter people than me tried to solve. But hey, let's play a game: You tell me what's a necessary condition for something being a science and I'll tell you an instance where that condition as broken or a "non-science" that fulfills that condition. Go!
- dsacco 10y ago"Relaxed definition" is a fairly pretentious way of describing social sciences. Is psychology also not a science, in your view? Science as a process of study can be effectively applied to phenomena that are not as easy to rigorously measure as physics and chemistry. I don't really understand where this view comes from. Is it a lack of exposure? There is a rich world of academic study in economics that is deeply complex, mathematical and even empirical, insofar as you can reasonably achieve in a domain that studies human behavior. There's more to it than the Pareto principle and "A Market for Lemons." Studying the individual or aggregate behavior of human beings is inherently more difficult than inanimate objects. That doesn't mean you can't be rigorous with it.
- anigbrowl 10y agoGet over yourself; that's like saying Newton wasn't a good scientist because he was wrong about a lot of things. Economics, like sociology, is a young discipline that yields a lot of mistakes and goes down a lot of dead ends because it gropes towards an understanding of hard problems. Criticizing economics is entirely valid. Pissing on it is not.
- ianai 10y agoI think economics is in its vast infancy. It studies a highly complex system after all. It's constantly in danger of being coopted and manipulated toward ideological ends, too.
- dsacco 10y agoWhat is your definition of "science", and why is economics not a science in your view?
- joubert 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science