5 ms·
Because blobs of paper look to similar to blobs of potential explosives when xrayed. They arent scanning it so much as removing it from the scan of everything
by sandworm101 10y ago
Because blobs of paper look to similar to blobs of potential explosives when xrayed. They arent scanning it so much as removing it from the scan of everything else.
- bbulkow 10y agoDo you know that to be true? Or is it that paper and/or ink blocks scanning and you can hide bombs in it?
- sandworm101 10y agoIt is the cellulose in the paper. Blocks of it are homogenous enough that they look similar in density to something dangerous. Add in ink, glue and other materials commonly soaked into paper and the situation is not totally unreasonable. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nitrocellulose https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nitrocellulose
- csydas 10y agoI lack the expertise to comment on the sensitivity of the cellulose specifically, but the metro stations where I live will perform random stops as you enter, and the monitors are in plain sight. Notebooks, stacks of paper, and note cards are usually pretty clearly detected by whatever software they're using to help highlight items. It seems weird to me that there could be such difficulty with TSA scanners versus the small, older ones set up at stations here. (St. Petersburg, Russia, just for reference for the location)
- learc83 10y ago>Notebooks, stacks of paper, and note cards are usually pretty clearly detected by whatever software they're using to help highlight items How do you know the problem isn't that the software flags dangerous items as paper incorrectly (which I think is the mostly likely problem here)? I doubt you've seen the X-ray image of someone smuggling nitrocellulose. The software is just using density--if you have an explosive of similar density to paper, it's probably not going to flag it.
- csydas 10y agoWell, I was more specifically replying to the comment "It is the cellulose in the paper. Blocks of it are homogenous enough that they look similar in density to something dangerous." Every time I've seen it on the scanners here, or the glimpses I've seen at airports last I was in the US, usually it's very clear what you're looking at - books and other paper products are plain to see. If they obfuscate, sure, possibly. But just from personal experience it doesn't seem like it would be indistinguishable. I'm not saying that these tools are infallible by any means, just that the particular claim didn't mesh with my experience.
- learc83 10y agoAn x-ray only shows density. 2 equally dense objects will look the same regardless of chemical composition. What you're likely seeing is computer enhanced images, which may be giving you a false sense of the capabilities of x-rays. There are explosives with densities fairly similar to paper. A block of those explosives, and a block of paper would look very similar on an x-ray.
- marcosdumay 10y agoBlobs of explosive normally have a chemical composition that is different from blobs of paper in a way that a X-ray scanner would detect. If somebody created an explosive that could pose as paper for X-ray, that would be noteworthy.
- djrogers 10y agoX-ray machines don't look at chemical composition, they care about density. Paper is quite dense, and a thick enough pile of it will show up as a solid block of 'something'.
- marcosdumay 10y agoThey differ elements by row of the periodic table, and modern ones have special filters for separating a single interesting element from the rest of its row.
- learc83 10y ago>Blobs of explosive normally have a chemical composition that is different from blobs of paper in a way that a X-ray scanner would detect. How is that? If a block of explosives is close to the same density as a stack of paper, they're both going to show up as similar colored blocks on the X-ray.
- marcosdumay 10y agoX-ray differentiate atoms by electronic distribution.
- neuronexmachina 10y agoYup, my guess is that it was causing time-consuming false positives when jumbled together with everything else in the bag, so they set it aside. That way they're easier to verify as safe, since they're isolated and laid flat, and if a closer inspection is required they don't have to go through the whole bag. I'm guessing that's the same reason laptops are scanned separately as well.