13 ms·
Iceland drills 4.7 km down into volcano to tap clean energy
- NicoJuicy 10y agoDoes anyone know where phys.org has their articles from? I suppose it has something to do with Elsevier. Since a LOT of their articles has to do with students and universities. Overall, they publish a great amount of "copy-paste" articles, either from other news sites and/or student papers. I am 100% sure their reports don't write original articles, just rewrite from other sources. It looks to me that Elsevier has found something new with the information they are tapping from (students/universities) PS. The source of their article now is : https://techxplore.com/news/2016-10-geothermal-power-potential-iceland-drilling.html https://techxplore.com/news/2016-10-geothermal-power-potenti... PS2. Elsevier seemed my best guess, since a lot of articles discuss research from students. Other articles are a rewrite
- thatwebdude 10y agoMakes sense, some neighbors in the Midwest have been heating their homes, driveways, etc. with geothermal heat pumps. Same principle, I suppose.
- Robotbeat 10y agoNot at all! Very different principle. "Geothermal" heat pumps are just using the ground as a thermal mass. There's no extraction of the energy from the Earth's interior, with such a heat pump, just using dirt as a thermal buffer (between the seasons). It's actually super annoying that the same word "geothermal" is used for both. If I were emperor of the world, I'd ensure that the proper "ground-source heat pump" were used instead of the criminally misleading "geothermal." Ground-source heat pumps are not energy sources, they consume energy. What Iceland is doing is actually developing an energy source.
- knd775 10y agoI need to start using that. "If I were emperor of the world..."
- Sharlin 10y agoIceland has also been utilizing its geothermal resources for centuries. Currently circa 22% of their electricity and 87% of the heating and hot water needs are met using geothermal energy.
- RugnirViking 10y agoCenturies? That's a lot of time. What kind of activities were they doing two centuries ago? Smelting iron ore?
- Robotbeat 10y agoThink like tapping hot springs for bathing and keeping your house warm or even cooking. When I was in Indonesia, I saw people would boil vegetables in the hotsprings.
- RugnirViking 10y agoCool, thank you
- accountyaccount 10y agoThe sulfuric smell in the hot water takes a little getting used to, but it's pretty amazing that it's naturally heated in most places throughout the country (though, a bit easier in such a tiny country).
- avar 10y agoThe sulfuric smell in the hot water has nothing to do with the use of geothermal power. Most tourists think so because they've only been to or near the capital area. Reykjavík artificially adds sulfur to its hot water to reduce the corrosion of their hot water pipes. I can't find a source for that in English but there's one in Icelandic, it's the "Vinnslutæknileg vandamál við vinnslu jarðhita" section. 1. http://web.archive.org/web/20160813045634/http://www.samorka.is/doc/1368 http://web.archive.org/web/20160813045634/http://www.samorka...
- thatwebdude 10y agoI was going to use "heat pump" but then was sure to get corrected on a traditional heat pump (like in your AC unit) vs a ground-based heat pump.
- Robotbeat 10y agoAir-source vs ground-source.
- thatwebdude 10y agoPo-teh-to/Po-tah-to https://energy.gov/energysaver/geothermal-heat-pumps https://energy.gov/energysaver/geothermal-heat-pumps If you have an issue with how it's marketed, I'd suggest inquiring against it.
- avar 10y agoThere's an English language summary page from the company itself at https://www.resourcepark.is https://www.resourcepark.is
- Robotbeat 10y agoAnd geothermal energy is a too-often-overlooked technology. It's not intermittent like wind and solar. It's more like nuclear but without the emotional baggage. As we try deep decarbonization, we're going to need more things like geothermal (or nuclear) or we'll end up spending like 2 or 3x as much money over-building solar to provide enough power even on cloudy winter days, building many more wind turbines, etc. The hard part isn't getting to 60-80% clean energy, it's getting that last 20%. Geothermal helps a LOT with that. (As does nuclear, which is why we should be protecting existing nuclear assets until fossil fuels are eliminated... The existing ~20% of our electricity in the US produced by nuclear will make deep decarbonization multiple times cheaper than relying solely on wind and solar alone, plus accelerate deep decarbonization by a decade.) An interesting idea is to build geothermal and solar at the same site. Consider areas where these two maps overlap in high potential for both: Geothermal: http://www.smu.edu/~/media/Site/Dedman/Academics/Programs/Geothermal%20Lab/Graphics/SMUHeatFlowMap2011_CopyrightVA0001377160_jpg http://www.smu.edu/~/media/Site/Dedman/Academics/Programs/Ge... and Solar: http://www.nrel.gov/gis/images/map_pv_us_june_dec2008.jpg http://www.nrel.gov/gis/images/map_pv_us_june_dec2008.jpg Places like New Mexico and southern Colorado are good fits for this. A problem with geothermal is if you draw heat too fast from the ground, the output will decline over the years. If you stop drawing heat, the ground will warm back up and then when you start again, output will be higher than it was when you stopped. So there is some sense in conserving geothermal power when demand for it is low. So the idea is, you draw from solar when the Sun is shining and draw from geothermal when it's not. By being co-located, you can use the same grid infrastructure and get higher utilization out of your powerlines. You've essentially converted some of your solar energy into a baseload power source. Or you can think about it as enhancing the output and lifetime of your geothermal power source. (And it's possible that if you have a LOT of extra solar power, you could run a resistive load underground, using the ground as a makeshift thermal battery.)
- tclancy 10y agoIf you're interested in tracking the efficiency of your geothermal install, there's an app for that (which I helped build): http://groundenergysupport.com/ http://groundenergysupport.com/
- mmwako 10y agoSomeone more knowledgable than me, please correct me... if they are drilling a hole in the ground and making steam come up from said hole, doesn't that heat up the Earth's crust and atmosphere more than the previous condition without the hole, therefore contributing to higher temperatures (and climate change), making it not that "clean" after all? Maybe cleaner than carbon/petrol, but not ideal for the current context.
- EGreg 10y agoIt doesn't matter what they use. There is a lot of heat byproduct. Read this: https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist/ https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist...
- giarc 10y agoI imagine any pipes down into the hole will be insulated however there was some work looking at the changes in bacterial make up of soil surrounding these access lines. I can't find reference, but it was mentioned last time this idea was brought up on HN.
- StavrosK 10y agoI don't know if it's a matter of absolute temperature, as much as one of rate, ie that we need more rays to be reflected than are now. Relatedly, though, won't this cool the core?
- ant6n 10y agoOverall, the warming effect of greenhouse gases is 100x the warming effect of waste heat: http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/tss/ahf/ http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/tss/ahf/
- cowboysauce 10y ago>doesn't that heat up the Earth's crust and atmosphere more than the previous condition without the hole, therefore contributing to higher temperatures (and climate change) It's irrelevant when compared to the amount of energy from the sun. World energy consumption is roughly 5.4 * 10^20 Joules per year. This is 86% of the total energy from the sun that hits the Earth in an hour. It's like worrying over putting a single drop of poison into the ocean.
- mmwako 10y agoSomeone more knowledgable than me, please correct me... if they are drilling a hole in the ground and making steam come up from said hole, doesn't that heat up the Earth's crust and atmosphere more than the previous condition without the hole, therefore contributing to higher temperatures (and climate change), making it not that "clean" after all? Maybe cleaner than carbon/petrol, but not ideal for the current context.
- devrandomguy 10y agoThat's pretty dwarfy! But, can they pump magma to the surface, to defend their rocky fortress? I just hope that they are being careful not to drill through any adamantine formations. http://dwarffortresswiki.org/index.php/DF2014:Raw_adamantine http://dwarffortresswiki.org/index.php/DF2014:Raw_adamantine
- logfromblammo 10y agoPraise the miners! I firmly believe that the technology to pump water that turns the waterwheel that powers the water pump (and also something else) must be extracting geothermal energy. We just don't see the details. %% It would be a whole lot cleaner (and friendlier to the framerate) to have a 3x3 geothermal power plant building with a magma reservoir under one tile, and a water reservoir under another, which transmits power to mechanisms or axles touching it, and maybe also pressurized steam to any pipe touching it.
- chris_va 10y agoI'd be careful about getting too optimistic. Conventional geothermal is about 4-5 cents/kWh, on par with natural gas in the US. The dominant capital cost is drilling a large well (you need volume), and so geothermal plants are generally only built in areas that require shallow (1km) wells. Well costs are ~quadratic in depth. Given how much money has already been spent optimizing drilling for the oil&gas industry, along with how cutthroat that market is, I don't see the cost coming down significantly. As a result, deep geothermal will likely be limited to niche regions like Iceland. And you need deep geothermal to scale it past the existing locations. I would love to be wrong, since geothermal checks all the boxes for renewables and is also suitable for base load power, but I don't see an obvious path forward short of a drilling tech miracle. (source: Climate and Energy R&D group)
- phreeza 10y agoA bit late to the party but i wanted to back this up by linking to the relevant chapter from the fantastic book by David MacKay: http://withouthotair.com/c16/page_96.shtml http://withouthotair.com/c16/page_96.shtml The chapter is only 4 pages long and he quickly works out that if done sustainably, even blanketing the entire country with geothermal plants could provide at most 2 kWh/day per person in the UK. Current consumption is about 125 kWh/day per person. So even without the capex argument, it is just not a very efficient source of energy long-term.
- therealdrag0 10y agoYour statement should be qualified with "for the UK region". > Other places in the world have more promising hot dry rocks, so if you want to know the geothermal answers for other countries, be sure to ask a local. But sadly for Britain, geothermal will only ever play a tiny part.
- gtvwill 10y agoIt can get pretty crazy the resources consumed by a drill rig during the average week drilling. New bits, roughly 1200 or so liters of fuel every 24 hours, all kinds of sacrificial bits of tube if they are core drilling their holes. Any hundreds of liters of drilling fluids depending on down hole conditions. I was blown away by the consumption when I saw it first hand. The fuel and drilling bits were the craziest. Then all of the maintenance consumables that you go through as a result of running 24/7. I shudder to consider the quantities of hardware consumed to drill 4km+ you would get all kinds of crazy hard rock down there, not to mention the time it would take for rod pulls.
- greatNespresso 10y agoThis looks like the beginning of the shinra to me
- cmbuck 10y agoYes, this seems much better than coal/oil, but isn't there a finite amount of heat under Earth's crust? Have we studied what would happen if we cool Earth's internal temperature by extracting heat in this way? The Magnetoshpere which protects us from radiation is generated by the magma under the crust[1]. Eventually, if we interfere with the magma currents too much, don't we run the risk of damaging our magnetosphere? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth%27s_magnetic_field#Physical_origin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth%27s_magnetic_field#Physi...
- everyone 10y agoI would just guess off the top of my head that, because of the sheer volume of the earths interior and the amount of energy stored there as heat, the energy to run our entire civilisation for 1000's of years would be trival compared to it. http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/Geophys/imggeo/earthsect2.gif http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/Geophys/imggeo/ea... The 4.7 km well is still in the earths crust, not even reached the lithosphere. As far as the earths interior is concerned it might just be like an era of slightly increased vulcanism.
- Retric 10y ago> isn't there a finite amount of heat under Earth's crust? We can't make meaningful change over the next million years which is vastly past any reasonable projections. The earth is 6 * 10 ^ 24 kilograms. Changing that much mass by 1 degree would take ~2000 Joules * 6 * 10 ^ 24 kilograms, but we don't get 100% efficiency so let's say it's 10% for a nice low estimate to get 1.2e + 27J. Worldwide energy use is 5.67 × 10^20J / year. So circa 2 million years of total worldwide energy supply for a 1 degree change. Of course it's not a static value as nuclear reactions and tidal friction are also adding energy, while energy also slowly escapes though the crust.
- cmbuck 10y agoThank you for this analysis. A 1 degree change over 2 million years strikes me as rather unlikely to meaningfully affect magma currents
- idlewords 10y agoDo you want to get firemonsters? Because this is how you get firemonsters.
- tonystubblebine 10y agoWhen I was in sixth grade I entered a science contest to invent a new form of clean energy. Mostly I entered because I was getting a B in my science class and needed extra credit to get up to an A. And the thing I "invented" was literally what's in this article, geothermal power. Pump water down near magma, have it turned to steam, have that steam come rushing back up to power turbines. The problem with my invention was that the company sponsoring the contest was a geothermal energy company. I'm still proud of myself though, because I thought of the idea independently and it is a pretty damn cool idea for how to get energy.
- Teknoman117 10y agoI'm at a loss a bit, are they directly tapping underground sources of hot pressurized liquid and not using some form of heat exhanger? How would they deal with various minerals dissolved in the water from gumming up their turbines or heavy elements escaping into the environment? IIRC there was one geothermal plant (in one of the nordic countries, i don't recall which) sitting by hotsprings that had to replace their piping every few months due to mineral deposits... random thought: Could geothermal power be considered nuclear power considering half of the Earth's internal energy comes from decaying radioactive isotopes?
- perlgeek 10y ago> random thought: Could geothermal power be considered nuclear power considering half of the Earth's internal energy comes from decaying radioactive isotopes? Only to the extend that all power is nuclear power. Solar power: the sun is a huge fission reactor. Coal: ultimately got its energy from the sun. Etc.
- IanCal 10y agoNitpick: the sun is a huge fusion reactor.
- akiselev 10y ago> How would they deal with various minerals dissolved in the water from gumming up their turbines or heavy elements escaping into the environment? This kind of ongoing, predictable maintenance is usually priced into the project, along with a health margin for error, and is rather easy to predict (except when you're one of the first such power plants using a new technology or exploiting a new geography). According to [1], the upfront capital cost for a geothermal plant is 5-6x that of a natural gas plant ($/kW) and the maintenance cost is over 10x ($/kW-yr) but since geothermal doesn't require expensive fuel it can be cheaper than fossil fuel based power (depending on price of fuel). Replacing pipes every few months isn't any different than buying tons of gas if you're still making profit and since geothermal plants rarely run more than 90% of the year because of diminishing returns, there's plenty of time for that maintenance. > random thought: Could geothermal power be considered nuclear power considering half of the Earth's internal energy comes from decaying radioactive isotopes? Technically yes, but nuclear power implies a concentrated sample of radioactive material. Radioisotope thermoelectric generators [2], which generate power from the heat of decaying isotopes, are relatively common nuclear power sources in space exploration. They were used on the Apollo 12-17 missions, they still power the Voyager 1 and 2 spacecraft, Cassini, and many more including, most recently, the Mars Science Laboratory rover. [1] https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/capitalcost/pdf/updated_capcost.pdf https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/capitalcost/pdf/updated_capcost... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_generator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_ge...
- Reason077 10y ago"The Institute of Economic Studies at the University of Iceland said in a February report that the country will not be able to abide by the COP21 climate change agreement signed in Paris in 2015. Greenhouse gas emissions are rising in all sectors of the economy, except in fisheries and agriculture, it said." This is unfortunate. Given Iceland's cheap & abundant renewable energy (2X Norway's electricity production per capita!), they really ought to be following the example set by Norway and prioritising Electric Vehicles through tax policies, etc. It would be easy to build excellent charging infrastructure for EVs in this island nation - instead you have hordes of tourists driving around the ring road in smelly diesels. I do see a few Nissan Leafs around Reykjavik and Akureyri, but there is barely any public charging infrastructure for driving between cities and tourist attractions.
- awqrre 10y agoIt would be cool to 3d print rock structures using magma from below
- hwillis 10y agogeothermal doesn't use magma, which would destroy the borehole. Its just a hole into very hot rock somewhat near magma. It's still far enough away that water/steam can flow in between the rocks. Steam is what comes up the hole.
- rconti 10y agoIceland has discussed building a ~7TW (I think?) cable to transmit power to the UK. At least in Reykjavik, hot water is piped directly into homes and used for heating (radiators) as well as hot water (with attendant sulfur smell). My host there told me "my wife doesn't like the smell so, we use heated cold water instead". I had to think for a few seconds to parse the phrase "heated cold water". Oh, right, that's what I call "hot water" :) It's so abundant, they don't mind the waste. Just leave the windows above the radiator open, the radiator keeps the room warm, you get fresh outside air inside, and the convective flow keeps the air moving. That chilled water is sent back to the geothermal plant and pumped back into the ground to replace the water taken out. IIRC there are definitely been geological issues (earthquakes) as a result of this whole process.
- avar 10y agoMost of your comment is wrong. They've been discussing building a 1GW cable. 7000 times smaller than 7TW. A 7TW cable would be enough to transmit Iceland's yearly electricity production 700 times over. It produces ~10GW per annum. Hot water is not piped directly into the homes in Reykjavík, it's heated up "cold" water, with artificially added sulfur. See another comment of mine here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14274085 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14274085 In Reykjavík the water you use is not recycled in any way, it's pumped into a sewer from there into the ocean. It's definitely not pumped the >50 km back to Nesjavellir for reprocessing.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rconti 10y agoThank you for the corrections. I was in the datacenter but now I've googled it and found the information about the 1GW cable: http://www.atlanticsuperconnection.com http://www.atlanticsuperconnection.com I'm very surprised to find that the hot water is heated cold water. Where is it heated? Offsite, with geothermal plants, I must assume? Otherwise I'd be VERY confused about how my host would not know that he had 2 separate water heaters. Seems quite odd that a local would not know this, but I guess that's how rumors work. Is the hot water in radiators similarly offsite-heated water?
- zoom6628 10y agoInteresting . NZ has had a geothermal plant for decades that is situated in a volcanic area (and right next to tourist hotspots of Rotorua and Taupo). They force cold water down and use the steam to drive turbines. No idea on the efficiency but the fact its been operating for decades would suggest its good enough to be viable.