8 ms·
Greenspun: Let's stop investing in our kids
- ilkhd2 16y agoRead the article. Visited link to Wikipedia article? Daymit, how you can SURVIVE on 35K a year in USA??? Maybe somewhere in Mississippi, but not in North USA. Still, you'll have to eat random crap from 7-11 and macdonalds...
- thecombjelly 16y agoI and many of my friends survive on less than 10K in the USA. Even Derek Sivers (from Mixergy interview) claims to live on 20K or less.
- pyre 16y agoAnd that is able to cover: shelter, food, health care, transportation, electricity, internet? I'd really be interested in seeing a break-down of costs and how that is possible. [Note: I realize that electricity and Internet are not necessary to survive, but the person claiming to survive on $20K/year obviously has both.] [Aside: I hope that the answer doesn't come down to something stupid like, "I invested $1-million in making my house/property as self-sufficient as possible." That kinda excludes a good portion of the population from trying.]
- nostrademons 16y agoA couple friends of mine have done it - they're both physics grad students in Boston. I don't know the full breakdown of their finances (nor would I share it on the Internet if I did), but I know rent and transportation and can fill in the rest from my experience: Person 1: Rent = $600/month (1 roommate in a small condo on a bus line) Transportation = $0 (walks to work/store/bank) Health care = ~$0 (grad school presumably covers it, modulo co-pays) Food = ~$200/month (guessing at this, lives on lots of rice & beans) Electricity = ~$50/month (also guessing) Internet = $0 (uses it from work if necessary) Total = $850/month = $10k/year Person 2: Rent = $400/month (basement apartment with 3 roommates) Transportation = ~$130/month (T-pass, off Green Line) Food = ~$200/month (guessing) Health care = ~$0 (presuming he's under the university policy) Electricity = ~$50/month (guessing, may be less with 3 roommates) Internet = ~$10/month (you could split $40 cable or FIOS among 4 roommates) Total = $790/month = about $9500/year. It's amazing how many necessities really aren't if you're willing to compromise on things like appearances, location, status, etc. Even in Silicon Valley, you can get rents of $600/month if you're willing to share a place in Sunnyvale or one of the poorer sections of Mountain View, and you can get really cheap food if you're willing to eat various rice/beans/pasta dishes. And many people seem to forget that they have two legs and can walk places: I'm in sprawled-out Silicon Valley, not densely-packed Boston, and yet I walk to the bank/library/supermarket and bike to work.
- ilkhd2 16y agoOk, but they have free healthcare (at least 400$/month worth), live in miserable living conditions (3 roommates in a basement), and have 0 savings. And, apparently they walk naked. Do not forget to add taxes. And waterbill. And trashbill. And phonebill. My observations are in total correspondence with Daniel Kanemann's research: For good life in USA you need $60K/year - more will not make you happier, less will make you unhappy.
- nostrademons 16y ago3 roommates in a basement is only miserable living conditions when compared to the McMansions that people are moving into now. My dad grew up in a 3rd world country. His family would be considered upper-class within their city, and yet they had 10 children crammed into a couple rooms, geckos in their living spaces, and mosquito nets to keep away the malaria. And they got bombed out of their home by the Americans, and had to move up into the mountains, shit in the river, and use stones to wipe their ass. I included waterbill and trashbill in my utilities estimates; I was basing it off what I paid for utilities when I lived with roommates in California. Person 1, at least, didn't have a landline - he used his cell (still on his parents plan) or IM from work. Person 1 also did not have zero savings: he managed to save up $20K over 2 years. Remember, a typical grad student salary is about $20k/year, and he was living off $10K/year. People who make $10-20k/year don't pay much in taxes. Many don't pay anything. That's reverse-income-tax land. You have a point with clothes, but over the short term, it can be ignored. I'm still wearing some of my clothes from high school, 10 years later. And you certainly have a point about health care, which is the elephant in the room, though that will hopefully get better as Obama's plan phases in. I suspect that Daniel Kanemann's research could be rephrased as "For a good life, you have to be making more than average." It's not coincidence that $60K/year is just slightly more than median household income in the U.S. I suspect that if he were to run the same experiment in Vanuatu - supposedly the happiest place on earth - he'd find that you need roughly $5K/year for the good life. That's just slightly over their per-capita GDP.
- ojbyrne 16y agoPeople who make 10-20k a year still pay FICA. I did some rough calculations and someone making $400 a week in California will pay 20% in federal and state taxes, medicare and social security.
- steveklabnik 16y agoHere's a rough look at my finances. I currently take home $2k a month, and live in the city of Pittsburgh, for reference. I live in one of the nicer neighborhoods in the city, though I managed to find a pretty cheap place. Rent: $325/mo ($950 split three ways) Student loan bills: $500/month Fios/gas/electric: $70/mo, (again, $210 split three ways.) Food: I eat out a fair bit, so probably like $500/mo, on average? I could cut down on this a lot if I tried. Transportation: I bike everywhere. Spent $600 three years ago. Phone: $60/month, Nexus One on T-Mobile with unlimited data/text, small amount of minutes that I never use. I don't currently have health care. That puts me at roughly $1450 of spending. I'm sure I'm forgetting something minor. But for just expenses, that'd end up being $17,400 / year.
- teaspoon 16y agoJason Rohrer is an American programmer whose family has annual expenses of less than $15k: http://hcsoftware.sourceforge.net/jason-rohrer/supportMyWork.php http://hcsoftware.sourceforge.net/jason-rohrer/supportMyWork... From the sound of it, they're not living on Big Macs. But they do live an unconventional lifestyle and have made material sacrifices to minimize their consumption.
- ilkhd2 16y agoI think, his parenting rights has to be taken back. He buys toys for kids used - which is very unhealthy. And he will not be able to buy cutting edge or very good stuff this way. No new books kids - Nope! Dad knows better. No new dress - nope! Dad has THE idea! In case of emergency he will not be able to pay for care for kids, unless he depend on government provided healthcare (do not get me wrong, I am "socialist" myself and I am pro-government-run-care), which unreliable, and does not cover many things. My opinion - yes you have to try to live cheap life, but not by buying used stuff - somebody else, with not really cheap life bought it first, but buying inexpensive stuff and using as long as possible, till it falls apart.
- ebiester 16y agoThere's a difference between survival and a middle class lifestyle. For those of us who have lived poor at some point, it's a point of privilege to have all of these luxuries. Even so, if you look at the lifestyle of a single person on 35k a year, it's vastly superior to that of someone in the 1980s in many aspects, with health care and real estate as major exceptions.
- ilkhd2 16y agohmm..Not sure. 35K in 1980 were a lot bigger money :). Superior by the way because of globalization - which created better (?) material supply, but made jobs in USA horrible trash.
- blehn 16y agoReally, it's not that hard. Conservative estimates: Wages: 35k Taxes: 10.5k Rent: 1000/mo = 12k Utilities: 200/mo = 2.4k Transportation (car): 200/mo+200/mo = 4.8k Food: 400/mo = 4.8k Total: 34.5k Get a roommate, use public transportation, get rid of TV, make your own meals, and you could probably put 5-8k in the bank each year. Even if you're living in NYC, it should be pretty easy to "survive" on 35k a year.
- BrandonM 16y agoFor me (the differences) -- Rent [1]: 300/mo = 3.6k Transportation [2]: 100/mo = 1.2k Food [3]: 250/mo = 3k Total: 20.7k Obviously that leaves a lot of things out, but that is what the other $14K+ is for. If you can't live on 35K, I'm guessing it's because you're either carrying too much debt, or you've convinced yourself you need to spend $X/mo on a car/living in <expensive city>/whatever when you really don't. [1] Right now I actually am renting an entire house with one roommate and we each pay $125/mo, but we are renting from a friend. Before I moved here, I paid about $240 a month. I could easily find a place under $300/mo here in Columbus, OH. [2] I don't have a car right now; instead I use public transportation or ride with my roommate or other friends. Even giving my friends gas money and renting a car once a month or so would only come to 1-1.5K per year. [3] I could easily get by on about $125/mo for groceries. Doubling that allows me to go out a couple times a week as well.
- HeyLaughingBoy 16y agoPeople do it all the time. I had a friend who never made more than $20k her whole life and yet was able to own her own house (a tiny cottage here in the Minneapolis metro area), have a running car (bought used and maintained properly) and eat well (cooked her own meals, rarely ate out). I haven't talked to her in about 7 years, but as far as I know, she's doing fine. I lived alone with no roommates in Fairfield County, CT (a pretty expensive area) for more than 5 years while making less than $30k and was perfectly happy. It just requires managing your finances well.
- steveklabnik 16y agoI've never made close to 35K. I've been self-sufficient for the last 4 years or so, and I was living on roughly $17k for most of that, and I'm living comfortably on $24k right now. I mean, Pittsburgh is a cheap city, but still, I live in the city. If I lived in the 'burbs I could do it for less. Well, maybe not, needing a car would probably make up the savings in other expenses.
- houseabsolute 16y agoI can't take an article seriously that claims we'd be better off without doctors and hospitals. Whatever fallacy that's called, I'm definitely guilty.
- shin_lao 16y agoThat's not quite what it says. It says that we're paying too much for the service we get in return.
- houseabsolute 16y ago> Just as we’ve produced a health care system so expensive that we’d be better off without doctors and hospitals This is what it says.
- shin_lao 16y agoNo one seriously believe we don't need doctors and hospitals, and probably not the author. But when you say "it's so bad we would be better without", you imply - through exaggeration - that the system is very bad. It's like when you say "I'd rather die than watch that movie".
- houseabsolute 16y agoIt reads to me like he is embracing a belief in a fact, not a rhetorical exaggeration. YMMV. I think the whole article is idiotic so I am perfectly ready to believe that the author has other stupid beliefs as well.
- sliverstorm 16y agoDid you read the other article it was referencing? The basis of the argument was Mexicans have a life expectancy of 2 years less than Americans, but massively smaller health care bills. The stipulation is that the return we get (2 years more life) is actually smaller than the cost (in terms of time worked, stress, etc) to bring it about. In other words, you give up 4 years of your life to your work so you can live 2 years longer. So, by giving up the 2 years greater life expectancy (cutting out/back/down hospitals and doctors) we'd get more back. Not necessarily saying I agree, but I did want to point out that the argument isn't QUITE as fanciful as the reference might make it sound. edit: it's all cool if you know the argument. Just wanted to make sure nobody was going solely off the sensationalist reference.
- younata 16y agoOr, we just learn to be more frugal when it comes to higher education. It doesn't matter at all where I get my diploma from, I just need one to get anywhere. If I can manage to go to a public college and pay <10k a year for it, that's awesome. If I can get other people, such as scholarship places, or the university itself, to give me enough money, I can essentially get a "free" higher education. I have a good friend whose family is paying nothing for him to attend UCLA. Personally, I'm not so lucky/dilligent about applying for scholarships.
- gaius 16y agoThe value of a Harvard (or any elite college) education is not in what you learn but in the brand name. That is what people are willing to pay a fortune for. And the brand name does have a value associated with it - it cuts down on the friction of getting through the initial stages to an interview at which a hiring decision will be made, for example. Is this right or wrong? Well, if historically graduates from a certain college have been a safe bet, then there is value for an organization in continuing to hire from there (even if only in time saved). If historically access to an alumni network is valuable, then that has value. Etc, etc. That's not to say they don't offer a great education, and a great experience of being immersed in a world where everyone is smart and ambitious for a few years. Similarly that immersion is part of the education. But that is another little secret: elite colleges only admit students who would succeed regardless. I attended an elite college for undergrad (which one doesn't matter) and viewed from that side, it's hard to see if it actually made a difference in my career vs any college. I've never explicitly seen an interviewer be impressed by it. But behind the scenes, for example, I don't see if there were a hundred applicants and mine made it through the initial screening because of that.
- rdtsc 16y agoIn some fields the value should be better determined by one's previous work (the portfolio). That has traditionally been true for designers and artist for example, but today it should also be true for software developers. There are so many open source projects that companies should be asked "what open source project have you contributed to?" and "show and explain that code to me". Basically that is what got me my job. My GPA was high and I worked my butt off for 5 years to get it, but it was a small open source project that got noticed and used as the basis of selection.
- houseabsolute 16y agoThe article pretends - That the current salaries of recent college graduates represent their probable average output over their lifetime. This is absurd for reasons that I hope I don't need to explain to all you startup founders. - That the salary of a graduate is a total representation of that person's value to society (and, transitively, of their education). This is wrong even if you think the total value of an education is in employment. Economics teaches us that for all voluntary economic transactions there are producer and consumer surpluses. It must therefore be the case that an employed person's value to their employer is at least the salary the person is paid. And as cynical as I am about college education sometimes, even I don't believe that the complete value of the education is in its utility for the labor market. - That there is a reliable way to make a ten percent return on investment overseas. Not as far as I've been able to find, and if you can find it you could probably make a lot of money selling the information to a big player in the American bond market. - And that the normal personal investment into a college education is really $300,000. This is anti-factual. It is probably also wrong that each marginal elementary schooler costs $200,000, but I can't say for sure about that. As rhetoric, this article plays well. As honest observation of the American educational system, it's a miserable failure.
- three14 16y agoYou're right about the article itself, but you're missing the context. Greenspun has had a long series of nuggets of cynicism that make up most of his blog posts. Together, they paint a picture that gives more excuse for his cynicism. - Public employees make up an ever growing percentage of the workforce, which still has to be paid for by the private sector. - Many public employees have large unfunded pension obligations that are very hard to cut. - As such, new graduates need to have lots of earning power to keep the whole country running. - His experience with college graduates both in the computer field and the in the context of flight school and his reviews of curricula imply to him that students actually learn very little, and are no more prepared than non-U.S. students to generate lots of value. - His exposure is mostly to Boston area students, who on average pay a lot for school, or someone else does via scholarships. So I don't think he means the blog post literally, but in context he's just offering another data point that supports his thesis that the U.S. in economic trouble in the medium to long term.
- Destruct1 16y agoa) He compares a 300k education over 4 yeards with an average master degree income. I have no idea about prices in the US but i would be very surprised if the decent, but not stellar schools have a 50k/year tuition (using 100k as living expenses). b) We have the same discussion in germany where universities are free. The general consensus about getting a degree seems to be that it is barely worth it (considering opportunity cost and taxes on higher income). c) I think we see a shift in the value of college degrees and need to change our mindset. In the old days only a small percentage of the population had a degree, yielding a guaranteed job and good career opportunities. Today nearly everybody has a degree and therefore the value goes down. I think people have to learn that a degree is not the road to riches and that they actually have to work and learn to get a good job. Another myth is this: I can have the same job my father had and he didnt need a college degree. That is just plain wrong. To do the same job your father did, you need a much higher education today. Accountant with a short certificate in the old days become B.A. in economics today. Simple configuration which might be done by a clever industrial mechanic in the 60s need a complete engineer degree today.
- teaspoon 16y agoThe $300k includes opportunity cost. That means it's tuition plus living cost plus four years of whatever after-tax salary you can make with a high school degree.
- gaius 16y agoInterestingly I was in Berlin a few weeks ago, people I chatted to said the point of a degree was that you were covered by healthcare (?) while an undergrad, so it was normal to stretch a degree out as long as possible, into your 30s if you could. I also learnt that Berlin is not at all like Frankfurt, where I've worked!
- oliveoil 16y agoHow about an added value in a well educated person. Like he or she feels better about themselves, is more likely to contribute to society with things as art (or open source software) as well as more likely to succeed starting a new business and bring in even more of that MONEY.
- rjurney 16y agoLets start investing in our kids across the board. State and federal funding for schools is inadequate. Wealthy areas invest additional money in education to bring the quality up to acceptable. Poorer areas cannot do so. Its an injustice that children from less affluent areas cannot get a good education in a public school, cannot have the same educational opportunities as students from more affluent areas. Inequality in education is one of our most pressing problems, and yet nobody talks about it because it doesn't effect the affluent.
- jancona 16y agoIf we don't invest enough why are per pupil expenditures highest in poor quality urban districts? Perhaps the "investment" isn't being well-spent--which I believe is Philip's real point in the OP.
- rjurney 16y agohttp://nces.ed.gov/pubs2010/expenditures/tables/table_03.asp?referrer=report http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2010/expenditures/tables/table_03.asp... $10,300. That is what we actually spend per pupil as a nation. Look here: http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2010/expenditures/tables/table_01.asp http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2010/expenditures/tables/table_01.asp See the large variance in state and local spending? Much of that is inequality. To address your question: your assertion is factually incorrect. Some cities spend more in inner city schools, and some spend less. The real inequalities lie in rural schools.
- patrickgzill 16y agoI think HN has missed one of Greenspun's points - that we always talk about "investing in our children's future" but never actually consider whether the investment (usually of public money, i.e. tax dollars for K-12, then crushing debt from the parents for college) actually stands the test of financial sense.
- sprout 16y agoNo, I think that's specifically the point I take issue with. An educated polity is a social necessity in a democracy - and we are failing at creating an educated polity. So there's no question to me that educating people stands the test of financial sense. It's a question apart from finance, and essential to our future. However, I do think it's fair to ask whether the money being spent is more than is necessary to properly educate our citizens.
- joe_the_user 16y agoRather, I would say HN is calling Greenspun on the point that "investing in our children's future" shouldn't be treated as an individaul economic decision but rather as a social decision. For the individual trying to educate their children, the motivator has historically been the effort to move up in social class but by extension, it's an effort to give the children a richer and more diverse life with more economic opportunity being only a fraction of this. But education has also traditionally been a priority for society rather than simply individuals. Theoretically, the US as a whole benefits if tomorrow more-skilled US workers are paid the same amount for doing the same job than less-skilled US workers were doing yesterday. This works better in practice if we're talking about either auto workers or programmers rather than about fast food workers.
- houseabsolute 16y agoI'm calling Greenspun on the fact that, if you want to make the argument that the investment is bad, using ridiculously overstated made up numbers is not an honest way to do it.
- blue1 16y agoSo the only reason for education is to produce more money?
- lr 16y agoAmerica (and we are not alone) is in a race to the bottom. Just like Coke and Pepsi spend more an more each year on advertising,-- because the other does the same -- doesn’t mean they are making that much more in profits each year. The same can be said for education: Costly perks need to be added because “the other guy is doing it”, and in the end, we just pay more for (mostly) what we had before. Seriously, has basic calculus changed so much in 30 years?
- dgordon 16y agoI would hope most students learn a lot more than basic calculus in four years of college.
- known 16y agoWhy not send American kids to China or India for education?
- antidaily 16y agoInvest in promising startups not Chinese Pizza Huts, goddammit!
- cageface 16y agoI went to public schools through high school and then, on scholarship, to the local public university. I doubt my family "invested" more than $10k in my entire education. Whatever it cost, it's certainly repaid itself many times over since then. The great thing about coding for a living is that most companies care more about what you can do than the name on your diploma.
- known 16y agoIn 1996, Ireland made college education basically free, creating an even more educated work force. http://www.nytimes.com/2005/06/29/opinion/29friedman.html?_r=1&pagewanted=print http://www.nytimes.com/2005/06/29/opinion/29friedman.html?_r...