7 ms·
Yes, Uber does have the right to remove you from their service, for mostly any reason -- probably even because they think you're a "narc". But Greyball went wa
by SilasX 10y ago
Yes, Uber does have the right to remove you from their service, for mostly any reason -- probably even because they think you're a "narc". But Greyball went way beyond that, and actively misled "suspicious" (probably sting agent) users into thinking cars would come, when they never did, wasting their time. That crosses over into interfering with an investigation -- the combination of "wasting someone's time" and "because that someone is an investigator".
Wasting the time of an abusive user? Probably okay. Kicking off law enforcement officers? Probably okay. Deliberately wasting the time of investigators? Probably crosses the line.
Compare two scenarios when an undercover officer is investigating a biker bar for dealing meth:
Scenario A: The officer seems somehow off to the bartender. Bartender glances around at his buddies, who shake their heads. "We don't want your kind in in here, get out."
Scenario B: Officer is identified as a cop. Bartender invites him to sit at a table far in the back with no view of anything. Any time the officer gets up, he's told to leave or sit back down. They have members stand within earshot of him and pretend to plan out fake meth deals at places where nothing will actually happen.
In A, the bar is on firm legal ground. In B, they're not, and that's basically what the Greyball program is.
Note: insights drawn from the earlier discussion about this https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13785564 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13785564
- MichaelGG 10y agoWhat if I think investigators are following me, so I get a friend to drive my car around all day, "wasting" their time. Am I now guilty of a crime? Seems like Uber did the same kinda thing.
- gertef 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obstruction_of_justice#Obstruction_trends https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obstruction_of_justice#Obstruc...
- ZoF 10y agoA real cogent and meaningful contribution. Thanks. If there is no formally defined investigation, how can you possibly call 'obstruction of justice.'
- nradov 10y agoIf the prosecutor is able to prove intent and you had committed some other crime as well then yes, you and your friend could potentially both be convicted of conspiracy to obstruct justice. This isn't some kind of game; judges don't look favorably on defendants playing tricks.
- inetknght 10y agoNote to self: if I find a car following me, I should immediately turn myself in to authorities or face "repercussions".
- wavefunction 10y agoIt would likely be the safe thing to do? Are you going to drive to your house or workplace and park and see what they do? Maybe the repercussions wouldn't be from the authorities, in your hypothetical situation.
- memmcgee 10y agoWtf are you saying?
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoYou're missing the other point. You had to also have committed a crime.
- MichaelGG 10y agoThat sounds as fake of a crime as money laundering. Certainly misleading officials that haven't identified as being on official business should not be a crime.
- derefr 10y agoThe point wasn't who you ended up misleading, but that your intent was to mislead investigators in particular. Throwing a brick off the top of a building into a crowded street is attempted murder, even if it doesn't hit anybody, because clearly you had intent to drop the brick on a person's head.
- mirimir 10y agoWell, there's civil forfeiture ;) I wonder if that's been used against Uber drivers.
- pyre 10y agoIf you believe that they are attempting to investigate you, and you intend to lead them on a wild goose chase, then it would be obstruction of justice. The word mincing that you're trying to do here is like trying to claim that murdering someone is just "moving some molecules around" and "moving molecules around isn't illegal." If you put into action a plan that's intent is to mislead investigators that you believe are attempting to investigate you, then how do you claim that this can't be obstruction of justice? They are attempting to obstruct the investigation. What you are doing to trying to evaluate the action separate from the intent, and claim that it's innocuous because there could be many explanations for the action. Obviously at trial, the DoJ would be trying to prove intent, so trying to ignore it doesn't really make sense.
- dorgo 10y agoSo it doesn't really matter what I do. If I have the intention to obstruct justice then I can stay at home and act criminally by doing so? Nice one. At this point I'm sure I'm a criminal. I don't know what my crime is, but I'm sure layers will tell me before they throw me into jail.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIntent is a factor. Also, even though law is like computer code in being pretty specific and executable, it's unlike computer code in being executed by humans. Or, like XKCD puts it, https://xkcd.com/1494/ https://xkcd.com/1494/. Or, more simply, judges are not stupid and can figure out if you're playing games with them.
- ForHackernews 10y agoIt does matter what you do. Criminal law recognizes two elements to a crime: mens rea ("guilty mind") and actus reus ("guilty act") http://law.jrank.org/pages/22506/Criminal-Law-Elements-Crime-Mens-Rea-Actus-Reus.html http://law.jrank.org/pages/22506/Criminal-Law-Elements-Crime... If there's no actus reus in your example, then there's no crime.
- cryptarch 10y agoWhat if you think it's a private investigator because they're plainclothes officers? Your points relating to Uber stand, I'm just wondering how it'd work in the case of an individual feeling like they are being shadowed.