4 ms·
Nobody was forcing Uber to do anything. They were trying to deny agents of public regulatory bodies the ability to assess them. That isn't any kind of 'right'.
by pvg 10y ago
Nobody was forcing Uber to do anything. They were trying to deny agents of public regulatory bodies the ability to assess them. That isn't any kind of 'right'.
- dangero 10y ago"right" is a moral judgement. It depends on whether you see this as civil disobedience. It may be "right" and also illegal at the same time.
- sqeaky 10y ago"Civil disobedience" is a term and group of actions used when fighting for racial equality during the civil rights movement. Equating that with anything uber, a multibillion international company, does is kind of gross.
- Dangeranger 10y agoThe law makes it pretty clear whether a business has the "right" to interfere with a criminal investigation. Disagreeing with a law doesn't give you the "right" to not follow the law.
- pvg 10y agoSince you can apply this to pretty much anything, this analysis is neither particularly insightful nor useful. It's a godwining in which you replace Hitler with Thoreau.
- wavefunction 10y agoYeah but Uber's behavior is definitely wrong.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y agoIf you look at civil disobedience as practiced by Martin Luther King, Jr and Gandhi, it was to highlight injustice by disobeying the law in question, and then accepting the full consequences of breaking the law. Breaking a law you dont like, doing shady things to avoid getting caught, and raising billions in investments is not at like civil disobedience and only cheapens the real civil disobedience that addressed great injustice at great personal cost to the people involved.
- sfilargi 10y agoI may be wrong but I don't think you can label something as "civil disobedience" when it is done by a corporation or when it is done for profit.
- wavefunction 10y agoI believe you to be correct in your understanding of what constitutes civil disobedience.
- sushid 10y agoI'm no fan of Uber, but if there are LEOs trying to use your product fraudulently (e.g. fake data, ordering an Uber not for a ride but to impound cars), doesn't it make sense to try and stop this sort of operation? If you had LEOs peering into your office windows (legal, but undesirable), wouldn't you want to at least have a blind to try and stop them from peeking?
- pvg 10y agoordering an Uber not for a ride but to impound cars Enforcement is not 'fraudulent use'. These analogies are very strained while the thing that took place is very simple.
- princeb 10y agono, doesn't really make sense. that'll be like arthur andersen shredding enron's financial accounts. can't investigate if there's nothing to investigate!
- dragonwriter 10y ago> I'm no fan of Uber, but if there are LEOs trying to use your product fraudulently (e.g. fake data, ordering an Uber not for a ride but to impound cars), doesn't it make sense to try and stop this sort of operation? If it's actually fraudulent, then, yes, you should stop it by suing and getting an injunction against the illegal government action. If it's just enforcing the law that you are breaking, maybe you should quit breaking the law rather than engaging in elaborate technical means to conceal the violation, and expecting that won't cause additional problems when it is discovered.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoA blind != a hologram projecting a false image while you do something illegal inside.
- MichaelGG 10y agoBut even that would be OK wouldn't it? Writing "Flour" on a bag before putting contraband powder in it shouldn't be illegal.