9 ms·
Who Wins and Who Loses in the Latest G.O.P. Health Care Bill
- kmicklas 10y agoCan someone explain to me how this can be passed off as anything but pure evil?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- shams93 10y agoThe comedy in this is that the Republicans will continue to scream about "the shrinking middle class" but when every policy is designed to benefit the wealthy elite at the expense of the center the middle class will not magically re-appear.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoVery much looking forward to see which Republicans in swing states get the boot next year.
- edgyswingset 10y agoI find your confidence in the stupid American voting population strange. In other words, I don't believe that they'll do anything like what you're implying they will.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoThis bill is going to end up killing people (through the removal of health insurance for the poor and those with "pre existing conditions"); even your most uninformed voter will come around once this starts being put into place. I'm hoping for riots, but will accept replacing representatives through the voting process.
- munificent 10y agoOur health care story in the United States has been killing people for decades, yet here we are.
- edgyswingset 10y ago> This bill is going to end up killing people I'm pessimistic that this will ever be known by those in swing states, let alone cared about. I've traveled to those places and met people there. They have normalized death due to medical complications and drug addiction. Why should more people dying make a difference there?
- maxerickson 10y agoRoughly half the people in a swing state would tend to be people that agree with you (because that's what a swing state is...). Edgy though, you hit that mark.
- badlucklottery 10y ago> the stupid American voting population That seems a little unfair. I'd say they're more insulated than stupid. But when people inside their bubble start losing subsidies and getting hammered with the true cost of coverage, that might be enough to break through to some of them.
- donatj 10y agoThe thousands I've paid because of the individual mandate sure didn't help my middle class status.
- CalChris 10y agoSo were you expecting free health insurance or were you expecting no health insurance?
- Avshalom 10y agoThe internet is full of people who seem to believe (at least for rhetorical purposes) that their insurances rates never went up before the ACA and were never going to go up, and they were never going to be dropped from their catastrophic deductible plan halfway through medical treatment for reaching a lifetime limit.
- tunesmith 10y agoWell, the 2% Medicare tax is, from their perspective, something that should never have passed in the first place. So repealing it is going back to a previous form of status quo. Beyond that, I think it's the basic philosophy that government should not be involved in funding health care for citizens (I think those high-risk pools are basically being set up to fail/abandon). I don't really understand it, because I don't see how the normal arguments of self-reliance and accountability translate to sickness, which is by definition out of our control no matter how self-reliant and accountable we are.
- lowtolerance 10y agoIf these people demanding taxpayer-funded healthcare were responsible enough to get real jobs before getting cancer, then we wouldn't be having this discussion.
- mevile 10y agoIs this satire? Are you serious? Do you know people get all kinds of illnesses at all ages and do you know that hospital bills are so high that even gainfully employed people in "real jobs" would have trouble paying for them with all their life savings? How much do you think a stay in the hospital is? How much do you think insurance will cost you if you have a medical condition? What if your insurance drops you or you lose it somehow and now you can't afford new insurance because you got sick?
- lowtolerance 10y agoI know sarcasm doesn't always translate, but dude... come on.
- kmicklas 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe%27s_law
- barrkel 10y agoHere's a different perspective: if the government is involved in paying for your healthcare, that gives voters a say in how you live your life. Taking too many risks? Like wine or soft drinks a bit too much? Maybe you enjoy rock climbing, or horse riding, or skiing, or some other dangerous activity? Well, maybe I don't want to pay for your risks, and I get to call you a drunk, fat and lazy, or foolhardy and reckless, needing more regulation and laws to keep you in your place - and your health costs low. We'll ban tasty food, nice drinks, and any activities that are more than a standard deviation or two out of the normal risk profile. We'll have a nice gentle bland life mapped out for you with low health costs. IMO the biggest elephant in the room is rationing. We can't give infinite healthcare to everybody for all their lives, particularly in very old age. We need to make hard trade-offs. In a free market system, the rationing is done by affordability and price levels: we choose who's more worthy of living longer by how much capital they've accumulated. In a more centralized system, we might choose to pay for interventions based on how much extra "life" they give, and ration by selecting a threshold for how much we pay for extra life year - this is how the UK NHS works, where life year is a QALY, quality-adjusted life year. But anything that doesn't address this elephant in the room, and appeals to emotions about the poor, sick, elderly, dying because they can't afford the treatment they need without considering who exactly we're going to leave to die and why, because we can't all be each other's caregivers for life, is intellectually bankrupt.
- muninn_ 10y agoNow, I'm in favor of single-payer healthcare. I can also understand the point of view of the "free market" health care solution. But calling a repeal of Obamacare "evil" is hyperbolic at best.
- ceejayoz 10y agoTaking away health insurance from 24M people isn't evil? Might need to recalibrate the evilometer.
- muninn_ 10y agoThat's quite the loaded question. If you're framing it as simply thus giveth, thus taketh then sure in a vacuum just taking healthcare away from people is evil (assuming a certain moral framework). But that's now what is happening here. There are some who believe that the government should stay out of healthcare (not me) and that prices will be lower, and care will be of higher quality. For them, repealing this act will move toward that outcome, which they believe to be good. There's certainly a philosophical argument to be made here. On the other hand, people such as myself believe that a nation should just provide healthcare for all citizens because we can afford to, and if managed properly (questionable at best considering the US government) could be cheaper and result in better care and will help make the United States more fair. So yes, I think it's quite hyperbolic to call the repeal of the ACA evil, and it's disingenuous to say that the repeal is simply "taking away health insurance from 24m people" as if that action is happening in a vacuum.
- badlucklottery 10y ago>But calling a repeal of Obamacare "evil" is hyperbolic at best. How about "profoundly amoral and uncaring"?
- muninn_ 10y agoAs I mentioned to another poster, it depends on your point of view. On one hand, I sympathize with people who believe in a minimal state, are are fearful of our (mostly shitty) government getting involved in the health care industry. It's uncaring if you believe that all people should have healthcare provided by the government and through taxation of other people whether they want it or not. It's not uncaring if you believe that people should provide for themselves. I am in favor of government run healthcare for a variety of reasons, but I don't consider the opposite point of view to be profoundly uncaring or amoral. In fact, I'd say that if you ignore that the intent of the ACA was to continue to entrench the government into the healthcare industry, it seems quite immoral to essentially guarantee corporate profits for health insurers. Neither the democrats or republicans in charge really want single-payer. I think at least the republicans are more honest about it.
- therobot24 10y agoChris: What do you do at a Young Republicans meeting? Alyssa: We help those who already have the means to help themselves. Also, we perpetuate the idea that Jesus chose America to destroy non-believers and brown people. Chris: I don't know why, but I feel safer already. Edit: clearly many on HN haven't seen family guy (http://www.familyguyquotes.com/quotes/779.html http://www.familyguyquotes.com/quotes/779.html)
- dvdhnt 10y agoThis is an ignorant and aggressive comment.
- raverbashing 10y agoLess aggressive than considering C-sections "preexisting conditions"
- dvdhnt 10y agoRegardless, attacking entire groups of people because elitists are doing so is childish and doesn't help the conversation.
- nojvek 10y agoI wonder Whether this will take 4 years to implement at billions of dollars of taxpayers cost. Then we switch presidents and the cycle begins again. This is where one would say "God save America"
- maxerickson 10y agoWho knows what gets through the Senate and conference. In any case, a single party Democratic government isn't real likely anytime soon, so anything that gets passed will be somewhat durable (Senate races in 2020 and 2022 will be hotly contested though).
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y ago
- tn135 10y agoThe healthcare bill was a lipstic on a bulldog to begin with and now it is more like a crayon on bulldog. Everyone is a loser here.
- rbanffy 10y agoI can assure you a lot of people who don't need to worry about paying health insurance will make some very handsome bonuses out of this.
- tn135 10y agoI don't think there is anything wrong in people making handsome bonuses out of this. In fact apriori I would love to invest in those companies. It is mostly the law firms I suppose.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ChairmanPao 10y agoAll they have to do is allow Insurance Companies to not cover one and only one preexisting condition: Obesity. This would be fair because this is the single biggest drain on our health care system and it can be cured for free, without medical care. Just eat less.
- credo 10y agoI have no pre-existing health problems (that I know of) and I get no government subsidies. The scorecard lists people like me as winners in the GOP health care bill. However, I think, most of us will lose from this bill, because we'll live in a country that is less fair * less fair (if you believe that a market-based approach to healthcare is unfair to people who are born with - or acquire - serious health problems, aka pre-existing conditions ...... and if you believe that poor people should get subsidies to let them get affordable healthcare)
- notacoward 10y ago> most of us will lose from this bill, because we'll live in a country that is less fair Most of us will lose, even financially. Uncertainty is a huge drag on business. Insurance is all about reducing uncertainty, and universal insurance is even more potent in that regard. Millions of Americans will now be less likely to change jobs or take other risks that might leave them exposed to a greater risk of catastrophic medical expenses. Lenders and businesses will have to adjust for an increased number of people defaulting on loans because medical expenses forced them into bankruptcy. In these and a dozen other ways, this regression on insurance is going to hobble the economy and end up hurting us all. BTW, I'm not at all trying to imply that it's only bad because it's bad economics. Far from it; I think the moral objections are even stronger. I'm just trying to explain how this change is wrong even according to the one criterion its proponents still (arguably) care about.
- tunesmith 10y agoWorth noting that the winners are mostly the people that are subject to the 3.8% medicare tax, which you don't see until after your first 250k of income, and is only subject to investment income. So, your average high-paid software engineer is still not going to be a "winner" in this case.
- davidf18 10y agoPeople who drive their cars recklessly and who speed pay higher auto insurance premiums. People who choose poor lifestyle behaviors (smoking, drinking daily Cokes, not exercising, drug use) were subsidized by those who "drove safely." Only with smoking were plans permitted to charge more (50%), but it was unverified and many plans did not offer different rates for smokers.
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y agoAnd to those born sick? Are we going to make our society a double jeopardy where not only do they have to contend with illness for their entire lives but also crushing medical debt?
- davidf18 10y agoI wrote: > "People who choose poor lifestyle behaviors" Most of the healthcare costs are from behavior, a much smaller proportion is from genetics. Insurance should be for insurance not to cover the negative externalities from choice. Do you really think that people who don't smoker, don't do drugs, don't abuse alcohol, don't drink Coke every day, etc should subsidize those that do? If that's the case, then we should be subsidizing people who speed and drive recklessly.
- frgtpsswrdlame 10y agoIf our options (as they are in this bill) are between people who live extremely healthily subsidizing those who don't live healthily AND those who were born sick vs. people who live extremely healthily helping neither then I'll take the first one any day of the week.
- davidf18 10y ago> "between people who live extremely healthily" I didn't say anything about "extremely healthily". I said people who don't smoke, who don't drink Cokes daily, who don't abuse drugs, who engage is some form of exercise. I also don't understand your sentence. It was wrong for the Democrats to put the financial burden of unhealthy lifestyle choices on others. Healthcare needs to be changed to fix that problem.
- a_humean 10y agoI think the cynical and only correct interpretation of this bill is that Republicans ultimate priority is to cut health provisions for largely sicker, older, and poorer Americans in order is to cut taxes for households with incomes above $200k via a budget reconciliation process that requires less than 60 votes in the senate. The Republican public campaign against ACA/Obamacare is a fraud masquerading as a campaign against all of the things people don't like about the ACA, which is its high premiums and deductibles, and incomplete networks. In fact this bill will literately deliver even higher premiums, higher deductibles, and more restrictive networks all to allow Paul Ryan to cut taxes without getting the Senate to press the nuclear button on the last vestiges of the filibuster.
- flukus 10y agoConsidering everyone knew this was coming and had time to prepare, can you point out how many blue states had legislation for single payer health systems ready to go? Either democrats don't seem to want it or they just want a nice wedge issue without actually doing anything.
- klipt 10y agoWon't that encourage red state inhabitants to not buy insurance, then when they get sick move to blue states and drain their systems?
- flukus 10y agoLimit it to people that have been residents for a certain period, say 2 years. Maybe even limit it against prior conditions for even longer. And verify it's a real problem. How many poor, sick people in red states have the economic mobility to move to a blue states?
- kcorbitt 10y agoThis legislation is a complete mess. That said, I'm bleakly optimistic that if it succeeds in breaking healthcare for enough people badly enough, the pushback may give us an actual shot at a single-payer healthcare system in the US in my lifetime.
- noobermin 10y agoThousands of people will die in the process, it's a high price to pay for a political win.
- mobiplayer 10y agoSingle payer is not a political goal, it objectively saves and improves lives.
- wayn3 10y agoSaving and improving lives IS a political goal.
- mobiplayer 10y agoThen everything is a political goal, and there's no point on you classifying anything as a political goal as to measure its value. "Too high price for a political goal" and "everything is a political goal" are not compatible. So, tell me, what's your point really?
- wayn3 10y agothe point is, one party values not redistributing money over saving peoples lives. the other does not. one of them got elected by poor rural people who really need the ACA. i dont think that political goals have value. theyre about the last thing to have "value". "Exterminate all jews" was a relatively popular political goal just a couple decades ago. As far as "valuable things" go, political goals range relatively low on that totem pole.
- llamataboot 10y agoIt's a GOP Bill? I don't even need to read the article. Winners: Rich people Losers: Everyone else
- llamataboot 10y agoI look forward to going back to the days where I couldn't buy insurance at any price because of pre-existing mental health conditions. Because you know what makes me a productive member of our glorious workforce? Not being able to get care.
- BigChiefSmokem 10y agoI'm "rich" (I make way over 250k) and even I feel this is completely wrong and unjust. I pay hundreds of thousands in taxes each year and am still thankful and grateful just to be in this country because I understand historically what it took to get us here. These people are truly heartless and self-interested in the most un-American of ways. I'm no Democrat by any measure but my party, the Libertarians, need to stand for more, stand in numbers, and replace the Republicans once and for all as the new face of conservatism in the 21th century. What these people are doing to our underclasses and disenfranchised groups is wrong.
- LyndsySimon 10y agoThe biggest deal here is that it removes the "individual mandate". Without the mandate, costs on the exchanges will got through the roof, so basically no one who doesn't qualify for a subsidy will be able to afford them. That said, catastrophic plans will once again be a viable option for many people. In short - it changed a flaws nationalized healthcare program into an expensive entitlement program for low-income earners.
- maxerickson 10y agoIt depends on what you expect the catastrophic plans to cover. In a lot of ways, the expensive, high deductible ACA plans are catastrophic plans. It just happens to be the case that they will actually cover a medical catastrophe, so they are expensive. A catastrophic plan that leaves the patient dead or declaring bankruptcy didn't really provide enough insurance. Also, it depends a lot on what you mean by low income earners, but a family of 4 on $65,000 is getting a bigger subsidy than a very low income single adult in a state that didn't expand Medicaid (http://kff.org/uninsured/issue-brief/the-coverage-gap-uninsured-poor-adults-in-states-that-do-not-expand-medicaid/ http://kff.org/uninsured/issue-brief/the-coverage-gap-uninsu... ).
- Overtonwindow 10y agoI'm torn about this legislation. Since obamacare passed I've had continually higher premiums which is pushing me to the breaking point. I support insurance for preexisting conditions, I don't believe insurers should be able to turn anyone away, for any reason. That said, I don't want the government running my healthcare, I don't want to have to buy insurance from the government, and I don't want to pay for the bad mistakes of others - that's difficult to do but that's my opinion. That all said, I think the media is still in the "fuck Trump" mode and no matter what the republicans or trump comes up with, the media is going to take a shit on it. All that being said, I don't think the issue is republicans, democrats, or trump. I think the issue with our healthcare is the insurance companies themselves, doctors, medical device companies, pharmaceutical companies, and everyone else who takes a cut, adds a surcharge, and has generally done all they could to squeeze every last dime for their shareholders. Like the big banks, I want to see reform of the health care INDUSTRY, and strict limits placed on what they can charge, whom they can charge, and the whole pile on, surcharge habit.
- krapp 10y agoYou can't have your cake and eat it too, though. Not covering preexisting conditions makes good business sense, as does not covering high risk or elderly people, as do many of the objections I've read about this. Maximizing profit and minimizing loss is exactly what businesses are supposed to do, and in the US, healthcare is a business in which anything but collecting premiums from the healthy and well off is an unnecessary risk. I don't think the healthcare industry is going to reform in the ways you want without the government forcing them to work against their self-interest, which likely requires some form of "the government running your healthcare."
- unprepare 10y ago>and I don't want to pay for the bad mistakes of others When some moron nail guns a board to his head and goes to the ER you are still paying for that. What you are now not paying for is people fighting cancer, MS, AIDs, and other long term and terminal diseases. What made you believe that this legislation would enable you to avoid 'paying for the bad mistakes of others'?