3 ms·
Without breaking the riser pipe connection to the rig an uncontained fire like this is pretty clearly going to sink it, boats next to it aren't going to be able
by hga 16y ago
Without breaking the riser pipe connection to the rig an uncontained fire like this is pretty clearly going to sink it, boats next to it aren't going to be able to keep it cool enough (you have seen pictures of the fire, haven't you?).
I think the Coast Guard oversaw the initial recovery, although many are questioning the decision to put out the fire and the failure of the Federal government to keep in stock fire booms as called for by a 1995? or so government study/recommendation for Gulf oil well blowouts.
- joezydeco 16y agoYeah, I've seen the fire. If you can't tame it like a land-based well blowout and let it burn, how does it sink the platform? The fire's hot enough to melt the metal and lose water-tightness? Why not let it burn while trying to figure out how to clinch the pipe from below?
- hga 16y agoAsymmetrical fire can destroy a steel structure by warping it. According to one analysis by a MIT materials science professor I've read of the fall of the WTC towers, what ultimately killed them was the difference in heat between the side that was facing the wind and the back side. The difference in expansion stressed the already weakened by heat floor supports to the point where cascading failures occurred. And as I noted, many people are asking the latter question, alhtough once the riser pipe detached and formed a shape like this (inverted V)_ on the sea floor that became much less clean of an option, one the Feds weren't in position to reconsider after putting it out due to their failure to procure fire booms ahead of time.