3 ms·
Ex fund manager here. Some things about this bet that need to be mentioned: - It should be risk adjusted. No idea how the numbers come out, but what's the sens
by lordnacho 10y ago
Ex fund manager here. Some things about this bet that need to be mentioned:
- It should be risk adjusted. No idea how the numbers come out, but what's the sense in comparing the return without the accompanying variance? For example if the S&P has 15% vol over the period but the hedge fund 30%, that factor of two needs to be taken into account somehow.
- Management fees of 2% are clearly too high for this day and age. They came about historically when hedge funds were collections of small amounts of money, happy to take large risks. If you're willing to have volatility of 36%, paying 2% a year is going to be different from paying 2% for 12% vol. Part of the reason vol is lower is institutional investors are not HNWs. I used to run a fund that ran 36% vol as a target, and the IIs came to us and said they couldn't present it to their superiors. The explanation that you could just put less capital in didn't seem to resonate with the box checkers. Must be something that Kahnemann and Tversky could illuminate.
- I'm not sure the thing about the S&P being unnaturally strong is a valid excuse. If you're a hedge fund, you are free to just do a leveraged play on the S&P, thus beating it if you think it's going up. Same goes for what will inevitably come up, the extraordinarily loose monetary policy following the crisis. Whatever caused the S&P to go up, you could have bet on it.
- The bets are against funds-of-funds, which compound fees. You might be paying 2/20 to the underlying funds and 1/10 to the manager of this portfolio. That's a pretty big chunk. Normally what the FoF says to its customers is they have access to funds that others don't, through good relationships gained over years. Though looking at the summary in Buffett's letter it looks like even if you added ~30% for the 10 years of fees to each group, you still wouldn't beat the S&P. But that's just my late night eyeballing, perhaps with the performance fee it would be in the ballpark.
- Buffett stipulated it had to be multiple funds-of-funds, probably because this would mean you'd get S&P with costs. What else are a bunch of mainly American hedge funds going to invest in, given you have hundreds of underlying funds? You might get the odd emerging markets fund, but they'll be swamped out by the hundreds of generic funds that just punt some US stocks. Restricting it to funds-of-funds is actually pretty smart, because FoFs are going to tend to be conservative and take a selection from the buffet (yeah I said that). Allowing individual hedge funds might have given a very different result.
- dsacco 10y agoYeah this bet was not a smart one for Ted given the terms. I'd gladly take it with a few slight revisions though: 1) The hedge funds don't have to be "funds-of-funds", and 2) I can choose the hedge funds. But I suspect Buffett wouldn't take that bet. He strikes me as someone who doesn't take bets without knowing pretty well in advance that he'll win. It also sort of alters the claim from "hedge funds as an industry will beat the S&P 500 overall" to "elite hedge funds can consistently beat the S&P 500." But given that he is a fund manager, I have no idea what Seides was thinking trying to claim the former.
- manyoso 10y agoYeah, its not like he gets paid to make smart bets or anything... oh wait!
- dsacco 10y agoWell it's good no one paid him for this bet because it was a shitty one. He could have chosen sensible options like Rentec or Baupost. Clear failure there...
- RockyMcNuts 10y agoIt was Seides's idea to make it funds of funds and he could choose them - http://archive.fortune.com/2008/06/04/news/newsmakers/buffett_bet.fortune/index.htm http://archive.fortune.com/2008/06/04/news/newsmakers/buffet... 5 hedge funds I'm not sure would make a lot of sense, too small a number to diversify, funds wind down. The hedge funds were winning for the first few years with the crisis. A straight up stock market is not great for the hedge fund side. Also worth noting that Buffett is an active manager and claims he could beat the S&P by a large margin if he was managing a smaller portfolio. And he's said the efficient market theory is dumb and makes his job easier. He tells people to put their money into index funds and then does the opposite. From his perspective he's talking his own book, if there is another Warren Buffett level talent out there, no need to tell everyone to find the best competition and back him, might as well tell people they're wasting their time, just buy the index.