7 ms·
Maybe I've read too many science fiction dystopias, but I think it will be interesting to see if any breakthroughs that this company makes are kept back to bene
by pmoriarty 10y ago
Maybe I've read too many science fiction dystopias, but I think it will be interesting to see if any breakthroughs that this company makes are kept back to benefit the Google elite or shared with the rest of society.
- DamnYuppie 10y agoI am sure they will be shared with as many people as can a) afford it and b) are of a similar mindset to the gate keepers.
- joe_the_user 10y agoWill it be: "Can afford it AND are of similar mindset" or would it be "OR". Just much, the ultimate cost is big question. The only way to make a breakthrough imo is some combination of procedures that cut the Gordian knot of current health care processes and ways to automate these processes. Together, this may be cheaper than artisanal Cancer care and research - well especially if it could be done without royalty payments in Costa Rica. So whether the knowledge gets out is a big question - cue the secrecy question again.
- pmoriarty 10y ago"Just much, the ultimate cost is big question." There's a really interesting Radiolab episode that deals with this question.[1] To quote from the episode: "What do you do if you have a really expensive drug that's really, really good? ... Everyone that I know pointed me to this new drug, it's called Sovaldi... it is a drug that treats Hepatitis C, which is caused by a virus, and the disease itself goes to work on your liver, it inflames it, it scars it, it can cause liver cancer, cirrhosis, it can be fatal, and for the longest time the treatments that they had weren't that great or they just had wretched side effects, and along comes Sovaldi. It's one pill, twelve weeks, you take it with some other antiviral meds, it's a super simple treatment option, and the side effects are very minimal. It was kind of like the wonder drug. So a lot of doctors start to prescribe it. In the first half of 2013 70,000 people in the United States were treated, and it had a 95% rate of cure, in other words the virus was erradicated... but this drug costs $1000 dollars a pill, for one pill that I take one a day..." Now imagine how much a cure for aging would cost. [1] - http://www.radiolab.org/story/what-year-life-worth/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/what-year-life-worth/
- joe_the_user 10y agoSure, priced like a contemporary drug, the price of a life extender would infinite. But then again, priced like a contemporary drug, the price of air or water would be infinite too. Fortunately, we have much of this around, so far, for nearly nothing (air more than water, so far again). What about the Hep C drug makes it expensive? The research? The production process? The patents racket? If you knew the recipe could you make it in your basement with some ingredient of modest cost? Of expensive cost?
- 65827 10y agoWe're google, we love you! As long as you're not a gunowner. Or whatever other group we decide to label as undesirables in the future.
- carapace 10y agoNo elixir for you 65827!
- lazaroclapp 10y agoFortunately, over a long enough time scale, it doesn't matter, the technology will eventually leak out of their control. If they come up with incremental medical treatments, well, then they will be under patents and initially only available to the wealthy in first world nations, but over time patents will expire and countries that don't care about patents will find ways to replicate the science. At worst it won't be different than any other medical advancements. If they come up with an immortality serum or something equally fantastic, I can see governments and nations just ignoring Calico IP claims under a "public interest" argument, anyways... I think you are overestimating the risk that "they will solve ageing, but be evil about it" and underestimating the obvious risk of "they won't solve ageing" (which, honestly, still probably means we get a lot of interesting science done in the process, so it is still worthwhile to try)
- pmoriarty 10y ago"over a long enough time scale, it doesn't matter, the technology will eventually leak out of their control" That long-term perspective may not be quite as comforting to someone whose loved ones are facing the miseries of old age and death while the elites hold the cure. Sure, eventually, in a 100 years, or 200 years, or who knows how many centuries or millennia, we'll all be equal in a Star Trek utopia, and everyone will have equal access to advanced life-extension tech, but by then those of us who might not have won the startup lottery or otherwise managed to siphon up enough money to matter will be long dead. As for patents, this tech might never be patented. It might be kept completely secret instead.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lazaroclapp 10y agoSure, but, I mean, will we get it sooner if private companies are not working on it at the same time as public research institutions are? If we don't have access to the tech because it is being hoarded, or because it does not exist, the effect is the same. I also think it will be hard to hoard it for long, particularly if it really works the way people are assuming it will work ("immortality serum" style). I think that's wishful thinking for now, and that at the very best we will get the Xerox PARC of ageing research, which, honestly, would be victory enough. > It might be kept completely secret instead. Easier said than done. Very few technologies are kept secret in that way. Keep in mind that even for the fission bomb, the Soviets got it fully replicated after just 4 years, and other countries soon followed suit. These days we are all in panic because even marginalized states can afford to build the damn things. The only reason not every developed country has a nuclear arsenal is not secrecy, but legal arrangements and joint defense treaties. Now remember that is literally the strongest conspiracy for scientific secrecy in the history of mankind, with good reasons and everything, and it involves a device for which manufacture is insanely expensive, not just R&D. Medical research is even easier to replicate given even partial information about its workings.