11 ms·
> The development of VR has been surprisingly tied to science fiction. Authors in the field have envisioned the futures that engineers set out to build Inciden
by minimaxir 10y ago
> The development of VR has been surprisingly tied to science fiction. Authors in the field have envisioned the futures that engineers set out to build
Incidentally, the high romanticism of VR one of the reasons why I am highly skeptical of the industry. The article argues "VR will also enable immersive concerts, reinvented museums, and live, court-side sporting events", but what is it doing now outside of games, which have been hit-or-miss? (the Samsung Gear VR commercials make VR look ridiculous, IMO)
AI is a similarly romantic industry, but the difference is that there are many practical, non-gimmicky applications of AI now and already implemented on your phones/PCs.
- erichocean 10y ago> what is it doing now outside of games I'm using room-scale VR to build and explore virtual film sets (HTC Vive, Unreal Engine) and scenes.
- avaer 10y ago> The article argues "VR will also enable immersive concerts, reinvented museums, and live, court-side sporting events", but what is it doing now outside of games, which have been hit-or-miss? It's literally doing all of the stuff you mentioned, if you look for it. The blocker is that most people don't have a headset to experience it. The same thing could be (and was) said about the early internet.
- smacktoward 10y agoWith the important difference that getting on the early Internet only required a telephone line, which everybody already had, and a modem, an inexpensive piece of hardware you did not have to physically strap onto your face.
- sbarre 10y agoNo it also required a computer, which a lot of people did not have back in the mid-90s, and not everyone was prepared to shell out the money to get one (it was certainly not "inexpensive" if you were buying one for the sole purpose of getting online). My source on this? I worked at one of the first consumer ISPs in Canada, and we regularly had people coming in to sign up because they heard about "this Internet thing" but did not have a computer. Most people thought we provided one with the service, and some people just didn't understand that you accessed the Internet through a computer.
- smacktoward 10y agoI left that out because VR also requires an expensive computer -- expensive at least compared to what most people have. Rift, for instance, requires not just a discrete GPU but a pretty serious one (GTX 970/1060 level), in a market where only about a third of PCs sold at retail in 2016 had a discrete GPU at all (see http://www.anandtech.com/show/10864/discrete-desktop-gpu-market-trends-q3-2016 http://www.anandtech.com/show/10864/discrete-desktop-gpu-mar...). So, if by "VR" you mean Vive/Rift-level VR, very few people will have a computer already lying around the house that can cut the mustard, even if they bought that computer relatively recently.
- plokiju 10y agoBuying a VR headset and a new gaing computer today is still significantly cheaper than buying a home computer in the 90's for the early internet https://pifflelab.com/2012/07/22/computers-the-1990s-you-paid-how-much/ https://pifflelab.com/2012/07/22/computers-the-1990s-you-pai...
- sbarre 10y agoI was not disputing your point that VR is expensive to get into (I own a Vive), but rather that getting online in the 90s was not expensive.
- avaer 10y agoIt also required ridiculous metered long distance fees, forced you to lock up the family telephone line, and buying and installing a modem was much harder without the help of the internet. I would advance the hypothesis that the prospect of the internet back then seemed much worse compared to dropping a few hundred to have Vive hardware shipped to your door and plugging it in. But the people who built the internet saw what it could be, not the garbage that it was. And we're still in the beta stages; this stuff only gets better with time.
- Pica_soO 10y agoLets not forget ruining two perfectly fine rubber plunger, if you did it DIY.
- jarsin 10y agoThe CEO of unity believes that AR/VR will be bigger than the internet and develop in much the same way [1]. Obviously he is biased but still pretty big statement from a CEO of the most popular game engine. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ODXMhaNIF5E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ODXMhaNIF5E
- haydenlee 10y agoBit of a cringey statement to say "bigger than the internet" considering almost every AR/VR application will rely heavily on the internet. I think the spirit of his statement was that it'll be bigger than the Web.
- JKCalhoun 10y agoHe meant to say "bigger than the Beatles".
- SimbaOnSteroids 10y agoNot really, platforms like the hololens are essentially the Commodore 64 of AR. It's neat, and has some practical application, but it can't quite deliver on its full potential. I don't know which AR headset will be the Windows/Apple of this technology but I can describe it. Lightweight, stylish, essentially a smartphone on your face. What AR not-so-obviously does is takes the internet and changes it from a limited access interface, wherein its a technology that has points of access that are limited to terminals that you have to actively access to an interface that you passively interact with. An interface that you have to seek out, to an interface that seeks you out.
- mbesto 10y ago> big statement from a CEO of the most popular game engine You mean someone that has a personal financial interest in a market growing is talking about how that market might grow. That's not very surprising to hear, don't you think?
- goatlover 10y agoCan't be bigger than the internet if it is one of the things that runs on top of the internet. It's like stating that computers are bigger than electricity.
- thenayr 10y agoOne good example as of late is The Wave VR. http://thewavevr.com/ http://thewavevr.com/ A crossover between game / social experience / musical fantasy. They have live shows once a week and have been gaining momentum within the VR community quite rapidly. Important to remember we are quite literally still just beyond the one year mark since consumer VR devices hit the market. It will only get better. I agree the Gear is not where VR is going in the future. You need full room-scale immersion to really "feel" like you are experiencing something truly new and exciting. 360 sports videos are NOT the future of VR.
- Nemo157 10y ago> Fans won’t have to travel the globe or miss out [...] - http://thewavevr.com http://thewavevr.com > This item is currently unavailable in your region - http://store.steampowered.com/app/453000/ http://store.steampowered.com/app/453000/ Really great internationalisation there. I'm guessing they're having the standard problem of not being able to get worldwide licenses for the builtin music.
- burkaman 10y agoI mean, did you click those links? All of those examples were things VR is doing now, not possibilities for the future.
- mattnewport 10y agoWe have paying customers for our VR surgical training - ossovr.com - I left the games industry in 2014 to work on non games VR applications because I believed (and still believe) that commercial applications of VR will be more profitable in the near term than games. Architecture is another field that is seeing rapid adoption of VR as a real business tool and not just a gimmick.
- strictnein 10y agoInteresting, I pitched VR training as part of a hackathon at [my very large employer] who offers platforms for employee training and onboarding. One of the studies I cited during my presentation was on VR surgical training [0], showing that it decreased surgeon error. I lost to a multiuser wiki document editor (think Google Docs, but less exciting). Because that's a huge market for a multi billion dollar company. No, I'm not bitter... sigh Another was how Siemens was able to reduce training times for oil rigs by significant periods [1] using VR tech. > "Architecture is another field that is seeing rapid adoption of VR" My architect is going to bring over a SketchUp model of the work he has planned on our house and I'll be loading it up with some software for the Vive [2]. He doesn't usually do that final step, but he's very interested in trying it out. [0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1422600/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1422600/ [1] https://www.siemens.com/innovation/en/home/pictures-of-the-future/digitalization-and-software/simulation-and-virtual-reality-immersive-training-in-virtual-worlds.html https://www.siemens.com/innovation/en/home/pictures-of-the-f... [2] https://www.kubity.com/ https://www.kubity.com/
- mattnewport 10y agoCool, we're in discussions with a major medical school to run a study to compare performance after training with one of our modules vs traditional training materials. Even outside of studies that specifically look at VR there is a lot of research into general learning, training and education that tends to support the hypothesis that VR will be a powerful tool for this type of application.
- Taylor_OD 10y agoNot quite architecture but I'd love to have a interior designer be able to see a vr version of my apartment or be able to see a VR version of a apartment instead of having to go apartment shopping. I believe stuff like this is out in the world but just not widespread enough yet.
- jraines 10y agoGoogle Earth VR is incredible, as one non-game example.
- haydenlee 10y agoimmersive concerts - TheWaveVR [0] reinvented museums - TiltBrush [1] court-side sporting events - NextVR [2] Not to mention architecture [3], communication [4], collaboration [5], medicine [6], 3d modeling [7], game development [8], film [9] and the myriad of other industries I'm forgetting. Also if you haven't tried any of the latest games on Oculus Rift or Vive you're really missing out. They've gotten incredible since the consumer launch last year. [0] http://thewavevr.com/ http://thewavevr.com/ [1] https://tiltbrush.com/sketches https://tiltbrush.com/sketches [2] http://nextvr.com http://nextvr.com [3] http://insitevr.com/ http://insitevr.com/ [4] https://web.facebook.com/spaces https://web.facebook.com/spaces [5] http://bigscreenvr.com/ http://bigscreenvr.com/ [6] https://www.technologyreview.com/s/601911/better-than-opioids-virtual-reality-could-be-your-next-painkiller/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/601911/better-than-opioid... [7] https://www.oculus.com/medium/ https://www.oculus.com/medium/ [8] https://blogs.unity3d.com/2016/12/15/editorvr-experimental-build-available-today/ https://blogs.unity3d.com/2016/12/15/editorvr-experimental-b... [9] https://www.oculus.com/story-studio/films/henry/ https://www.oculus.com/story-studio/films/henry/ *Disclaimer: I work or have worked for a few of these co's.
- strictnein 10y ago> court-side sporting events I still want to stand on the 50 yard line during a live game, or position myself wherever the action is, with fully realized 3D models of the players.
- kirrent 10y agoThat sounds like what virtually live is promising: http://virtuallylive.com/ http://virtuallylive.com/
- intrasight 10y agoI've long thought this to absolutely be the killer app for VR. And just imagine the advertising options.
- nostalgiac 10y agoNBA does this already. https://watch.nba.com/page/vr https://watch.nba.com/page/vr
- jamesrcole 10y ago> but what is it doing now outside of games Clearly VR is still in very early stages of its development, so I don't see how what's being done right now provides any valuable insight into its potential. > the high romanticism of VR one of the reasons why I am highly skeptical of the industry. Whether that romanticism exists or not doesn't change the technology or what can be done with it, so I don't see why that's a reason to be skeptical of it.
- sidlls 10y agoThere is a large market for training simulators that are essentially very advanced virtual reality systems.
- photojosh 10y agoIn Australia (NSW specifically) we have the requirement for learner drivers to complete 120 hours of accompanied driving time before they can get a solo licence. I think that's insane, and we should do what fighter pilots do... some hours of "normal" flying, and LOADS of time in a simulator dealing with extreme cases. So... know of any good VR driving sims that attempt to model commuter traffic?
- JauntTrooper 10y agoDesert Bus 2!
- blhack 10y agoThis stuff takes time. I know of at least one music venue that is currently being built with VR attendance as a major goal. For concerts and sporting events, you need the right cameras, video pipeline, and bandwidth. One potential camera is here: https://www.orah.co/ https://www.orah.co/ But how many music venues were built with the bandwidth requirements of high-resolution 360 streaming video in mind? My guess is almost none. The bandwidth to support things like that is an industry in itself. As far as after-the-fact concert attendance, I know that at least Red Bull had a major presence at Bonnaroo (a major music festival with an attendance of around 70,000) last summer, and they were shooting concerts with 360 cameras with the intent of sharing them online. (According to this article, they may have actually been live streaming, but I'm not sure: https://www.axs.com/bonnaroo-2016-to-be-livestreamed-on-red-bull-tv-83889 https://www.axs.com/bonnaroo-2016-to-be-livestreamed-on-red-... I know first hand that they were there shooting stuff on gopro rigs, though, which requires post processing, so probably wouldn't have been live)
- Para2016 10y agoI think it might be interesting to have VR use in the military. For example, small unmanned recon drones fly/move through an area, get a very detailed virtual environment, and then mission participants get a walk-through beforehand.
- cr0sh 10y agoDARPA has been using VR since at least the 90s for training. One of the main players in that area is a man named "Rudy Darken"; he was instrumental in quite a bit of the "Dismounted Soldier Training System (DSTS)" - and developed quite a few interesting input devices (one was a 360 degree treadmill with force feedback - think of two overlapping treadmills at 90 degrees to each other, with the surface made of rollers place parallel to the direction of travel of the belts - the part in the "center" of the intersection is such where you can walk, and move both belts at the same time, and your direction of walking determines the relative speed of the belts). They've also long had networked simulator training systems, which also were setup to participate as part of "real" on-the-ground training and war-game simulations (that is, ones using live bodies and vehicles, aircraft, etc). It wouldn't surprise me in the least if your scenario wasn't part of that already.
- vincentschen 10y agoI agree that there are much fewer applications of VR "now", but let's consider its timeline: the first mainstream HMD (Oculus Rift) was released in 2012. Last year (2016) was the first time that hand-tracking was introduced by Oculus and HTC. If anything is holding back the industry right now, it's the lack of content, but keep in mind that we are still incredibly early!
- santaclaus 10y agoThe timeline goes further back than 2012... VR has been around for what, 30+ years?
- cr0sh 10y agoVR as we know it today basically started when NASA built a rig sometime in the 1980s, using portable "pocket" TVs for the screens (Casio brand, IIRC). You can find pictures of these early systems (as well as early VPL datagloves) with a google search of course. Before that, there was Ivan Sutherland's "Sword of Damocles" - arguably the real beginning of AR/VR (Philco had an earlier system, but it was meant for tele-operation, whereas Sutherland's system used computer generated graphics): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sword_of_Damocles_(virtual_reality) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sword_of_Damocles_(virtual... Interestingly about this system - and isn't mentioned much - is a part of it called the "Twinkle Box" - it was a three-dimensional position tracking system that used light "beams" (generated by some form of slit-scanning mechanical system) to track an object...sound like anything familiar? http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=1500278 http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=1500278 Further back than that? Well - Hugo Gernsback had some kind of idea about a TV or such you strapped to your head: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2010/05/ralph-124c-41-a-century-later/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2010/05/ralph-124c-41-a-...
- GraffitiTim 10y agoWe are using VR to help people overcome fears at Fearless. http://FearlessVR.com http://FearlessVR.com It is based on lots of research showing that VR exposure therapy is extremely effective.
- return0 10y agoGreat idea. I do have an irrational fear of cockroaches, but i am not sure overcoming the fear of spiders is a good thing.
- tripzilch 10y agoassuming that spiders are actually a serious risk where you live, and if it's a phobia in any way like my own irrational fear of heights, then yes it's a good idea to overcome. the sudden panic reaction when you perceive something that looks like a spider[0], really isn't going to keep you safe when it counts, while acting calm, rational and with common sense will. heights can be dangerous but my fear of heights is not doing much of protecting me. the heights I may encounter but prefer to avoid aren't actually dangerous (see-through/grated floors are the worst :) ). the situations that are dangerous, I'd rather have my full faculties if I were to find myself there. [0] i know people who react very strongly to just an image of a spider. living in NL where there's zero dangerous wildlife (just 1 or 2 endangered species of tiny poisonous snake, a lost/dead wolf every few years and 17M humans), that's quite an irrational fear but I won't mess with that because the panic reaction is very real and involuntarily. For fun, however, we tried an experiment where I very slowly drew a cartoon spider, to see at what amount of legs the reaction would kick in :) turned out drawing tiny hairs on the legs did way more for the response than whether I drew 5,6,7, 8 or 9 legs (at which point the other party didn't think it was fun anymore, so I had to end the experiment). and just in case you wondered yes I play with my own phobia in a similar way, whenever I find myself on a perfectly safe balcony that triggers my acrophobia, I like to see how many minutes I can enjoy the view before the GTFO feeling becomes overwhelming (on balconies it's not quite immediate, but still very strong when it kicks in, making it an interesting process to observe).
- sp332 10y agoVR is still very new in the sense that there has been relatively little interaction research done on it. I've been watching what elevr has been coming up with, and it's exciting but they're still inventing basic building blocks. http://voicesofvr.com/515-embodied-cognition-experiments-with-elevrs-math-museums-hyperbolic-space/ http://voicesofvr.com/515-embodied-cognition-experiments-wit...
- drzaiusapelord 10y ago>The article argues "VR will also enable immersive concerts, reinvented museums, and live, court-side sporting events" As a day one Vive owner I also agree these kinds of statements are fairly bullshitty. VR doesn't remotely compare to the real experience of a real outing. Nor is it able to do much outside of gaming and there are probably valid reasons why. Gamers are used to being in virtual spaces, using VR is fun, etc but its also isolating, uncomfortable, expensive, and low res. The good news is that "games" encompasses many categories of experience. Social fun like Rec Room, or RPG's, or MMOs, or shooters, or playing pool, or pingpong, etc. Its a varied experience and I think its a little dismissive to say something like "Oh but its only games now?" Games are huge! Why are we discounting this incredible part of the human experience and something part of all human cultures? This is like saying, "Oh you're in love and getting married? That's just endorphins and patriarchy." Its dismissive to an extreme. That said, I've watched a bit of youtube with my Vive and can certainly see it making in-roads with consumption of media, but even the best pool simulators, gun range, or pingpong simulators not only feel nothing like the real thing, but they're barely a fraction of the fun of the real thing. If futurists are banking on VR replacing many real experiences, well, they better be ready to be disappointed. VR's strengths aren't being a digital version of real experiences, its making fantastic worlds and experiences of its own that feel 'real' and interesting.
- monk_e_boy 10y agoEducation. I taught over a hundred kids with google VR. None of these kids have had to opportunity to go to a big city or see the seven modern wonders of the world or go scuba diving. They loved it. They learnt a huge amount.
- lincolnpark 10y agoWe're developing a VR application for chronic pain management. http://karunavr.com http://karunavr.com I don't think it's too sci-fi.
- vincentschen 10y agoThis looks awesome! What are some of the engineering/hci challenges you've come across?
- Sir_Substance 10y agoCAVE virtual reality[1][2] has been available for quite some time, and has quite a lot of industry penetration. There are multiple off-the-shelf software and hardware packages available, and it's fairly commonly used in the automotive industry. It's quite something to use one of these systems, I was responsible for maintaining one a few years ago. Our demonstration trick for visiting guests was to put a chair inside the cave that matched the coordiantes of a virtual helicopter cockpit command chair. We could sit guests in the chair, turn the system on, and ask them if they could comfortably reach the switches above their heads. They'd stretch out their hands and be able to give a confident yes or no within seconds. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cave_automatic_virtual_environment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cave_automatic_virtual_environ... [2]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=STMcWUtQr1Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=STMcWUtQr1Y