11 ms·
Who dissented? I would be interested in reading the dissent and seeing if it was based off of some technicality of this case, or a belief that requiring someone
by pc86 10y ago
Who dissented? I would be interested in reading the dissent and seeing if it was based off of some technicality of this case, or a belief that requiring someone to prove their innocence wasn't a violation of their Constitutional rights.
- jimrandomh 10y agoClarence Thomas. https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/16pdf/15-1256_5i36.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/16pdf/15-1256_5i36.pdf
- wnevets 10y agoI think we all knew this was the answer before reading a single thing about the case
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- alayne 10y agoIt doesn't sound like he supports forfeiture in general. According to the article "And Justice Clarence Thomas (the lone dissenter in the Nelson decision) recently slammed civil forfeiture for its “egregious and well-chronicled abuses.”"
- jbooth 10y agoYeah, but he has a history of dumb contrarian lone dissents that throw some poor citizen under the bus. Generally when the question "who the heck dissented on that?!?!" is asked, the answer is Thomas.
- zeveb 10y ago> Yeah, but he has a history of dumb contrarian lone dissents that throw some poor citizen under the bus. That's because he interprets the Constitution and the law according to what he believes them to mean, not according to what he wishes they would mean. In this case, he clearly states that he sees no constitutional requirement for the State to return property after it has been confiscated post-conviction (as an aside, the article title is misleading: this wasn't confiscation prior to or absent a conviction). The Constitution does not mandate all good things, nor does it forbid all bad things.
- jbooth 10y agoWell, that's your opinion, and Thomas's, but very frequently it's not the opinion of 8 other Supreme Court justices, several of whom also claim to be textual originalists. The constitution does not mandate all good things, does not forbid all bad things, but VERY NOTABLY includes the 9th amendment. They put that one in for a reason.
- burkaman 10y agoCan someone with legal experience interpret the dissent? I don't really understand the distinction he's making between "substantive entitlements" and "procedural due process".
- otterley 10y agoVery briefly: * Procedural law is the body of law around how a case is heard and handled: how to petition a court, how cases are adjudicated, jurisdiction (i.e. does the Court have the authority to handle this case), etc. * Substantive law is basically everything else. Rights, remedies, criminal law, civil law, administrative law, etc.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoWhat I'm gathering at a really brief read of it (and without legal experience), is that Thomas is suggesting that if the money collected is no longer the individual's property, there's no Constitutional or legal obligation for the government to return it. So, like, evidence collected generally remains property of the owner, and people can recollect it, but if fines or fees are paid or assets are seized, it assigns the property rights of something to the state, it's no longer the individual's property and hence they have no right to get it back... even if they were found innocent later of a court case. EDIT: cookiecaper's read on it is probably better than mine, go read that.
- will_brown 10y agoNot sure why you were down voted, that is basically the entire second part of Thomas' legal dissent. 1. Colorado law doesn't provide for an automatic refund when convictions are overturned, rather Colorado law provides a process and the defendant's didn't attempt to use the process (Therefore, no Constitutional violation in application of this law); 2. The Defendants here already lost their property rights, and so the Due Process Clause of the Constitution does not apply (Colorado doesn't need to provide any process to refund, so we don't need to even look at the Colorado Law to determine if the process is Unconstitutional).
- 10y ago
- cookiecaper 10y agoFrom my non-lawyer skim of the dissent, this appears to be its core: >The Court today announces that petitioners have a right to an automatic refund because the State has “no legal right” to that money. Ante, at 8, n. 11. But, intuitive and rhetorical appeal aside, it does not seriously attempt to ground that conclusion in state or federal law. In the rest of the dissent, Thomas discusses the due process that was available under Colorado's Exoneration Act and indicated that this law did not automatically entitle convicted persons to an automatic refund of any fees associated with their convictions, partially because state law ordered that money to be dispensed via victim compensation funds. This highlights a potential chilling effect of this ruling. As states are now on the perpetual hook for any monies that may be confiscated from someone who is eventually exonerated (and in the case of white-collar crime, this could be millions of dollars), and since you can't know that someone won't be exonerated in the future, states who are interested in keeping their budgets balanced will be incentivized to hold such money in escrow instead of dispensing it for victim's relief. If the exonerated individual could demonstrate his legal entitlement to those monies, he was free to bring a suit under the applicable statutes to do so. Because the law applied equally and anyone could seek relief, Thomas appears to believe it does not violate the 14th Amendment. If the people of Colorado did not think this was fair, it was within the purview of their representative government to change. The role of SCOTUS is not to make sure the world is fair; it is to review statutes for compliance against the Constitution and other relevant federal law. In short, it seems an accurate summary would be that, in Thomas's opinion, the Court's opinion was "activist judgeship", as they merely thought it "intuitively and rhetorically [appealing]" that a state would not be entitled to the funds already paid by an exonerated person and already dispensed by the state, but could point to no law codifying this "intuitive and rhetorical appeal". Again, IANAL.
- sswaner 10y agoPart of Thomas's dissent seems based in the fact that Nelson and Madden had been convicted, so at that point in time the state was entitled to those fees, and that the fees went into the public pool. The later overturn of convictions didn't change the fact that the state was at one point entitled. Thomas: "It does not follow, however, that petitioners have a property right in the money they paid pursuant to their then-valid convictions, which now belongs to the State and the victims under Colorado law."[1] I believe in the value of a diverse court, but I rarely agree with the logic of Clarence Thomas. https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/16pdf/15-1256_5i36.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/16pdf/15-1256_5i36.pdf
- kristofferR 10y agoHow can you possibly agree with that? If overturned convictions are still financially valid then you have no de facto right of appeal (in financial disputes).
- beamatronic 10y agoIt sounds like there is really no such thing as an overturned conviction. There is no constitutional right, apparently, to being "made whole" if your "conviction" is "overturned".
- ghaff 10y ago>There is no constitutional right, apparently, to being "made whole" if your "conviction" is "overturned". Which in the general case is pretty clearly true. If someone is arrested and found not guilty, have their conviction overturned on appeal, etc. they're not in general entitled to payment for lost wages, legal costs, etc. It seems reasonable to consider this a different situation in that it involved a specific fine but I can at least see the counterargument that it's not.
- sswaner 10y agoI rarely agree with Thomas and certainly don't in this case. I find his rationale to be nonsensical.
- protomyth 10y agoIt looks like Justice Thomas wanted to write a dissent because "But both opinions bypass the most important question in these cases: whether petitioners can show a substantive entitlement to a return of the money they paid pursuant to criminal convictions that were later reversed or vacated.". It starts on page 25 of the PDF. It is deep in procedure. It ends with the summary: No one disputes that if petitioners had never been convicted, Colorado could not have required them to pay the money at issue. And no one disputes that Colorado cannot require petitioners to pay any additional costs, fees, or restitution now that their convictions have been invalidated. It does not follow, however, that petitioners have a property right in the money they paid pursuant to their then-valid convictions, which now belongs to the State and the victims under Colorado law. The Court today announces that petitioners have a right to an automatic refund because the State has “no legal right” to that money. Ante, at 8, n. 11. But, intuitive and rhetorical appeal aside, it does not seriously attempt to ground that conclusion in state or federal law. If petitioners’ supposed right to an automatic refund arises under Colorado law, then the Colorado Supreme Court remains free on remand to clarify whether that right in fact exists. If it arises under substantive due process, then the Court’s procedural due process analysis misses the point. I respectfully dissent. I'm personally glad it went the way it did, but I'm really not a law type to figure out if it went that way in a good way.
- BookmarkSaver 10y ago"The law doesn't say that they should get their money back explicitly, therefore the state is free to rob citizens blind while they have the chance with absolutely no repercussions". God I hate this judicial philosophy. If legislation was perfect we wouldn't need judges. Every gap in the legal code that some lawyers can concoct is not valid grounds for exploitation.
- bkeroack 10y ago> Every gap in the legal code that some lawyers can concoct is not valid grounds for exploitation. Yes it is, by definition. Advocate for better legislation, rather than expect lawyers to pinky-swear not to use whatever loopholes they find. An analogy might be: "Every bug or unescaped input in my application is not valid grounds for attackers to pwn my server! How dare they!"
- a3n 10y agoThe article links to the decision at the SCOTUS site. Thomas dissented. > GINSBURG, J., delivered the opinion of the Court, in which ROBERTS, C. J., and KENNEDY, BREYER , SOTOMAYOR, and KAGAN, JJ., joined. ALITO, J., filed an opinion concurring in the judgment. THOMAS, J., filed a dissenting opinion. GORSUCH, J., took no part in the consideration or decision of the cases. Gorsuch is from Colorado, and so might have had a conflict.
- dtparr 10y agoGorsuch wasn't on the court when this was argued either.
- MaxfordAndSons 10y agoI don't think just being from the state a case originated in is commonly, or ever, seen as necessitating self-recusal; after all most judges are residents of the states they adjudicate in. Pretty sure Gorsuch just wasn't yet seated on the court when the case was being heard.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]