3 ms·
In certain situations where an anticompetitive monopoly exists, the government does and should regulate. Take, for example, the birth of cable tv in the US. T
by dhimes 19y ago
In certain situations where an anticompetitive monopoly exists, the government does and should regulate. Take, for example, the birth of cable tv in the US. The cable companies were granted monopoly in regions because otherwise it was senseless to commit the funds to build the infrastructure necessary to develop the industry. In this case, the trade-off is; yes, you get a monopoly but we're going to regulate the prices.
Same with utilities (water, sewer, electric,...).
Many times, however, the regulation is a farce (the regulators and the regulated are all friends). In some cases, the government steps in to see what the shenanigans are.
Usually the defending companies argue that their increased margin is needed for "future investment costs," or something. Sometimes the regulators agree, sometimes not.
So, yes, in certain cases where a few tightly-knit companies are committed to control essential resources, they are "forced" to sell at "reasonable" prices.
Interesting that you bring up software companies. In the 1992 presidential election, the deciding issue to me was the building of the internet. Bush (41) wanted to let the private companies do it all a la cable, sewer, etc. Clinton said, no, it was to be a vital infrastructure to our country and the government should build it (a la our interstate highway system).
I voted for Clinton.
- nradov 19y agoI don't know why you're bringing up monopolies. ExxonMobil is not a monopoly. They have minimal pricing power. The only petroleum organization that is anything remotely like a monopoly is OPEC. US presidents have some influence over certain OPEC member countries, but in general it isn't subject to US antitrust laws. Attempting to regulate the prices they charge is tilting at windmills.
- dhimes 19y agoThere seems to be little competition among US oil companies in prices at the US pump. You seem like you know quite a bit about this--much more than I do--why don't they fight for market share at the pump? The station owners can't do it without help from the "mother" company--their margins are too slim (at least on petrol). It doesn't seem like normal market forces are at play here. I would ordinarily expect one company to drop their margins to try to make more profit on volume. Do you have any idea why we don't see this? Perhaps there is a brand-loyalty factor that makes it pointless to try.
- nradov 19y agoGas stations constantly fight for market share. Brand loyalty doesn't count for much when purchasing a commodity. Consider the area near the intersection of El Camino Real and Grant Rd. in Mountain View, CA. http://www.sanjosegasprices.com/map_gas_prices.aspx?z=11&lat=37.379688&long=-122.073799 http://www.sanjosegasprices.com/map_gas_prices.aspx?z=11&... Prices per gallon of 87-octane gasoline in that small area range from $3.559 for "generic" to $3.649 for the branded product. If there was any brand loyalty then they would be able to charge more than a 2.5% premium. Above the local station level, gasoline prices are largely driven by crude oil prices and refining capacity. Crude oil is a fungible commodity and prices are set at a variety of markets around the world in a way that can't be directly controlled by any government. Refining capacity in the US is constrained and not really growing. There is little financial incentive to spend billions on a new refinery, plus no one wants to live near a refinery (NIMBY). I would actually like to see much higher gasoline prices via something like a carbon tax. That would provide the revenue necessary to temporarily subsidize development of alternative energy sources. As a side effect it would also tend to reduce oil company profits. But unfortunately a carbon tax is probably not politically feasible in the US right now, plus there would serious implementation problems.
- dhimes 19y agoAs I mentioned, the gas stations don't have the margin to fight. Those guys get killed in price wars. Chevron has to fight Exxon-Mobile has to fight Shell--and that doesn't seem to happen. So you are claiming that we don't see this fight because everyone has all the market-share their refining capacity can handle? Perhaps you're right. The problem I have with the carbon tax is that it heavily taxes those who can least afford it: people who have to live in cheap areas and commute to expensive areas for jobs.
- nradov 19y agoDue to the invisible hand of the market, the oil majors are constantly fighting each other. If they were colluding instead of fighting then profit margins would be even higher than they are. But at current prices, customers are buying all the gasoline and diesel available so there is no pressure to cut prices. The impact on poor people who live in suburban and rural areas is one of the problems with a carbon tax. But unfortunately in the long run those people are screwed anyway. Fossil fuels can't stay cheap forever, tax or no tax. Probably some of the tax revenues would have to go to subsidizing them through buying back inefficient vehicles, additional mass transit, housing vouchers near urban areas, etc.