8 ms·
Soma Water Filters Are Worthless
- paulcole 10y agoSoma sent out a really self-congratulatory marketing email on Black Friday a few years back, telling people, "Don't buy a Soma today." gushing about living in the moment and enjoying time with friends and family instead of shopping. I wrote back and asked if they were so serious about that message, why didn't they take the Buy button off their website? Shockingly, no response.
- atomical 10y agoFreedom of choice.
- bykovich 10y agoGreed.
- mikestew 10y agoI wrote back and asked if they were so serious about that message, why didn't they take the Buy button off their website? If you can't readily answer that for yourself, I wouldn't have replied to you, either.
- paulcole 10y agoSend a stupid email get a stupid reply.
- artursapek 10y agoHahah that's so pretentious what they did
- glorpGlorp 10y agoI WAS GONNA SAY
- lj3 10y agoI prefer a Berkey myself.
- revelation 10y agoBut do you have the evidence
- lj3 10y agoYes. I tasted the water and I liked it.
- celticninja 10y agoSample size of 1 works for me. In all seriousness though in issues of personal taste as long as you are happy with your decision then it's the correct one.
- mmagin 10y ago"HOW I USED R TO WIN AN ARGUMENT WITH MY WIFE"
- wnevets 10y ago> this point I just decided to throw the pitcher into the fridge (cold water masks poor taste) and use it for a few weeks to see if there were any changes. if chlorine was the actual cause of the bad taste, wouldn't the water "aired out" the chlorine after a hour or so?
- bradknowles 10y agoMany years ago, I had an argument kind of like this with my mom about the difference between decaf Diet Coke and plain Diet Coke. Since she was the Mathemetician in the family, I let her design the double-blind taste test. When I could conclusively tell the difference every time, she was flabbergasted. But she did finally believe me that there actually was a taste difference between them, at least there was for me. So, she stopped trying to get me to drink decaf.
- antisthenes 10y agoThat people exist who drink decaf diet sodas boggles the mind. Why not drink carbonated water at that point? Or just water, you know. Or drink real soda in moderation.
- sp3000 10y agoI'm one of those who prefer decaf diet sodas. I have sleep issues so I don't like taking any amount of caffeine after a certain time, and once you get used to diet sodas, regular ones don't taste as good (on top of the ridiculous amounts of sugar that each one has).
- tptacek 10y agoSame. Also, real soda is poison.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 10y agoA general drink typically has— a) a certain taste b) a certain mouthfeel (due to the CO2 in case of sodas) c) caffeine and / or other substances People might want some or all of the above. For eg. I sometimes drink decaf Starbucks blended drinks at night because I don't want to mess with my sleep cycle but I like their taste.
- tchaffee 10y agoDecaf still has caffeine. Maybe not enough to affect you personally, but pay closer attention and maybe it does.
- kylehotchkiss 10y agoI have a Soma water filter... their filters used to work well and quickly, then they "improved" them and it takes 10 minutes to fill the pitcher. Yeah.. i'm probably gonna toss the top soon and just enjoy the glass pitcher
- yongjik 10y agoEh, I get the author is being sarcastic, but for someone who buys water filters for their looks, his Soma jug looks just like a slightly plump version of Brita. (What's wrong with Brita, anyway?)
- gcb0 10y agoin stereotypical gender role parlance, it does not pass the "wife test". also filters are overly expensive and useless. issues that the fancy filter only aggravates, so...
- glubGlub 10y agoIf there are two and only two roommates and they disagree, and they settle an argument with evidence-based results, what do you call that? If there are two and only two roommates and they disagree, and they fuck but are not married, and they settle an argument with evidence-based results, what do you call that? If there are two and only two roommates and they disagree, and they fuck but are not married, and they differ in gender, and they settle an argument with evidence-based results, what do you call that? But if you have a married couple, and while adhering to traditional gender roles, they happen to disagree about anything, uh oh! Everybody sulks about the patriarchy.
- conradfr 10y agoThe WAF https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wife_acceptance_factor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wife_acceptance_factor
- gweinberg 10y agoThis was an All in the Family episode. For whatever reason, Gloria can;t tell the difference in taste between Coke, Pepsi, and RC but Meathead can.
- zaroth 10y agoWhy was Soma so hard to distinguish from Bottled? Article seems to gloss over this point?
- celticninja 10y agoIt wasn't and I think that's the point. Essentially soma was hard to distinguish from tap water, which OP had said tasted chlorinated, given that soma was supposed to filter and improve tap water it was failing to meet its stated objective.
- casion 10y agoHe says he can differentiate tap v bottled. He also says he can _not_ differentiate tap v soma. So the difference between soma and bottled should be obvious (or there is some other factor in play), but it's clearly not. Obviously taste is not commutative, but there's something fishy here regardless.
- mattkrause 10y agoFor further reading: The Difference Between “Significant” and “Not Significant” is not Itself Statistically Significant (Gelman and Sterns, 2006): http://www.stat.columbia.edu/~gelman/research/published/signif4.pdf http://www.stat.columbia.edu/~gelman/research/published/sign...
- vmarsy 10y agogp is right, there was 8/23 wrong classifications of "Bottled vs Soma" vs. 10/23 wrong classifications of "Tap vs Soma" In Figure 6 , the author shows there's no statistically significant difference between "Bottled vs Soma" So like he wrote : > Soma filtered water performed the worst, having a taste statistically indistinguishable from tap water I could write using the same data: Soma filtered water performed the best, having a taste statistically indistinguishable from bottled water
- casion 10y agoThis bothered me a lot too. If he can tell the difference between 'tap v bottled' but not 'tap vs soma'... then 'soma vs bottled' would intuitively have a different result if his conclusion is 100% correct. I suspect there's more to it, but the author was focusing on winning an argument so... I guess that killed the curiosity required to dig further for a more thorough conclusion.
- antisthenes 10y agoI wonder how much efficiency and productivity hours are lost to stupid preconceptions like "Brita isnt something you put on a kitchen counter".
- canes123456 10y agoAesthetics matter and make us happier. It also signals things about yourself regardless of if you mean to signal it or not.
- mikeash 10y agoFun little article, but I find the overall premise a bit weird. I always thought of water filters as something that you use to remove harmful things in the water, not improve the taste. Filtered water may taste different, possibly even better, but that's not the goal when I use one.
- driverdan 10y agoNot in the US. The vast majority of US tap water is perfectly safe to drink. The only reason to filter it is taste.
- mikeash 10y agoFor me, it's a hedge against incompetence by the local utility (e.g. Flint), a hedge against problems with my own plumbing, and (for the most part) to shut up that part of my brain that worries too much.
- Fomite 10y agoThese two things are not necessarily uncorrelated.
- mikeash 10y agoRight, but neither are they necessarily correlated, and they might even be correlated oppositely.
- crazygringo 10y agoIt's definitely my goal -- I assume my water's perfectly healthy, but removing the chlorine makes a world of difference in terms of taste. But I live in a city. If you're in the country and drink well water, your priorities might be the complete opposite.
- pitaj 10y agoSome well water also has a very high iron content which could taste good to some but to others it tastes overwhelmingly metallic. This is the case in a lot of mountain areas where drilling deeper than normal to hit a purer part of the aquifer is more expensive.
- Legion 10y agoThe part I find interesting is the 100% success rate between bottled and tap, which is something bottled water drinkers insist is true (being able to taste the difference, that is), but are often told is just in their heads.
- zeta0134 10y agoI live in south Texas, where the water is quite hard, and therefore somewhat bitter. There's no mistaking the difference. I've always described bottled water as being more pure; to me it has no taste (as it should), and filters seem to do a decent job of masking that taste out.
- ajmurmann 10y agoWhy do you think water should have no taste? Good water should has minerals and those have lots of flavors.
- zeta0134 10y agoI think it's because the "bad" taste of water (bitter, sour, or kind of metallic) in the areas where I live is so very strong, that "good" water is tasteless to me by comparison. I'm sure there's something there, but it's really subtle.
- celticninja 10y agoIt will depend on your tap water.
- tzs 10y agoIt also depends on the bottled water. Different brands have different mineral content, and sometimes other things that can affect taste. Furthermore, I think the packaging may affect it sometimes. At least that is my guess after buying a case of small bottles of one particular brand to see if they would be more convenient than filling my own bottles with filtered tap water, and finding that the damn things had a strong flavor that is what I imagine you would get if you ate an ear of corn on the cob for lunch at a picnic on a hot day, and then left the cob sitting out on the table for a few hours until it gets to that state where it has that "it was once part of food, but now it is garbage" smell, and then stuck it in your water and let it sit there for a few more hours, pulled it out, and then drank the water. Since I cannot believe that they intended this flavor, I'm assuming it is something that leached out of the cheap plastic they used for the bottles.
- Someone 10y agoVery nice setup, but he didn't show he couldn’t tell the difference between tap and the Soma water. A biased subject who can pick out both untreated water and Soma-filtered water from the other variants could lie about that, and claim that untreated water and Soma water taste the same. As a thought experiment, assume the variants are plain water, orange juice, and beer. A biased subject could easily claim orange juice and water taste the same and look the same, and are easily distinguished from beer. Also, but minor: this is about taste. Such experiments typically are done in the dark, to rule out an effect of how the water looks on taste judgments.
- crazygringo 10y agoIf you think he's lying he could have made up the entire blog post too... :P But more seriously, how would you suggest designing an experiment that worked even with liars determined to thwart it?
- ghayes 10y agoYou don't need biased subjects to have ambiguous results. Suppose for instance all people from group A can taste chlorine at 20ppm, and below that threshold, those individuals have no perceived chlorine taste. Individuals from group B can taste chlorine only at 80ppm and above. If the tap water has chlorine starting at 100ppm and the filter removed half (as stated in the article) then we would have water at 100ppm and 50ppm. Some observers would perceive a difference and some would not. If the Pur filter removed 90% of chlorine, then individuals in both groups would perceive a difference in taste. To point, this experiment depends on your taste preferences, as the author has stated that there is a physical difference in the makeup of the water samples after filtration.
- averagewall 10y agoHe would have to convince his wife who participated in it, so he can't lie about everything. To her, he can pretend two water types taste the same when really they don't, but he can't pretend the opposite. He can also lie to himself with subconscious bias. The point of blinding is that you can suffer from this even if you're trying to be honest.
- ArlenBales 10y agoI have a Soma pitcher and PUR pitcher at home (I drink enough water to need both). They taste about the same to me.
- weaksauce 10y agoWhy not a reverse osmosis system? Not terribly difficult to maintain and they are much better than a single carbon filter at removing impurities and improving the taste.
- spangry 10y agoI didn't even know these existed until reading your comment. Finally, a new topic to obsessively research :) The last one was indoor air quality and air filters. It sounds kinda lame but it's a really fascinating topic (with a very scammy industry attached to it). Do you use a reverse osmosis system? Any recommendations?
- dec0dedab0de 10y agoDid you settle on an air filter? The obviously scammy industry always turned me off every time I looked in to them.
- Terretta 10y agoThe big Honeywell cylinders w/ charcoal filters. https://www.amazon.com/Honeywell-50250-S-True-HEPA-Purifier/dp/B00007E7RY https://www.amazon.com/Honeywell-50250-S-True-HEPA-Purifier/... At one point a couple of these handled 6 cats and 5 ferrets. The scammmy stuff made no dent. Commercial use hotel + mold ozonaters worked, but unsafe.
- gommm 10y agoNot OP but I've also researched this topic and settled on an iqair filter back when I lived in China. I did borrow a particle monitor and the drop in the number of particle was flagrant when turning it on. Subjectively it also did a lot to improve the air in the house... I'm not sure that something like an iqair is needed in a place that isn't as polluted as China (we sold our air filter when we moved out)
- justinzollars 10y agoYou aren't going to be married long.
- bjterry 10y agoIt may be worth noting that if your water is only chlorinated with chlorine (and not chloramine, which is quite common now as well), leaving it in the fridge overnight can allow some of the chlorine to evaporate, making your water taste better even without a filter. In this case he allowed both his tap water and filtered water to cool overnight, which would tend to understate the taste difference between freshly pulled tap water and freshly filtered water (if that filter effectively removes chlorine).
- tomcam 10y agoApparently the author is married to a water filter, but at least she's stylish. > This experiment was inspired by an argument with my wife, a stylish but atrocious water filter, and the explosion of start-ups attempting to turn everything you purchase into a subscription service.
- xupybd 10y agoHahaha. But I think the author is just listing the things that inspired the argument.
- tomcam 10y agoYes, like an atrocious wife
- saagarjha 10y agoIf only English had precedence rules!
- mcguire 10y agoIt's got the Oxford comma. What more do you want?
- pitaj 10y agoThis; right here; is why I replace all of my punctuation with only semicolons;
- kk_cz 10y agoThat would explain this: > How I Used R To Win An Argument With My Wife I don't know about author, but the set of arguments with my wife that can be won using R is pretty much empty. :)
- oceanswave 10y agoAren't we all just complicated water filters given a particular perspective?
- 10y ago
- alyx 10y agoMaybe I didn't do a good job scanning the comments, but I'm surprised nobody (not even the article) mentions the NSF certification body. Taste is important but very subjective. I don't buy a water filter unless it shows up as certified by NSF[1]. A few years ago I almost fell for a "water purification system" on Amazon, with stellar reviews that was supposed to filter out everything. With a baby on the way I figured it was worth the price tag. Good thing I did my research. The water filtration system was not certified or verified by anybody. edit: Same thing applies to humidifiers, air cleaners, air conditioners, etc. Don't buy unless it has been certified[2]. [1] http://info.nsf.org/Certified/DWTU/ http://info.nsf.org/Certified/DWTU/ [2] http://ahamverifide.org/ http://ahamverifide.org/
- fujipadam 10y agoThanks!!! Safety above taste seems obvious for a water filter.
- an_account 10y agoTap water has more stringent safety standards than bottled. So unless you live in flint, then safety shouldn't really be an issue.
- prostoalex 10y agoNot just Flint. https://www.wsj.com/articles/pittsburgh-tries-to-avoid-becoming-the-next-flint-1493550002 https://www.wsj.com/articles/pittsburgh-tries-to-avoid-becom... "A total of seven U.S. water systems, which each serve more than 100,000 people, had lead concentrations above the federal action level of 15 parts per billion in recent months, according to Environmental Protection Agency data. They include Portland, Ore., and Providence, R.I., which both exceeded the limit at least one other time in the past five years."
- kurthr 10y agoWell, maybe it's a bit more complicated than that. It's certainly true that if you're using a water filter to remove something dangerous rather than remove "hardness" or "chlorination", then you're going to want a certification (and regularly test to see if the RO filter is still working). I'd put ship, cistern, and catchment on that list of critical filters. However, if your decision is primarily based on flavor (as the article's is) or mineral build-up, then it's not clear that it's so important since you're drinking the water anyway! I'd note that one brand you may be referring to (although it's true for others) has both "residential" and "professional" series. The latter are WQA Certified (NSF/ANSI 58 & 53)... although you won't find them listed on the NSF website, they are both ANSI and SCC (Canada) certified. http://yourwaterfilterguide.com/difference-apec-water-residential-reverse-osmosis/ http://yourwaterfilterguide.com/difference-apec-water-reside... https://www.wqa.org/learn-about-water/faqs https://www.wqa.org/learn-about-water/faqs
- gwern 10y agoI recently did a similar blind taste-test for mineral waters vs my tap water: https://www.gwern.net/Tea#water-experiment https://www.gwern.net/Tea#water-experiment I used a lazy susan to implement randomization/blinding, and an interesting Bayesian variant on best-arm finding to try to optimize sample selection. I found my tap water is weakly in the middle and perhaps 1 or 2 mineral waters were better, but not strongly so. The results are not quite comparable to OP because I designed it in terms of deciding which in a pair tasted better, not whether I could guess which was which correctly.
- dsfyu404ed 10y ago"Initially I thought just to buy a Brita, but Brita filters always seemed like something you’d shove in your dorm room mini-fridge and not display on your kitchen counter." This is a pretty abrupt context switch after coming from the article on stereotypes, trailer homes and rural folk that's on the front page right now.
- mbfg 10y agoWhen does Soma sue this guy? This seems like a risky article to me. Whether or not they have a case, doesn't matter. They can make life miserable.
- russellbeattie 10y ago"...a practice pioneered in the 90s by “8 CDs For A Penny!” Columbia House" LOL. Try 1950s. I love how Millennials think everything was "pioneered" in the 90s and 2000s.
- DanBC 10y ago> First, I filled all the pitchers the previous night Chlorine evaporates. If he's worried about chlorine taste this step - allowing the jug to sit overnight - will fix it.