2 ms·
I don't think we're talking past each other, as I think we both understand the differences in each of our definitions, ie. I understand you think identity is ce
by naasking 10y ago
I don't think we're talking past each other, as I think we both understand the differences in each of our definitions, ie. I understand you think identity is central but I disagree, and you understand that I think procedural abstraction is central, but you disagree.
Where we differ is which definition ought to deserve the label "object", in the pure sense the way we have a definition for "function".
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoEven function has a definition in the philosophical sense unrelated to even the technical details of the lambda calculus. Especially when the function is pure and/or continuous, these are really useful distinctions in a design vs. using a bare bones definition that talks about a function being a pointer to some code.
- naasking 10y ago> Even function has a definition in the philosophical sense unrelated to even the technical details of the lambda calculus. Agreed, "function" has many concrete definitions, but arguably, there is some essence of what it means to be a function that we see reflected in each instance, and so virtually all of them are interconvertible in some real sense. For "object", I see this essence as procedural abstraction. Every discussion of objects features access to data mediated by arbitrary code, which is how they implement behaviour. Object factories and numerical abstractions (fixed, rings, arbitrary precision, etc.) simply don't fit into your narrative of objects, so defining objects as requiring identity is immediately refuted in my mind. Certainly you could argue that your approach to objects is better for software construction, but I don't think that means other approaches are no longer object-oriented, in the way that we can say that C permits you to violate the essence of functions.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoI see objects as being completely unrelated to procedural abstraction, especially in its purest anthropomorphic form where objects have their own independent actuators and sensors (e.g. As in Kodu without any procedures at all, but also heavily used in etoys, scratch and of course Simula). In that case, they are just little entities (with identities of course) doing their own thing and communicating only through their environment.
- naasking 10y agoSounds like actors, not objects.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoActors are objects, of course. Do you want to ask Hewitt? :)
- naasking 10y agoI think this thread is long enough! But I agree actors are objects, I just don't think all objects are actors.