7 ms·
Imagine if you picked a sports team by the most paid players in their league. The football team would be half quarterbacks, the hockey team mostly goalies and
by BurningFrog 10y ago
Imagine if you picked a sports team by the most paid players in their league.
The football team would be half quarterbacks, the hockey team mostly goalies and so on.
- geoka9 10y agoGoalies are the highest paid players in hockey? Interesting.
- patejam 10y agoThey're out on the ice the entire game, and usually the only person on the team that can play that position at any acceptable level. That on top of goalies being your last line of defense, having to take 25-35 shots per game. The same reason your team fights a lot when the other team messes with your goalie; can't afford an injured goalie.
- ssharp 10y agoI'm not a fan of hockey, so I'm asking this question out of pure curiosity and ignorance. I'm assuming advanced analytics have made their way to hockey. Have the analytics supported this?
- dionidium 10y agoNo, not really. Top-line centers are usually the most valuable player on a team, followed by other scoring forwards. Scoring is a premium in the NHL, which means that a very good scorer is harder to replace than a good defensive player, all else equal. http://www.thehockeynews.com/news/article/new-war-stat-for-hockey-aims-to-provide-greater-insight-into-player-value http://www.thehockeynews.com/news/article/new-war-stat-for-h...
- schwap 10y agoNo, this is not true. The top paid players in professional hockey are almost all high-scoring forwards. 4 of the top 50 highest paid players in the NHL are goalies.
- BurningFrog 10y agoI didn't do my research there, sorry. You hear a lot about how a good goalie is half the team in modern hockey, so I thought that would translate to salaries. Anyway, I hope I made my bigger point clear, despite the questionable example.
- cowardlydragon 10y agoA hot goalie is more important than a hot forward in the NHL playoffs...
- Will_Parker 10y agoOn the other hand, a star quarterback or goalie has a disproportionate positive effect on the team's winning chances, and chances to win championships.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoSure. But even great quarterbacks struggle if the O-line is dysfunctional. And you definitely wouldn't be better off with 6 star quarterbacks than 1 average quarterback and 5 O-line players.
- dionidium 10y agoThis is probably true of a quarterback, but it's not generally true of hockey goalies. You'd much rather build your team around Sidney Crosby than any goalie to ever play the game.
- Will_Parker 10y agoOk, fair enough! Though, has anyone ever analyzed this question rigorously with data? I.e. is there a Bill James equivalent in the ice hockey world? The larger point is that individual stars definitely matter a lot in pro sports. And recruiting and retaining them with extremely disproportionate amounts of money doesn't seem to be irrational for most sports.
- badloginagain 10y agoThat's not true. You can take a look at the Rangers right now, whose only true "superstar" is the goalie- Lundqvist.
- hkmurakami 10y agoWell the US Olympic Basketball Dream Team did crush it.
- kenjackson 10y agoEven that team was fielded based on position. They didn't have 12 centers.
- caminante 10y agoThey didn't have 12 Cs [0], but can you think of any absolute snubs? The team only had 1 true center and 1 true PG. Isiah Thomas was deserving, and Laettner was picked over Shaq. At the time, both were tossups. Johnson was older and so was Bird, but I assume they had high salaries per the topic. [0] http://www.basketball-reference.com/olympics/teams/USA/1992/ http://www.basketball-reference.com/olympics/teams/USA/1992/
- sien 10y agoThe soccer team would be Real Madrid. The baseball team the New York Yankees. They seem to do OK.
- saghm 10y agoThe baseball team currently with the highest roster salary is not the Yankees, but the Los Angeles Dodgers by almost 20%. They're currently in third place, behind teams with the 16th and 26th highest roster salaries (out of 30 MLB teams)[1]. Obviously it's early on the season, but we can look at last year's season to get a better heuristic. The top two teams in terms of roster salary were once again the Dodgers and Yankees. The Dodgers did come in first in their division but finished the season 12.5 games behind the eventual World Series winners, the Chicago Cubs, whose roster salary was barely 2/3 of the Dodgers. Oh, and the Yankees came in fourth place (of five) in their division, a whole nine games out of first place. So yes, spending money helps you be a contender, but spending the most money is not a good metric for the best team (at least, not in baseball, and I'd imagine that being smarter about spending your money rather than spending more is useful in other fields as well). http://www.spotrac.com/mlb/payroll/2017/ http://www.spotrac.com/mlb/payroll/2017/ http://www.spotrac.com/mlb/payroll/2016/ http://www.spotrac.com/mlb/payroll/2016/ http://m.mlb.com/standings/?yyyy=2016&view=divisional http://m.mlb.com/standings/?yyyy=2016&view=divisional
- ethbro 10y agoI'd imagine the majority of sports have a fairly loose correlation between money spent and winning due to (a) limited sample size leading to high variance (even with a superior player selection strategy), (b) limited number of games played (though baseball does better than other sports here), and (c) games consisting of more dependent than independent events (leading to low chance events having cascading repurcussions). At least in MLB, 40 multi-year players isn't that large a sample!
- saghm 10y agoI don't disagree, but I also don't think that's indicative that paying the most money is the optimal strategy. I'd much rather play for a team that does win rather than one that "should" but doesn't. My point, which I alluded to in the last paragraph, was not that teams shouldn't spend a lot of money, but that spending a lot of money is not a good substitute for spending money intelligently.
- georgeecollins 10y agoSports is a terrible analogy for work. A sport is a game with rules that are created to create an entertaining event. The rules are defined. The outcomes are always instances that never build to a lasting change to the structures that created the outcome. Work is not like that in any way.