3 ms·
> I definitely don't analyze other paradigms technically. You should know me better than that. I'd rather all paradigms be analyzed based on how they are used t
by naasking 10y ago
> I definitely don't analyze other paradigms technically. You should know me better than that. I'd rather all paradigms be analyzed based on how they are used to write programs and how they influence program designs. The technical details are just details.
The technical details define how programs are structured. I don't see how you can separate these questions if that's what you mean by "design".
> Again, it is how you design your programs: are you relying heavily on equational reasoning, or have you divided things into a bunch of nouns with behavior.
Sure, but this doesn't preclude immutable objects from being used in subprograms that don't depend on state transitions. For instance, object factories may or may not be immutable, but if they are, they're suddenly not objects anymore? That distinction seems pointless.
> They might indeed, but it is a vacuous statement to begin with.
I agree that many people might take virtually anything to be a message, but when you try to specify with technical precision what that phrase actually entails, you get meaningful constraints, and I think Cook did a pretty good job distilling those properties.
For instance, "the only way to interact with an object is to send messages" means that no information can be revealed than what the object volunteers, ie. encapsulation, and this voluntary disclosure can't be captured statically to enforce stronger properties as with ADTs.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoDesign is like what does my program look like when I use X vs. what does it look like when I use Y? What are the implications of those two choices? I see objects and functions are pure design abstractions: you can easily emulate one or the other in a language that doesn't provide them as first class constructs, and even when they are provided as first class constructs, you can always use them in ways that are poor for the designs they support. That "objects communicate via messages" leads to absurdities like numbers being considered as objects. It is completely blind to their benefits and drawbacks as anthropomorphic entities.
- naasking 10y ago> That "objects communicate via messages" leads to absurdities like numbers being considered as objects. It's only absurd if you're implicitly ascribing properties to objects that haven't been explicitly justified. It seems perfectly reasonable to me that numbers would be objects, because numbers have a multitude of representations, all of which we'd like to be interchangeable. For instance, machine registers vs. arbitrary precision numbers. With ADTs, we'd have to explicitly define overloads for addition that handle the various permutations of parameters for addition of various number types, but a Cook-like object language wouldn't need this at all. Any representation of a number would be interoperable with any other implementation, automatically. That's neither vacuous or absurd, and these properties follow directly from taking that phrase describing objects to its logical conclusion.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoWhen we come down to this, it is clear we just have very different of what objects are or are supposed to be. Interoperability (polymorphism) is at the center of the definition that you are using, and it is nowhere near as important in my definition of object, where polymorphism is possible with values and not related to their objecthood (it is a technical detail in how values can be made polymorphic). We are talking past each other because we don't possess compatible meanings of the word object.
- naasking 10y agoI don't think we're talking past each other, as I think we both understand the differences in each of our definitions, ie. I understand you think identity is central but I disagree, and you understand that I think procedural abstraction is central, but you disagree. Where we differ is which definition ought to deserve the label "object", in the pure sense the way we have a definition for "function".
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoEven function has a definition in the philosophical sense unrelated to even the technical details of the lambda calculus. Especially when the function is pure and/or continuous, these are really useful distinctions in a design vs. using a bare bones definition that talks about a function being a pointer to some code.
- naasking 10y ago> Even function has a definition in the philosophical sense unrelated to even the technical details of the lambda calculus. Agreed, "function" has many concrete definitions, but arguably, there is some essence of what it means to be a function that we see reflected in each instance, and so virtually all of them are interconvertible in some real sense. For "object", I see this essence as procedural abstraction. Every discussion of objects features access to data mediated by arbitrary code, which is how they implement behaviour. Object factories and numerical abstractions (fixed, rings, arbitrary precision, etc.) simply don't fit into your narrative of objects, so defining objects as requiring identity is immediately refuted in my mind. Certainly you could argue that your approach to objects is better for software construction, but I don't think that means other approaches are no longer object-oriented, in the way that we can say that C permits you to violate the essence of functions.