4 ms·
What do people really think about business school degrees? To me there seems to be a large disconnect between what we think of the person who takes one (ambitio
by lordnacho 10y ago
What do people really think about business school degrees? To me there seems to be a large disconnect between what we think of the person who takes one (ambitious, hard-working) and what he is taught there (basically nothing).
I went to business school as part of my degree at a top UK institution. They have 1 year MBAs so the joint school people got a fair taste of what the MBAs did.
And let me tell you, as half engineers nobody was impressed. Is this really what they do? Read a bunch of stories about Betamax or various Japanese firms, and extract lessons from that? That's not even a rigorous history course.
As to what the overall effect is, it just appears there is a class of firms who are fearful of hiring the wrong people, so they hire a brand name. These people are more likely to get into such firms, but it's not clear at all anything from the course is used there in a way that is more than superficial.
Have they damaged society by being too focused on short term gains? Well, it's not just Harvard and MBAs that went that way in the 1980s. Society as a whole did, too.
- arethuza 10y agoI always got the impression that MBAs were about signalling that someone was serious about wanting to be be in the "management" stream (or if I'm feeling cynical "class") rather than a mere practitioner in a particular area. Edit: Nobody that I know who did an MBA seemed that interested in the area they worked in. I'd rather do a PhD in History or Archaeology than an MBA - perhaps my own desire to signal that I have no interest in "management" for its own sake.
- tnecniv 10y ago> I'd rather do a PhD in History or Archaeology than an MBA To be fair, business schools offer PhDs which are different beasts I suspect.
- manuelflara 10y agoSeveral friends who have done MBAs have all told me the same thing: When you do an MBA, you pay for two things. First, for the network of alumni. Second, for the badge in your resume. In both cases, obviously the more prestigious the school, the better (and more expensive). Since that's what would carry more weight as a brand name (i.e. Harvard) and also richer / more influential people will attend as alumni, thus those personal connections being more valuable. Recently I heard about some MBAs called "Executive MBA" or something like that, which were basically shorter (1 year) and more expensive. They justified this by saying they were targeted at people already on the workforce, usually in management, who wanted to move up, and would really appreciate 1 year titles instead of 2 years. But again, it's for the same reason. More expensive title => "Wealthier" alumni => Looks better on your resume. And to top it off, you just have to spend a year "studying".
- sirtaj 10y agoThis almost sounds like a finishing school for corporate courtiers.