4 ms·
To be honest: it's a fad for startups. Serious enterprise, with a need for data durability, consistency, auditing, real IT security, regulatory conformance etc
by mschuster91 10y ago
To be honest: it's a fad for startups.
Serious enterprise, with a need for data durability, consistency, auditing, real IT security, regulatory conformance etc. won't touch that stuff with a 10-feet-pole.
Also, once you choose your provider, you're locked in into this vendor (be it Amazon, GCE or Azure), while you can move your bare metal servers around to whichever colo/DC fulfills your requirements.
- rco8786 10y agoHm. I see your first point(s), but maybe won't immediately concede that they aren't solvable. But to your second point, lots of really successful enterprise companies get "locked in" to Aws, Gce etc and are running just fine.
- stonogo 10y agoAWS is right around ten years old. I have children who could read before it was launched. That's not enough time for a business to stabilize, but it would be a good idea for any business to start planning an escape route.
- dogma1138 10y agoTBH that was they said about DevOps.
- peterwwillis 10y agoAnd yet fortune 100 and 500 companies are increasingly adopting cloud technology. And there are plenty of solutions already available to distribute your cloud infra to multiple providers at once. I think the writing's on the wall. Software devs are coding Ops out of a job. Even the network is software now.
- holydude 10y agoFortune 100-500 run myriads of different software. Really your "avg" fortune 500 company cant be used as a benchmark.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mschuster91 10y ago> Even the network is software now. Only at Facebook, probably one of the few companies in the world which can afford dedicated engineers for that stuff (and probably needs SDN because a server might shift totally in its roles and thus its networking dozens of times a day). The rest of the world keeps using Cisco or HP gear, which works fine enough for everything I have seen (from SOHO equipment in small offices over 6-or-so-HE switches in a medium company to rack-sized switches at a municipal government). Also, the amount of HP or Cisco certified network engineers outweighs the amount of SDN by far.
- peterwwillis 10y agoIt's definitely more than just Facebook. Every major network equipment vendor already provides SDNs, including Cisco, and HP, who has an entire site and app store dedicated to SDN. 2015: Cisco's SDN business is booming. http://www.computerweekly.com/news/2240240260/Cisco-software-defined-networking-business-booms http://www.computerweekly.com/news/2240240260/Cisco-software... 2016: Top 10 SDN market leaders: "market is set to top $12.5 billion by 2020" ... "SDN in the data center and enterprise LAN is going to go mainstream in late 2016, early 2017," ... "We're seeing significant customer deployment. Cisco's got over 1,000 deployed customers for their SDN solution. VMware is around the same number, even though revenue might be higher on the VMware side. NEC has over 250 scaled deployment customers." http://www.crn.com/slide-shows/networking/300079644/top-10-sdn-market-leaders-in-the-data-center-and-enterprise-in-2016.htm http://www.crn.com/slide-shows/networking/300079644/top-10-s... Just as an example, Cisco's been running Linux on its new gear for years. They can run multiple OSes in different planes on their custom gear and get crazy fast traffic flows while doing things like deep packet inspection. They wrote custom interfaces to do things like get super-low-latency traffic control. You can make your own Python apps, and run them when triggered by an event, on the appliance or remotely, with several APIs. You can use Ansible, Puppet and Chef to manage the appliance configuration. You can also configure them with netconf, or XMPP. You can have your switches send you instant messages or post in your ops chatrooms. And you can deploy all your devices from a clean slate using kickstart scripts. Automating with NX-OS https://www.slideshare.net/CiscoDevNet/automating-with-nxos-lets-get-started https://www.slideshare.net/CiscoDevNet/automating-with-nxos-...
- bsenftner 10y agoI think it is lemming stupidity. Building one's own "cloud" is easy, and can be one in a tiny fraction of the expense any cloud provider charges. The mindless march to the cloud is a huge competitive advantage for anyone "brave" enough to buck the propaganda and run their own hardware. There is a breed of developer that is doing REST in C++, building services that live in only a few hundred K, and a single physical server can concurrently host thousands of such services for an expense of $75 a month, running 24/7 with 16 cores and 16 GB RAM. The same capacity on a cloud provider is exponentially higher for a single server. You know that "fake news" idea? I think it has been manipulating developer opinion for a while. The cloud does not make sense, unless you are a cloud provider with a reason to sell that lie.
- kuschku 10y agoExponentially higher does not even cover it. You pay several orders of magnitudes more. I’ve run the numbers several times, going from colo -> rented dedicated -> rented VPS -> cloud VPS (think EC2) -> containerized cloud (think heroku) -> serverless (think AWS lambda) is, on each step, at least a 2x or 5x increase in cost for the same computational power. I started out a few years ago with my hobby projects on Heroku, migrated them to Digital Ocean, from there to OVH’ VPS, and now migrated them last year to rented bare metal. Every migration multiplied my available resources at the same cost, and it’s definitely been worth it. I did a price comparison of VPS and some bare metal providers over at https://gist.github.com/justjanne/205cc548148829078d4bf2fd394f50ae https://gist.github.com/justjanne/205cc548148829078d4bf2fd39... and the result is pretty much just that. For 16$ a month I can get enough performance to run services handling tenthousands of concurrent users if I go with bare metal, or I can’t even handle a few hundred if I go with the "cloud".
- bsenftner 10y agoA few years ago, I got a deal on a cabinet at a colo, and then when one of the research labs at USC dumped their servers for the cloud, and they gave me 17 servers. I'd previously custom built a 32 core, 32 gig server just out of hacker interest, and between the USC servers and my previously owned hardware I put together a 196 core cluster with 3 redundant ( dev, staging, live ) environments for my own playground, and similar setups for hosting clients. Adding to and modifying the system for a few years, I had what would have cost $96K a month at AWS, but was only $600 a month to me.
- aries1980 10y agoYes, but honestly what percentage of businesses need regulatory conformance or anything like signed logs? My main problem is the lack of transparency, vendor lock-in (so you can't enter non-mainstream markets with some regulatory expectations, such as Vietnam or Russia).
- mschuster91 10y ago> Yes, but honestly what percentage of businesses need regulatory conformance or anything like signed logs? Uh, as soon as you're processing PII, be it health information, social security numbers like in payroll, or credit card information, you're required by law (or the CC industry) to have these. And no, cutting corners is not an option, at least if you want to avoid some serious jail time. Media processing (in the sense of professional movie studios) requires MPAA certification, which in turn requires that all systems handling "customer data/assets" even be airgapped to the Internet (source: MPAA best practices guidelines). And if you're ever dealing with car manufacturers, goodbye to cloud - they're similarly sensitive when it comes to anything near unreleased products. No Dropbox/Slack/... allowed, and for good reason.
- aries1980 10y ago> Uh, as soon as you're processing PII, be it health information, social security numbers like in payroll, or credit card information, you're required by law (or the CC industry) to have these. And no, cutting corners is not an option True, but you can still organise out less sensitive components to serverless, and there are plenty of payment and payroll gateways to outsource the compliance problems.
- mschuster91 10y ago> True, but you can still organise out less sensitive components to serverless, and there are plenty of payment and payroll gateways to outsource the compliance problems. Good luck building all the firewalling and other logic required for a sane system. And everytime I see "outsource" in reference to the core parts of a company (which payments and payroll definitely are), I cringe. That's a desaster waiting to happen.
- linsomniac 10y agoMy company is hardly a startup (16 years old), and we are in the process of converting a few of our processes over to Lambda and API Gateway (via luigi), with good success. I wouldn't agree with the "You're locked in to this vendor" statement. Our Lambda code is just Python Flask apps and our "if Lambda is down" plan is to run the services from our data center via uwsgi serving the Flask apps. GCE also can easily serve Flask apps, but the environment there is weird and I spent tons of time struggling with things that worked in my GCE dev environment to work in the real GCE. I had high hopes for GCE but it was a total pain in the butt. As far as moving your bare metal servers around to whatever DC... Enterprises don't easily move data centers. Minimum to move our couple of Lambda apps, deployed on uwsgi, is probably a contract for 2 years at a grand a month, and $30K worth of hardware. We wouldn't take down one data center until another is fully up and running and proven.