10 ms·
The psychological importance of wasting time
- hrxn 10y agoTL;DR?
- moxious 10y agoThis is very oddly framed. If the time is psychologically useful, then it isn't wasted. Some people need more, and some people need less relaxation time. I think the author's real issue is with the psychology of trapping yourself into feeling you must work at every moment and feeling guilty if you don't. The trouble with that in turn is that it's a person's habit or emotional orientation, and likely doesn't change just by being given evidence that you're more productive if you give yourself a break sometimes. Habits don't respond to evidence because they're pattern continuations, not logical choices.
- qntty 10y agoI've definitely developed habits that were based on mistaken beliefs, then changed them fairly easily when my beliefs changed. I don't think it's crazy to think that someone who is obsessed with optimizing every second of life could change their tune when they start to think of "down time" as productive.
- philipov 10y agoPeople respond more strongly to the framing of an argument than to its logical content (case in point: GP), and so I would argue that choosing the frame of the oppressor (e.g. it is wasted time) actually reinforces the belief and is counterproductive to changing the habit. It would be better to attack the frame directly by challenging the notion that it's wasted time, instead of parroting it.
- kmonad 10y agoWhat is GP? Why do you use an undefined acronym for your case in point?
- labster 10y agoGrandparent post: the post two levels up.
- freshhawk 10y agoI'm not sure about that, how much of the benefit remains if you look at leisure time as another productivity optimizing activity? I like the attack on the fundamental ideology at play (not just the frame built on top of it) in the statement that "wasting time is good". I think it might be far more helpful.
- nicky0 10y agoHowever, using the phrase "wasting time" supports the idea that time is something that can be wasted, and reinforces ideas that being "unproductive" is somehow wasteful.
- freshhawk 10y agoIf it was a habit and you "changed [it] fairly easily", then it either wasn't a habit or you have an exceptional ability there, one most everyone doesn't have.
- hrxn 10y agoExcellent observation.
- ivm 10y ago> I think the author's real issue is with the psychology of trapping yourself into feeling you must work at every moment and feeling guilty if you don't. I would say that you need to grow as a person at every moment. This includes sleeping, walking in the park without thinking about work, learning themes unrelated to your professional occupation (humanities are great for software engineers), spending time with good people, and of course meditating. There are almost universal time-wasters though, especially if you spent enough time with them in the past – online and other endless games, most of the movies and TV series, arguing on the Internet, etc. When you have a subtle feeling that you have experienced it before – it's time to quit.
- gosheroo 10y agoIs it even possible to waste time? Consider meditation. Widely considered to be a valuable and healthy activity, it literally consists of doing nothing.
- wtetzner 10y agoMaybe doing something that's actively harmful could be considered wasting time?
- gosheroo 10y agoI don't think anyone intends anything harmful. People do harmful things because they are mistaken about stuff, including about what is good. But mistakes are a normal part of discovering the way forward, so, no, not a waste.
- rukuu001 10y agoSure, when anxiety and exhaustion from your schedule stop you from doing anything productive (actual work) or healthy (meditation, walks in the park etc etc).
- ihaveahadron 10y agoNo it's not actually possible to waste time in the literal sense. In specific situations someone can claim someone is wasting time but it's just some lame manipulation. If you were wasting time you wouldn't be doing whatever it is your doing in the first place.
- inimino 10y agoSleeping consists of doing nothing. But you are still breathing, so it's not nothing. I would say watching TV often qualifies as wasting time.
- gosheroo 10y agoSleeping isn't a waste of time, either. TV is source of background cultural knowledge and is enjoyable for that reason. When it ceases to be enjoyable one can stop watching. OK, one might be addicted to watching TV, but that's a separate issue. Here one is using the TV to avoid addressing other problems. True, it might take a period of mindless watching in order to appreciate this. Has that time been wasted? Well, no, because it had to be spent in order to gain that very appreciation.
- zeta0134 10y agoThis is one of the main reasons I've stopped taking lunch at my desk. I cheat a bit, eat my lunch right before my long break while I'm getting to a stopping point, then put on my headphones, leave my desk, and wander around our campus for an hour on foot. The music relaxes me and doesn't let me focus on any surrounding snippets of conversation, and I just let my mind wander along with my feet as I traverse our campus with no particular destination. (Our "office building" was originally an old mall, so it's huge and spacious.) This is surprisingly refreshing, and I usually find that I arrive at my desk energized mentally by the end of the hour.
- dev1n 10y agoHow do you escape coworker's asking to go to lunch without seeming like an uninterested a$$? Would love some advice in this area.
- alansammarone 10y agoI've been faced with the same dilemma. Eventually, I just started telling people "I have something important to do". After all, being on your own every now and then is something important.
- rdiddly 10y agoYou can also say you've got a previous appointment or engagement... which is also true, even though it's with yourself.
- mack73 10y agoYou must all be very popular people since you have to have a strategy to get out of doing things with others. Most people have the opposite problem. You'll seem very unsincere after a while though, if your strategy is to not tell the truth. Is it that you don't want to hurt the feelings of others that you lie? It's a little immature.
- suneilp 10y ago
- ssivark 10y agoThe notion of measuring one's quality of life by "productivity" seems very strange. When one is focused on micro-optimizing what one does, it is difficult to dwell on the bigger and more important questions (such as what life goals might be worthy of pursuit). On the basis of the obliquity principle [1] most metrics that we try to optimize for are probably corollaries of a life well lived. Further, the irony of articles that try to justify "downtime" as an enabler for better productivity is very funny. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obliquity_(book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obliquity_(book)
- NickNameNick 10y agoAt least measuring productivity makes some sense. A lot of people seem to measure busyness, or even the appearance of busyness as a proxy, but business without achievement is not productivity.
- hartator 10y agoI would said depend wasting time on what right? And still we are here commenting on HN. :)
- ihaveahadron 10y agoThis sounds like when someone says don't make paper airplanes so you don't waste paper. How the fuck is it wasting it's being used to make a paper airplane. I get teachers say that just because they have rules or whatever but how fucking stupid do you have to be to buy that. I'm justing writing whatever pops into my head and it's kind shitty writing or whatever but the point I'm making is in response to a really fucking dumb thing so I'm not trying make my writing all fucking pretty and shit.
- andrewchambers 10y agoToo often wasting time in an endless youtube/HN/reddit loop takes away from a real break you could be enjoying fully instead of being in guilty limbo. Everyone needs breaks, so factor these into your plan and commit to them fully, planned breaks can be enjoyed without guilt.
- spcelzrd 10y agoFor the typical office worker, much of the day is spent pretending to work.
- simplydt 10y agoThere is a big difference between wasting time and doing nothing or resting. I think the title is quite misleading as I doubt the majority of time wasting as it happens in the modern world has any good psychological implications: A while back I wrote a post analysing Coldplay, Minecraft and my own previous start up in relation to "doing nothing", someone might find it useful: http://unratedtogm.blogspot.co.uk/2013/12/doing-nothing-will-make-you-more.html?m=1 http://unratedtogm.blogspot.co.uk/2013/12/doing-nothing-will...
- orschiro 10y agoDecluttering is the keyword for me. Rethinking what I am consuming, how and what the effects of its consumption are, i.e. what do I do with what I consume? Do I share it? Do I digest it? Do I make something based on it?
- abalashov 10y agoIt's harder to follow this advice when you're self-employed—in the bootstrapped, struggle-with-bills, glorified one-man-show sense, not the funded-with-plenty-of-runway sense. In addition to the guilt and social pressure to "look busy", there's the knowledge that making rent really is tied to how much you work. That leaves one feeling not only guilty for doing not-work in the abstract, diffuse sense related to societal messaging, but indeed, it feels financially irresponsible and often financially deleterious. It's not that grinding away at the PC makes one any more productive than folk who follow the article's advice. It's just an even bigger weight on one's shoulders. Instead of feeling like you owe society, your coworkers or your employer something, you think about owing people paychecks that don't bounce and owing the bank account balances that aren't negative. Seeing past that and becoming aware that taking a walk now and again won't change any of that in the big picture, because the big picture depends on the more cosmological success or failure of your business model to grow/scale, is hard when life is that kind of constant struggle. And then you constantly feel like a moral failure—I mean a real piece of shit, not just a slacker getting away with slacking—when you binge-watch something on Netflix or cruise HN or YouTube because you're constantly burned out.
- Swizec 10y agoI struggle with this a lot. It's like I have to make appearances for me. Forget pointy haired bosses and managers who like to see you work. Nothing is harder on yourself than yourself. You have a very clear insight into just how much you procrastinate and slack off and everything feels like too much. This of course does not lead to more productivity. It leads to a lot of "productivity" where you work late into the night or early into morning, but know a surprising lot about all the latest memes and goings on du jour of the internet. What I found works for me is exercise. Can't convince yourself that you can sit still and stare at the ceiling for an hour? Going for a run has the same effect and it feels productive. Added bonus: you don't look idle to others either. Saying "I wanna read for an hour" is often met with "Ok but can you do the dishes and the laundry while you're not doing anything anyway?". Going for a run or hopping to the gym is met with "Ok." Both from your subconscious and the people around you.
- spaginal 10y agoI thought so too. Ego plays a huge part in this when it comes to business. Working less can help you with working more meaningfully in a small business in my own personal experience. For others it may not. The thing that helped me with my small business, is the age old wisdom, the less I spent, the less I had to earn for the business and the more I could keep for myself. Instead of burning money on things that didn't help the business, or provided very small benefit financially but added more hours to grind out, I killed those things off and buried them. Changed my life with owning a small business for myself. It went from spending money like it was going out of style to gain a few more on top, working insane hours everyday, literally almost killing myself with neglect to my health and sleep, to enjoyment again and restoring my health. Frankly, some businesses and ideas won't scale, no matter how hard you try, and they won't exit for millions or billions at an IPO, but it doesn't make them failures if they give you the ability to provide for your home and find time to do other things that might down the road. Just my two cents. I've been in your shoes as have most here. Starting a business is one of the most insane experiences I think anyone can go through.
- spaginal 10y agoJust in my own experience, after having started a very small company several years ago that is moderately successful for me, nothing Hacker News would care about in the million and billion scheme, but it pays my mortgage and gives me a comfortable life, I found that you will naturally fall into wasting time during work to relax if you ignore it at the expense of said work. Granted, this time doesn't offer much benefit in the course of the working day, personally I'd find if I started work early, that sometimes the meat of my day really wouldn't be productive until later, even though I had been at work for several hours before productivity really took off. When I had my second son and my wife stayed home for three months, I found myself spending most mornings going to the park with my children and wife and just enjoying the first part of my day with them. Each day I did this I came into work in the afternoon with a lot more energy and focus and finished the same amount of work, or more, plus I was able to enjoy my family and felt more fulfilled overall. If I had started my day rolling groggily into the shop with coffee in hand and heroically pounding away, it would have taken me those same hours just to wind up into productivity, and my day would feel more tiring and unfulfilling in the end. Honestly, 7 years in now, I've found I have a natural rhythm to my day, hours I'm focused, hours I'm tired, hours I just don't care and want to do something else, and if I try to work outside of this rhythm, it doesn't make me any more productive, just busy on my own time and needlessly braggadocios towards others when I can say I "worked" 16 hours yesterday when really only 5 hours had anything get done. This is my own experience though, and to each their own. I tried all the productivity hacking and life hacking and it seemed for me, at the end of the day, that finding time to not work did more to help my work than working for the sake of work.
- 1_player 10y agoYes, I agree with you 100%. In my case I am a freelancer, so I have strict deadlines and clients might expect me to work the full 8 hours or more. Hell, I've even been asked to work over the weekends and get my hourly rate adjusted accordingly. I always decline, my flow state does not last more than 5 hours per day with plenty of lazying around on weekends, and working more than that would mean spreading it to a mediocre productivity. Deadlines are met, and clients are happy (as far as I know). Unless we are underachievers, I suspect many are in the same boat and would be as productive with 20% fewer hours.
- suppacodah 10y ago+points for the big boobs in the center xD
- fredoliveira 10y agoYou seem to be new - have a look at the guidelines for comments here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- suppacodah 10y ago+points for the big boobs in the center
- atemerev 10y agoI wonder how people in the US are still struggling with this obvious notion that having a good rest is important, not only for the "quality of life", whatever it is, but for the quality of work itself. Here in Europe, this is regarded as self-evident.
- real-hacker 10y agoMaybe it is not wasting time that is fulfilling, it is adjusting the rhythm that is fulfilling. I think it's more about allocating enough time for both left brain/right brain, or id/ego.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoI believe that I have elevated wasting time to an art form. For decades I only worked 4 days a week, even for large corporations, and spent my extra day off on my sailboat or at the beach. I am fairly busy right now, but I am still taking two short hikes today, morning and late afternoon with two groups of friends. A recent book I bought written by Cal Newport "Deep Work" inspires me to keep my habits, with some refinements. I pay a price for taking lots of time off: "leaving money on the table." For me it is worth it.
- stevenkovar 10y agoSpending time on fun or interesting things is a good way to zero out your 'stressbox' and can be (I'd say should be) just as deliberate a daily habit as zeroing out your email inbox.