6 ms·
On emotional authenticity and masking as an autistic person
- zw123456 10y agoI have often thought that autistic people or socio-path people who have had to learn the appropriate responses to various human emotions would be a good resource for AI research in the area of developing more "human like" interactions. I am not autistic but I think I have elements of that lack of empathy, so I have had to also learn certain rule sets in a similar way: if someone says thing A that is supposed to have reaction B. Intensity of A implies Intensity B depending on situation C and so on. It would be interesting to capture all those rule sets from various subjects.
- throwaway91111 10y agoI always thought that austic people had an abundance of empathy but dealing with that is very hard.
- zw123456 10y agohmmm, could be I am confusing sociopathy and autism ?
- throwaway91111 10y agoI have no idea; some people on the autistic spectrum may have issues with it too. I guess my point is that autism seems to be about ability to handle social situations rather than the underlying reasons.
- mercer 10y agoAs I understand it a distinction is made in psychology between affective empathy and cognitive empathy. Affective empathy is feeling sad when you see someone sad. Cognitive empathy is the ability to "put yourself in another's shoes", so to speak. Autistic people can come across as lacking empathy because they have difficulty with the latter, but the 'affective' form of empathy is (usually?) quite functional. In fact, there's even some evidence that autistic people have more affective empathy on average, or at least they experience it more intensely. For many people with Asperger's this is perhaps the shittiest part of their condition. In social interaction they can appear quite narcissistic and lacking in empathy, but internally they feel just the same amount of guilt, sadness, or regret as 'regular' people, if not more.
- trevyn 10y agoIt would be, if explicitly capturing rule sets was a thing people did in AI anymore. ;)
- zw123456 10y agoCapturing rule sets has not gone away, they just call it something else now.
- mcguire 10y agoNTs?
- ColinWright 10y agoNeuro-Typicals
- kingkawn 10y agoThis concept seems like a fallacy designed to deepen one's own sense of alienation without illuminating what it is that the others are actually doing
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoCould you elaborate on this? I disagree with what it seems you're saying, but I'm not sure I get your point.
- NikolaeVarius 10y agoThe idea of a Normal person/other. Sort of like one of those "Normal People Scare Me" T-Shirts
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoI find it strange people are so averse to the idea there's a "normal", particularly if we confine ourselves to talking about, eg, social behavior traits. Statistically, there is, and most people cluster around being sort of that, even though no one is exactly the "norm". I think people just get used to making hyperfine distinctions within their cluster and forget how homogeneous the cluster actually is from the outside. Sort of like you can generally tell apart faces from peoples you grew up around better than ones you didn't. The truth is we do all look alike, just like outsiders see, even if the differences seem prominent to us.
- DanBC 10y ago
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoI want to read this, but it's slightly too wide for my phone screen (the start of words is cut off with no way to scroll) and I can't figure out how to adjust it. It starts loading where it fits, then jumps to too wide woth no ability to fix by zooming. Edit: Works on desktop site, so I'm sure it's just the mobile version being "clever". But seriously, annoying. (Left in case anyone else has the same issue -- requesting desktop site fixed it for me.)
- Analemma_ 10y agoIt's not just you, it started happening to me on Tumblr a lot several months ago. Something has gone badly wrong with their mobile layout. I wouldn't be surprised though; I can't imagine Veri-hoo considers Tumblr a priority.
- throwaway91111 10y agoI really recommend the app.
- alexashka 10y agoI can relate to the frustration but this whole article is in poor-me mode. The author expresses his/her frustration with developing connections - I understand. The most important thing to realize is, no one wants to be around complainers. Except other complainers, they get together and complain, and theorize about why the world is not the way they want it to be. Being able to emotionally relate is honestly a false flag - there are plenty of people who are socially oblivious and they're doing just fine. If the author was a super athlete and couldn't relate to people, he would simply be a 'jerk'. I bet he wouldn't have written that article :) So really, it's not that you can't relate to people - it's that you haven't found a way to win despite having a bit of a setback and you are spending your energy on complaining. Here's the solution: go and become really good at something, that other people value, and they'll forgive your social strangeness, in fact, they'll find it exotic and interesting. Just go be really really good. At social dancing, at sports, at music, at dragon boating, beach volleyball, etc. Something social that takes skill and persistence that regular people don't have. Autistic people have the gift of not being burdened by the same social programming most people are living in. The ones who take advantage of it live a great life. I mean, look at Elon Musk...
- CarolineW 10y ago> ...this whole article is in poor-me mode. That strikes me as being very ungenerous. The article comes across to me as an honest attempt to explain as clearly as possible the social interactions internals of one particular autistic person - the author - to someone who is not autistic. I found it an interesting insight. > Here's the solution: ... How do you know? What are your specific qualifications that let you speak with such definite certainty?
- alexashka 10y agoCaroline, you're giving me a version of 'that's just like, your opinion man', coupled with 'I don't like your tone'. I understand the author better than you think. The author has a worldview of 'my life is hard because X', coupled with 'X is something most people can't relate to'. My point is, everyone goes through 'my life is hard because X' - the solution is to work around it. I offered a few options that have worked for me and people I know. In regards to qualifications - people who have them don't go around asking, the qualifications are implicit in the value they bring to the table. People who explicitly ASK for qualifications, are typically just being passive-aggressive, which's fine - it's just good to be aware of what you're doing.
- Kenji 10y ago>It’s unsafe for me to react authentically to anyone. Not sure if that's a problem of our society or of the individuals themselves. I feel like we have extremely low tolerance for nonstandard behaviour.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- HarryHirsch 10y agoCompared to other nations, I find Americans extremely standardized. It must be the repressive schooling combined with the extremely regimented college experience. They have a great need to belong.
- maxerickson 10y agoHigher education attainment isn't uniform and is thus unlikely to be a particularly large factor in uniformity. https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publications/2016/demo/p20-578.pdf https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publicatio... (even among young people less than half the population has an associates degree or more)
- thatcat 10y agoThe intellectual community has its own standards and protocols that mostly homogenous and are an extension of the us high schools standards.
- oneplane 10y agoThe 'how are you doing' you always seem to get from total strangers always baffles me when I visit that country. Whats, worse, it's not a real question, but just a protocol that demands the "I'm fine, thank you" type of answer in all cases. Neither party gets anything out of it, and instead of being some sort of prelude/preamble it's just something on it's own with no use whatsoever.
- 10y ago
- DenisM 10y agoThere is a set of skills that might help quite a bit. Big Bang Theory to the rescue: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vkSwXL3cGUg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vkSwXL3cGUg It's not an easy skill, but it only need to be learned once.
- gcr 10y agoBringing up the Big Bang Theory as a realistic example of how to deal with a person with autism and calling your action a "rescue" is petty and hurtful. That show only shows harmful stereotypes of nerds for people to laugh at. What social skills could you possibly hope to magically convey through one two-minute laugh track? The author is fighting a lifelong battle here. Please at least respect their struggle.
- DenisM 10y agoThe video is a good example of active listening. You don't have to understand what the other person is saying in order to connect with them. It's a very useful skill, removes a lot of stress from interaction.
- gcr 10y agoOh, that's what you were getting at. I suppose so, but it feels like that scene was played up for laughs because of how fake Anne felt the conversation, which completely went over Sheldon's head.
- Neliquat 10y agoThis is here because it applies on some level to us all. I have a couple autist friends and they are awesome, and I understand that their emotions calibrate differently, but are still there and meaningful. After a while, you learn to calibrate to them, and can connect on another level. But this takes both sides letting down their guard and assuming good intentions. Something rare enough in love, let alone friendship. The time spent is worth it in either case.
- mercer 10y agoIndeed. Autistic people are often extremely loyal, non-judgmental (in particular ways), and lacking in much ego. If you can get past the problems that this 'miscalibration' cause, there are a lot of benefits to having an autistic friend! I don't blame people who are not up to the challenge, but I do hate it when people aren't even willing to respect the differences and instead choose to cast moral judgment.
- danellis 10y agoHe says he attributes it to his autism, but maybe that isn't the cause at all. I'm not autistic, but I recognized what he was writing about. I have difficulty showing genuine emotions. My wife joking calls me Captain Holt (a reference to the stoic leader of the Brooklyn 99). Encounters with strangers are a draining experience involving a constant inner dialogue that sounds like am-dram director: "Emote more! Bigger smile! Deliver with eye contact! Now bring it down a notch. Act concerned by this revelation."
- ColinWright 10y agoAccording to the profile at the top left of the page, this person's preferred pronouns are "they" and "them". They self-identify as non-binary.
- badosu 10y agoI am sorry, not a native english speaker. What does this mean?
- danellis 10y agoSome people have a mental illness that makes them feel like their biological gender isn't the correct one. For some, they "feel like" the opposite gender. Others feel somewhere in between and extrapolate that to mean that there is a spectrum of genders, hence "non-binary".
- badosu 10y agoSo maybe this is some variation of Gender Dysphoria [0]. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_dysphoria https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_dysphoria Edit: It seems it maybe caused by biological factors as well
- oddlyaromatic 10y agoWould this really be considered a mental illness? You can experience gender in many ways whilst remaining in good mental health. Gender identity is not always mapped directly to biological sex. It is much, much more than something you "feel like".
- dom0 10y ago> NTs seem expert at knowing which of their emotional reactions are appropriate, so they can effortlessly express the appropriate emotions and suppress the inappropriate ones. Emotional reactions and empathy are not consciously regulated on a basic level (at least not for me). Conscious masking of emotions still produces micro-expressions, for example. By the way, emulating an emotional response is not uncommon for "regular" people, too, e.g. when attending a funeral where you don't care about the deceased or attending a wedding where you hate the bride or groom. I'd say it's an important skill for social survival. (I guess it could be argued that empathy is kind-of a low-level emulation of emotional responses... at least in some situations?)
- Analemma_ 10y ago> By the way, emulating an emotional response is not uncommon for "regular" people, too. I think that was the author's point. Everyone, autistic or not, finds themselves in situations where they need to fake emotions. The difference is that "regular people" can detect if the fakery is not working, know instinctually what the "right" response is, and can usually switch gears fast enough to satisfy the other person and save the interaction. The author seemed to be saying that not only do they need to operate off a "playbook" (which is normal for everyone), but that if the playbook goes wrong, they both can't detect it and don't have a backup plan. > I'd say it's an important skill for social survival. I mean, practically the defining characteristic of autism is the extreme difficulty, if not impossibility, of getting these skills. We get them for free "in hardware", but they're trying to do as best they can without them. Reminders like this are kind of redundant and unhelpful.
- scandox 10y agoI am very far from Autistic but I think the whole idea of authentic feeling is rather fragile. I may generate appropriate responses very smoothly but I have no idea if they're authentic until much later. Mostly not. Mostly just what I know people need to see and hear. I imagine an Autistic mind-adventurer who got inside my head would be very disappointed.
- besselheim 10y agoI agree, expressing non-authentic feelings is so common we even have figurative expressions to describe it, e.g. to "put on a brave face" or "grin and bear it". On the other hand, it seems that autistics have the unpleasant pressure of doing this in almost every social interaction.
- make3 10y agoThis post is slightly surlrising to me, although I don't doubt that many people feel like they need to behave that way to be accepted / loved. However, an authentic only response exposes your true feelings and opinions about something, and I feel like most of the time, you should be able to generate a decently socially respectful and well attuned response without misrepresenting yourself, even if it takes a slight bit of effort or risk feeling rejected
- throwaway91111 10y agoThis seems to imply there IS a current feeling. Is that that always the case?
- anotherevan 10y ago> I have no idea if they're authentic until much later. Your emotional response about something can change over time as you process it. Thus your initial response can be authentic even if it isn't how you feel five minutes later.
- arcbyte 10y agoI am not autistic but I relate 100% with the author. In fact I have given lots of thought to this same subject. I have realized that while I usually struggle to find the appropriate emotion to express to people, sometimes I do have authentic emotional experiences, and I wonder if the author does as well. For instance, do you laugh at jokes?
- stared 10y agoIn this subject: https://gist.github.com/stared/98599fc53959b77ac6769de07e759061 https://gist.github.com/stared/98599fc53959b77ac6769de07e759... (from A Mind-Body Look at the Concept of Asperger's Syndrome by Michael Samsel, LMHC)
- throwaway65537 10y agoThat sounds a lot like my current state of mind. Only that I'm not on the autistic spectrum. Just did the wrong thing in trying to tough out a major depression on my own which tuned me to feeling vaguely neutral all the time, plus I somehow lost the ability to be empathic almost completely. I do remember how it's supposed to look though, so hardly anyone notices. If you're feeling like you're blowing fuses, stop what you're doing and get help before you adapt in the worst possible way.
- riyadparvez 10y ago> Just did the wrong thing in trying to tough out a major depression on my own Can you please post what did to tough out
- jancsika 10y ago> Imagine if you had to consciously process every breath. It would seem stilted and robotic. You wouldn’t be able to fully concentrate on anything else. Imagine how exhausting and disabling that would be! This is a dangerous analogy. The logical consequence is that any reasonable person with this condition would take a "cure" if (well, when) it's available. After all, who in their right mind would want to think to breathe! What happens when those "cured" patients want to go to sleep to revamp the cognitive exhaustion they're used to, they're instead treated to an entire new domain of emotional impressions and memories to process? When they try incessantly to "solve" these emotional impressions and memories, but only end up creating yet more emotional impressions? What happens when they realize that "null" doesn't actually equal "0"-- that they cannot ever turn off their new sensory perception?
- tjalfi 10y agoAn Experimental Autism Treatment Cost Me My Marriage[0] is a concrete example of the costs of a cure. Edited to add the title of the article and move the link to a footnote. [0] https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2016/03/18/an-experimental-autism-treatment-cost-me-my-marriage/?_r=0 https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2016/03/18/an-experimental-au...
- jancsika 10y agoThat's a great example. I was speculating after having seen an interview with someone blind from birth who had gained limited sight late in life. But it appears the point applies quite well to this case.