10 ms·
BMW i3 Long Term Battery Capacity Report: Better Than Expected
- _benedict 10y agoThis is an interesting article, but the cross-validation is perhaps suspect? It seems likely the 'percentage used' indicator is based on the same underlying measurements as the 'estimated capacity' service indicator. So it's quite likely illusory validation of the 4% loss figure.
- faragon 10y agoTL;DR: if manufacturer gives a guarantee for a component, the component will last for honoring the guarantee.
- chiph 10y agoThere is a catch. A coworker had the battery on his wife's Honda Insight go bad. No worries - it was only 18 months old, so get it replaced under warranty. Afterwards, they were informed that the new battery would be covered under Honda's replacement part warranty - 12 months. And not the remainder of the 8 year/80,000 mile original equipment warranty.
- mikeash 10y agoThat can't be legal.
- xexers 10y agoIt likely is legal. The BestBuy extended warranties work the same way. If BestBuy ultimately needs to replace your product, then your extended warranty is finished.
- mikeash 10y agoExtended warranties are totally different from original warranties.
- URSpider94 10y agoWarranties on cars are much more highly regulated than service plans on consumer electronics.
- eganist 10y agohttp://www.insightcentral.net/KB/faq-purchasing.html http://www.insightcentral.net/KB/faq-purchasing.html Seems like this source disagrees. They may wish to get their money back.
- chiph 10y agoThey don't mention the warranty on the replacement battery, which is what my friend discovered isn't so great.
- madez 10y agoThanks for this information. I didn't think about checking replacement parts warrenty rules, silently assuming they were the same. That they are not smells fishy.
- chiph 10y agoIf you're shopping for a hybrid or EV, talk to the service manager and ask what the policy is. It's possible Honda may have changed it since then.
- gambiting 10y agoSucks, but it depends where you live. In Poland the law specifically says that if a replacement is provided under warranty then the replacement has to be covered for the same amount of time as a brand new component would be covered for(so in this case if the battery is replaced at any point under warranty the replacement has to have 8 years of warranty by law)
- jsight 10y agoI suspect that they were wrong. Unless this is a state by state thing or something, a warranty replacement cannot shorten the length of the existing warranty. The replacement part warranty should only apply to any time after the expiration of the original warranty.
- protomyth 10y agoWas it a manufacturer warranty or one of the after-market ones that some dealerships sell?
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoOne of the original Tesla founders pointed out that the 2-3 year life everyone is used to from laptops and phones was mostly due to lack of any business need for longer lasting batteries. Now that EVs demand it, people are doing the engineering to make it happen.
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoGM seems to have the best battery health system. Doesn't let you charge past 85%, 90%, always keeps 10% or 15% in reserve. Only reports the chunk between. Dedicated robust temperature control system. Volt has been out since 2011 with as-far-as-I-know no battery degradation issues. Some people have driven well over 300,000 miles with no problems.
- zwily 10y agoBest out of who? Tesla's seems very robust as well.
- sremani 10y agoBest of affordable cars. I get your point, but none of the Tesla's available on the market are really outside high end luxury segment.
- patrickpkt 10y agoThat's how the i3 works as well. There are 22kwh of batteries in board, but it only uses about 18kwh for the sake of efficiency and longer life.
- mtgx 10y ago> Some people have driven well over 300,000 miles with no problems. I assume at least 2/3 of those miles were on gas?
- sremani 10y agoThe Volt with most miles (in real life) is 379201.03 and its has 132643.18 ev miles, so you are about right for that one. edit: https://www.voltstats.net/Stats/Details/1579 https://www.voltstats.net/Stats/Details/1579 There may be longevity tale unfolding with PHEVs, but we can only guess.
- jessriedel 10y agoWhy do we even call "90%" if the battery is disallowed to charge higher for (presumably) longevity reasons? Why not call that "100%"? Assuming I disabled the automatic cutoff at the filling station, I could squeeze a bit more gasoline in my tank by filling the pipe up to the gas cap, but I wouldn't say I'm at 95% for not doing this. (In contrast, it makes sense to say that the car reports "empty" even when it's at 10%, because you can keep driving it .)
- jgrahamc 10y agoThe BMW i3 is a really nice car to drive around London for short trips. There's a pretty good charging infrastructure through ChargeNow and the car is nippy. It takes a short while to get used to the regenerative braking system and I particularly like the rear mounted camera for parking.
- xattt 10y agoIs there anything special about the camera or did you previously have a vehicle without one? Rear view cameras will be mandatory on US cars starting with the 2018 MY.
- swozey 10y ago> Rear view cameras will be mandatory on US cars starting with the 2018 MY. Woah, never expected that. I remember thinking they'd be a gimmick when I first got one. Life changer.
- sandworm101 10y agoI am 100% against those cameras on everyday cars(not trucks). In a few minutes im heading to the local pool to swim laps. That parking lot is a nightmare. Older people in the nicer/largest cars heads-down watching the screen while backing up. Ive seen far to many close calls. Cars should be limited to 0.01 mph while using such cameras. Remember what happens next. They will want to remove mirrors. Then rear windows will go. Backing and changing lanes will become like instrument flying. Pedestrians and two-wheelers beware.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lucaspiller 10y agoCould you explain a bit more? If you are going backwards, and looking at the view behind you, then what is the issue? I have one on my car, and it shows ~140 degree field of view - I can see more from the camera than I can through any of the mirrors.
- Theodores 10y agoThe i3s that I see in London don't appear to be plugged in, they seem owned by people who don't have that at home. I presume they plug in at work but without knowing that there is no way for knowing for sure. Are people buying these things, doing a small amount of miles with them and powering them from the petrol engine on-board rather than plugging in? In that way getting preferential parking spaces at airports and in the city centre, no congestion charge needed? I am fine with people using them in 'Prius mode' if it does mean people that did rule out electric due to not having home infrastructure can actually go 'electric lite', running off petrol and opportunistic charging.
- dogma1138 10y agoMore likely that they plug it just around the corner. If they don't have it near the entrance to their building it means that there is one very near by, the council will not put a new one if there is one within walking distance from your residence. The street level charge spots usually have a hour limit for this reason even for resident parking. Source: I live in central London(W2) and when inquiring with Westminster council about a charge spot they've directed me to 3, one at the end of my street and 2 in streets parallel to mine all within 5min walking distance.
- Neliquat 10y agoThis is full of suspect data and shilling on a car that has gotten a lot of bad press. This feels like pure PR. Please respond if you disagree.
- madengr 10y agoThere is the LeafSpy app for Nissan Leaf owners that lets you monitor and log (to DropBox) several battery parameters. Unfortunately Nissan removed the 80% charge timer in newer models, so you have to estimate charge time if you don't want to hit 100%. That being said, you do want to charge to 100% periodically so the cells can be equalized. You can see this happening if your EVSE can log current.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoAll the batteries in the world won't make the i3 pretty.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y agoIt's ugly on purpose to minimize sales.
- danderino 10y agoWhy
- gruturo 10y agoThis is unfortunately so true. I am waiting for the model 3 even though it might mean losing the sizeable German government subsidy, because the i3 is such an eyesore. BMW, if you're listening, stop being afraid of cannibalizing your petrol car sales and make a decent looking EV in the i3 price segment, because this just made you lose a sale to Tesla, and I'm far from alone here. Unless the reason is that the i3 is just a compliance car and you lose money making one, in which case, get your act together because it's 2017 and you risk doing a RIM vs Apple.
- themihai 10y agoI wonder why would someone buy an I3 instead of a Model 3? Model 3 seems to win on all fronts: looks, performance and value for money/price. Is i3 really just a POC for BMW?
- zbrozek 10y agoThe i3 is available _right now_ and the Model 3 isn't. Actually getting getting the car might be a consideration for a lot of people. My housemate has an i3 and it's a fantastic vehicle - the best utilization of plan area of any vehicle I've ever been in.
- pjc50 10y agoThis is hacker news, where allowing the theoretical, unavailable best to be the enemy of the available good is all part of the game :/