3 ms·
Huh, couple years ago Santander in the UK changed their web layout. No big deal, except that my password wouldn't work anymore - I rang them up, and they said "
by gambiting 10y ago
Huh, couple years ago Santander in the UK changed their web layout. No big deal, except that my password wouldn't work anymore - I rang them up, and they said "did you have any special characters in your password? If yes, then they have been removed because the new system does not support special characters. Please use the same password as before, but without special characters".
1) This is one of the largest banks in the UK and they don't accept special characters?
2) If you store my password encrypted(as you should be!), how could you remove any characters from it?
I sent them an official complaint, they replied saying their security is fantastic and there is nothing to worry about, I closed my account a week later.
- OJFord 10y agoThey (as seems to be standard) ask you to enter 3 characters in positions of their choosing, so they need plaintext to be able to do that. It's clearly not as secure as it could be, and it's annoying to work out too - I wish they'd just do normal 2FA. Those plastic keyfobs HSBC use are even worse.
- IshKebab 10y agoI like the plastic keyfobs. They're much more secure than using your phone as 2FA. Basically the only thing keeping HSBC/1st direct secure.
- city41 10y agoHow are they more secure than your phone? If by phone you mean SMS, then I agree. But as far as I understand, TOTP (ie Google Authenticator) is pretty secure. But I'm not a security expert.
- MertsA 10y agoThe plastic key fob is totally isolated from any network. If your phone was isolated like this you would need a new phone. Google Authenticator can be cloned if you compromise the device. A plastic key fob that has no input is for all practical purposes impossible to clone and if it's stolen it can be easily revoked.
- ekimekim 10y agoThis is getting into very marginal territory, but attack surface. Your phone is an entire network-capable OS with god-knows what security vulns or backdoors. Those dongles are an air-gapped, often tamper-resistant chip. For the record, I think services should ideally offer all three options (SMS, TOTP and physical device), since the biggest problem in security is actually getting users to use ANYTHING at all, and something like SMS that offers 99% of the protection in return for easier setup/ease of use is well worth it.
- OJFord 10y agoI'm not convinced they're more secure, but they're most certainly a UX nightmare.
- tsukikage 10y agoThis approach is geared at telephone banking. It means no single employee will learn the entire secret during a call. You generally have a regular password in addition to this step.
- OJFord 10y agoWhy can't I tell a bank employee a time-based 2FA code over the telephone?
- empath75 10y agomy (former) bank used social security numbers as user accounts, and lets you reset your password over the phone with nothing more than address and birth date.
- degenerate 10y agoOK this one takes the cake. WOW.
- ilamont 10y agoChase doesn't except certain characters, including "&"
- jrockway 10y agoIt's one thing to reject special characters at password change time, that's silly but not massively insecure. It's another thing to modify passwords at rest to delete the special characters. (However, the backend could easily have always been doing that, and the frontend changed from silently deleting what you typed to refusing to accept what you typed.) It's silly but probably has to do with some percentage of customers not realizing that - and _ aren't the same character or something.