4 ms·
The landlords one makes the most sense. Land is not elastic. It is a limited resource, and so it doesn't follow supply and demand. The supply in a city never
by jedberg 10y ago
The landlords one makes the most sense. Land is not elastic. It is a limited resource, and so it doesn't follow supply and demand. The supply in a city never changes, only the demand does.
And building up isn't necessarily a solution -- it's exponentially more expensive to go up, because you start needing things like elevators and full time building engineers and so on. So going up only keeps things the same, as the price per square foot of going up is higher, only elevating the cost of that land.
Building out also isn't a solution, because people want to be close to the city center or the things they go to the most. Self-driving cars may help with this issue in the long term, but not the short term.
This blog post[0] summarizes some of the issues.
[0] http://meetingthetwain.blogspot.com/2017/01/live-work-commute-2.html http://meetingthetwain.blogspot.com/2017/01/live-work-commut...
- loeg 10y ago> Building out also isn't a solution, because people want to be close to the city center or the things they go to the most. Self-driving cars may help with this issue in the long term, but not the short term. Self-driving cars won't help in the long term either, for the same reason traffic is terrible in sprawling cities like LA today. Fast, high-density regional transit is needed and even that is only a better constant factor. The N^2 or whatever scaling problem remains.
- hyperpape 10y agoHere are condos renting for $2-3k per month in downtown Raleigh on the 20th-30th floors of a relatively new development (http://www.theplazacoa.com/homesforsale.php http://www.theplazacoa.com/homesforsale.php). Now, that seems astronomically expensive for 1000 sq feet to me, being from the South, but it's cheaper than SF rents from what I hear. And plenty of buildings in Queens, Brooklyn or any US city are shorter than 100 feet. There's tons of room for more building. Building costs are not a complete explanation for the current astronomical prices. Political choices to restrict construction play a huge role.
- bufordsharkley 10y agoWe enact zoning laws with consideration to what we're being taxed to live and work in a high-demand, low-density environment. If a tax on holding onto unimproved land is nearly zero, we're very likely to implement zoning laws banning development, because citizens have little reason to change things. But if the holding cost increases, (say with a significant Land Value Tax) folks now have a reason to legalize development. ...Californians should consider the role of Prop 13 in its current housing crisis.
- s73ver 10y agoThey do, but detractors of Prop 13 also need to remember why it was enacted. Property taxes were skyrocketing, and causing people to lose their homes. Homes they had lived in for most of their lives. These people had done absolutely nothing wrong, except choose to buy a house in a place that later became very desirable. Any solution that does come up should not cause people to be forced from their homes because they became too expensive, or because other people with more money want it.
- bufordsharkley 10y agoThe plight of a person in such a situation should never be discounted, but it's simply not a viable option to guarantee any land holding to be held in perpetuity regardless of ability to pay for its rent. If you ration off land this way (quite inefficiently, that is), you cease to have enough land for everyone else. Which causes a class of suffering far greater than granny deciding to sell out, and move to a condo.
- CuriouslyC 10y agoFrom my perspective, if new tenants are willing to contribute more to society to live somewhere, that should trump who was on the land first. When they sell, the original owners are well compensated by appreciation in property value. Artificially suppressing property taxes to protect entrenched owners is a lot like taxing the internet to support newspapers and record stores.
- nostrademons 10y agoThat doesn't explain the move towards larger cosmopolitan cities, though. The economically rational thing to do if land values in, say, San Francisco or NYC become more expensive is to move to different cities, ones with abundant land and low housing prices. Yet the predominant migration we see is the other way, from small towns and minor cities to big metropolitan areas. Anyone who's been in this situation could explain the reason why: because most of the good jobs are in cities. But then answering the question of "Why are the good jobs in cities?" brings us back to square one, where we have to consider China, robots, monopolies, etc.
- bufordsharkley 10y agoI'm reminded of Jane Jacob's statement about the economics of cities: "To seek 'causes' of poverty in this way is to enter an intellectual dead end because poverty has no causes. Only prosperity has causes." [0] To find that a small city that used to have a manufacturing plant is now struggling shouldn't really be surprising―the city never really had a robust economy, and it's hard to say that it really has a future. Getting a functioning economy that works is really a sort of black magic―when it happens, capture it! Our big cities are one of the surest places we see it, so maybe the real question isn't "why are people moving towards larger cosmopolitan cities," but "why are we making it so hard for our cities to accommodate them?" [0] http://www.efficology.com/the-gift-of-relationships/appreciating-government/455-jane-jacobs-the-economy-of-cities http://www.efficology.com/the-gift-of-relationships/apprecia...
- InclinedPlane 10y agoThere are no jobs there. If you're lucky enough to have job security in a low cost of living part of the country that might work out, but otherwise it's not such a great idea for most people due to high unemployment and lack of high paying jobs. And that's aside from all of the other issues such as friends, culture, things to do, and, frankly, local politics.
- s73ver 10y agoThat's the economically rational thing to do if things are all equal. However, the reason many people are moving to SF is because that's where the VC money is, and therefore that's where the tech jobs are (yes, I know there are other tech hubs out there, but none as big as SV). If the VC money was more willing to spread out, and not require everything to be in SV, then we'd have less of a housing issue there.
- davidw 10y ago> exponentially more expensive to go up A lot of Europe is 2-6 stories over large areas, and that works pretty well and is quite doable with the technology of 200 years ago.
- branchless 10y agoGermany has had flat land prices in real terms for a long time because they have many small banks who are issuing against productive endeavor first and foremost. Hence Germany as an industrial superpower. They also make it easy to procure land to build on to avoid the artificial scarcity used to drive up prices. These are all understood problems.
- logfromblammo 10y agoI think people underestimate the elasticity of land. While it is true that the surface area of the ellipsoid is not changing, economic resources are only counted when they can be brought to market. You don't usually create new [economic] land by dumping dredged sand into a harbor--though such projects do exist. More often, new land is brought to market by building a road to it, or an airstrip on it, or a pier on its shore. And such land is not fungible, it most often has multiple competing uses, and some non-competing uses. And those uses can be amplified by capital improvements. When I want "land" in a city, that's usually at least 75 m^3 of interior building volume as a safe location to sleep and store all my useful stuff. You can make more of that in the same footprint by erecting buildings with more floors--not even necessarily taller, just more floors. Or you can dig down, and again, add more floors. And I value proximity by time, rather than distance. So you can make land "closer" to the city by enabling faster transportation. The 50th floor of a building with a fast elevator is closer to the ground than the 50th floor at the same physical height, but with a slow elevator. The suburb next to an expressway is closer than the one without convenient roads. We really still have plenty of available land, barring situations like Hong Kong or Singapore. The Chicago-Pittsburgh megalopolis has more untapped land supply than the Boston-DC megalopolis, but those acres can all be gridded and developed to the limit of human engineering ability, which is a pretty darned distant limit. The problem is usually that development is often politically constrained such that supply cannot change as quickly as demand. You just can't build fast enough in Silicon Valley, and you just can't demolish fast enough in Detroit.
- bufordsharkley 10y agoThis is essentially accurate, but I have to ask: why do you think that development is often politically constrained?
- benjiwengy 10y agoLand is defined as everything not supplied by human effort. It is thus perfectly inelastic in supply. Bringing land into use is a service ie Labor. Hope this helps.
- 10y ago