7 ms·
Virtually eliminating road fatalities is quite possible, Sweden has done it. The low speed limits and infrastructure spending on separated pedestrian & cyclis
by bryanlarsen 10y ago
Virtually eliminating road fatalities is quite possible, Sweden has done it. The low speed limits and infrastructure spending on separated pedestrian & cyclist paths would never fly in the United States.
http://www.visionzeroinitiative.com/ http://www.visionzeroinitiative.com/
- froh42 10y agoWhich is really sad, because (and I say that as a hard core auto driver) riding a bike through the city significantly lowers your death risk (also by health benefits) as long as there are bike lanes. Bike riders also solve traffic jams (by NOT going bar car), make cities more silent and more liveable, bring more business to local stores and restaurants etc.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoI feel like there should be an internet wide ban on comparing Sweden and Norway to the US, China, India or Russia or, hell pretty much anywhere. Obligatory Reference to wit: http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_world_/2014/08/29/will_everyone_shut_up_already_about_how_the_nordic_countries_top_every_global.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/the_world_/2014/08/29/will_everyo...
- foxbarrington 10y agoI was hoping there would be a novel reason to stop comparing Nordic countries to the rest of the world. Sadly the main points the article makes are: (1) they are welfare states and that would never be welcome anywhere else and (2) they have small populations. So... (1) maybe a welfare state isn't that bad? and (2) that's akin to not believing in small-scale trials/pilots because they're small.
- strange_quark 10y agoAlso that they're incredibly homogenous and that they may be just as racist and unequal as the rest of us, but nobody notices because everybody in their country is the same race.
- vacri 10y agoSweden has its share of problems. It's not a fantasy state where everything is hunky-dory. The south of Sweden is a European hotspot for anti-semitic violence, for example. It also currently has a spate of hand-grenade attacks by organised crime, the only area of its kind in the West[1]. As for 'incredibly homogenous', they have a larger foreign-born population (15%) than the US (14%) or the UK (12%). While that number doesn't tell the full story, sure, it does show that Sweden isn't some hermit-state. And it's neighbour Norway has the highest immigration rate of any western democracy that isn't a city-state. Trying to find reasons to exclude Sweden as a comparator is basically condoning bad behaviour. It's not a perfect fantasy state; they're just doing really well in the quality-of-life stakes. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_grenade_attacks_in_Sweden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_grenade_attacks_in_Swe...
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoI think #2 is the most valid and compelling reason for a host of reasons. The other thing that is in the article that shouldn't be dismissed the homogeneity of the population. That goes a long way toward making #1 possible as it's easier to empathize across a smaller population.
- corybrown 10y agoPlenty of US states have small populations, no? Also lots of states are comparatively homogeneous (Sweden has 19% of population as recent immigrants).
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoSure, so those comparisons are actually more apt! You rarely if ever see them made however. Georgia, Michigan, NC and NJ are the closest in size but that's about where it ends. Michigan probably has the closest demographic homogeneity. However the existence of the federal government as well as natural resources as a economic base throws a wrench into any further comparisons.
- corybrown 10y ago> natural resources as a economic base True for Norway, but not any other country in the neighborhood (fine, Scotland I guess)
- foxbarrington 10y agoHomogeneity isn't one of the main points though. The article barely touches on it -- mentioned in one sentence, almost as an afterthought. Also, as some other commenters point out, their homogeneity isn't on a different scale from places that aren't topping the charts.
- rtpg 10y agoI don't understand how having a small population means anything when it comes to the most local of things: the speed limit on a bit of road. I can understand saying "well they have a bunch of Oil money and not much ground to cover" but most things in the universe can be solved at scale in the same way they're tackled in these countries. It'd be like if Sweden was the only place that invented spark plugs and you're like "Well they're a really small country so they have less people to give spark plugs to so it's feasible".
- m00x 10y agoGeographically, Sweden and the US are immensely different. Sweden, as well as most of Europe, is densely populated and has good public transportation infrastructure. The US on the other hand is a very large area with low density and poor public transport.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoSweden and the US have almost exactly the same population density (22/km2 vs 24/km2) and GDP (50K vs 56K). The only reason that Sweden has substantially better public transportation infrastructure than the US is because it chooses to.
- Nadya 10y agoIt's also much easier to build infrastructure in regions of 447,435 km² than it is for 9.834 million km². Sweden is a little larger than California (423,970 km²) "The United States has terrible public transport" doesn't hold true for pocket regions which have very reliable public transport. You just can't very reliably go across the country because some of our states are larger than many, if not most, European countries. Not to mention geographical differences. Compare a topography map of Sweden with California.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> You just can't very reliably go across the country because some of our states are larger than many, if not most, European countries. This is such a weird argument. I can take a train from London to Paris to Zurich to Berlin, despite them being entirely different countries. You're telling me travelling between US states is somehow massively harder? > Compare a topography map of Sweden with California. Switzerland has a) some of the most challenging topography in the world and b) one of the most extensive, heavily used train systems in the world.
- soared 10y agoYes, the US is bigger than Europe: https://jeffsbiketour.files.wordpress.com/2016/05/usa-europe.png https://jeffsbiketour.files.wordpress.com/2016/05/usa-europe...
- strictfp 10y agoThis only works since Sweden is so sparsely populated. People here routinely drive 40 -60 kmph above the speed limit, especially where the new limits are ridiculously low considering road conditions.