5 ms·
Range anxiety ... any word on the hydrogen powered car revolution? Perhaps we should move on that one.
by JKCalhoun 10y ago
Range anxiety ... any word on the hydrogen powered car revolution? Perhaps we should move on that one.
- _ph_ 10y agoClean hydrogen production takes about 3x electricity for driving the same distance, than directly charging a battery powered car. And that does not even take the difficulties of transporting hydrogen into aspect. So hydrogen might have a future for airplanes, but much less so for cars.
- Neliquat 10y agoHonda thinks otherwise, and just rolled out a new model based on fuel cell tech this month iirc. The biggest issues have been lack of filling stations, and decreased trunk space. Hydrogen is similar in safety to lpg, and filled in a similar way.
- _ph_ 10y agoIf you look at the complexity of a fuel cell vehicle, you can easily see why car manufacturers like this technology :). Toyota, who did create the Mirai, recently launched an electric car program. Hydrogen is more complex to handle than lpg, which as the name says, is liquid at 5-10 atmospheres, while hydrogen is a gas and stored at 300 atmospheres pressure, the filling stations have to compress it to 700 atmospheres to fill the tank in reasonable time. This compression is a big factor in the energy overhead of hydrogen.
- pdelbarba 10y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted. This is the reality of the situation. I don't really see hydrogen being used in aircraft either, honestly. It's not even the energy imbalance, it's storage in the vehicle. It's not Hindenburg levels of unsafe but it's definitely worse than batteries and maybe gasoline. The amount of energy you can store per unit volume is only about twice a Li-ion cell (slightly better by weight, but that's not the issue in cars and supporting equipment further hurts this) and will likely be no better than the next generation of LiS cells.
- Symmetry 10y agoI agree about the infeasibility of hydrogen cars but I always imagine that if you were going to run a hydrogen gas station you'd just manufacture the hydrogen on-site taking advantage of the already existing water and electrical grids.
- Robotbeat 10y ago... then it might be more like 4 or 8x as much, since you'll be operating at a lower scale and thus likely to have a less efficient electrolysis unit. Additionally, your electricity tariff will likely be much higher than the rate of a centralized electrolysis station.
- Roritharr 10y agoIsn't most Hydrogen made from Breaking up Methane anyway?
- JKCalhoun 10y ago3x the electricity isn't an issue if transporting the hydrogen were reliable. There's a reason energy-gobbling industries like the aluminum foundries are situated along rivers where hydroelectric power is nearly free.
- Pica_soO 10y agoUsing the hype of yesterday to vaccinate against hyperitis of tomorrow? That sounds like meme-medicine.
- koreyb 10y agoAlmost no hydrogen station infrastructure. 34 total stations nationwide (most are in California) http://www.afdc.energy.gov/fuels/hydrogen_locations.html http://www.afdc.energy.gov/fuels/hydrogen_locations.html
- Robotbeat 10y agoPretty good case to be made that you'd have a LOT more range anxiety in a hydrogen car. Take the Toyota Mirai, for example. 312 mile range, slightly less than the best Tesla. So right off the bat, not at all clear you're better off from a total range perspective. Filling stations are 4 minutes for hydrogen. Tesla has shown battery swap in about 90 seconds. But it turns out that's not really necessary, as Supercharging can be done fast enough, ultimately in about 10 minutes. But there's another thing: unless you install a hydrogen station in your home, you'll always be on the look-out for a hydrogen station (which are incredibly rare). In an electric car, you leave your house with a full charge (or nearly full) just about every day. And the Supercharger network is big enough to easily go cross-country. Same can definitely not be said for hydrogen. This ability to leave home with a full charge every day is why electric cars (with Supercharging capability) can actually have LESS range anxiety than gasoline, diesel, or hydrogen vehicles, especially as more high power chargers are installed. As it stands now, you'll have FAR less range anxiety in a Model S (or model 3 when it comes out) than a hydrogen car, and this will only get better as more stations are installed. And even for the same number of stations, a Model S/3/X will do better than hydrogen simply because you leave home with an (almost) fully charged battery. (additionally, workplace chargers aren't uncommon, and even some other destinations include chargers... With the high capacity and high charge rate enabled by large-battery electric vehicles, "range anxiety" is basically a thing of the past.)
- tim333 10y ago>LESS range anxiety than gasoline I don't have much range anxiety in my gasoline powered car. The last hackathon I attended I chatted to a girl who arrived 6 hours late having set off from a home 2 hours drive away. Turned out she was driving an electric BMW, took a wrong turning, ran out of range as a result so then had to drive to a charging station, wait for it to charge and continue. So these things are not totally fixed.
- Robotbeat 10y agoYou chopped off my quote. "can have LESS". "can" be an operative word, there. An electric BMW is not compatible with the Supercharger network, which is faster and more extensive than other networks. Additionally, it has one-half the electric range of even a lower end Tesla, and about a third the electric range of a large-battery Tesla. It's really not a good example of what "can" be done. You also picked a 2 hour drive. For a lot of people, this isn't super common. More common is commuting every day, when you might run low on gas and have to worry about when in your schedule to fit in a trip to a gas station while if you have an electric vehicle, you simply charge at home each night and so don't have to worry about it.