5 ms·
Hate-speech can be tricky. There are edge cases where what is "true" can be hard to determine. But in a large proportion of cases veracity is easy to determine.
by Angostura 10y ago
Hate-speech can be tricky. There are edge cases where what is "true" can be hard to determine. But in a large proportion of cases veracity is easy to determine.
Are you suggesting that we just throw up out hands and say "there's really no point trying to determine what is a fact, these days?"
- LyndsySimon 10y ago> Hate-speech can be tricky. It seems pretty clear to me. Hate speech is free speech.
- mratzloff 10y agoSure, and a private company isn't obligated to present it.
- talmand 10y agoI have no problem with this as long as the company is being honest with what they're doing and why.
- dmerfield 10y agoNor is a government. But the founders thought the principle of free-speech was a good one and so we have the 1st amendment.
- splawn 10y agoWith the 1st amendment, the government can never censor (with a few exceptions)... however companies can censor whatever they want for whatever reason they want, perhaps ironically, as an expression of freedom of speech.
- dmerfield 10y agoI'm aware. My point was that the founders of the US Government chose to uphold the principle of free speech. The founders of companies like Google, Facebook and Twitter chose not to.
- splawn 10y agoI see. Your point is that the principle of free speech is something different than the 1st amendment and the authors of the amendment messed up and allowed a loophole.
- apostacy 10y agoI think that if a company has enough of a monopoly on information that they become a de-facto governing agency, that they should be forced to uphold the principles of the 1st amendment. Facebook should be classified as something like a common carrier.
- splawn 10y agoI understand now, and it's hard not to agree with that perspective. On the other hand, because of the fundamental relationship of the free press and health of democracy, shouldn't there be some kind of criteria for validity the same way that health claims in advertising do, for example? I understand that some things are subjective and impossible to apply criteria to, but what about cases where people are knowingly publishing demonstrable falsehoods to mislead masses of people. Seems like a major problem. Btw, im not sure what my opinion is on this.... Im just "devil advocating", I guess. EDIT:/foundational/fundamental Im having a hard time with words today. :/
- deciplex 10y agoSo is yelling fire in a movie theater, then.
- ChairmanPao 10y agoIdiot much? https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2015/05/07/no-theres-no-hate-speech-exception-to-the-first-amendment/?utm_term=.8613b3e8c4cd https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/201...
- deciplex 10y agoall the time fucko
- Frondo 10y agoNot in a lot of places, e.g., Canada and Germany, to name two off the top of my head... (And for the record, I'd happily vote to place additional restrictions on hate speech in the U.S., following the models presented by those two countries. I'm simply not afraid of the slippery slope arguments that people bring up; I think they're fallacious.)
- coldtea 10y agoYeah, what issue could there be from additional restrictions on "hate speech" in a country with litigation happy fundamentalist christians on one side and "freedom fighters" on the other each considering their own BS ideas of hate speech. With a history of red scare and McCarthyism and other such niceties to top.
- droopyEyelids 10y agoBoy you misinterpreted that one. He's saying it's dangerous as fuck to let anyone determine what is appropriate to say and what is not appropriate to say. When you're talking about infrastructure fundamental to everyone's life determining what can be communicated you're talking about building 95% of the infrastructure of tyranny in one fell swoop. Do you think the government or the officers of Alphabet will always be Good people that you agree with? History is rife with examples of awful people taking over once-benevolent powerful institutions.
- LeeHwang 10y agoI think it is dangerous as well. Alphabet has shown to more interested in political power than principles. From Eric directly being involved in the clinton campaign. https://qz.com/823922/eric-schmidt-played-a-crucial-role-in-team-hillarys-election-tech/ https://qz.com/823922/eric-schmidt-played-a-crucial-role-in-... http://www.googletransparencyproject.org/articles/googles-support-hillary-clinton http://www.googletransparencyproject.org/articles/googles-su... And now google donating money to Trump. http://dailycaller.com/2017/04/21/google-donated-285000-to-trumps-inauguration-despite-avid-hillary-democrat-support/ http://dailycaller.com/2017/04/21/google-donated-285000-to-t... Plus we know the amount of pressure PRISM and the other intelligence agencies can put on Silicon Valley companies.
- coldtea 10y ago>Are you suggesting that we just throw up out hands and say "there's really no point trying to determine what is a fact, these days?" I'm saying it's not Google's job to determine what is a fact. Was a reporter denying WMDs in 2003 a fact or "false news"? Was Garry Web [1] a writer of facts or a fake news spreader? The answers were much less clear at the time, and the established press and media/internet overlords would have labeled both fake news and be done with it... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gary_Webb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gary_Webb
- lordCarbonFiber 10y agoI don't know why this seems to be so hard for people to understand. We already have, very effective I might add, laws that tackle grey areas. The entire notion of "due diligence" in business is this exactly. As a business you have to prove that you did all that a "reasonable" (deliberately vague to allow the term to grow as technology does) entity would to follow the law. Suddenly the idea of "fake news" isn't so murky. A reporter doing his/her due diligence in 2003 could have concluded there were wmds in Iraq, a reporter in 2017 that says the same is a hawker of fake news. It's not a hard bar to apply, especially to the most grievous offenders today (the Breitbarts and Huffington posts of the world for example). There's no overlord trying to hide the conspiracies of the world, it's just bringing a much needed regulation to the news, as essential component to the modern democracy.
- yunocat 10y ago> There's no overlord trying to hide the conspiracies of the world, it's just bringing a much needed regulation to the news, as essential component to the modern democracy. Who defines 'reasonable' when 'news' is inherently opinionated? The one with the deepest pockets for legal protection? Who says that only 'businesses' are and should be the ones reporting news? And who regulates the regulators? Seriously.. EFF v ATT, for starters, along with any of the entirely half baked 1-sided, spin-laden 'real news' that is coming out of just about any major entity these days..
- coldtea 10y ago>A reporter doing his/her due diligence in 2003 could have concluded there were wmds in Iraq That's what I'm afraid of. Google doing the same kind of BS "due diligence" and then forbidding counter opinions (the equivalent of "no WMDs" in 2003) as fake news. >There's no overlord trying to hide the conspiracies of the world No, just many private interests that treat each other well...
- ChairmanPao 10y agoDo you really think that, say "flat earth" people, who do little harm, should be removed from the Internet? What about people who believe in Bigfoot, or the Loch Ness Monster? Or UFOlogists? There are things that are obviously false, but probably harmless enough.