7 ms·
"Learning haskell" is pretty much in the same category as "Write that novel I've been thinking about."
by empath75 10y ago
"Learning haskell" is pretty much in the same category as "Write that novel I've been thinking about."
- 1ba9115454 10y agoYou've got more chance of writing the novel.
- 27182818284 10y agoThat was similar to my thinking. I chuckled a bit when I saw so much of what I think folks would consider corporate tool-sets like VBA being used in the day compared to like Haskell (that I've never seen in the professional world but know several people that hack around in it) being written at night. Kind of a fun chart.
- csours 10y agoI'm torn between laughing and crying; having used VBA extensively in the past. I've used VBA for stupid things like Excel based apps (not stupid at the time, but in hindsight there was a better way) and stupid things like HMI software with VBA hooks (GE Fanuc Cimplicity, in case you were wondering).
- thepratt 10y agoThe biggest player using Haskell would be Google.
- eru 10y agoThere have been a bunch of 20% projects; but only recently have they started any full-time Haskell work, as far as I know.
- Morgawr 10y agoOne of the biggest(.) Google projects with Haskell is probably Ganeti ( https://github.com/ganeti/ganeti https://github.com/ganeti/ganeti ), which is a mix of python and Haskell and has been around since 2008ish (although Haskell was introduced later, iirc). We recently moved our main development to github so the repo seems a bit empty, we're certainly happy to get more contributors if you are interested, as the community is fairly small and specialized. Everyone is welcome. Source: I'm one of the current main developers of the project. (.) Note: I actually have no idea if it's the 'biggest'.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- _ao789 10y agoLol at stating a fact and then citing thst you have no idea. Haha
- kobeya 10y agoLol at the citation being the emoji of an anus, where he likely pulled the factoid from.
- eru 10y agoI helped out a bit with the BCL pretty-printer in my day. (Mostly contributed in-depth code reviews.) Is Ganeti related to Ganpati? Sorry, it's been a bit since I left Google. Memory is fading.
- actsasbuffoon 10y agoMicrosoft and Facebook are also using Haskell in production.
- mrkgnao 10y agoAnd also happen to employ Simon Peyton Jones and Simon Marlow, respectively, two of the originators of the GHC project.
- pseudonom- 10y agoI'm pretty sure Simon Peyton Jones is still at Microsoft Research.
- cookiecaper 10y agoYes, please note that BigTechCo using something in production is not an endorsement that it's production-ready. Ironically, more often than not, it means the opposite. BigTechCo employs the best computer scientists in the world to make all of that stuff work together, frequently including the project's founders/BDFLs so they can get whatever changes they need rammed through. Your company does not have this luxury.
- pyrale 10y agoIt is definitely an endorsement that it is ready, although maybe not we-search-code-monkeys ready. A large part of our jobs is figuring things out. People looking for so-called production-grade tech are usually looking for ready-for-managers tech in my experience.
- evgen 10y agoA huge chunk of the site integrity bits (e.g. general spam prevention and application of this technology to other problem spaces like instant messages, etc.) for Facebook are done in Haskell and if you know Haskell and fancy working in London I am fairly certain that team is always on the lookout for new people.
- dualogy 10y ago
- kobeya 10y agoI'm pretty sure the biggest player using Haskell is Microsoft, which develops and maintains Haskell in the first place...
- bluejekyll 10y agoI though MS was pushing towards F#. Is there any indication they plan to focus more on one or the other?
- naasking 10y agoThey're not focusing on Haskell commercially, but in Microsoft Research where they employ some of the main Haskell devs. A lot of their research has gone into F#, C# and .NET libraries (like LINQ).
- ookdatnog 10y agoI don't think that's accurate. Microsoft has a role in the development and maintenance of Haskell because they currently employ Simon P. Jones, one of the big driving forces behind Haskell, as a researcher. However, new versions of Haskell (the language) are created by temporary committees (which are not composed by Microsoft). GHC (the main implementation) is an open source project with developers from different organizations. According to this page (https://ghc.haskell.org/trac/ghc/wiki/TeamGHC https://ghc.haskell.org/trac/ghc/wiki/TeamGHC), SPJ is the only one employed by Microsoft. He is one of the core contributors and he owns a large part of the code base, but not to such an extent that GHC can be called a Microsoft project even if Microsoft would want that. Haskell is not a MS product, it has been under development since well before SPJ was employed by MS. Finally, I'm not aware of MS funding the project beyond paying SPJ's wage.
- panglott 10y agoExcept in his 5th chart (the animated one), all the enterprise technologies and Haskell all pulsed up in the morning and afternoon local time, while Haskell was the only one to also pulse up in the evening. In fact, Haskell's evening pulse was smaller than its daytime pulse.
- marcosdumay 10y agoIt's easy to miss the explanation there. Everything tops in the working hours, the article is about the relative size of those tops.
- sotojuan 10y agoLearning Haskell has been made much easier with Haskell Book[1]. Unlike LYAH, it actually has a ton of exercises and in-depth explanations so you understand the why behind things as you make progress. That said, it requires discipline to read through. [1] http://haskellbook.com/ http://haskellbook.com/
- NickM 10y agoThe big problem I've had with Haskell is that even after gaining a pretty good understanding of the language (including monads and such) I still can't fathom how to do anything real with it. Exercises are great and all, but once I try to go past exercises, I start getting lost in layers of monad transformers, and I struggle to figure out the "right" way to do anything. It just feels like there are all these layers of abstraction and complexity that are required for even simple applications, and I can't seem to reach the point where it all clicks for me and becomes manageable. Reading the TOC and chapter notes for that book, I'm not convinced it'll help me. Even the "final project" at the end of the book is described as "a little weird, but small". I don't need more weird, small examples, I need a full-fledged application! I've tried picking out random Haskell OSS apps and studying them, but without newbie-friendly documentation to walk me through the code, I find it very hard to follow what's happening....
- sotojuan 10y ago> The big problem I've had with Haskell is that even after gaining a pretty good understanding of the language (including monads and such) I still can't fathom how to do anything real with it I agree with you but the book has chapters where you write a URL shortener and the final project is an implementation of the `finger` Unix command. For me, the book was a stepping stone towards materials like Write You a Scheme (Scheme interpreter in Haskell). I will admit though, I read Haskell Book for the ideas and learning typed functional programming. I wasn't planning on using Haskell everyday for projects.
- marcosdumay 10y agoTry doing everything in IO, passing stuff around by hand and ignoring all that abstraction. You will immediately spot some places where a monad will help you. Where that happens, use the monad, elsewhere, keep it simple. With time you will regret some of that simple code, when that happens, change it (Haskell's best use case is on refactoring). With even more time you'll get a taste for where it's good to go complex from the start.
- unit91 10y agoYes. So far Learn You a Haskell for Great Good has translated to "learn a little Haskell to kill some free time".
- krylon 10y agoHehe, those have both been on my to-do-one-day-this-time-for-sure-list for quite a while. I remember Lisp having a fixed place on that list (pun intended?) for a number of years, copious amount of caffeine, weed, and patience eventually allowed me to grok it. Haskell has been more stubborn in that regard. I get the functional part just fine, but the part where you get side effects and I/O and such confuses me to no end. Maybe I should just give up on Haskell finally and try OCaml, which seems to offer many of the same benefits.
- badloginagain 10y agoI can see a whole new line of O'Reilly books: "Haskell at Midnight"
- evincarofautumn 10y agoI used to feel that way. I tried reading the various tutorial-style learning materials online, such as Learn You a Haskell, but they didn’t really help me learn how to use the language. In the end, I just dove in and started trying to build real software with it, asking questions when I got stuck. Even though there was a lot to learn, it turned out to be pretty easy. Nowadays Haskell is my #1 programming language for hobby projects—at least when GC is acceptable. And often when I’m trying to design some code in another language, I’ll prototype it in Haskell first to get more clarity of thought and faster iteration.
- raphlinus 10y agoI wouldn't say category here, to be precise it's the same cofunctor over the initial algebra.