11 ms·
Since a properly executed barrel roll can be a 1-G maneuver, it's technically possible in any aircraft. The reason most aircraft are incapable of flying upside
by falcolas 10y ago
Since a properly executed barrel roll can be a 1-G maneuver, it's technically possible in any aircraft.
The reason most aircraft are incapable of flying upside down isn't usually due to stresses on the airframe, it's because the fueling system relies on some form of force pushing the fuel through the bottom of the aircraft. A 1-G barrel roll does exactly that.
There's some interesting trickery done with carbureted aerobatic aircraft to let them fly upside down for an extended period of time, including special valves which shut off fuel flow to the bowls when gravity isn't in the direction they expect it to be, so the aircraft won't lose that fuel back into the fueling system (or out the top of the engine) and can run for a bit on that fuel in the carburetor bowls until the plane is righted.
- elmar 10y agoelectrical planes don't have this problem.
- falcolas 10y agoNor do fuel injected engines, nor jet engines. Electrical planes have a weight issue with the need for batteries (or humongous wings covered with solar panels). Petroleum products, for better or worse, still have a huge advantage in the energy/weight department.
- sathackr 10y agoHow does the fuel get from the tank to the jet or fuel injected engine when the pickup is on the bottom of the now upside-down tank? There are ways to ensure fuel delivery, but the problem certainly isn't unique to carbureted engines, only the particular issue of managing the fuel in the carburetor bowl.
- Neliquat 10y agoThe issue is a non issue. For ages in planes, race cars, etc we have had fuel cells. A few types exist, from just adding more baffles and pickups with vapor locks, to fuel bags (no air to make it to pickup) or the more modern foam matrices that use capilary effect.
- sathackr 10y agoAs I said. There are ways to combat the problem, but the above comment that it did not apply to jet engines or fuel injected engines did not take into consideration the requirement that the entire fuel system be able to operate at low or negative G's
- bigiain 10y agoIn "toy planes" we (used to) use "clunk tanks", where the fuel pickup is a piece of flexible tube with a weight on the end, so no matter what orientation the airframe is in, the "sloshed fuel" and the fuel pickup end up in the same place (near enough). For aggressively aerobatic model planes (like control line combat wings) a pressurised fuel bladder was sometimes used (made, back in my childhood, we made these from baby pacifiers!) Note: this is a couple or more decades old knowledge... Modern electric powered rc planes and builders don't have this problem to deal with.
- pedrocr 10y ago>Since a properly executed barrel roll can be a 1-G maneuver, it's technically possible in any aircraft. Although it's a low positive G maneuver it's not 1G, only straight and level flight is 1G, everything else requires a deviation from that to change direction. Wikipedia says it will vary between 0.5 to 3G throughout the maneuver which should be possible in almost all aircraft as it keeps fuel flowing and isn't a major stress on the airframe. It's probably even possible to do it at no more than 1.5G if you do it large enough so that it's even comfortable and not particularly noticeable for the passengers that don't look out the window.
- throwaway91111 10y agoI don't think this is correct. There's a constant 1G force; you can adjust for the difference necessary in angular momentum as you turn. Sure you won't be perfectly level in the same way have a constant rotational velocity would be but it's still a barrel roll. Of course, it would point in a different direction, but the magnitude would be 1G. Hell, i think you could easily develop an intuition for it.
- falcolas 10y agoThe 1G is from the frame of reference of the passenger. Gravity's effects are essentially nil for the passengers (and the aircraft itself), since everything in the aircraft is accelerating in the same way at the same time. You only really feel the force of the lift generated by the wings.
- kobeya 10y agoPhysicist here. There is no law of the universe that prevents flying an absolutely perfect 1G barrel roll. Maybe those numbers are assuming perfectly steady thrust and a constant angle of attack, or true circular motion? That's the best I can think of.
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoHow do you ever ascend or descend without accelerating up or down?