6 ms·
They routinely give the men with children/wives the better hours, pay, and whatever else at my work. They just changed several peoples' schedules so that my pee
by ianai 10y ago
They routinely give the men with children/wives the better hours, pay, and whatever else at my work. They just changed several peoples' schedules so that my peer could have Saturdays off with his kid. Contrast that with myself: I have requested the same shift and been denied. I don't have kids. I also have better reasons to be on that shift. In my anecdotal experience, it appears classist. I would file that under 'human capital'.
- cmdrfred 10y agoYou say you have "better reasons", childcare is pretty important when you consider all the downstream effects. Are you certain you are objective on this?
- ianai 10y agoOf course I'm not objective. I can't be objective since it's my direct experience. I'm also asking you to take my word on me having the overriding reasons. There's too much going on for me to explain fully in an internet forum. My point is they have two workers vying for the same shift. Overriding corporate policy and business interests would put me on that shift. But they're going with a married guy because he has a kid. That's all I can give you for the circumstances. Judge away. My judgement is that they're choosing someone based on social standing. I think they'd classify that as 'human capital' in this article.
- kobeya 10y ago> Of course I'm not objective. I can't be objective since it's my direct experience. I'm also asking you to take my word on me having the overriding reasons. It's kinda hard to. What are you doing on that time? Caring for your elderly and sick grandmother? Tutoring orphans? It's kinda hard to come up with a legitimate reason that is better than that guy spending time with his kids. "Spending time with" being shorthand here for performing quality parenting that over time makes their kids grow up to be well-adjusted, valued members of society. What could a single, childless person possibly do with that schedule that is more important than improving the future of a dependent that has more life ahead of them than you or I? No, you don't have to provide an answer if you choose not to. But don't expect us to take you on your word either.
- bluGill 10y agoYou say your reasons are more important, but your actions don't seem to back that up. If your reasons were more important you would find a new job - perhaps making less money (it is understood that you might have to work the bad hours for a couple months while looking). Beyond that, importance is different to everyone. To the company it isn't just your reasons, it is also if they give you the better shift they look anti-family. So they are not only risking you or the other guy quitting, they are also risking dozens of other people deciding this isn't a company they want to work for.
- dikdik 10y agoIt shouldn't matter if his reasons are he wants to sit at home, get high, and eat doritos. Businesses aren't families, employees shouldn't be discriminated against because another employee needs/wants help.
- djrogers 10y agoPeople who can't arrange their work schedules to spend time with their kids often find other jobs. If the company has 2 people who want the same shift, management has to make a choice, and choosing the one most likely to impact the company by leaving is a reasonable decision.
- scld 10y agoIt's possible that the business is making a bet that the married person needs better compensation to be stay at that job, simple supply and demand. OR, as the article states, it has nothing to do with marriage and the married person is better at their job and gets to push their weight around more where scheduling is concerned.
- pixl97 10y ago>employees shouldn't be discriminated against because another employee needs/wants help Explain why not?
- kobeya 10y agoShift selection isn't discrimination.
- cookiecaper 10y agoIf two people are in competition for the same resource (a more desirable shift), someone is going to lose. The company has to choose one of them, making at least one happy, or neither of them, upsetting both. How are they supposed to "not discriminate" here? They are forced to choose which employee should receive the shift. Bear in mind that if the tables were turned, the other guy would be going all over the internet saying "My employer gave this shift to another guy because they hate children and discriminate against families with kids", and the same responses would be had in the opposite direction. Making these choices is always going to alienate someone, but they're a fact of life.
- strictnein 10y ago> "I don't have kids. I also have better reasons to be on that shift." It may be unfair, but if the person who is making this decision has children, they likely view spending time with children as the most compelling reason.
- nilkn 10y agoI think the idea is that employees with kids are being given extra perks at work because they have kids. Viewed abstractly, the parents are being compensated more than the non-parents, when all forms of compensation -- financial and otherwise -- are taken into account. (That's the idea anyway. Whether it's actually true I cannot say. There are so many confounding variables and pretty much no conclusion can be drawn from one example.)
- Oxitendwe 10y agoOf course you were denied, he has standing to ask for time off (his kid) and you don't. Having children is incredibly important to society at large and it makes sense incentivize it, especially at the expense of people who don't have any yet. When you have kids, you will also have access to these perks.
- antisthenes 10y agoGuess I'll just start lying about having a kid then.
- Arizhel 10y agoExactly: this is the correct way to handle the situation.
- Oxitendwe 10y agoIs your imaginary kid going to pay into social security? Pay taxes for the roads you drive on? Take up arms to defend your country? If not, then you have no standing to complain when people who contribute more than you are rewarded more than you.
- ionised 10y ago> when people who contribute more than you are rewarded more than you This is one of the shittiest attitudes I've seen on HN in a while. Having a child is not in itself something that qualifies as a greater contribution to the species than anything anyone without children can make. Honestly this is the weirdest kind of child-worship.
- eveningcoffee 10y agoIf you do not have children then you have to contribute considerably more than people with the children just to offset similarly capable people with the children. But I do not think that these matters should be handled on the employer/employee level.
- Falling3 10y agoWhat is the part of it that appears classist?
- freeflight 10y agoThe part where people are treated differently based on their personal procreation/relationship choices? While not strictly classist, it's at very least discriminatory. Some people just don't want to produce offspring or commit to a traditional marriage for a number of different reasons, some of these even include focusing on work/business. Why should these people "earn" less than people who went with the cookie cutter nuclear family approach?
- Falling3 10y agoDiscriminatory sure. I'm not arguing it's right, but I'm just not seeing anything classist about it.
- ianai 10y agoIt's classist in that it denies the person seeking what the other person has the opportunity to progress. I would personally benefit from those hours in ways that include family forming. I'm not a member of the "family man" class and I'm being denied the opportunity to join it. My current work situation puts me in a very disadvantaged position for family forming. You, of course, have to take my word on much of this.
- linkregister 10y agoI think this might actually be a leverage / tolerance question. Your employer knows that your peer would probably not be able to tolerate too much time away from children and are a higher risk of leaving if he were not able to spend that time with his child. Where unless you were to adopt a lifestyle with hard time requirements (mandatory night & weekend religious ceremonies), your employer knows you are less likely to leave. In previous jobs, child care hours accommodation also included a political / PR aspect: they didn't want to deal with the shit storm of spouses going to the press or contacting senior leadership / powerful stakeholders with complaints about time spent away from children.
- ianai 10y agoNo doubt there are many factors involved. Clearly from my point of view it feels wrong and from other points of view it appears correct. A more interesting question to me is this: Those hours would allow me to have a more socially adjusted life. I would have more opportunities to meet women with similar views and personalities to my own (outside of work). I would have more time to date during traditional hours, for instance. So which should it be? Should society always optimize for the families that exist or should it optimize (in circumstances left for debate elsewhere) at least some of the time toward the possibility of new families? I'm talking the difference between pure strategies and mixed strategies. Usually mixed strategies work out best for everyone involved over repeated games - and this is definitely a repeated game situation.
- linkregister 10y agoIf this were a universal problem for singles, they would adapt to socialize during non-standard hours. Since it isn't, I suspect there's opportunity for you to change jobs or roles to trade off for the comparative advantages you have in your current role (maybe you have lots of opportunity to learn or have a pay premium). I suspect that your situation is temporary, and once you have accomplished the short-term objectives you have in mind, you'll take advantage of a better opportunity.
- marcosdumay 10y agoOn the article language, that would be 'signaling'. This is the usual name for unfair discrimination in economics. The 'human capital' name refers to real increase in production, on this case, probably because people tolerate higher hours and shitter jobs and 'ability bias' because of higher competence people self-selecting into marriage.