6 ms·
All the departures can't help but make you wonder what is up. Something Scott McNealy told me about becoming a senior leader is this, "The higher you are in th
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
All the departures can't help but make you wonder what is up.
Something Scott McNealy told me about becoming a senior leader is this, "The higher you are in the company the more easily something you have no control over can get you fired." It isn't exactly intuitive but it builds on the notion of leadership that doesn't like the situation and wants to do something.
I think Uber is navigating a really difficult time, some of the challenges are their own fault, some are situational, but the turmoil in the stories almost palpable. While it might be tempting for someone to leave thinking the ship is sinking, it could also be pretty powerful to be part of the leadership team that navigated through that time.
- yeukhon 10y agoChaos could be opportunity for some, indeed. But usually outsiders will be brought in to stabilize the situation (company surgical doctors) and there will be little room to grow except those remain absolute loyal to the real boss (in this case, the investors, as the CEO himself is in a disarray).
- Analemma_ 10y agoEspecially when Uber is by far the most valuable unicorn and you'd think these guys would want to stay on for their IPO payday. Maybe they know it's not happening?
- yeukhon 10y agoI don't think Uber can go IPO any time soon. The financial of Uber is very bad. Bank is happy to manage the IPO, but the stock will probably be very unstable or fail to single digit if Uber continues to lose that much of money. If a company lives on investment money, the stock is useless.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI believe it would not serve them well to consider its 'unicorn' status, as that emphasizes what might be its biggest challenge, justifying its alleged value, and losing money at the rate they do. Most (if not all) of the companies that went Chapter 7 (complete liquidation) in the dot com boom were like Uber, racing to grow their place into a profitable level of business through private placements. When people stopped believing they could do that, they stopped participating in the equity rounds, and the cash burn was so horrendous that they couldn't slow down if they wanted to. The only possible outcome was a complete flameout, and with no access to capital, and a business model that didn't make money yet, all they could do was go home. Maybe insiders see something like that coming, maybe not, but I have worked in companies that were going to really existentially tough times and it isn't fun. It's actual work. You really learn who is a fair weather soldier when that happens.
- DamnYuppie 10y agoCan you elaborate on 'fair weather soldier"? As employees of a company we are not soldiers we don't have to obey orders. It would be irresponsible to stick it out at a company that is going to flame out. If the option is work in a horrendously stressful environment with no real upside vs get another job that is as equally rewarding but more stable and less stressful that is a no brainner to me. I previously was a startup were we worked very long hours over a prolonged period of time trying to turn the ship around. Unfortunately we didn't succeed. Yet I look back at that and don't feel like it was a positive experience where we could collectively feel good about our exploits. I saw what was going on and decided to try and work through it. Yet hindsight being what it is I don't foresee me making the same decision if I find myself in similar situations.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThe term 'fair weather soldier' is a colloquialism that describes people who are present for the "fun and glamour" but leave as soon as things get difficult or un-glamorous. Generally when a place is hip enough to attract people just so they can say "I work at X!" you'll get people for whom the only reason they work there is because it is hip and cool to do so. And when it starts being 'uncool' or 'lame' those same people will find the exits.
- mahyarm 10y agoYou can get other offers that will match the expected value at other companies, especially as an executive. You use it as a negotiation tactic. "Can you beat what I got at Uber?"
- bspn 10y agoI'm not sure there will be a payday for anyone holding common. Outside investors will hold preferred stock with a preference multiple that will likely absorb any exit returns at this rate.
- linkregister 10y agoDidn't all of them wait until their 1-year-mark to vest?
- 65827 10y agoIt ain't gonna be a "unicorn" much longer at this rate.
- mc32 10y agoDepending on the reason for the departures (voluntary, involuntary) these could present opportunity for some brave folks who like a bit of excitement in their job. Of course, everyone has to make their own judgement as to whether this is a good opportunity or one they'd rather pass. Just saying where there is change there is opportunity.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoTotally agree, chaos is the fuel for change, change is the fuel for opportunity. Only with chaos comes opportunity. I've known managers who inject chaos into their group just to figure out who gets frightened by it and who doesn't. Not a technique I recommend though.
- tyingq 10y ago>I've known managers who inject chaos into their group just to figure out who gets frightened by it and who doesn't. That's roughly one of main goals of basic training in the military. Inject unsolvable manufactured problems, see who doesn't figure out how to cope. Not recommending it either, but the key to recognize when the goal isn't really to solve the intractable issue.
- htrp 10y ago>I've known managers who inject chaos into their group just to figure out who gets frightened by it and who doesn't. I shudder to think of the examples of this.
- rdl 10y agoI'd rather work at Uber today than Uber of 2 years ago. (Uber of the first year or two would be better, of course) -- it's a challenge. The real question to justify Uber's valuation is "will they build something with a real moat" -- I don't think "network of drivers" is that. They did the hard work on breaking open protected taxi mafia markets, and educating the public, but it's too easy for any local city to have a dominant "Uber for our city" which isn't Uber. Self driving is the one way I think they can differentiate themselves, and the scary thing is a lot of the departures seem to be from there. If those people have lost confidence, they're fucked. It wouldn't be hard to turn Uber into a solid $5-10b company, but due to how financings work, that wipe out a lot of people. The only winning outcome for most employees and most investors (weighted by $ invested) is the $50-100b+ "global transportation monopoly".
- crdb 10y ago> it's too easy for any local city to have a dominant "Uber for our city" which isn't Uber I disagree. By virtue of being in the city, and only in the city, it would be too small to withstand pressure from local interests for long, and would end up like the local taxi monopolies. This will be especially true in countries "with lower GDP per capita". Uber's international nature with its HQ in a country where corruption is relatively low, clearly enormous political and financial connections, track record in neighbouring countries or cities with clear and visible benefits to the customers (aka electorate), and willingness to fight (which is public knowledge, thus becoming signalling) allow it to scare off such pressure. Uber has more to fear from Apple than from Paris' UberX clones.
- rdl 10y agoThat's true if Uber didn't ever exist, or if uber ceased to exist. I think it would be relatively straightforward to have a "local competitor to Uber", perhaps propped up by some stupid local regulation, once the taxi mafia is broken. Austin sort of has this, but not really, now.
- michaelt 10y agoIf you believe the 'taxi mafia' is caused by regulatory capture of local government by taxi operators, in the absence of Uber you might expect local regulation to hinder, rather than help a "local uber"
- exelius 10y agoNothing is up; it's what happens when companies have to transition from Silicon Valley "bro" culture to a real business where you manage risk like any other business variable. IMO Uber's problem is that they were 5-10 years too early for their business model to work. They're getting mired in driver disputes and -- worse -- driver rules are getting codified into law in many cities. That's going to make it very hard for them to compete with leaner competitors who are not managing drivers, workforce reductions, etc. once self-driving cars are more available. Uber will have to fight tooth and nail for every piece of automation while a competitor can fly under the radar until they're big (sound familiar?)
- fullshark 10y agoAs an outsider, I think the best case scenario for Uber is that these people are leaving because they realized this isn't the sure fire rocket ship ride to worldwide dominance it looked to be 2 years ago (most of the departures are relatively new hires) and they want to bail as times get tough. The worst case scenario is that the underlying financials are awful, the Alphabet suit is a legitimate existential threat, and these people want to jump off a sinking ship.