4 ms·
How about stopping the revolving door between those who are regulated and those is the agencies doing the regulation? Conflict of interest appointments result
by r00fus 10y ago
How about stopping the revolving door between those who are regulated and those is the agencies doing the regulation?
Conflict of interest appointments result in probably the vast majority of anti-market, cartel-style behavior.
- bpodgursky 10y agoThat's not a good idea. The alternative is having regulations written by people who have no idea what they are regulating, which is the whole problem. You can eliminate conflicts of interest via financial disclosures etc, without eliminating competence.
- basseq 10y agoI agree with you, but is this also a symptom of another problem? I'm thinking about it in the government-to-industry direction, and particularly where compensation is so high for these ex-govvies. Why are these people worth so much? Either because: 1. The regulations are so complex to get around that companies need to pay a premium for that knowledge. (Bad.) 2. The regulations have so many loopholes that I need to hire someone to help me do whatever it is I want to do, but legally. (Bad.) Both of these would appear to favor entrenched players who can afford this talent.
- grigjd3 10y agoPeople who used to be in government know the levers of power.
- r00fus 10y agoSo you either choose a potentially adversarial actor who knows exactly what they're doing, or someone who has to figure stuff out but has not vested interest? For the past two Presidential elections where the incumbent was term-limited, we've chosen the outsider candidate twice. If these positions weren't appointed but elected - one could assume that the outsider would be preferred. If conflicts of interest could be eliminated (I'd say reduced) via financial disclosures, why aren't they happening? I can name several appointees in the current and past 2 administrations that had conflicts of interest.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Frondo 10y ago"You can eliminate conflicts of interest via financial disclosures etc, ..." No, you can expose conflicts of interest that way, but merely disclosing who's on whose payroll does not actually eliminate any conflict of interest. And it's a false dichotomy that you either get industry insiders or "people who have no idea what they are regulating".
- Rmilb 10y agoDoes anyone else see an added benefit of a universal basic income, is that it could in a small way help disincentivize the revolving door between the public and private sector that sometimes results in regulatory capture?
- notahacker 10y agoNo, that sounds like the most extreme version of UBI-as-panacea arguments I've seen yet. Why would the ability to earn $12k per annum for not trying to work have the slightest effect on ambitious high-flying executives' willingness to move from a very high-paying private sector role to a very high-paying regulatory role and back again?
- L_Rahman 10y agoThe mistake here is to assume that there's a causal relationship between having worked in the industry and taking a pro-industry role as a regulator. This isn't inherently true. Industry alums can and have taken regulatory actions in the public interest. Tom Wheeler, the former Chairman of the FCC, used to be a cable industry lobbyist and passed regulation in favor or net neutrality and despite the protests of the industry he used to regulate. It turns out that the person and their intentions matter. When a revolving door person happens to take pro-industry actions it's not because they somehow fooled the government into thinking they'd act in the public good. The government knowingly appointed someone with pro-industry biases because the industry lobbied the government. If we want the government to appoint people who will act in the public interest at the expense of the industry, we have to demand that. Sometimes that person will be from the industry. We may call them a dingo. But they'll turn out to act in our interests.