4 ms·
Feminists face an interesting challenge here; STEM seem to be their Waterloo (I believe that's the right phrase). They stand upon the claim that women are total
by sliverstorm 16y ago
Feminists face an interesting challenge here; STEM seem to be their Waterloo (I believe that's the right phrase). They stand upon the claim that women are totally equal to men.
This means that for their cause to survive, they have to prove that they are totally equal in every way, which means being proven wrong when it comes to STEM would be disastrous. Thus they can never acknowledge the possibility, and will likely do their best to tear down anyone who suggests it. This is, of course, not particularly any different from anything else political, though it seems to be more savage thus far.
I personally wish someone would just figure out a truly unbiased test and get the answer already. I don't care what the answer is, I just want cold hard fact to back up them claims & decisions made in regards to all this.
edit: cummon, if you're gonna downmod, please leave a reason.
edit2: I use equal in the sense of 'the same', not 'superior'/'inferior'.
- tomjen3 16y agoI have a feeling that STEM isn't going to change anything, people want to believe whatever they want to believe and they are not going to let the facts stand in between them. Take Intelligent Design as an example. There is a shit ton of evidence that proves that it is all a bunch of bullshit, but it doesn't matter because a lot of people want to believe it, so that is what they do. So sure it would be nice to know the answer, but it isn't going to change anything.
- DaniFong 16y agoProblem 1: You're impute a rather radical belief onto all feminists. You are constructing a straw feminist. Problem 2: How is a person supposed to choose an unbiased test? What do you even mean? Problem 3: The most obvious fact should be that people are complicated, and aren't so easily reducible to a neat pile of normally distributed aptitudes dependent on a binary gender variable. The cold hard fact you should be aware of is that those who are trying to make this sound simple or concrete or objectively determined are deceiving themselves. The counterfactual you'd look for -- if everyone were gender blind, how would women fair in science and technology? -- hasn't come close to true. And as long as people continue to slam their fights and debate over whether women are innately unsuited to this kind of work, they won't be -- the nature of the stereotype threat (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stereotype_threat http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stereotype_threat) will ensure it.
- SnydenBitchy 16y agoI’m not sure that’s a fair representation of mainstream feminism (“They stand upon the claim that women are totally equal [in the sense of ‘the same’] to men”). Obviously, biology differs between the sexes. It’s not at all controversial, under the umbrella of feminism and gender studies, to explore the influence of brain chemistry in the assignment and acceptance of gender roles. Few will dispute that hormones affect the expression of, say, aggression and empathy, on average characteristic of men and women respectively. The more pressing and socially current matter is how these differences (rooted in biology or not) are respected or disrespected by institutions, including the social institutions of our prevailing cultural norms. For example: is it fair to demand that female scientists jockey for position in academia as ruthlessly as male scientists are accustomed to doing? Would it not benefit us if our scientific institutions were more accepting of “non-masculine” approaches to research, however those might be defined? In short, the argument is for accepting diversity, not blindly insisting on exact sameness between genders. That’s also why feminists will argue there’s no such thing as the “truly unbiased test” you seek: testing, by attempting to quantify the qualitative (scientific aptitude), will naturally privilege the testmaker’s perspective to the exclusion of alternatives. I think there’s room to argue that science would benefit from encouraging a diversity of perspectives.
- sliverstorm 16y agoI believe the difficulty is this particular topic is discussing ability rather than characteristic. Even when they acknowledge that there are differences in disposition, character, etc, no feminist I've met has been willing to entertain the idea that either gender might be better at (more able to do) something than the other (even though they are undoubtedly better at giving birth than men! :). I think the discussion usually gets hung up on a miscommunication though- they assume I am asking them to consider it is impossible for all women to do a certain task, when the question is only ever, is it possible one gender (not even necessarily males) might have greater potential at something. This is a valid question, no argument here. How does one address diversity in a field whose first concerns are (or should be, damnit) results and/or answers? IMHO you get answers/results, I don't give a darn who or what you are- you could be a squirrel for all I care. By the same token, if you don't, I'm not going to give you preferential treatment just because you are diverse. Though, I realize this is a very black and white position that probably fails to take into account some important realities.
- zasz 16y agoNo, I don't think feminism implies that feminists have to show women are the same as men in every way. It's perfectly feminist to say that women deserve to be judged as individuals on their own merits, as men are. I'm sure there's no feminist who would disagree that women are physically weaker, but they don't need to concoct studies asserting that women are physically equal to men just so they can advocate for suffrage and property rights. My understanding that the claim women are totally equal to men is that they are equal in some moral sense, which should be disconnected from natural ability anyway. I suppose if women were empirically shown to be twenty times dumber than men, and that women capable of learning to read and write were as rare as Einstein, then feminism really has no case to stand on and women's suffrage would be ludicrous, but the average woman is as smart as the average man, and that's sufficient to give men and women equal moral standing. So I don't see why feminism would fall over if it was shown that fewer women were ever going to win a Fields Medal. Unusual cases like that don't matter much for day to day morality.
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>I suppose if women were empirically shown to be twenty times dumber than men, and that women capable of learning to read and write were as rare as Einstein, then feminism really has no case to stand on and women's suffrage would be ludicrous, but the average woman is as smart as the average man, and that's sufficient to give men and women equal moral standing. http://en.wikinews.org/wiki/UK_study_claims_men_have_higher_average_I.Q._than_women http://en.wikinews.org/wiki/UK_study_claims_men_have_higher_..., states: "In a study accepted for publication by the British Journal of Psychology, Dr. Paul Irwing (Manchester Business School, Senior Lecturer in Organizational Psychology) and Prof. Richard Lynn (University of Ulster, Professor Emeritus) conclude that men are on average five points ahead on IQ tests. The study also found that men outnumbered women in increasing numbers as intelligence levels rise. There were twice as many with IQ scores of 125, a level typical for people with first-class degrees. When scores rose to 155, a level associated with genius, there were 5.5 men for every woman." But also notes that: "Several subtle points popularized by the Pinker vs. Spelke debate are relevant to the Irwing & Lynn study. First, females benefit significantly from single sex education, but single sex education has little impact upon males. As a consequence, the Irwing & Lynn study can not lay claim to a biological difference in intelligence, unless it restricts itself to women attending all girls schools. Secondly, the process of natural selection leads males of any species to have more variance in most traits. As a result, Stephen Pinker suggests that one should find "more geniuses and more idiots" among human males (see Pinker slide 41). As a consequence, any omission of people at the lower end of the IQ spectrum would bias the average male IQ upward, relative to the average female IQ ."