5 ms·
If, as your post seems to be recommending, such regulations were abolished, Japanese farmers would pretty much cease to exist because of their inability to comp
by emodendroket 10y ago
If, as your post seems to be recommending, such regulations were abolished, Japanese farmers would pretty much cease to exist because of their inability to compete with cheaper imports. Maybe you consider that an unacceptable tradeoff for some potato chip shortages but it's not clear that the Japanese share your sense of priorities.
- kijin 10y agoThe regulations can be changed without putting domestic farmers out of business. For example, they could add tariffs to imported potatoes to make them cost as much as (or even more than) domestic potatoes, and use the revenue to help Hokkaido farmers rebuild their farms. No need for a hard limit on the imported amount.
- emodendroket 10y agoTrue enough, although I'd think that by the time such a huge overhaul were accomplished the shortage would be over.
- kijin 10y agoIf there is political will, things like that can be done remarkably quickly. South Korea had a massive shortage of chicken eggs last winter due to an avian influenza epidemic. It took only a few weeks for the government to start importing fresh eggs from abroad, something that had never been done before. It wasn't enough to get prices down to normal levels, but at least the government acted quick -- especially considering that the nation was in the middle of a Presidential scandal. Unlike South Korea, Japan is essentially a single-party dictatorship. They can pass whatever laws they deem necessary if they really want to. I'm assuming that they don't want to, probably because there's someone who profits from high potato prices.
- emodendroket 10y agoIt wasn't that long ago that the DPJ held power. Anyway, that's a fair point, but I think a shortage of eggs where people eat a lot of eggs and a shortage of potato chips are kind of different situations that don't necessarily need the same kind of response.
- zeroer 10y agoI guess as a democratic state they can decide to restrict imports. But then don't ask anybody to give two shits that that there's a shortage.
- emodendroket 10y agoI don't think Japan is appealing for international sympathy for its potato chip shortage, man.
- zeroer 10y agoPoint taken
- Barrin92 10y agoWell in this case it's Bloomberg and not the Japanese people. I guess a people who can keep composure in face of a nuclear meltdown and tsunami won't exactly lose their minds over a few weeks of potato chip shortage.
- mikekchar 10y agoGood grief. We went nearly 2 years without me ever seeing butter on the shelves. Shortages happen here.
- mcphage 10y agoWell, when they ask you to care, you can tell them that. I wouldn't hold my breath, though.
- roenxi 10y agoIf you regulate against selling potato chips at the market rate, a likely outcome is a shortage of potato chips. Grandparent didn't suggest a problem with protectionist regulations - simply that the regulation is the probable cause of the shortage. There is a link.
- emodendroket 10y agoActually what he said is that regulation is "primarily responsible" for the shortage, which seems contentious -- what about the failed crops, after all -- but it seems to me that he probably had some motivation for saying that beyond pedantry.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- iopq 10y agoNo amount of failed crops would cause a shortage if trade were free since there's a region in the world SOMEWHERE that's having a good year.
- emodendroket 10y agoI suppose that's why there are no more famines anymore.
- nradov 10y agoFamines are caused by bad governments, failed states, and violent conflicts. Not because there isn't enough food.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- iopq 10y agoIf you have money, and trade is fairly free, you would never have a famine unless it's world-wide. I mean, let's say all of your crops failed. So what? Just buy them from another country. It's a little more expensive, but better than starving. So why do people starve? It's when your money can't buy anything from another country because people from other countries don't have faith in your currency. Or when you can't trade at all for some reason. Famines are chiefly an economic problem.
- hueving 10y agoIt's not about priorities, it's about the cause. Just be frank and admit a protectionist policy is the cause of a market inefficiency. It's okay to make that tradeoff, just be honest with yourself.
- mistermann 10y agoYou may find Japan a bit frustrating if you were ever to visit. :)
- hueving 10y agoI have visited and it's not that frustrating to me because I don't have to live there and I completely understand them deciding to make protectionist policies over choosing market efficiency.
- iopq 10y ago> If, as your post seems to be recommending, such regulations were abolished, Japanese farmers would pretty much cease to exist because of their inability to compete with cheaper imports. Good, they can do something more useful with their time because Japan does not have a comparative advantage in farming. Having farms in Japan is very inefficient, since there are better regions to grow these crops. Sure, you can't displace these farmers tomorrow, but slowly increasing the imports is a good idea. For one thing, it would decrease the cost of living for the average Japanese person, even if farmers are negatively affected. Why is a farmer more important than a city dweller?
- zaphoyd 10y agoI would assume because maintaining some level of domestic food production would be important for national security.
- iopq 10y agoI would assume maintaining healthy trade relationships is important for food shortages like these, as well.
- emodendroket 10y agoIs the claim here that Japan is not able to trade as often as it would like? That seems to be obviously wrong.
- iopq 10y agoOf course it's not. When you erect trade barriers with other countries, they don't want to trade with you that much either. So exports to other countries are probably limited by the import policy of Japan, since they never made trade deals that lower tariffs on both ends.
- emodendroket 10y agoBut that is what is, in my opinion, obviously wrong. Go on a drive in any town in America and tell me there aren't a lot of Japanese products being sold here.
- Pitarou 10y agoIt‘s not as simple as that. Japan‘s agricultural system was intended to be a temporary prop, to help agriculture recover after the War. The people would experience inflated prices and erratic supplies, but that was thought a price worth paying. The system has been kept in place for decades longer than its stated purpose required. The forces that keep it in place are powerful, and democratic only in the loosest sense of the word.
- mikekchar 10y agoBut nothing in Japan is really ever temporary. Once it's in place, it takes something pretty major to move it out of place. And for the record, I don't think it was ever intended to be a temporary measure. The whole reason a million people died of hunger after WWII was because there was no local production of food. And not only that, there was no centralised food distribution system, so even when food became available, there was no way to get it to people. Nobody that I know of complains about about the agricultural system here (granted, I live in a farming community :-) ). The only people I see complaining are people with foreign interests who want to dump their produce in order to destroy production in other places in the world (as a Canadian, I will say that our country has historically been one of the worst in the world for this). The biggest problem is really that all of the farmers are dying of old age and nobody in their families want to continue, so I suspect that the "pretty major" thing will probably happen sooner rather than later. I feel strangely thankful to Trump for killing TPP so that the solution is less likely to be selling out to foreign interests.
- Pitarou 10y ago> Nobody that I know of complains about about the agricultural system here (granted, I live in a farming community :-) ). I did (granted, I have a background in Economics). Tell a Japanese how much a tin of tomatoes costs in Japan compared to the US or the EU, or a mango, or even a packet of generic acetaminophen (paracetamol) for that matter. Now ask them why. Nine times out of ten, they’ll say something about the Japanese culture of quality and attention to detail. To be fair, Japan often does demand higher standards, but that’s not nearly enough to explain the full price discrepancy. They don‘t complain because they don‘t know what’s going on.
- brownbat 10y agoI don't think GP was making a political statement, just commenting on the buried lead, but I'll play devil's advocate. I want farmers to have jobs too. I'd still find it sad if that were the rationale here, though, because while protectionist measures can save jobs, they remain one of the worst tools to do so, typically costing several hundred thousand dollars per job. Tire manufacturing jobs saved at $900,000 per job: https://piie.com/publications/policy-briefs/us-tire-tariffs-saving-few-jobs-high-cost https://piie.com/publications/policy-briefs/us-tire-tariffs-... Textile jobs saved at a cost of $4 million per job: http://www.heritage.org/report/the-textile-and-apparel-trade-act-saving-jobs-cost-4-million-each http://www.heritage.org/report/the-textile-and-apparel-trade... Sugar quotas costing $800,000 per job: http://davidstockmanscontracorner.com/41418/ http://davidstockmanscontracorner.com/41418/ Those are all US examples. Maybe the Japanese are better at saving jobs through protectionism and get a better return on their restrictions, but those are 10-100 times the salaries in those fields. It seems unlikely they are closing that gap. Sadly there's just no free lunch. It's like the second law of thermodynamics for economies. When you shut down economic activity to improve health and welfare, that's fine, you can accomplish a lot that's useful for society. But when you try to shut down economic activity to create wealth, you generally pay far more than you were trying to save.* * With the possible exception of infant industry protection, but that's controversial, and hardly an exact science. Either way, potato farming is hardly some new technology where Japan is likely to corner the global market once they build up a little more volume.
- mistermann 10y ago> Sadly there's just no free lunch. There's such a thing as no lunch though, a situation one may find themselves in if their job is re-accomodated to a global location with "higher economic efficiency".
- brownbat 10y agoDefinitely, the plight of people put out of jobs, regions losing industries, it's not to be understated or trifled with. That's a major half of the problem. The rock on the other side of this hard place though is that there's also no lunch at all for someone who can't afford basic foodstuffs because of tariffs and quotas block access to reasonably priced goods. What's worse is that trade protections tend to be incredibly regressive, hitting those shopping for basic necessities hardest, far more than people who can buy yachts from whatever jurisdiction they like. How do we confront this dilemma? How do we thread the needle? We've never really pulled it off correctly in the past... but there is a way to do it. If you have real trade assistance programs, then you create a situation where every single person is better off under trade liberalization. The problem is we've talked a good game on trade assistance, but never done it right, and never really reevaluated what works and doesn't. It doesn't mean three year retraining programs for people five years off from retirement. It's going to include mix of solutions, including some small taxes on goods likely to be imported and straight up wealth transfers to former employees. Relocation assistance or retraining if they want it, but some people won't. If protectionism costs $800,000 per job, then this is easy. Just tax that good, give the worker their old $60k/yr salary for a few years, no questions asked, and let consumers pocket the difference. You could pay them $60k for life and we'd all still be better off, but some people might prefer a phase out, either way.
- baddox 10y agoJapanese farmers are being subsidized by these trade regulations, at the expense of other Japanese workers (namely, any worker who produces something that Japan could trade for foreign potatoes).
- mistermann 10y agoMy understanding is that Japan has a very flat pay structure across society, with much less diversity in wages. If so, and if the rest of the world is the correct "market" price, then lots of people in Japan are being "subsidized". In a sense, their society has chosen this structure, in which case it's not even a subsidy, it is the natural price.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]