2 ms·
1) The rich pay most of the taxes in the US. The top 10% take home 45% of all income and pay 82% of all income taxes. The US has a very progressive taxation sys
by adventured 10y ago
1) The rich pay most of the taxes in the US. The top 10% take home 45% of all income and pay 82% of all income taxes. The US has a very progressive taxation system overall.
2) Most large corporations pay a substantial corporate tax rate. Exxon and Chevron for decades have routinely paid over 35%. Walmart pays a 30% rate. Facebook has averaged a 32% tax rate the last five years. Boeing has averaged a 25% rate the last five years. Intel routinely pays 20% or higher. Pfizer has averaged a 22% rate the last five years. 3M has averaged a 28.6% rate the last five years.
Would you like me to continue listing the tax rates of major US corporations? Because the overwhelming majority of them pay a high rate compared to the rest of the world.
So much for your theories.
- maxerickson 10y agoHow much of the federal budget does 82% of income taxes represent?
- adventured 10y agoThe top 0.3% of returns paid $500 billion in federal income taxes. That's from half a million total returns. For that segment, they paid an average combined tax rate of 33% (27% income tax rate) - roughly double the combined rate of the middle class in the $50k-$75k bracket (about 4x the income tax rate). That group is the $1m and over line on income returns. Also, that's just the federal income tax. Combined, the top 500,000 tax payers cover around 20% of all federal tax receipts (there are about 12-13 million, millionaire households in the US in terms of assets, excluding the value of the primary residence). The top 20.5% of returns (incomes over $100k), paid $1.27 trillion in federal income taxes out of the $1.35 trillion total for all returns. That group paid a total of $2.15 trillion in federal taxes. That's out of about $3.2 trillion in total federal tax receipts for that year. So the top 20% of tax payers, are providing around 67% of all federal taxes. Now by comparison: The $40k to $50k income bracket, has 14 million returns and $640 billion in income. On that income, they paid $4 billion in federal income taxes, or a 0.7% average federal income tax rate. That group paid a total combined (all federal taxes) of $75 billion, or a 11.7% average rate for all federal taxes paid by that group (eg including things like Social Security). The $50k to $75k income bracket, has 25.5 million tax filers, with a combined income of $1.56 trillion. On that $1.56 trillion, they paid ... $59 billion in federal income taxes, or a 3.8% average federal income tax rate. Need I say more?
- maxerickson 10y agoI understand the US system is progressive overall. I was questioning the value of analyzing it in terms of "income taxes".
- adventured 10y agoIt's pretty valuable to analyze it that way in my opinion. The bottom 80% of tax returns have $5 trillion in income, and are paying $65 billion in federal income taxes. Read that a few times over. The $500k to $1 million income bracket, has 13% as much income as that bottom 80% group, but pays about ~120% more in income taxes. Personally, I think that's fine, I'm all for a progressive taxation system, especially in a country as rich as the US. However, throughout any thread on taxes, as with this one, you'll see a lot of posts claiming the rich pay little in the way of taxes, when in fact it's the exact opposite. It's not even up for debate, it's a fact easily proven. Should the rich pay even more? That's the debate.
- maxerickson 10y agoI just don't see it as reasonable to exclude payroll taxes from the measurement of progressiveness, that's all. The 80% you break out there is contributing a lot more than $65 billion to Social Security and Medicare. I mean, those programs are explicitly designed to not be progressive, that's why there is a cap on income considered for social security (Medicare became progressive under the ACA, a little bit).