10 ms·
What the Hackintosh community wants in the new modular Mac Pro
- sigjuice 10y agoBy "modular", Apple probably means that it is easier for themselves to provide multiple configurations and make updates, rather than end-users having the ability to stick in random cards/drives/memory/CPUs.
- hilyen 10y agoI agree, I think they just mean they probably will stop the soldering and glueing of pieces that should be easily replaceable.
- sigjuice 10y agoI hope they improve things on the iMac as well. The situation with the current iMacs is ridiculous. The 27 inch iMac has user-accessible SO-DIMM slots, but the 21 inch iMac has the memory glued on.
- IBM 10y agoIf you read the transcript [1] of the meeting closely, when Schiller mentions modular, he seems to be making the distinction that the new Mac Pro would not be an iMac Pro. That is it would continue to be a product that doesn't come with a keyboard or monitor. Their other answers saying they want to deliver regular updates speaks to what you said, but the part where he actually mentions modular just reads to me as reassuring people that it's not going to be a higher end SKU of an iMac. >As part of doing a new Mac Pro — it is, by definition, a modular system — we will be doing a pro display as well. Now you won’t see any of those products this year; we’re in the process of that. We think it’s really important to create something great for our pro customers who want a Mac Pro modular system, and that’ll take longer than this year to do. >I think, as you talk about the pro user, the fact that our user base is split over notebooks, all-in-one desktops and modular desktops is important. We aren’t making one machine for pros. We’re making three different designs for pros. We’re going to continue to. >We care about our Pro users who use MacBook Pros, who use iMacs and who use Mac Pros, who use modular systems as well as all-in-one systems, who use the pro software we make. [1] https://techcrunch.com/2017/04/06/transcript-phil-schiller-craig-federighi-and-john-ternus-on-the-state-of-apples-pro-macs/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/04/06/transcript-phil-schiller-c...
- throwaway7645 10y agoI'm curious, most of the people with the skills to build a hackintosh could easily build a Linux box as well and some probably do. However, is there any reason they just don't go to Linux? Is it hardware support or Adobe?
- lacampbell 10y agoAnecdote: I've been running Linux at home for 10 years, but I can see myself switching to OSX because the input methods for Chinese characters are so much better. Even googles ones are top notch.
- kristofferR 10y agoLinux isn't nearly as fluid/polished/nice as macOS tends to be, and has a severe lack of good apps. I can't even find a good calendar app for Linux.
- darpa_escapee 10y agoI use desktop Linux and Mac OS. The latter Just Works and most proprietary software has a version that works with it. Lately, however, I've had to janitor my Mac more than my Linux system. Experienced more kernel panics with it as well.
- tyteen4a03 10y agoTwo deal breakers: 1. None of the Ui packages out there in Linux is as good as macOS. 1.5. Gestures. Though I can live without one, I've grown accustomed to the slick motions. 2. Chinese input on Linux is unusable. It was so confusing I gave up setting it up on my (was) Ubuntu installation.
- kristofferR 10y agoI've got a Hackintosh as my main system, I love it. I dual boot macOS (default) and Windows 10 on it. A nice feature is that I can use my Windows installation while I'm using macOS through virtualization (Parallels), yet boot natively to the same Windows installation when I need the full performance. Getting the Hackintosh working properly was hard as hell though, although I kinda enjoyed it since I'm a geek. Now that I've got it working, it works flawlessly. Recommended for people who want to save money/maximize performance and don't mind the grueling effort required.
- dfischer 10y agoMind sharing your build?
- kristofferR 10y agoGigabyte Z270X Ultra Gaming Intel Core-i5 7600k (4,6Ghz OC) 32GB 3200MHz DDR4 RAM Nvidia Gefore 970 GTX Samsung 960 Evo 500GB NVMe SSD ~10TB HDDs
- johnbellone 10y agoNice rig, everything work? You have a BT 4.0 for Handoff?
- kristofferR 10y agoYup, stuff works great now. I just ordered a BT 4.0 USB a couple of days ago actually, looking forward to it arriving.
- dfischer 10y agoWhat was most frustrating about turning that into a hackintosh?
- stingraycharles 10y ago
- draw_down 10y ago"Here's what people who don't buy Macs want Apple to do"
- smacktoward 10y agoYeah, that was my first thought too. Has Apple ever seen a single dime from the "Hackintosh community"? Why would they care about what people who by defintion are not customers want?
- elsurudo 10y agoMight be an opportunity to make them into customers. A lot of these people are probably people they alienated with their last Mac Pro generation.
- danieldk 10y agoI don't know. I know some Hackintosh users, who do Hackintosh because real Macs are too expensive for them. I think for many people (including me), the Mac Mini was the next logical step, since it was affordable. Especially when it was still expandable (memory and disk). I think they make a mistake with making the Mini so unattractive. It may not be a blip on their radar, but I think it was a gateway machine for many people who later buy more Macs. However, now it's so unattractive that I can't see anyone buying them.
- xor1 10y ago>Has Apple ever seen a single dime from the "Hackintosh community"? My first three Mac systems as a poor student were Hackintoshes. Couldn't afford a real Macbook. The first one was a Dell Mini 9, which was a $200 netboook that could somehow run Snow Leopard flawlessly (with significant contributions from the community of course). As a working professional, I have spent close to $10k on Apple hardware in the past two years. I've also helped them make quite a bit of money through their App Store cut. I recently put together a dual-booting Windows 10/OSX system for usage at home, used for both gaming and development. I spent about $1200 on it, and I couldn't even get an equivalent desktop from Apple no matter how much I spent. My ceiling would have probably been around $3k.
- klodolph 10y ago> I think it’s also important that Apple continues to keep the CPUs in Mac Pros socketed.#5 Honestly I wonder if this is actually the future of CPUs or if it will all be soldered in. That, and RAM too. The history of computers is a history of demodularization. Unlike, say, 15 years ago, today I expect a high-end CPU + Memory configuration to remain high-end for a few years, so I'm not worried about upgradability. That's definitely not true with GPUs.
- poidog44 10y agoIt seems Apple is pushing away more and more of the "Pros," just take a look at the latest macbook pros. The only way I use MacOS anymore is with a hackintosh.
- killbrad 10y agoAlso known as "please tell us how you might try to make our system more open so we know where to close it off."
- btgeekboy 10y agoI wouldn't mind if the CPU remained soldered - I don't think I've ever done an upgrade that didn't require a new chipset too. Give me standard ram, m2 slots, and pcie graphics card slot, and I will order on day one.
- ksec 10y agoMac Pro represent may be 1% of Mac Sales, and in terms of volume it is likely to be a rounding error for Apple. If this assumption is correct, I wonder why Apple doesn't make a high price but also high value machine. Aiming at Prosumers, Pro Gamers ( If they are still on Mac ) and Professionals. With starting price of $1299. The lowest config could have been done with AMD Zen 2 and non ECC Memory. And Scale up all the way to 32 Core Zen and 256GB ECC Memory. It fix the developer's need for a "Desktop" Machine to program the iPhone, or Web Development. And the years' of cry for just "Mac". And Something clearly the Mac mini shouldn't be aiming at. I still believe there is at least another 5 - 10 years of life in Mac before we sunset it, and unless Apple will be moving to ARM Mac ( which i doubt they will ), there is no better time to bring some of these people into the Apple's ecosystem. Whether it is iPhone, iPad, or Mac.
- gonyea 10y agoI've been using a Linux workstation for the past year and actually feel like I could go with a Linux laptop too. I was contemplating Hackintosh but no need. I only miss the Magic Trackpad. Atom + Chrome (with a dozen extensions) makes web development a breeze. I can do a lot of quality front-end work. You're also not stuck with god awful Homebrew for installing dependencies. OS X is a pretty hostile place for developers who don't live out of XCode.
- agumonkey 10y agoTalking about trackpads, I toyed with a MS Surface Pro at a store. I hate trackpads with a passion (unlike trackpoints) but I felt different about the MS SP one. Extremely precise and right material. I wonder if the latest Mac have a similar grade device.
- maksimum 10y agoConventional wisdom is that Mac laptops have had the best trackpads since the 2006 macbook pro. When did you last try a Mac trackpad? On the other had, only recently has Microsoft started build/licensing well tuned trackpads.
- agumonkey 10y agoI probably touched a few between 2006 and 2010 but not sure. Also since these were Macs Im not sure I wasnt ignoring it because it's the level I expect from Apple. Unlike Windows machines.
- wishinghand 10y agoI've only used Homebrew to install Node and that went well. What're the areas Homebrew gets ugly?
- gonyea 10y agoInstall a modern Bash and set it as your default shell. When Homebrew updates (which it does automatically now) you might be locked out of your Terminal. `brew --prefix package` returns the latest installable package, and not the version you actually have installed. Also things like: https://github.com/Homebrew/brew/issues/2402 https://github.com/Homebrew/brew/issues/2402 It tries to do too much and ends up being a never ending surprise from hell. (The solution to the Bash issue is to hard code the path for chsh, etc.)
- URSpider94 10y agoWhat distinguishes the Mac ecosystem over other PC OS'es is that the small number of supported hardware configurations makes it possible to do much more thorough system-level testing and optimization. The result is a much more stable and secure OS. As soon as you start letting users swap out components without restriction, you're going to see user experience decline. EDIT: I'm still fully expecting Apple to allow change-outs of key components through Apple-supplied upgrades.