6 ms·
> This release includes logs, excel files, and even for the first time PowerPoint of TOP SECRET documents. This is a first from Shadow Brokers, this would mean
by dmix 10y ago
> This release includes logs, excel files, and even for the first time PowerPoint of TOP SECRET documents. This is a first from Shadow Brokers, this would mean ShadowBrokers has definitely more than only tools.
I'm curious what the implication is here. Why would a TOP SECRET power point slide be packaged together with malware on an attack server? It's either really sloppy OPSEC by NSA TAO (or random hired contractor) or may just be a collection of files put together by an intel agency/'criminal' hacker group from various sources to embarrass NSA.
- posixplz 10y agoThe implication is that they're working directly with leakers. It's pretty hard to imagine that a PPT would be left on operational assets where tools are traditionally found.
- devoply 10y agoSo why is the NSA leaking all this shit. What's the leading theory on that? It's like just get it all out there, just to preempt an eventual leak? Maybe see who picks up this stuff and uses it? Mis-lead the other side on the capabilities which are actually far superior than a few things which have been released?
- evilantnie 10y agoIf we do buy into the fact that the NSA is behind the leaks, it would most likely be in response to some sort of loss-aversion or negative leverage play. i.e. they want to severely devalue these assets on the black market.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"So why is the NSA leaking all this shit. " It would be insiders who oppose what's going on Snowden-style or plants from a foreign, intelligence service.
- mike_hearn 10y agoAren't we overlooking a rather more likely possibility here - that the NSA has itself been hacked? You're right, I see no reason why slideware would be sitting outside the NSA corporate networks and I'm sure they have various procedures to try and prevent exactly that. The two remaining possibilities are: 1. Another leaker who isn't Snowden 2. A third party who has gained access to the insides of the NSA I don't see why we're apparently ignoring 2 in this thread. The Snowden leaks made it very, very clear that essentially nothing is unhackable. And it's not like the USA has a monopoly on hacking skill. What else do we know about the NSA? That they perform the largest WireSharking in history, they literally parse most of the internet with a giant collection of programs which I will assume are written in C or C++ for the sake of performance (though a lot of Perl seems to crop up for analysis purposes too). What are the chances that the NSA have managed to build a huge network with hugely complex interfacing to the entire internet, and huge amounts of software, without opening themselves up to attack by equally sophisticated attackers? I'd say close to zero.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"Aren't we overlooking a rather more likely possibility here - that the NSA has itself been hacked?" That's the most obvious one to me. I thought everyone assumed it until I saw some of these comment threads. If it's Russian, it probably goes back to Kaspersky tracking the Equation Group. They put together about everything about how they operated. Giving Russian intelligence this information combined with trip-wires or tip-offs on live activity by NSA hackers would let Russian hackers attempt to own their boxes. They could just work from there. Alternatively, it could be result of long-running infiltrations that U.S. government has been talking about for decades. At various points, U.S. TLA's said China is throwing piles of spies at us in a numbers game whereas Russia was using (I think it was) 4x more than during height of the Cold War. We also know they're easy to infiltrate and have terrible security since Snowden did and showed exactly that. Plus Manning just pulling everything they had from an Army private's account in Middle East. The leaks could've come from infiltrators, too. So, we have infiltrators, hackers via Kaspersky data (or similar), or insiders that for whatever reason want to humiliate them. Whatever Shadow Brokers say about themselves is just propaganda. They're one of the above with probably typical motivations of agents in those categories.
- jerf 10y agoThe Shadow Brokers are speculated to be an insider [1] (or my own speculation, a small but >1 group given what we've seen), which would mean that these things are packaged together because they've chosen to package them together, not because they were necessarily proximal "in the wild". [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Shadow_Brokers#Speculations_and_theories_on_motive_and_identity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Shadow_Brokers#Speculation...
- Bartweiss 10y agoYeah, this is fascinating. I thought the prior understanding was that Shadow Brokers had found/located a TAO box which had unintentionally been left with a full pen suite. That was an interesting error already, but this implies either a ludicrous screwup (how would you even package those together?) or some much deeper compromise.