3 ms·
> but it's hard to see what 20 or 100 CPUs would do for a laptop. It requires a few assumptions, but here it goes: 1) Assume applications increase their CPU d
by adventured 10y ago
> but it's hard to see what 20 or 100 CPUs would do for a laptop.
It requires a few assumptions, but here it goes:
1) Assume applications increase their CPU demands significantly over the coming decades. Why? Who knows. Maybe (very plausibly) extremely advanced (compared to today) AI use & integration.
2) Move to, essentially, a CPU per process model
I have a couple dozen processes running on my system. Make the CPUs cheap enough and give me 30 of them.
Perhaps the average system will have four or five major AI agents running locally on it, that are particularly good at various things, and those agents will be constantly running processing intensive tasks (I'm assuming here that ~95% of all AI tasks will be performed in the cloud; which is to say I expect the computing power consumed daily by an individual in ... 30 years to be a hundred plus times what the average user is consuming per day now (doing things like watching YouTube or checking Facebook or running Snapchat or WhatsApp)).
- valleyer 10y ago> Why? Who knows. Possibly for the same reason it's already increasing today: as software becomes more complicated (or complex, depending on your POV), we are shifting toward languages and abstractions better suited to manage that complexity, often at the cost of CPU cycles. Examples: dynamic dispatch, interpreted code, libraries on top of libraries on top of libraries, boxing of machine-native types, bridging between old unsafe languages and new safe languages, automatic memory management, automatic bounds/overflow checking.
- vidarh 10y agoI kinda like the idea of this, and that's also one of the reasons I find architectures like the Adapteva Epiphany (the chip that makes the Parallella [1] interesting) interesting. At the moment they're more curiosities because each core is so weak, but they're at least exploring the space of architectures designed for ultra-high core counts (their latest chip is 1024 cores [2], and what makes them different from GPUs is that these are 1024 fully independent cores, running different instruction streams). The problem, though, remains, that for most systems, unless each core is tremendously weak, you can run most of the ongoing tasks on a typical current desktop system on a tiny timeslice of a single core. OSs certainly can paralleise more. E.g. AmigaOS relied far more on using multitasking as a basic OS primitive 30 years ago than most modern OSs, because message passing was exceedingly cheap (no memory protection, context switched involved moving a few registers). Something as simple as cut and paste could involve nearly a dozen processes (device drivers for mouse and keyboard, input handler, console device and higher level console handler, a process specifically managing the console clipboard (other apps might handle it themselves), the clipboard handler, the clipboard device, a filesystem handler for wherever the clipboard was mapped, the underlying disk device - usually ramdisk but could be anything, and more depending on setup). That was to make latency predictable first and foremost, at the cost of throughput, but the overall model could be adapted. But part of the challenge is to write applications this way without just ending up being bottlenecked on the message exchanges. Even if you can make that cheap enough, we still have the problem of the vast number of tasks that are simply very hard to parallelise. For some of them splitting them up and spreading them out certainly could make things like pipelining processing help us cut latency when something is done repeatedly, but whatever we do, we will have big challenges ahead. [1] https://www.parallella.org https://www.parallella.org [2] http://www.adapteva.com/announcements/epiphany-v-a-1024-core-64-bit-risc-processor/ http://www.adapteva.com/announcements/epiphany-v-a-1024-core...
- coldtea 10y ago>Assume applications increase their CPU demands significantly over the coming decades. Why? Who knows. Maybe (very plausibly) extremely advanced (compared to today) AI use & integration.* I'm willing to bet that "extremely advanced AI use" will not come to applications in the "coming decades". It's another fad (in fact a cyclic fad, it had made the same promises back in the 80s), like all the buzzwords that take over an industry for 3-5 years and then give way to the next. In 2040, for all the predictions for its transformation or demise, the business and home desktop will look more or less like it does now.