14 ms·
I'm kinda curious if there's any evidence that would support or rule out intelligent life having existed on earth before. I mean, if humanity goes extinct and
by nostrademons 10y ago
I'm kinda curious if there's any evidence that would support or rule out intelligent life having existed on earth before.
I mean, if humanity goes extinct and it's another 65 million years before another intelligent species evolves, what evidence would they have of our existence? All our buildings would've long since crumbled into dust or been crushed by plate tectonics. Metal will corrode and rust away after a few thousand years. Our largest stone monuments will be gone after 10,000 or so. You'll find occasional fossilized skeletons, but all that would tell future species is that a bipedal mammal with a large brain once existed. Even plastics, the bane of environmentalists, degrade over a couple thousand years.
Probably the only thing we'd see would be a huge mass extinction and an unusually rapid change in the earth's climate. Which we've seen several times in the geologic record already.
- herbstein 10y agoIsaac Arthur has a very interesting video that touches on that specific topic, but with a space exploration angle. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k7fLNvpl0c8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k7fLNvpl0c8
- Ataraxy 10y agoMy favorite youtube channel out in the wild! His videos are such a treat every week.
- nikolasavic 10y agoI love his channel! I'm surprised it isn't more popular, it has top notch content and regularly scheduled releases.
- leonroy 10y agoThat was incredibly good. Some of the ethical and practical implications raised in that video by humans actually achieving interstellar travel were pretty eye opening.
- ddinh 10y agoWhat about space artifacts? Out in the vacuum stuff corrodes/degrades much slower - would satellites still be around or would they have had their orbits degraded and burned up in the atmosphere? Also, how detectable would the stuff we've left behind on Moon (the mirror, perhaps? Only thing that can probably destroy evidence of our presence on the moon would be asteroid impacts) be to a civilization that doesn't know it's there?
- nostrademons 10y agoMost satellite orbits should decay and burn up in the atmosphere long before a few million years has passed. Most of the near-earth orbits become unstable within decades, and the ones that don't are subject to gravitational perturbations from the moon and other planets. The stuff on the moon will remain there for a very very long time, but until another civilization acquires the technological capability to explore a good amount of the moon's surface, it's doubtful they would stumble across the exact same spot as the Apollo landings.
- c517402 10y agoThere are corner reflector arrays on the moon that might make someone curious, if millions of years of moon dust doesn't effect them or they aren't destroyed by an asteroid impact.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jerf 10y agoI've thought about this and my conclusion is that we will likely leave behind a very strange pattern of certain natural resources. "Oh, look, here's a vein of copper! It's getting better, and better, and, that's weird, it's gone now and there's a complete break in the strata for some reason." Over time new mountains may form some new deposits, but it may be noticeable in the older mountains (that are today the younger mountains) for a long time. If we make it for another few hundred years, not only will there be a mass extinction, but there will also probably be a traceable sudden explosion in a novel form of gene transfer and creation that can't be explained by any other theory. The modern fashionable self-loathing idea that we are a uniquely biodiversity-destroying organism may be merely a consequence of our current point of view; rather than "extinction" this could in fact be an inexplicable explosion in diversity if you could see 1000 years into the future. But of course the mass extinction will still be there. I haven't done an analysis but it may also be the case that the extinction has a very characteristic pattern; again, rather than the fashionable self-loathing model of "humans just destroy everything" it may be noticeable that fauna died out in favor of things that are clearly domesticated even just from their skeletons, and that human predators were preferentially extincted, etc.
- nostrademons 10y agoCurious if anyone's ever observed something similar to this? It'd be super easy to detect if you're looking for it, but most miners aren't thinking "Hmm, I wonder if a previous intelligent species existed on earth millions of years before us."
- azernik 10y agoMining companies generally hire very smart geologists who care a lot about the processes that shape resource deposits, in order to predict where new deposits will be found. If there were any pattern that didn't fit with natural processes people would notice
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoSurely if a previous society extracted megatons of ore from the ground there would be something left of that civilisation. At least a wheel track or a scrape mark, not to mention maybe a spanner.
- Swizec 10y ago> I'm kinda curious if there's any evidence that would support or rule out intelligent life having existed on earth before. How intelligent is intelligent? Homo Neanderthalensis predated Homo Sapiens by about 100,000 years. They were intelligent enough to build tools and have communities. Oldest corvid fossils are 25 million years old[1]. They are known to be very intelligent and modern crows can solve 8-step puzzles, build tools, teach their young etc. etc. I mean, intelligence has evolved independently many times in animals on earth. It's hard to say which species was first to become intelligent, but I'm pretty sure humans weren't the first. [1] http://www.reed.edu/biology/professors/srenn/pages/teaching/web_2010/ndr_site/phylogeny.html http://www.reed.edu/biology/professors/srenn/pages/teaching/...
- rojobuffalo 10y agoWe're sharing the planet with several intelligent species at this moment. Maybe a worthwhile distinction would be intelligence sufficient to dominant an entire planetary ecology; or sufficient to intentionally become multi-planetary.
- Swizec 10y agoDominate the planet is tricky too. Corvids for instance are almost as widespread as humans. They don't do greenland and the southern parts of south america. But they happen to be less destructive to their environment than humans so maybe that disqualifies them from the "dominate" part? That said, humans also don't quality for multi-planetary. I like that definition, though.
- rojobuffalo 10y agoGood point about corvids. Ants are another example I was thinking about. They actually do engineer ecology on the scale of individual mounds by feeding and growing fungi that they eat. They are spread all over the Earth, and I think they have us beat in terms of biomass. Maybe there could be another definition for a weaker form of intelligence that covers those cases.
- flubert 10y agoI wonder about satellites. How far above the earth's surface would a satellite have to be to keep atmospheric drag low enough to keep an artificial satellite in orbit for a long long time. And how big would it need to be for it to be naked eye visible at that distance. And what could be done to make it unlikely to be mistaken for a natural phenomena? Have clusters of satellites in geometric patterns? 65 Million years is a long time. That sounds like a more interesting project than the "Long Now" effort.
- crooked-v 10y agoFor something to last a really long time, you'd want to have it at one of the Lagrangian points. Have it be big and reflective - say, a tremendous expanse of reflective cloth behind a relatively small probe - and anybody with a telescope and patience will eventually spot it as a weird "star". Something shiny at a Lagrangian point will suggest something weird (compared to the non-shinyness of objects collected at the Lagrangian points of other planets), making it an obvious target for investigation by space probes. There are actually a number of probes at the Sun-Earth and Earth-Moon L2 points already [1], because it's a perfect spot for telescopes and observatories. I don't know if any of them are big enough to easily observe from Earth, though. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_objects_at_Lagrangian_points https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_objects_at_Lagrangian_...
- alphydan 10y agoNot any Lagrangian point will do. L1, L2, L3 are unstable so a small perturbation will send your satellite away. Only L4, L5 will do under certain conditions for the mass of the satellite [0] [0] https://map.gsfc.nasa.gov/ContentMedia/lagrange.pdf https://map.gsfc.nasa.gov/ContentMedia/lagrange.pdf
- Baeocystin 10y agoAnything in geosync is there* until the sun boils the oceans. (*it will rather quickly wander from its original position, but it isn't leaving orbit or crashing down.)
- Cyph0n 10y agoHow do we know that 65 million years is long enough for a species with a human-like intelligence to evolve? What if our evolution was merely a biological fluke that took much less time than usual?
- zeroer 10y agoI'm still waiting for intelligent life.
- kahoon 10y agoCertainly possible. Dinosaurs were around longer than mammals and their intelligence did not reach human-level. Makes sense if we consider that evolution is a blind process which does not "aim" for creating higher intelligence, and may only happen by chance if it suits the given environment better than other traits.
- Baeocystin 10y agoI think this is a particularly salient point. Earth is already well on the backside of how much longer it will be hospitable to life. First life was ~4 billion years ago. First multicellular life, 1.5. And now here we are, the first intelligence of our kind, clearly closely related to the animals we descended from, but just as clearly different in how our minds work. That's one example in 4 billion years, and the Earth has between 500 million to 1 billion years left before the ever-increasing brightness of the sun boils the oceans and sterilizes the planet. It could easily be that life is stunningly common across the universe, but that 80% is at the level of bacteria, and 99.x% is simple animals at best.
- swombat 10y agoMy understanding from Astrophysics class back at uni was that sun-like stars spent 5-10b years on the main sequence, so I thought we may well have another 5b years of quality sunshine to enjoy. Or not.
- Baeocystin 10y ago
- nerfhammer 10y agoSome of the skeletons will be wearing gold jewelry.
- S4M 10y agoHow about the things we would have left in extreme environments: Internet cables at the bottom of the sea, rubbish (or dead people with clothes) high in the mountains, or remnants of polar expeditions in the South pole?
- scythe 10y agoAntarctica will eventually leave the South Pole if I understand it correctly.
- technotony 10y agoWell geologists think our impact can already be measured enough to leave a trace and are calling the era of man the 'Anthropocene'. Climate change and mass extinction are two of these features, but there will also be radiation from nuclear tests, plastic waste and impact of domestication on animal fossils. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/aug/29/declare-anthropocene-epoch-experts-urge-geological-congress-human-impact-earth https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/aug/29/declare-...
- sharun 10y agoStone degrades faster than bone? Stone tools have been found that are 2-3 million years old - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stone_tool https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stone_tool
- spydum 10y agoalways wondered how exactly this process works.. you can date the stone itself, but how do you date the shaping of the stone?
- stevenwoo 10y agoThe assumption is the surrounding sediment can suffice for a good enough approximation. http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/13/science/13qna.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/13/science/13qna.html
- scythe 10y agoMines seem like a possibility. Hmm, this kind of rock is usually associated with these minerals, but not when these weird streaks appear. But radionuclides are the ultimate signals. Palladium-107 is a byproduct of nuclear weapons use that becomes incorporated into palladium-bearing rocks and decays to silver, which can be detected by the presence of Ag-107 in palladium ores lacking other silver isotopes. Remaining Pd-107 can be used to estimate the date at which the palladium was deposited or the ore can be dated by its depth. So we can exclude the use of uranium-based nuclear weapons by previous inhabitants going back about... 60-80 million years since the half-life of Pd-107 is about 6 million years. In theory we could have tried to detect whether nuclear weapons had been used on Earth in the last 120-150 million years by looking for iodine-129 in the oceans, but we already blew up too many bombs to confound that experiment. Finding iodine-129 some place we don't expect it would be interesting.
- caf 10y agoPresumably we could look for ¹²⁹I in deep Antarctic ice cores?
- GlennS 10y agoLargest stone monuments gone after 10,000 years? Are you sure? The pyramids are already approaching 5,000 years old. Do they show any signs of disappearing?
- JuliusKaiser 10y agoNo, because they are maintained for tourist and historical value.
- usefulcat 10y agoBut said maintenance is relatively recent (~100 years?) compared to their age.
- adrianN 10y agoI'd guess that the Egyptians maintained them. If I'm not mistaken they where in pretty good shape during Roman times.
- logfromblammo 10y agoHuman activity weathers stone monuments faster than desert winds. If I recall correctly, the original sheathing stones and capstones of the pyramids were gradually stolen. The Sphinx was used for target practice. Water, on the other hand, will tear through your stones much more quickly. In a wet, temperate climate, the weak acid falling from the sky will wear limestone. The moisture invading cracks and freezing will widen those cracks. Lichens will bore tiny holes into the rock, and plant roots will cause fissures to expand. Additionally, moisture that penetrates to metallic structural reinforcement will oxidize and swell that reinforcement to pop bits off of the stone (observable from earlier attempts at restoration at the Parthenon, where the replacement anchor pins weren't coated in lead correctly, and they started to crack the rock blocks--now they use non-corroding titanium pins). Sometimes mortar does not swell or expand at the same rate as whatever it binds, and something will crack, admit water, and generally deteriorate from there. Water is the enemy of preservation. They pyramids didn't survive just because they are stone, but because they are also dry. And on a long enough geological timescale, every potential building site will eventually experience every climate, including being entirely immersed in salt water.
- BurningFrog 10y agoOne thing we can observe is that parts of the planet have been completely isolated from each other for many millions of years, until very recently when human travel has brought "invasive species" to places where they've never been. I think this proves that there was no civilization advanced enough to travel between continents for however many millions of years the evolutionary isolation can be proven. I'm guessing it's at least some dozen Megayears.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> All our buildings would've...been crushed by plate tectonics Our buildings are on dry land. Dry land is dry because it's predominantly made of continental crust [1]. It's lighter than oceanic crust [2]. When oceanic and continental crusts meet, the oceanic tends to get driven under the continental crust, which floats on top. Keep in mind that we still have fossil shells feom 65 million years ago. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continental_crust https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continental_crust [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oceanic_crust https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oceanic_crust
- colordrops 10y agoIf we can find tons of fossils of animals and plants, I'm absolutely sure there would be fossils left behind of cars, houses, etc
- Houshalter 10y agoI've read an interesting theory about this before but I can't remember the source. If there was intelligent life on Antarctica, it would be impossible for us to detect it today. Antarctica was warmer once and could have supported much more life. It's plausible any life that evolved there would be restricted to that continent. Humans evolved in warm climates and could adapt to cold climates by building shelters and wearing clothing. An animal that evolved in a cold climate would have a much harder time colonizing warm climates. And since then glaciers have scraped the surface clean and there would be little remains of them. <ridiculous_conspiracy_theory> I read another, much more crazy, theory, that the government is covering up something in Antarctica. There are so many untapped resources in Antarctica. And after WWII, lots of were exploring it and trying to lay claim to them. Then suddenly everyone left and a treaty was signed banning mining there. To protect the most desolate continent on Earth from... environmental harm? In the 1950's when environmentalism was such a big thing? And there are a suspicious number of military bases down there... And they are guarding what, exactly? What did they find... </ridiculous_conspiracy_theory>
- winfred 10y agoHere you go: http://www.coolantarctica.com/Antarctica%20fact%20file/science/threats_mining_oil.php http://www.coolantarctica.com/Antarctica%20fact%20file/scien... Mining wasn't banned until 1991. And as the article outlines, Antarctica is a really, really inhospitable place, to the point that it might be easier to colonize a different planet than to colonize Antarctica (I'd probably prefer equatorial Mars over Antarctica) and even mineral extraction would be very complicated.
- api 10y agoI read a great rundown once on /r/space about how Antarctica actually is in many ways less hospitable than Mars, at least in winter. I find that rather amazing.
- awirth 10y agoPerhaps you're thinking of this thread? https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/2xvdow/why_worry_about_colonizing_mars_when_weve_barely/ https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/2xvdow/why_worry_abo...
- throwaway91111 10y agoIt would still be visible in the fossil record, IMHO. Stone can still form around structures that long faded away, and there is zero evidence of any tool before our recent relatives (apes). EDIT: fossil record -> geological record.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoI think strip mines wouldn't be too difficult to detect. Some of them are comparable in size to the ancient craters we've discovered. Maybe canals--I don't think there'd be much left, but maybe enough to notice an unnaturally straight depression running for hundreds of miles. I wonder if aqueducts and transport tunnels could survive the ages, in hard rock in a geologically inactive area; but I suppose the entrances would probably be buried in any case. My personal nerd theory along those lines is there there may have been life on Earth before the giant impact that created the moon. All evidence of any sort of life whatsoever would have been buried under hundreds of miles of magma. It's very unlikely, as the Earth was so young at that point that it might not even have had a solid crust yet, but I find it compelling. :)
- kortex 10y agoThere are a lot of things which would likely not break down oven millions of years, provided they were largely protected from the element. A lot of glasses, ceramics. Tungsten carbide (pretty much any super hard machine tool, as long as it wasn't subducted). The isotopic distribution of nuclear waste would be a big clue. And anything we've stuck on the moon. Not to mention, all of the LACK of things. Giant holes from mining operations. All the straight cuts we've made through mountains. The Panama Canal.
- kobeya 10y agoFossilized bone survives 65Myr, but granite buildings and metal tools do not leave even the slightest fingerprints? I'll call BS.
- SmellTheGlove 10y agoYou might be able to find some of our shit still in orbit. Also, I'm not sure of the timescale for things to decay on the moon, but would something from Apollo be left up there? Depending on how far into the future, what if something bigger eventually got built? 65M years is a long time and I have no idea what, besides radiation and meteorites, would cause something to decay on the moon. Is it possible for something the size and rough composition of a car to survive?
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> You'll find occasional fossilized skeletons, but all that would tell future species is that a bipedal mammal with a large brain once existed. Scrimshaw seems like it would be pretty good evidence of intelligence.
- pchristensen 10y agoIf this comment is interesting to you, you may enjoy the book The World Without Us. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/248787.The_World_Without_Us?ac=1&from_search=true https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/248787.The_World_Without...
- njwi332 10y agoDon't forget radioactive waste/byproducts. That will be around for a long time, and thinking about how future humans might interact with it is an interesting problem. I wrote a little about it http://stochastication.com/2016/06/13/inverse-archaeology/ http://stochastication.com/2016/06/13/inverse-archaeology/