19 ms·
What made Xerox PARC special? Who else today is like them?
- Dangeranger 10y agoThere are some especially qualified answers on Quora. But to have your question answered by Alan Kay on the topic on Xerox PARC is truly special.
- throwaway7645 10y agoAgreed. I think he is a hackernews user as well
- jasonkostempski 10y agoWasn't he going to do some kind of work with ycombinator attempting to recreate some of the spirit of Xerox PARC? Maybe I just dreamt it.
- jacquesm 10y agoHARC https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11679680 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11679680
- jasonkostempski 10y agoThat was it. Official site: https://harc.ycr.org/ https://harc.ycr.org/ Nothing super interesting there yet, at least to me :/
- azeirah 10y agoBret Victor (worrydream.com) is a PI at HARC, having seen his previous demos, I'm very optimistic about HARC's future.
- stevenj 10y agoHe is. https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=alankay1 https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=alankay1
- steveeq1 10y agoFor those interested, more answers from alan kay available here: https://www.quora.com/profile/Alan-Kay-11 https://www.quora.com/profile/Alan-Kay-11
- sounds 10y ago> Who else today is like them? > PARC still exists, but Google advanced technology projects is probably the closest. Neither of these is that close to the old Xerox PARC since they tent to focus on near term commercializable projects. https://www.quora.com/Whats-the-most-similar-thing-to-Xerox-PARC-that-exists-today https://www.quora.com/Whats-the-most-similar-thing-to-Xerox-... ... While I can see how Google is an engine of scientific progress, Silicon Valley is bigger than Google. Stanford deserves a lot of credit. Without diving into "what makes Silicon Valley Silicon Valley," I think I should point out that Stanford has consistently produced disruptions since at least Xerox PARC's founding. (Obligatory: I have only ever visited Stanford, long after graduating from a different university.)
- tmccrmck 10y agoThere was an interesting post on HN years ago about why Google isn't a modern day Bell Labs. [1] A common sentiment on the thread was that Microsoft Research was more akin to Bell Labs. > I've always had the impression that MSR (Microsoft Research) was generally doing much more fundamental research than Google. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6919184 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6919184
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"> I've always had the impression that MSR (Microsoft Research) was generally doing much more fundamental research than Google." They definitely are. Just look at all the MS Research labs and projects. I did once to find them all over the place in terms of both categories of tech and fundamental vs general vs narrow. The Duffy posts on Midori with its design/implementation decisions show how unconventional they can be even when just trying to build a robust, desktop OS whose UI isn't actually radical. Only bad thing is most of best stuff gets turned into patents to stomp on competition. :(
- tmccrmck 10y agoI've met people who worked on Midori and they describe it as the best project they've ever worked on. Used to work in a building with a bunch of old Midori-folks and would ask them about it anytime I heard the word 'Midori'. I don't think it was MSR though. Personally, I've always been most impressed by the research into formal verification: Z3, Dafny, TLA+, F*, Lean, and many more.
- tostitos1979 10y agoMicrosoft Research Silicon Valley (MSR-SVC) used to be like PARC of old. Too bad it was shut down a few years ago. I don't know if any place comes close. To be fair, there are pockets of awesomeness at places like IBM T.J. Watson and MSR Redmond .. you need to be lucky enough to work with the right group of people. Edit: I should point out that while it is awesome to work in such a storied place, there is some stress associated with it. Read about the weekly "Dealer" meetings at PARC.
- azhenley 10y agoI interned a Microsoft Research last summer and will be interning at IBM Research this coming summer, and they both seem great. I can't compare to PARC, but there are a lot of cool things happening at these places.
- scott_s 10y agoIn that case, I should see you around the building in a few months.
- ultimoo 10y agoInteresting read on "Dealer" meetings. From The Myths of Creativity By David Burkus >> In the 1970s at Xerox PARC, regularly scheduled arguments were routine. The company that gave birth to the personal computer staged formal discussions designed to train their people on how to fight properly over ideas and not egos. PARC held weekly meetings they called "Dealer" (from a popular book of the time titled Beat the Dealer). Before each meeting, one person, known as "the dealer," was selected as the speaker. The speaker would present his idea and then try to defend it against a room of engineers and scientists determined to prove him wrong. Such debates helped improve products under development and sometimes resulted in wholly new ideas for future pursuit. The facilitators of the Dealer meetings were careful to make sure that only intellectual criticism of the merit of an idea received attention and consideration. Those in the audience or at the podium were never allowed to personally criticize their colleagues or bring their colleagues' character or personality into play. Bob Taylor, a former manager at PARC, said of their meetings, "If someone tried to push their personality rather than their argument, they'd find that it wouldn't work." Inside these debates, Taylor taught his people the difference between what he called Class 1 disagreements, in which neither party understood the other party's true position, and Class 2 disagreements, in which each side could articulate the other's stance. Class 1 disagreements were always discouraged, but Class 2 disagreements were allowed, as they often resulted in a higher quality of ideas. Taylor's model removed the personal friction from debates and taught individuals to use conflict as a means to find common, often higher, ground.
- icelancer 10y agoI try to run the R&D side of my sports science business like Xerox PARC. I take a ton of inspiration from them.
- tyingq 10y agoDifferent space, but after reading Alan Kay's answer, the only current entity that comes to mind is CERN.
- dpflan 10y agoRelated to this special time in computing that Kay discusses is the book "What the Doormouse Said?" It's a good, relatively quick read about the rise of personal computing in the 1960's. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/What_the_Dormouse_Said https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/What_the_Dormouse_Said
- Simorgh 10y agoAs mentioned by Alan right at the beginning of his answer, the true visionary behind our current technological age was Licklider. He was an ARPA researcher who, it is argued [1], initially dreamt up the connected network we now know as the internet. Interestingly, when an early iteration of the 'net was put to UCLA academics, they refused to get involved! [1] Sharon Weinberger, The Imagineers of War (2017).
- jacquesm 10y agoTo be like Xerox PARC today you'd have to move back to the time when Xerox did what they did there. It's not just the company or the people but the total environment in which that took place. Once the canvas is no longer blank it becomes a lot harder to be that innovative. All kinds of brakes on the system engage almost automatically: conventions, languages, processors, window managers have all become a lot less open to really new concepts. The biggest changes of the last couple of years are deep learning coupled with the advent of GPUs that have computing power that was only affordable to universities not that long ago for very little money. Possibly that will engender a totally new computing environment in which our 'old' stuff no longer matters as much and we'll be more free to pursue things that are less anchored in the practical requirement to make money. I suspect the whole 'deep learning' revolution will be as big as the original invention of the transistor or the web. It won't give us full AI but maybe by the time we've mined that for all it's worth we won't feel the need for it anymore.
- nikofeyn 10y agodo you really think that about deep learning? it has zero application or effect in my job (i don't see that changing for at least the next decade) and in my personal life, it only serves to produce "better ads".
- mayukh 10y agoAnd what effect did a better ux manager have when pc's were used by a miniscule percentage of the population?
- michaelbarton 10y agoI would disagree. If you've ever requested a web page translation, done an image search, or spoken with an Alexa or google device I believe it's deep learning going on in the backend. I don't work at any of the large tech companies but I imagine they're applying deep learning as pervasively as possible where it can make a difference. That's not to disparage with your comment, only to say that while it might feel like a negligible effect on your life, I would say that it is non-zero. My completely uninformed and lay persons opinion is that we might not yet know what we can really do with deep learning yet. For example there were many years between the discovery of electricity and the invention of the microprocessor. The latter certainly required the discovery of the former, but did not logically lead to it. I use this example because Andrew Ng called AI the new electricity.
- surfmike 10y agoYC HARC (https://harc.ycr.org https://harc.ycr.org) has a lot of talented people working on PARC-like problems. Alan Kay has close contact with a lot of the team as well.
- Glench 10y agoHaving worked there, HARC is explicitly modeled after PARC (it's even there in the name) e.g. give a few visionaries a relatively small amount of funding and let them go. Even if nothing interesting happens your investment wasn't very large, but if anything interesting does come out of it then it might be as big as the personal computer and networking (so the theory goes).
- mozumder 10y agoA similar organization today is DARPA. You can submit proposals to them and they may fund you.
- alankay1 10y agoIt isn't similar, either to PARC or to ARPA-IPTO (before the "D"). It was that "D" that caused PARC to happen, because of the qualitative change in what "Advances Research Projects" were supposed to mean.
- aerovistae 10y agoThis link led me on to a little bit of wikipedia reading where I learned something that really surprised me: according to wiki, Xerox today still employs more people than either Microsoft or Apple, 130k to their 115k each. Am I the only person who finds that shocking? I had no idea they were still so huge. And this despite their market cap being a hundredth of Apple or Microsoft's.
- jacquesm 10y agoHP tops all of them at 300K (or rather, did until the formation of HP Inc.).
- brettproctor 10y agoIBM currently at 380K according to wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoEven after the Conduent spin off?
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoWow. What do those people do? For that matter, what does Xerox do these days?
- jon-wood 10y agoXerox these days still make photocopiers, but they also work as really nice printers and network connected scanners. I imagine a lot of their employees are in the service division. When you buy a high end printer it also comes with a service contract where someone will proactively come and do things like clean the printer and make sure toner is stocked.
- vinhboy 10y agoI work in a building next to a Xerox rented building. Apparently Xerox does a lot of government contracting. They bid on government IT contracts and hire people to work on them.
- kilroy123 10y agoI'm not sure what places are like Xerox PARC now, but I want to create something like it again in the near future. Only for space-related ventures. My uncle was on the original PARC team so I'll see if I can get an answer from him to answer the quora question.
- zengid 10y agoI've been reading the book he mentions, "The Dream Machine", by Mitchell Waldrop. It has been a great read so far (I'm a little past the point of the creation of ARPA), particularly the section about John McCarthy developing LISP and conceiving of the architecture for time-sharing. Reading it has felt like I'm paying my respects to the pioneers of our field, because I am humbled by what they achieved.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoSame here with a lot of the older works. I felt it as I read on Barton's B5000, LISP machines, PARC's stuff, high-assurance security, some high-availability (eg NonStop), SGI's graphic hardware, and so on. Although not with new fundamentals, even Microsoft's VerveOS was a pile of nice engineering with ExpressOS following its lead for Android.
- noir_lord 10y agoIt's interesting (to me at least) how much of the ideas they had back then are still waiting to be expounded on, they (and people like them) did the foundational work we still build new things on now, I read a book (I wish I could remember the title) about the architecture of the 2nd and 3rd generations of IBM's mainframes as they battled with the problem of "how do we keep the same software running on different hardware" and came up with virtualisation etc. I wonder how many dusty copies of papers sat in university libraries contain ideas that brushed up and given a new coat of paint would be considered revolutionary. The other side of it is I still use stuff those guys wrote every day, while typing this I switched a bash terminal to run an install command using a program that is pretty much identical (if a superset) of a program written in 1977, 3 years before I was born.
- jraines 10y agoA few favorite quotes from "The Dream Machine" The idea began to dominate my thinking and for the next two evenings I went out after dinner and walked the streets in the dark thinking about it -Jay Forrester, on the idea of magnetic memory Trying to avoid every conceivable error is a recipe for paralysis, having the freedom to make mistakes is necessary for achieving any progress at all -Waldrop (author) on Herbert Simon & the idea of satisficing in the context of behavioral econonmics (he was awarded the Nobel in 1978) . . . a way of life in an integrated domain where hunches, cut-and-try, and the human 'feel for a situation' usefully coexist with powerful concepts, streamlined technology and notation, sophisticated methods, and high powered electronic aids -Englebart, prophesying You couldn't develop and improve the system without seeing how a large and diverse community used it in practice. -Robert Fano, on the development of time sharing The spirit at that meeting was as good as it gets - the most civilized, ecumenical, incredibly supportive atmosphere you could want. People would cheer you on even if they didn't agree with you, just because they loved the fact that you were good -Alan Kay on the early ARPA community We felt strongly that only a very small group could do the project on that timescale . . . I don't remember such a thing as a weekly progress meeting. We were more in tune with progress than that. -Dave Walden on the development of the IMP, the first packet switching node To Lick, the obvious solution to the software crisis was to apply better and more interactive computing . . . when the systems are truly complex, programming has to be a process of exploration and discovery [H]ire the smartest people you can find and give them their head - but let them know who's paying the bills . . . it wasn't enough to hire a bunch of super smart individuals, you had to build a community, a culture, and an environment of innovation. You had to give your people the kind of challenge that would light a fire in their eyes, that would generate an atmosphere of non-stop intellectual excitement, that would let them feel in their gut that this is where the action is. You had to provide them with lavish resources - everything they needed to do the job. And through it all, you had to keep your bottom line guys at bay so your guys could have the freedom to make mistakes -Jack Goldman, founder of PARC
- agumonkey 10y agoI remember thinking a lot about PARC when visiting biohacklabs. The feeling of random ideas implemented by people of various skills organically without clear goals. Lesser costs, new designs, new implementations.
- grabcocque 10y ago1) Smart people who have great ideas 2) A business model that has no need of those ideas 3) Management who have absolutely no idea how to capitalise on those ideas outside of a core business? ... That's Google. Google are Xerox.
- moolcool 10y agoGoogle is an ad company which makes products to put ads on
- nine_k 10y agoLike self-driving cars? I think they are desperately groping for something to diversify, because the ad models come and go, and the revenue can some day dry up.
- petepete 10y agoWell, what are you going to watch while you're being driven around?
- ClassyJacket 10y agoTechnically Google doesn't own Waymo, Alphabet does. Maybe that's part of the reason why.
- alaskamiller 10y agoGoogle is a data company, offering the opportunity to manipulate some of that data in exchange for money.
- Nemcue 10y ago.. manipulate some of that data to improve their ads.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoGoogle hasn't done much that's game changing that I've seen. Their incentives and goals are different than PARC most of the time. They did a lot of practical solutions to their problems that are similar to other solutions. The one, ultra-clever thing that jumped out at me was Spanner's TrueTime. Utterly brilliant. Google could become PARC if they chose. Even have some groups like Spanner's doing unconventional stuff. I think it would take changes in management's priorities and evaluation of employees to get it there. It's not yet but there's potential.
- zem 10y agoi wonder why he (presumably) did not think "dealers of lightning" was a good book. not read "the dream machine" yet, but i thought "dealers of lightning" was a great look at the history of xerox parc.
- alphadevx 10y agoSuperb book, recommended reading for those managing engineering teams as you will learn a great deal about the culture at Xerox Parc, and what made it so successful (peer review was a huge part of it, or as they called it "beat the dealer"): http://amzn.to/2nLvMFO http://amzn.to/2nLvMFO
- zem 10y agorecommended reading for engineers too; I found it very inspiring in a "makes you feel like building things" sense.
- bitwize 10y agoA blank check from the Feds in the hopes that giving money to smart people will make tgem develop something we could use to blow up the Russkies. That's what made Xerox PARC.
- JustSomeNobody 10y ago>There was no software religion. Everyone made the languages and OSs and apps, etc that they felt would advance their research. I feel like there is a lot of software religion in this industry today, however it is mostly perpetuated by mediocre developers.
- pekk 10y agoNaturally that group does not include you or most of HN.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoMe? I try not to. I don't like windows but I don't preach about it. C++, Java,C#, etc. I like em. I prefer Python. But I don't preach about it. Python 2 vs 3? Who freaking cares? Just get stuff done. But I don't preach about it. I just go about getting my work done. I think my only true religion is that I want open protocols. Chat, home automation, auto, etc. should all use open and documented protocols.
- carapace 10y agoKay's own Viewpoints Research Institute is worth mentioning in this context. http://www.vpri.org/ http://www.vpri.org/
- gradstudent 10y ago> Fund people not projects — the scientists find the problems not the funders. So, for many reasons, you have to have the best researchers. > Problem Finding — not just Problem Solving Lessons not yet learned
- morphle 10y agoWe are (playing the Wayne Gretzky game of invention).
- CalChris 10y agoI'm less of a PARC fan and more of a Lampson fan. In fact, I'm a huge Butler Lampson fan. I've read his PARC valedictory Hints on Computer System Design many times and he's updated it recently. He went from PARC to DEC SRC (maybe 5 miles). I saw him give a talk at SRC and for about 15 minutes afterwards, I understood. Hints is the favorite paper of a lot of my heroes like John Regehr. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/acrobat-17.pdf https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/wp-content/uploads/... http://bwlampson.site/Slides/Hints%20and%20principles%20(HLF%202015).pdf http://bwlampson.site/Slides/Hints%20and%20principles%20(HLF... http://blog.regehr.org/archives/1143 http://blog.regehr.org/archives/1143 From SRC, he went to Microsoft and he also taught at MIT. https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/electrical-engineering-and-computer-science/6-826-principles-of-computer-systems-spring-2002/ https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/electrical-engineering-and-compu...
- alankay1 10y agoLet me encourage you to be both. Butler is one of the most amazing people I've met and had the great pleasure of working in the same environment with him for many years. I also think that all of us who were there would not want to try to separate "the great people" from "the great environment" nor would it be possible without great distortion (this is the point that most people miss about ARPA/PARC).
- Animats 10y ago"You know what makes the rockets fly? Funding." - The Right Stuff. What really made PARC work is that they were funded to develop the future of computing by building machines which were not cost-effective. It was too early in the mid-1970s to develop a commercially viable personal workstation. But it was possible to do it if you didn't have to make it cost-effective. That's what I was told when I got a tour of PARC in 1975. They had the Alto sort of working, (the custom CRT making wasn't going well; the phosphor coating wasn't uniform yet) the first Ethernet up, a disk server, and I think the first Dover laser printer. All that gear cost maybe 10x what the market would pay for it. But that was OK with Xerox HQ. By the time the hardware cost came down, they'd know what to build. Previous attempts at GUI development had been successful, but tied up entire mainframe computers. Sutherland's Sketchpad (1963)[1] and Engelbart's famous demo (1968)[2] showed what was possible with a million dollars of hardware per user. The cost had to come down by three orders of magnitude, which took a while. Another big advantage which no one mentions is that Xerox PARC was also an R&D center for Xerox copiers. That's why they were able to make the first decent xerographic laser printer, which was a mod to a Xerox 2400 copier. They had access to facilities and engineers able to make good electronic and electromechanical equipment, and thoroughly familiar with xerographic machines. Ah, the glory days of Big Science. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6orsmFndx_o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6orsmFndx_o [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY
- BurningFrog 10y agoMoney is a necessary ingredient, but I've been in and near enough very costly endeavors that produced very little brilliance to think it's probably not even in the top 3 most important ones.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jackfoxy 10y agoMoney is necessary, but not sufficient.
- 10y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y agoTo like PARC you need the following things: 1. A monopoly that prints money 2. Company desire to investigate cool stuff 3. No pressure to productize the research 4. Smart people hired and given lots of leeway. I think parts of Google, Microsoft,AT&T, and IBM are/have been like this.
- jacinabox 10y agoIt is special because it happened in a different era and its technological and cultural ideas are no longer legible. Time was computers were for mathematics, now they are Potemkin villages and vehicles for almost stunning cultural paranoia and new sectarian hatreds.
- dualogy 10y ago> vehicles for almost stunning cultural paranoia and new sectarian hatreds Expound =)
- bane 10y agoThere's a few, not quite the same, but bits of pieces of places like this exist. Monopoly driven companies like Google or Microsoft have nice R&D arms, car companies can get involved in weird things. There's the big research universities, who are these days just as commercial as PARC ever was. There's also DoE National Labs who, because of the downturn in the nuke business, get involved in all kinds of cool R&D and are surprising to most people only semi-government. And finally there's pure government R&D centers, mostly in the military.
- nataz 10y agoControl F for national labs, and this is the only comment that came up. That makes me sad. The DOE and NNSA national labs are enormous R&D institutions and have grown far beyond their original propose in the atomic weapons complex.[1] I personally work for an office that pumps over 100 million annually into the system, and frankly that's small change. Probably about 40%-60% of that money goes into overhead and facilities which enables research outside of my project. There are a lot of fair criticisms of the system, but most of that is because real R&D works like ycombinator. Lots of investment, with the hope that eventually something pays off in a huge way. Like the system or not, most people who are unhappy with it are really just unhappy about government sponsored R&D. Almost by definition, it's not going to be "efficient" in the short term. If people are interested in big money, complex problem science, i encourage you to take a look at the labs. They cover everything from supercomputers, to marine science, to renewable energy. [1] https://energy.gov/about-national-labs https://energy.gov/about-national-labs
- jv22222 10y ago> The commonsense idea that “computer people should not try to make their own tools (because of the infinite Turing Tarpit that results)”. The ARPA idea was a second order notion: “if you can make your own tools, HW and SW, then you must!” All the best breakthroughs of my career have come from a build don't buy bias.
- dualogy 10y agoGot some examples to roughly outline? Am curious for encouraging anecdotes as a chronic (semi-willing) NIH syndrome "sufferer" in all areas I can hypothetically attack with just a laptop and a compiler..
- partycoder 10y agoXerox was an immensely profitable business once. Being first to market with photocopiers, and keeping a large market share for a long time. In the Palo Alto Research Center (PARC), they had the right team, the right ideas and research was absolutely going in the right direction. For instance, they had former SRI International researchers that participated in the Douglas Engelbart's "oN-Line-System", presented in 1968 in what is now known as "the mother of all demos" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Mother_of_All_Demos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Mother_of_All_Demos). Their achievements include the creation of the excellent Xerox Alto computer system featuring a GUI and a mouse as input device, which inspired the Apple Macintosh and MS Windows (a story dramatized in multiple occasions, notably in the classic "Pirates of Silicon Valley"). Xerox leadership failed to visualize how innovations like the Alto could be converted into profitable products... even if it looks self-evident today. That's a once in a lifetime opportunity that they let go and as a result other companies heavily profited from PARC's findings and continue to do so today. In addition, photocopiers are no longer at the center of business activities, and usage paper is decreasing. This makes Xerox a company of the past, like Kodak or Blockbuster (not trying to be offensive, but it is fair to say so).
- milesrout 10y agoYeah people go on and on about how much 'amazing' stuff Google does or Microsoft does as if they just have a knack for picking the right people. No, they have some good people and a huge amount of money gained from monopolies, which are by definition not legal.
- chrisseaton 10y ago> monopolies, which are by definition not legal By exactly what definition? Monopolies are not illegal. Abusing a monopoly is illegal in some cases.
- milesrout 10y agoIf it's not illegal, it's not a monopoly. Microsoft still has an illegal monopoly with Windows. There's no political will to deal with it, but it absolutely exists and has for years.
- chrisseaton 10y ago> If it's not illegal, it's not a monopoly. Where are you getting this information from? "The courts have interpreted this to mean that monopoly is not unlawful per se, but only if acquired through prohibited conduct." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law#Monopoly_and_power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law#Mo..., which cites a 1945 court case United States v. Aluminum Corp. of America.
- milesrout 10y agoWhy would American law be relevant?
- chrisseaton 10y agoYou've mentioned two companies - Microsoft and Google. Both of these are American companies so they're subject to US competition law in at least their home markets. No other country would have the power to do anything fundamental about their monopoly such as breaking them up. They could only fine them, require them to support competitors, or lesser things like that. If you want to talk about some other countries, a monopoly is also not illegal in the UK. Again, only abusing the monopoly may be considered illegal. https://www.gov.uk/cartels-price-fixing/overview https://www.gov.uk/cartels-price-fixing/overview If you were thinking of a different country's law (which would be odd since you mentioned two US companies) can you name one where a monopoly is by definition illegal?
- fuzzygroup 10y agoI’d strongly recommend the book Dealers of Lightning. Now I should comment that Alan Kay was at Parc and its where he did amazing work that holds up to this day so pay the most attention to his answer of course. But I learned a ton about Parc’s history from Dealers of Lightning. I’d also point out that Bob Taylor apparently had a hard limit of 50 researchers because he felt that was all he could manage. This meant that he, by this criteria, had to get the absolute best, smartest scientists / researchers he could find. If you look at the sheer number of absolutely brilliant people assembled at Parc during the same time period, it is astonishing: Alan Kay (smalltalk), Butler Lampson (alto, *), Bob Metcalf (ethernet), the founders of Adobe (postscript), Charles Simonyi (bravo which later became Microsoft Word), etc. Close to 100% of modern computing directly came from Parc.
- peterburkimsher 10y agoThe article itself is by Alan Kay, and lists Butler Lampson, as well as Bob Taylor and Chuck Thacker by name.
- techrich 10y agoI second this, if any youngsters out there want to learn some computer history. This is a great place to start.
- EdwardCoffin 10y agoThis might be relevant: in the AMA that he did less than a year ago [1], Alan Kay said [2]: > "Dealers of Lightning" is not the best book to read (try Mitchell Waldrop's "The Dream Machine"). That said, I have read Dealers of Lightning myself, and really liked it. I have not yet got around to The Dream Machine. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11939851 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11939851 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11940756 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11940756
- _pmf_ 10y agoI'll say it: Microsoft. They have a lot of research stuff that never makes it onto (mass) products. It's atrange that Apple does not publish its internal research projects; maybe they are more focused on actual direct applicability, which is decidedly un-PARC like.
- jon-wood 10y agoI feel like Apple's culture is one of extreme secrecy even where its counterproductive or unnecessary. I once worked at an ad agency who did a lot of work with Apple and it was ridiculous. People working on banner ads for artists to be shown in iTunes had to go and sit in a windowless office behind a card lock. This wasn't highly secret stuff, this was stuff like "You can buy the new Coldplay album on iTunes".
- GrumpyNl 10y agoThey did great groundwork for Apple, they monetized on it while Xerox was left behind empty handed.
- Stranger43 10y agoIt's probably not anywhere in america. Szhenzen is pretty close to being the global center of hardware innovation and getting into software in a climate where state funding and commercial enterprise is merged in a way california havent seen since the rise of modern liberatarian economics in the 80ies. The birthplace of the web at CERN is also still in play as a center where lots of things happens. And thats before we head into the fringes where the oil exploration industry is leading in VR research almost as an afterthought of having to process and visualize the kind of big data most big data start ups only dreams about being able to handle. Remember that Xerox wasn't an IT company but a printing/photocopier copier so it's just as reasonable to expect that the next big leap will come from someone that is not currently seen as an IT giant, as to go looking within the Californian IT industry.
- tellarin 10y agoThe Shenzhen model is really nothing anywhere close to Xerox PARC. If any place gets close, I'd say it's Microsoft Research. But even that has changed a lot in the last few years. Disclaimer: I work there.
- coldtea 10y ago>What made Xerox PARC special? All expenses paid, pure but pragmatic research without having to rush to market and add buzzwords and marketing-inspired crap. Oh, and no compartmentalization between teams and narrow-focused projects either. >Who else today is like them? Nobody. Google research labs for example is more like a "throw something out there as a marketing gimmick to show we do 'innovation', and see if it sticks" affair.
- cpr 10y agoI can vouch for the "fund people, not projects" aspect of ARPA funding in the early 70's. I was a lowly undergrad but working with Tom Cheatham (who ran the grad Harvard Center for Research in Computing Technology) and others, and helping in minor ways with their annual ARPA proposal. ARPA pretty much was sending money our way, and we just had to cast the annual work in terms of what was "hot" at the time (mostly "program understanding" at Harvard) to get the funds.
- mseebach 10y ago"Who else today is like them?" I don't know, but for sure, they're not in computing. PARC was special, among many other reasons, because it existed (and had the vision and the funding) in the early, gold rush era of computing. Google Research isn't it, not because they're not generously funding important and worthy research, but because computing as a field is too far along for them to have a chance of introducing truly fundamental research in the area. Self-driving cars comes close, no doubt hugely important, but even they have a quite incremental feel to them, especially next to inventing something like the graphical user interface.
- United857 10y agoI'd say quantum computing is still in a very early stage with many unsolved problems, especially on the implementation side.
- wonderous 10y agoOrganization succeed when people understand and believe in WHY they do what they do and how. PARC's mission was to "create the architecture of information" in a way that enabled strategic business growth. In hind sight, it's obvious how important this was, but back then, it was just a belief, and one that turned out to be adopted in mass. If you want to be like PARC, understand WHY you do what you do and how in a way that makes sense strategically for the organization, it's members, and those it impacts.
- jtraffic 10y agoA desire to recreate great things from the past always comes with some hindsight bias. What we'd like is a dataset about hundreds of labs like PARC and what happened to them. Of course, we could never get it, so we have to work with our observed history. But sometimes, in the case of these big labs, I wonder how much we can conclude. I recently read The Idea Factory, about Bell Labs, and it has great insights, to be sure, but enough information about the causality to recreate Bell Labs? I don't know. Maybe it really does come down to one thing, like funding, as the top comment (currently) on this thread suggests. But I doubt it. When I was younger, my siblings and I played this game that we sort of made up as we went (too detailed to explain), and it was awesome. Years later, in a bout of nostalgia, we tried to recreate it and it was just awful. Enough small details had changed that it didn't work. One of the important details that changed was a total lack of spontaneity. All of us knew what the outcome should be like, and it made us behave differently. I don't think big orgs are at all immune from this effect of expectations. Don't get me wrong, I'm obsessed with the famous labs like anyone, a big fan of Alan Kay, etc. I just think somebody needs to call attention to a giant hurdle in learning from them.
- azeirah 10y agoThere's another lab that was successful in a somewhat similar manner, a way larger scale, but still great results. I recently bought a book on the Philips Natlab, same idea as Xerox PARC. They invented the optical drive (cd's), the wafersteppers that bootstrapped ASML, the company behind the machines that create chips and some other inventions that I can't find right now. I have more details in the Natlab book which I have at home, if you're (or anyone else is..) interested.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 10y agoBob Taylor made it that way.
- derstander 10y agoI was working as my department's internal R&D director a couple years ago and I was interested in the first question as well. Note that that position probably sounds way more important than it actually was. Coincidentally, it was at one of the places Alan Kay mentions in an answer to the linked Quora question. I pretty much focused on 3 different entities: DARPA, Xerox PARC, and Bell Labs. These are the books I read to try to answer that question: [1] Dealers of Lightning. https://www.amazon.com/Dealers-Lightning-Xerox-PARC-Computer/dp/0887309895 https://www.amazon.com/Dealers-Lightning-Xerox-PARC-Computer... [2] The Department of Mad Scientists. https://www.amazon.com/Department-Mad-Scientists-Remaking-Artificial/dp/0062000659 https://www.amazon.com/Department-Mad-Scientists-Remaking-Ar... [3] The Idea Factory. https://www.amazon.com/Idea-Factory-Great-American-Innovation/dp/0143122797 https://www.amazon.com/Idea-Factory-Great-American-Innovatio... I personally thought that having access to a diverse set of disciplines & skills and a reasonable budget were two of the more important things.
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y agoI've always wondered what enabled Xerox PARC to 'succeed' and Interval Research to languish. PARC was developed more or less organically where IR was an intentional construction. To me, that contrast is a proxy for other regions attempting to re-create Silicon Valley. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interval_Research_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interval_Research_Corporation
- 77ko 10y agoZzz, suuwuuuojuuusujuuojoljllujluo ass wasàhhhhhl