18 ms·
The Shamanic View of Mental Illness (2010)
- apeace 10y agoApologies if I'm missing something--what is this doing in the front page of HN? This person claims he can see spirits perturbing the mentally ill. He claims he has the cure for schizophrenia. What kind of science or unbiased analysis is going on here that is OT for HN?
- metaphorm 10y agoyou're absolutely sure that there are no spirits?
- apeace 10y agoWhat would move my needle is reproducible results, i.e. science. For example, have a shaman go into a room and describe the spirit he sees. Then have another shaman go into the room, and see if his description matches. Or, write about how many schizophrenic people this shaman has actually cured. Interview the patients, do a profile of their lives before and after, and explain the process that was used. While this article is interesting from a cultural perspective, I still don't see how it is OT for HN.
- metaphorm 10y agoa psychiatrist goes into a room with a patient, has a brief conversation with him and then comes out and says "I see schizophrenia." a second psychiatrist goes in and has a conversation with the same patient and says "yes I concur, I see schizophrenia." what did they see?
- mikelyons 10y agowatch out for dogmatic belief in science and unbiased analysis. Check out the mechanics of belief
- thescribe 10y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary proof. Barring that I will send you an immortality potion that keeps the grim reaper away.
- smohare 10y agoYou can always spot someone who has near zero comprehension of science as soon as they speak about "belief in science".
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoCan you, personally, demonstrate that the atomic theory of matter is accurate? Maybe you can, I dunno, but most of us can't. We've had it explained in a way that makes at least superficial sense, but we don't grasp it on a deep level. Yet we accept it as true. We trust that the people who really did the research knew what they were doing. We believe it. What would you call that?
- eveningcoffee 10y agoThe difference is that if you really wanted, you could.
- sideshowb 10y agoCareful. For sure, Science, unlike dogma, prides itself on changing belief in the face of conflicting evidence. In theory, anyway. In practice, I have a PhD in Computer Science and Geography. Do I understand climate models? No, they're not my field. Do I have the time to verify them? Certainly not. How do I know then that the field of climate science is getting it right? I have to trust the institutional process, which as Kuhn points out is far from perfect. If they're getting it wrong, it's not likely to be me that figures it out, so for the time being the rational course of action is to accept the consensus of experts. tldr; belief in science. Though cynically speaking you're right, people who trot out that phrase usually don't understand the above.
- mikelyons 10y ago
- mcphilip 10y agoI found the shaman's perspective fascinating from an evolutionary psychological point of view. Cultures have had to decide how to treat the mentally ill long before science was around to try and explain it. The shaman's perspective also had some interesting food for thought about the implications of western society's lack of ritual for the right of passage into adulthood.
- gosheroo 10y ago'Spiritual emergency' and 'mental illness' are both pretty weird concepts. The latter, for instance, is a bit like attributing software bugs to hardware faults, isn't it?
- wu-ikkyu 10y agoWhat you might be missing is the fact that the condition and diagnosis of schizophrenia is completely subjective; meaning there is no objective science surrounding schizophrenia and many other such conditions (i.e. depression, bipolar).
- cmrx64 10y agoThat's one way to look at the world I guess.
- zepto 10y agoHaving more than one way to look at the world is important.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoIt's essential: there's a reason we have physics, chemistry, biology, neurology, psychology, and sociology. (There are other similar chains of approximations.) Each provides a tractably computable approximation to a scale that the preceding ones can't be worked through at, while also discovering emergent properties that manifest at that scale. There's no reason to think that our dominant paradigms in any of those fields are the only sensible way to approximate the underlying phenomena, and other (radically different) models might be able to express features present models struggle with.
- smohare 10y agoNo evidence? Except for the vast predictive and explanatory power of science over magical thinking? Please, go ahead and list some major contributions to humanity of the latter.
- c22 10y agoWell, among other things, it gave us science.
- smohare 10y agoNo evidence? Except for the vast predictive and explanatory power of science over magical thinking? Please, go ahead and list some major contributions to humanity of the latter.
- ouid 10y agoWhy?
- mentalprivacy 10y agoThis is a pretty interesting perspective. I'm someone who was 'diagnosed' with severe depression not that long ago. Treatment in the USA is drugs and talk therapy, but this is an interesting perspective. Maybe depression is a call from a higher being to wake up in your life and make big changes on your path, to adopt a different mindshift. That could be evolutionary adaptive, and it's more inspiring than the medical communities approaches.
- throwaway2048 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Night_of_the_Soul https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Night_of_the_Soul https://rightabsorption.wordpress.com/2009/02/21/dark-night-of-the-soul/ https://rightabsorption.wordpress.com/2009/02/21/dark-night-...
- robotresearcher 10y ago> Maybe depression is a call from a higher being What's the more likely explanation: (1) various different conditions including depression and psychosis are calls from a higher being, not thus far sensible to science; or (2) the brain, a vastly complex organ with significant structure and dynamics, grown out of meat from a tiny unique egg and trained over decades of unique experience, works a bit differently to the norm in some people, in ways that can be distressing. Occam's Razor is tingling.
- pmoriarty 10y agoThis reminds me of a story by Wynette Barton: "When my son was four or five years old, he asked one of those interminable questions that children ask: 'Why does the sky get dark at night?' "Eager to increase his understanding, I put a lamp in the middle of the floor to act as the sun, got down the world globe, and used a tennis ball for the moon. Then I walked around the "sun", carrying the globe and turning it, explaining how we are suspended in space, constantly moving. It was the universe in a nutshell - sun, earth, moon, stars, seasons. "My son watched the production with silent, squint-eyed attention. When I finished, he said to me, 'You don't expect me to believe that, do you?'" For a lot of people, the supernatural explanation is the simpler explanation. The so-called "scientific" (or more properly Scientistic[1] or maybe Naturalistic[2]) world view rests on explanation after explanation that takes years and years of education to even understand, much less accept. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientism [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalism_%28philosophy%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalism_%28philosophy%29
- findateamfirst 10y agoI went through a pretty intense major depressive episode (6 months not getting out of bed) plus chronic dissociation and depression. End to end from the onset of the episode to reaching a point where I feel I'm "fully actualized" took 6 years. During that process I went from being one of the angriest and most unpleasant people to being very happy with many close relationships, and a clear sense of purpose. My mental health crisis was absolutely a wake up call. It lead me to make significant structural changes to my approach to phenomenology, aesthetics, morality, and epistemology. I totally restructured my moment to moment experience of existence.
- bordercases 10y agoAmen my brother. Phenomenology and aesthetics is great medicine. We need to find greater purpose beyond just optimizing for/against pleasure pain. EDIT: Or are you a sister?
- kome 10y agoVery well put, thank you for sharing your experience. Often O feel that depression in an "healthy" reaction to something wrong: there are good reasons to be depressed.
- bttf 10y agoWhat were some resources that put you on the path to recovery?
- mikelyons 10y agoHow did you do this? I spend almost every waking moment fantasizing about ending my life
- cat199 10y agowow.. Don't want to give any real advice here other than talk to someone! - that sounds very scary. will keep ya in mind..
- oheard 10y agoThe key thing is to realise that YOU control your thoughts. We're creatures of habits. YOU choose what to think whether you realise it or not. Something within you associates the feeling of "depression" with reward. Actively review your history, your relationships, patterns of behaviour. Look at your own thought processes critically, document them, decide how you want to think instead, and force yourself to think in the new way. You control not just what you think but how you feel. You can feel how you want to feel. That's the key. Once you decide or are told you're "depressed" you "accept" that you have an "illness" and internalise it. Stop doing that shit. Ignore those bastards. Change how you think. This is basically CBT. You have to actively control your thought processes to change them to something you want. Once you've done that for a while it becomes the new default. Don't allow yourself to think things that don't help you. When you start fantasising about death, don't let yourself think about it. Force yourself to make plans for the next few days or something instead. When you think "I don't have the energy/motivation to make plans because I'm 'depressed'", tell yourself, "I'm not allowed to think that, instead I'm going to MAKE THE FUCKING PLANS". Fuck all that bullshit about "chemical imbalances". You know what that means? It means your brain is wired wrong. Those chemicals? The sames ones everyone else has. Wanna know what the imbalance is? YOU LEARNED TO BEHAVE IN THE WRONG WAY, SO YOUR WIRING IS ALL FUCKED UP. Those neurotransmitters are going exactly where they've learnt to go. YOU have to retrain your brain. Fuck everything people have told you about being "mentally ill". Recognise your brain as a learning machine and TEACH THAT MOTHER FUCKER HOW TO BEHAVE. Life sucks? You either learn how to change it or learn how to change what you think about it. You think those poor mother fuckers in third world countries with just enough food to eat who save up for years to buy a BICYCLE are depressed? FUCK NO THAT MOTHER FUCKER GOT HIS BICYCLE. He's 40 years old, barely feeding his family, but he's got a smile so wide he lights up every mother fucking heart in his village. You know WHY? Because he doesn't think about why things are shit. He thinks about why things are SHIT HOT. MOTHER FUCKING BIKE HAS A BELL CHECK THAT SHIT OUT. YOU define your reality. YOU define how you perceive the world. With a great deal of influence from those around you. Surrounded by mother fuckers who are "depressed"? Get the fuck away from them. Find happy people. Catch their disease instead. Control your thoughts, control your environment, discipline your brain to only allow you to think things that help you. Fuck everything else. That's how you cure depression. You control what you think by understanding why you think what you think right now and throwing away the bad shit and keeping the good shit. Do yourself a favour. Next time you think "I should be dead". Think "lol brain you're not allowed to think that shit anymore", SMILE and write down some shit you're grateful for. Call your friends/family and chat about some good shit that went down in the past. Think about the people who have done good shit for you over the years, and how happy it makes you that those mother fuckers exist. Think of the mother fucker who you're most grateful for. Why do you like them so much? How did they make you feel? GOOD. Now go make other people feel like that. Be happy. Make other people happy. Feed on their happiness. "But I want to die". Shut the fuck up brain you're not allowed to think that. Hey brain, remember that fucking awesome ice cream we ate last week? Yeah that was some good shit. I should show someone that ice cream, they'll like that shit. Remember that kid we used to hang out with when we were kids? Wonder what he's doing with his life now. We laughed our fucking cocks off at such and such. What a good memory. What's that brain, feels good? Yeah, yeah it does feel fucking good. That's why you're gonna think good shit from now on brain. BECAUSE IT FEELS GOOD. Fuck. Think good stuff. Don't allow yourself to think bad stuff. Make it a habit. Eventually you stop thinking bad stuff. Make plans. Make people happy. Feed on happiness. Think of good memories. No good memories? Go fucking make some. Then think about them. Fuck depression. Ain't nobody got time for that. Here have a hug. They're free. Pass it on. Have a smile too these fuckers are great. :-D Okay I'm done.
- skilled 10y agoNice to see something like this on HN.
- simplexion 10y agoI'm thinking the exact opposite.
- ghusbands 10y agoAs food for thought about how we treat the mentally ill, it is quite interesting. Hopefully, nobody will go away believing the nonsense about spirits attaching to people, but the manner in which they give the depressed a role to grow into and an external reason for their suffering could really help some. The alternative "you are internally broken" message from modern science can be unpleasant, even if it's true.
- boomboomsubban 10y agoFrom my experience, it sounds like they're pinning the cause of the illness on their ancestors, allowing the mind to get past the fear that fixing the problem involves a destruction of yourself. Conventional psychology tries to do something similar by saying these problems are a chemical imbalance or a dysfunction of the brain, but both of those are hard for a person dealing with the illness to separate from "your mind or yourself is wrong." This is a terrifying idea that only gets worse when an illness goes untreated for long periods. When the only life you remember is depressed, if you work towards fixing it you find the things you like, the friends you've made, and the life you've built will pull you back towards depression. This overcomes all of that by putting you in a new situation and setting a new path for your life. The causes they claim seem silly to me, it's not far away from "of course you have cancer you unrepentant sinner," but some aspects of their treatment methods seem helpful.
- armitron 10y agoThis process has been known for thousands of years in the west and falls under the term "Initiation" (1), when it is deliberately induced and not as a result of trauma or other pathological causes. In modern terms, it can be described as mind reprogramming. Moreover, in my view, all of the useful techniques for inducing and successfully guiding such a process, come out of the western mystical tradition and include tools such as the Tarot and the Hermetic Qabala. The modern non-mystical paradigms (psychology, new age spirituality and religion) and various disparate shamanic systems are lacking too much in terms of understanding and are thus too imprecise and even dangerous if taken too far. (1) http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=716ACCF7F16455CD2EED7DA72AE0DD96 http://gen.lib.rus.ec/book/index.php?md5=716ACCF7F16455CD2EE...
- pmoriarty 10y agoIt's really debatable how much understanding mystical, magical, shamanistic, religious, or occult traditions have themselves. You'll note first of all that many of them disagree with one another as to what is really going on in the world. Is it spirits that are controlling what happens in the world, or is it ghosts, or ancestor, or God, or gods, or demons, or what? It's any or all of them or none of them, depending on which mystic, magician, Kabbalist, or shaman you ask. If they had some kind of understanding of what was going on, you'd think they could at least agree on the baseline of what was happening, but they don't. Next, it's quite possible to be effective while being mistaken about the nature of the underlying phenomenon or the mechanism (figuratively speaking) at work. There's a great Radiolab episode on placebos that has a number of very entertaining examples on this front.[1] Finally, history has shown that human fallibility and potential for self-deception is vast if not unlimited, and the potential for abuse of controlling the narrative around the nature of the world is great. I'd be very wary of anointing any world view as the one that has the secret key to understanding. [1] - http://www.radiolab.org/story/91539-placebo/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/91539-placebo/
- armitron 10y agoIt's not the worldview or the underlying philosophy that's important, but the techniques themselves. And when it comes to the techniques, the western esoteric tradition is without equal. Moreover, in many cases, the techniques have been obscured behind layers and layers of metaphysics (occult knowledge) and a superficial examination of the material will quickly lead one to reject it. Which is why traditionally, such knowledge was passed down in chains of transmission through teacher-student relationships. These days, most of that knowledge is no longer occult ("hidden") but it's been obscured by vast amounts of garbage, a lot of it falling under the so called new age/wicca/esoteric psychology categories.
- interfixus 10y agoI have consulted the HN guidelines to find a polite way of saying this. Best I can come up with is "What an utter load of superstitious crap". Purely anecdotal, of course, but everything I have ever seen confirms a very clear positive correlation between mental illness and all sorts of dabbling in various squishy 'spiritual' matters. I don't know which way the influence goes, but suspect both, really. The strong version: I believe that if you encounter serious mental health issues, and you start seeking cure in this strange mumbo jumbo alt.reality, you will very likely never get well again. [Typos edited]
- peteretep 10y agoI was going to reply less politely too and ask if we'd have a similar tolerance for "The homeopathic view of oncology"
- jacobolus 10y agoIf you ignore all of the “superstitious crap”, what you end up with is: people experiencing mental illness in this tribe are treated with kindness and respect, told that they are experiencing something important and special and helped through their recovery by a patient and sensitive guide, instead of being told they are broken and thrown into a jail-like setting where they are treated with drugs that have severe side effects.
- reddytowns 10y agoIn other words, religion trumps modern medicine for mental illness. I agree, but I don't see this tribe's beliefs having a special status or better probability of success above any other religion.
- Nekorosu 10y agoThere isn't much of a difference between religion and psychology (I'm talking about applied one, psychotherapy). As far as I remember the only method coming from evidence-based medicine approach is CBT. Everything else is based on anecdotal evidence. The problem of the article is that it ignores physiology which is evidently related to mental illnesses. A lot of illnesses have genetic factor. I actually don't like calling inherited conditions illnesses. And I'm talking about anything including diabetes. You can't get sick with bi-polar disorder or diabetes. They're given from birth. You can't be completely cured and have to maintain yourself with medications for the rest of your life.
- _pmf_ 10y agoI honestly believe that (at least for the siberian variant of shamanism) a) conceptually, this is not very far from modern psychotherapy and b) the implementation is more straight forward than the instruments of modern psychotherapy and c) this article is pretty much bullshit
- edem 10y agoSo where is the proof that this is not just some mumbo jumbo?
- k__ 10y agoOh lord, this site looks like one giant click-bait
- Nekorosu 10y agoThis isn't a complete bullshit. I have had similar experience. My problem is I've been having this kind of experience every several years including long depression phase with some breakthrough in the end of it with "I'm smart and feel high" phase next. I absolutely had some real breakthroughs both spiritual and psychological (I was visiting a shrink) but in the end the cycle was there. Finally I've got help from a professional physician and psychiatrist (not the same person) and now I'm taking pills to treat my inherited hypothyroidism and Type 2 Bipolar Disorder. The only thing left is to find a good shrink (probably CBT) 'cause living with untreated BPD for a long time leaves your mind in a overshadowed state with a lot of negative self-believes and harmful mental habits.
- johnchristopher 10y ago> That what we sometimes call depression, bi-polar, psychosis, schizophrenia, might actually be a significant transformation in consciousness and a necessary stage on the path of human development. Right. You'll tell that to the guy who put me on a police watch list and cost me a job opportunity because he reported me (and two other persons) for computer fraud and illegal access to his computers. Because he thought he had seen photographies of his sister's wedding on my computer screen. And I was hand in hand with koreans forcing him to sleep so they can launch missiles over Japan. /anger tldr; Nope, mental illness such as bpd, schiz., etc., are illnesses that have real consequences.
- metaphorm 10y agowhat you said is a total non-sequitur. the antisocial behavior of the person who harassed you is a result of poorly treated mental health issue. to use the shamanic model, this would be a person who has not been properly guided through a spiritual transformation and therefore is living in a state of painful unintegrated delusional paranoia. a shaman's job would be to help them complete that transformation and cease their antisocial behavior.
- johnchristopher 10y ago> the antisocial behavior of the person who harassed you is a result of poorly treated mental health issue Exactly. It's not a significant transformation in consciousness and a necessary stage on the path of human development.
- metaphorm 10y agoI don't see the difference. What is mental health treatment besides "significant transformation in consciousness"?
- johnchristopher 10y agoWhat is sleeping besides "significant transformation in consciousness" ? Seriously, « That what we sometimes [0] call depression, bi-polar, psychosis, schizophrenia, might actually be a significant transformation in consciousness and a necessary stage on the path of human development [1]. » is loaded with so much personal development and alternative medicine red flags I am not surprised the only way to defend it is already to start a word definition war. [0] derogatory wording. Emphasis is mine [1] are we referring to « humanity » or to that « individual » ? The whole sentence reads like it's the former approach.
- zyxzevn 10y agoAs someone who can work with both worlds, I am already helping some psychiatric patients (together with certified professionals). I help them first with some simple meditations: it really helps them to learn to focus. Focus on the body and emotions. Often their thinking has run wild and that causes them to overstress and think unclearly. By just breathing and if possible, feeling they can get their senses back slowly. It already helps with people that have a light psychosis. The spirits, as I perceive them, are often in a psychosis themselves. Others are in a huge depression, or in an extreme panic. They can feel like a cloud enveloping the mind. It draws us into their world, if we are not grounded well. That is why people that are close together can get into the same psychiatric problem. People often call these spirits the "negative voice" or inner demon. But it is a bit more complex than that. Spirits are part of the consciousness of people that have died, and have not returned to their source. They lost contact with themselves, and with reality. They identify themselves with anything that they can attach themselves to. So when you are very stressed due to work or life, it can happen that a spirit joins your experience and identifies itself with you. And suddenly you "lose your mind". In deeper stages this can lead to depression or psychosis or other psychiatric problems. https://imgur.com/gallery/SOS4E https://imgur.com/gallery/SOS4E By removing the spirits, a person can recover his/her own mind. I have often spoken with people in total panic and seen them calm down in a few minutes after removing the spirits. Depression and psychosis take a bit longer, because there are more factors involved. But there have been some improvements. In scientific sense it all seems impossible, since we have no models for spirits or consciousness or whatever. I am working on that on http://www.reddit.com/r/paradigmchange http://www.reddit.com/r/paradigmchange Medicine can help to slow everything down, but does not magically remove the psychosis or depression. It makes it less active. Modern medicine works by slowing down so much that most stress can go away, after which the patient can recover. Sadly that means that the patient can sometimes fall back into the same psychosis or depression if the medicine is stopped or when it has grown less effective. To heal better, it is always good to learn to meditate and regain control over your own mind. Mindfulness can already be effective. Enjoying some peace in nature works very well too.
- alphapapa 10y ago> Spirits are part of the consciousness of people that have died, and have not returned to their source. They lost contact with themselves, and with reality. They identify themselves with anything that they can attach themselves to. So when you are very stressed due to work or life, it can happen that a spirit joins your experience and identifies itself with you. Upon what do you base this claim?
- dmitrybrant 10y agoAt least he's not selling anyth... oh, wait....
- kerkeslager 10y agoI'm an atheist and don't believe in spirits, but when I came across a viewpoint similar to this a few years ago it really changed how I empathize with people. I really don't agree with how widely we apply the disease model when thinking of human behaviors. Some people are mentally ill, but the world we live in is more certainly ill. The expected arc of a life in the Western world is that you spend your healthy years working on other people's goals so you can spend the last few years of your life doing what you want with what resources you've amassed and what health you have remaining. We wage wars and torture, reward greed, deny each other healthcare, homes, food, our leaders are cartoon villains. If we manage to find love, it is discriminated against unless it fits into a narrow set of parameters. If we are unlucky, we are born, starve for a few years, and then die of preventable, curable disease. Happy participation in this society is not rational. As Krishnamurti said, "It is no measure of health to be well-adjusted to a sick society." I have been lucky in the opportunities that I have had available to me, but it's not hard for me to conceive of situations where the rational choice is to drink oneself to death. Life is unkind to many people. The ideal solution is to fix all of the world's ills, but obviously that isn't realistic, at least not in our lifetimes. We can make progress, but help will arrive too late for many. I can empathize with those who choose to say that the individual is sick, rather than the world, because the individual is easier to change. But it's simply not true in some cases. Instead of telling someone, "Something is wrong with you, let's fix it," we should often be telling them, "You're right, there's a lot wrong with your life and the world, and much of that can't be changed; let's see if we can find a way to find you some contentment despite that." To be very clear: some people are mentally ill. Individuals can be ill AND the world's can be ill. The two are not mutually exclusive.
- Jhsto 10y agoI had a case where I had a mental disorder but eventually, I found out that much of it was me being afraid of how the society will accept it. I personally thought I had a self-caused mental illness because of a psychotic episode from drug abuse. Drug abuse having a huge stigma in my country, I was afraid to seek mental health help because both my relatives and a firsthand experience with a GP were negative experiences. To me, it seemed like everyone I talked to condemned my behavior. The condemnation was so bad that the advice I received was just to avoid drugs and to not talk about the use to anyone. When I asked a GP to prescribe drugs to me which I thought would be helpful in my situation, I was basically told that as I just admitted drug abuse that would not work. Eventually, I sought mental health help (to get the drugs I sought from GP) where I was being treated from the article's perspective. I was told that instead of a mental illness, I seem to have a PTSD and the way I am having delusions is a natural behavior. I also got some drugs, not the ones I wanted, but the ones I actually needed. Either way, I finally found an authority that accepted me and my situation. Surely enough, all my symptoms disappeared within days the appointment. The experience showed me how fine line there is in mental health and how much the outside world can affect the image of yourself.
- thisisforyou 10y agoI'm pretty ashamed to see this sort of stuff making the front page of HN. If an argument for a similarly archaic and backwards explanation was posted about some other topic (this sort of stuff is on par with heliocentrism, creationism and homeopathy, at best) it would be ignored, but for some reason (it's hard for me to pin down exactly, but perhaps because it has to do with mental illness?) it is given a free pass.
- _pgmf 10y agoThank you for your comment. It's a shame. Only the most ignorant or naive reader could believe this garbage. My youngest brother was diagnosed with schizophrenia a decade ago. I've watched him cycle through horrible psychotic episodes for years until he gained insight into his illness and agreed to start taking medicine. It's only since then that he's been freed from the voices that tormented him, and the paranoid delusions he would obsess over. He would tell you that there's nothing spiritual about the symptoms of his illness. I'd also note that the guy who posted this also recently posted an article on LSD micro-dosing. Tells you a bit about where he's coming from...
- metaphorm 10y agodo you know for certain that LSD micro-dosing has no merit? there are significant indicators that it might have quite a lot of merit.
- mr_overalls 10y agoI agree. While there are certainly some improvements to be made to the way mental health care is delivered in modern societies (not to mention living a balanced lifestyle amidst work stress, ever-present social media, etc.), reverting to a pre-scientific world-view full of evil spirits isn't the answer.
- wu-ikkyu 10y agoMetaphysics aside, which model for dealing with mental illness do you think would have the least adverse effects on one's fragile mental state? 1) a model which stigmatizes you for life and rejects you as a functioning member of society and has the supra legal power to subject you to a vast array of human rights abuses including but not limited to: indefinite detention, solitary confinement, sleep deprivation, forced drugging, and other forms of psychological torture[1]. 2) a model which accepts and respects you as a member of society [1]https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/29gr27/redditors_who_were_involuntarily_admitted_to/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/29gr27/redditors...
- _wwz4 10y agoSome other questions that may be more relevant: * Which model is more likely to prevent someone with mental illness from harming himself or others because of incorrect diagnosis? * Which model is more likely to lead to scientifically sound treatments for his malady? * Which model is more likely to encourage people to generally think rationally about the real world around us? Science isn't embraced because it's always right and every impact of its rational-based methodology doesn't have any losers anywhere. The shaman and the priest and the holistic healer all tend to be on the losing end of the argument when Science is given primacy. The tradeoffs of Science vs everything else have proven to be worth it over and over.
- wu-ikkyu 10y agoBy science, do you mean objectively observable/testable inquiry and analysis? Because that's not what psychiatry is. Medical pathology is an objective science, but psychiatry is subjective conjecture, generously classified as a "soft science". >The tradeoffs of Science vs everything else have proven to be worth it over and over. I hate to invoke Godwin's law here but it is worth noting the key role "science" and psychiatry played in propagating the Holocaust[1]. If we're going to play the science card, we should make sure it's objective. [1]https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23511221 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23511221 Edit: curious you spell Science with a capital "S"
- shipman05 10y agoNext up on HN, "Practical Guide for Casting Out Demons and Drowning Swine"
- falcolas 10y ago/angry Tell me, how does dementia lead to the birth of a healer? How does someone regressing mentally, with their ability to communicate being completely lost, with their behaviors becoming more and more childlike to the point where they can't even feed themselves, how does that signify becoming a healer? The only blessing in watching my grandmother's decline like this is that it was swift. Six months of hell, of watching someone you love becoming frustrated at their inability to communicate even the most basic thing. Of watching them forget how to take basic care of themselves. Of watching a simple door lock with the code printed right above it being sufficient to keep them from using that door. Of watching them play with a child's woodworking set because they no longer know the difference between that and the beautiful works they used to make with wood. Fuck this shit. Birth of a healer my ass.
- jonas_b 10y agoChill out, dementia is something very different from schizophrenia.
- falcolas 10y agoIt's a mental illness, and while the article focuses on schizophrenia (and depression), they generalize it to all mental illnesses. I'd be a bit less angry if they hadn't generalized it like that. A bit: how many "healers" have been lost to their visions, or to their depression? I have a feeling they'd simply sweep that under the rug as a natural consequence of seeing the spirits that others can not.
- theoh 10y agoThe best way to look at it is a corrective to the harmful pathologization of unusual mental states by psychiatry. Yes, the new-agey claims are not really plausible. But mental illness is less prevalent in traditional societies where it is understood in a more nuanced way. AFAIK dementia patients don't generally get involved in the oppressive and demeaning psychiatric system. It's a horrible business. It is important to listen to the experiences of the "neurodiverse" to understand how we need to make life better for them. It's true that schizophrenia is generally a disaster that destroys the life of the sufferer and the people around them. What needs to be more widely recognized is the psychosocial aspect of illnesses like schizophrenia, e.g. the extent to which they are caused by toxic families and/or social circumstances. This is where "healing" becomes relevant: a psychotic problem can be an opportunity to change and escape from a toxic situation. Of course, it often has the opposite effect, when the patient is pathologized, medicated, and told that they are the problem.
- blhack 10y agoHere's the medical view on depression: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NOAgplgTxfc Robert Sapolsky is a genius. Listen to this lecture, please.
- dubaithrowaway 10y agoedit: this was a low-quality post that I should have made. Sorry. If you are suffering from depression, please seek medical help.
- metaphorm 10y agowhich yoga teachers have promoted anti-vaccination? did you encounter that somewhere or are you making up strawmen to lash out against?
- dubaithrowaway 10y agoYou're right. It was a strawman. I'm sorry.
- FailMore 10y agoHi sir, I'm afraid that I must respectfully disagree with you. I'm not sure if you have suffered from depression, but I have. And I have been fortunate enough to systematically work through it with therapy. I know that the cause of the depression was not a chemical imbalance my brain, with all other aspects of my life being fine - but was in fact directly related to my own beliefs about myself and the world that we live in, and how these beliefs were impeding my actions and the set of actions I believed were available to me. While I think the underlying ideas behind the article are not correct (the mountains were not speaking to me at least!), I am firmly of the belief that the pain of depression is a great driver for self-exploration which is done best in a kind environment. Pills that kill the senses are not the solution your mind is asking for. If you have not had depression, or if you have it and have not overcome it, then I think you should do some user research by talking to people that have both had it and moved through it. If you have not done this then I think you should hold onto your current opinions loosely. J
- youdontknowtho 10y agoI'm all for taking a fresh look at our basic assumptions, but..."seeing entities" around the patients? Do what now?
- sixstringtheory 10y agoThe best part of moving the discussion to a nonfalsifiable premise is that your assertions can never be "proven" wrong. This stuff is interesting to think about, but I find it lacking substance to explain reality with any sort of consensus.
- metaphorm 10y ago"explain reality" seems like it is not at all the objective of the Shaman, or even of a Western mental health worker (psychiatrist, for example). the objective is to help a suffering person. the measure of success or failure is whether or not the person is suffering more or suffering less. even within the positivist worldview you are advocating it is wise to consider that there are, in fact, non-falsifiable premises underlying some of our most important tools. mathematics requires axioms. the standard model of physics requires non-falsifiable assumptions about initial conditions. there is no escaping this. not everything is falsifiable.
- sixstringtheory 10y agoWe must first understand the reality of a problem before we can begin to address it. Redefining "suffering" and "mental illness" to be completely fluid ideas that depend on who you ask moves us farther from the objective of helping people, in my opinion. I don't think we can redefine "suffering" to be a state of spiritual exaltation and pat ourselves on the back for a job well done. You are excusing a departure from the progress we've made in understanding the human mind because: not everything is falsifiable, so may as well throw rigor out the window?
- metaphorm 10y ago> We must first understand the reality of a problem before we can begin to address it. I fundamentally disagree with this statement. But then, I'm just an engineer, not a real scientist.
- sixstringtheory 10y ago
- jaygaddis 10y agoHey guys Jayson Gaddis here. This post is on my blog. What's fascinating to me is how many people this post has struck a chord with. Clearly our culture's approach to mental illness if exceedingly limited. And, fortunately, there is growing research with psychedelics and "alternative" substances such as MDMA, Ibogaine, psilocybin, and even LSD as legitimate forms of healing PTSD, trauma, and various ailments people suffer from. I really appreciate everyone's comments here. Hundreds of thousands of people have read this post. 15,000 people have joined a private facebook group to share their stories. Wow. This post is 7 years old. Now I'm a relationship student and teacher and run The Smart Couple Podcast to help individuals and couples learn better tools and skills for long-term partnership. I also founded The Relationship School™ because I believe the source of so many of the world's problems are relational in nature. My aim is to eventually bring relationship education to teens and young adults everywhere. Thanks for reading and engaging guys! Respect, Jayson