5 ms·
Edit for folks having trouble understanding: the post you're replying to literally mentions two of the best tabbed terminals for Windows. That's not the problem
by nailer 10y ago
Edit for folks having trouble understanding: the post you're replying to literally mentions two of the best tabbed terminals for Windows. That's not the problem.
A fast, inbuilt, 2017-era terminal is.
- ConEmu has a UI that's a shotgun blast of shit.
- Hyper still fails at basic shortcuts.
- ConEmu plus other software still has a UI that's a shotgun blast of shit.
- Some person's half maintained fork of putty is some person's half maintained fork of putty and we already have Windows openssh for SSH purposes.
- A proprietary app you need to pay for is a proprietary app you need to pay for.
- tmux is not a tabbed terminal.
- Something that uses cygwin is something using cygwin.
The post is requesting a clean tabbed terminal, included in Windows, and maintained full time by Microsoft employees (whether Open Source or proprietary).
Edit: removed 'fully featured' as someone below thinks that means I want all the bullshit the other terminals add, rather than tabs, working escape sequences, and other terminal features.
- tjoff 10y agoConEmu has the best UI I've ever seen in a terminal. Way better than anything I've seen in *nix.
- nailer 10y agoI use ConEmu for 5 hours a day. it's the best terminal on Windows, but its UI is absolutely awful https://conemu.github.io/img/ConEmu-Maximus5.png https://conemu.github.io/img/ConEmu-Maximus5.png https://conemu.github.io/img/Settings-Main.png https://conemu.github.io/img/Settings-Main.png - Minimal contrast in active tabs - can't be fixed due to Windows XP support. - Flashes it's hidden console proxy on screen continually - Settings menu with around 5000 options and no sense of heirarchy - something that's rare is just as prominent as something that's common - Giant colorful icons and wasted space in the title bar. I can't throw my mouse to the top and pick a tab when it's maximised. - Freaks out when your console is too large - Does a bunch of things better done elsewhere: my profile bash/powershell profile sets environment variables, I don't need my terminal to do this.
- tjoff 10y ago1. I understand the developer, I don't see the issue (wouldn't mind it being configurable but if it is the only thing that breaks XP support I can understand it). 2. I've seen it, happens probably once a month for < 50 ms when resizing or something. I can deal with it. 3. This is awesome, you go through it once and have every detail exactly they way you want it just because everything was shown (contrast to being forced to read the entire manual just to know what you can do). Great for discoverability. Take 15 minutes, quickly test out different settings and looks, reap the benefits for years to come. 4. I've removed the titlebar altogether. No borders at all either - Just a tiny (half row) discrete status bar at the bottom. 5. No idea what you mean here, can't recall to have seen it freak out ever.
- nailer 10y ago1. Color contrast and it's ability to help users distinguish items from each other is a very well researched objective thing. Your personal experience doesn't overturn it as a concept, or make it easier for anyone else to find to find the active terminal. 2. That's great for you. My experience differs. 3. See 1, but for heirarchy. 4. Are sure you sure you can get the tabs all the way to the top? 5. See 2. I suspect I maximise the terminal more often or use a larger screen than you do.
- tjoff 10y ago1. I'm not arguing that it is. There are more cues than color contrast before taking into account your mental state. As said, I wouldn't mind it being configurable but I understand the reluctance to do it if it breaks XP support. 3. Yes, a perfect hierarchy of the settings would be nice, in theory. Because never mind that what is important depends on the user and context - making the whole concept extremely tricky to get right. It is a tradeoff. And I haven't seen any terminal and few other applications that I've enjoyed setting up as much as ConEmu, most settings are logically where they should be. There are, understandably considering the amount of options, a few places where it can be difficult - but to help with that there is a great search function. 4. I don't even have a tab bar anymore, takes up way too much space and I always switch between tabs using the keyboard (since I only interact with the terminal from the keyboard anyway). But I tested it now, there is about 2px of space above the tab bar but if you try to press that area you still hit the tab you intended. So if you have maximized the window there is no possible way to click above the tab bar. ConEmu is one of the most well polished applications I use on a daily basis, it doesn't get in the way. I miss it to death every time I'm using a non-windows machine.
- amyjess 10y agoIt would be nice if someone ported Konsole to Windows. A number of other KDE apps have already been ported, so hopefully it won't be too painful.
- Notre1 10y agoOut of curiosity, what tabbed terminals on other platforms would you consider to be significantly better than ConEmu/Hyper? (I've never actually used any GUI platform other than Windows for any length of time, so I would be interested in seeing what other people do use.)
- llimllib 10y agoiterm2 is far and away the best I've ever used. https://iterm2.com/ https://iterm2.com/
- nailer 10y agoiTerm2, GNOME terminal.
- jcurbo 10y agoiterm2 on OS X is really good, maybe the gold standard as far as I'm concerned.
- mikewhy 10y agoApple Terminal, iTerm, gnome-terminal, konsole. I can't really name one worse than ConEmu. ConEmu likes to do this cute thing where it stops accepting key presses. And with the all the options it has, "starting a new terminal in the directory of the previous" is nowhere to be found. But still, it's probably the best on Windows if you want tabs.
- bitcrazed 10y agoTo be fair to ConEmu, Cmder, Hyper, and all the other Windows terminals/consoles, we don't currently provide a way for them to truly become genuine consoles. We're working to fix that, but we have to clean things up a little first. Bear with us.
- felipelemos 10y agoAnd besides the iTerm2 on OSX that everyone here agrees it one of the best, Terminator on Linux does a good job too.
- ygra 10y ago> a clean, fully featured tabbed terminal, included in Windows You'd either get a Microsoft Word equivalent of a console window in that case, since everyone has a different set of features they consider essential, or the Notepad equivalent (more likely). A tool's value doesn't necessarily increase with more features and features are never cheap (in Windows, at least, where there are documentation, translation, configuration, group policy, and other concerns). Tabbed console windows exist as 3rd-party applications already, seemingly with minor problems for one user or another, but I'd argue those problems are easier to rectify than for MS to develop yet another alternative that people grumble about even more because it doesn't contain their own personal pet feature.
- nailer 10y ago> A tool's value doesn't necessarily increase with more features and features are never cheap What I mean when I write 'clean and fully featured' is: a console, tabs, a nice scroll buffer, working escape sequences, suppressing the bell. That's about it. This is 1000x less features than ConEmu - I don't care about a new exciting way to set terminal variables, or integration with a file manager nobody uses, or support for a bitmap font format, or per-app antialiasing settings. Or various silly extras the other terminals add - I don't want a new way to do Unix on Windows, I don't want a new SSH client this isn't as good as openssh, I don't want a new windowing system. I'm suggesting EXACTLY something like notepad. Do 1000x less things, and do the remainder well. > I'd argue those problems are easier to rectify than for MS to develop yet another alternative Just add tabs to the console app as suggested. Or use whatever Edge uses for window chrome and shove the console app in there rather than html.
- tolger 10y agoI'm with nailer on this. All I need is a decent built-in console with tabs and good support for bash, powershell and cmd.
- e12e 10y ago> Some person's half maintained fork of putty is some person's half maintained fork of putty and we already have Windows openssh for SSH purposes. I wonder if an MS port/fork/patch-set contribution to putty might not be the best way to a great windows console host. At least until there's a native port of libvt. Putty gets a lot of the console handling right - while win64/32 openssh is pretty outdated and lagging as a ssh client - I find it's preferable to run a recent full openssh under wsl to using openssh on Windows over putty. As for console for Windows - I'm currently using conemu - considering moving to putty, but haven't quite figured out if it makes sense as a local powershell (and ipython) host...