5 ms·
Windows Console folk: any chance of tabs in the official terminal? Current Windows terminal options: - ConEmu: mainly excellent but a little dated - eg, the a
by nailer 10y ago
Windows Console folk: any chance of tabs in the official terminal?
Current Windows terminal options:
- ConEmu: mainly excellent but a little dated - eg, the active tab color is hard to distinguish but it can't be changed, apparently due to maintainer's insistence it works on Windows XP.
- Hyper: excellent but Ctrl C, Ctrl R etc broken in powershell.
Adding tabs to the Windows console makes more sense than have a third party create an entire console just to support tabs.
- uaaa 10y agoThis is a more modern wrapper around ConEmu: http://cmder.net http://cmder.net
- nailer 10y agoCmder is ConEmu, just with a bunch of other stuff added to the download, including: - Something called 'git-for-windows' which isn't actually git for Windows https://git-scm.com/download/win https://git-scm.com/download/win but unremarkable things like shell additions which give you git status in the prompt, and a not-particularly-good GUI. - Clink (which is for cmd.exe). I.e., this doesn't in any way address the limitations mentioned in the post you're replying to.
- neilsimp1 10y agoDoesn't it, though? It lets you create tabs, Ctrl+c - Ctrl+v, and works for Cmd, PowerShell, and Bash on Windows.
- zouhair 10y agoConEmu does that
- nailer 10y ago> > - ConEmu: mainly excellent but a little dated - eg, the active tab color is hard to distinguish but it can't be changed, apparently due to maintainer's insistence it works on Windows XP. > It lets you create tabs, Ctrl+c - Ctrl+v, and works for Cmd, PowerShell, and Bash Not sure why you think that's addressing this.
- teh_klev 10y agoWhat I do is start sshd in WSL then ssh to <username>@localhost from mobaxterm which is quite a nice (tabbed) terminal app. Works a treat, even with the free edition. http://mobaxterm.mobatek.net/ http://mobaxterm.mobatek.net/
- tejinderss 10y agossh has its own typing latency, doesn't feel like native to me
- teh_klev 10y agoCan't say I've ever noticed any difference, even over the VPN to our stuff in the DC. Even serious vim editing sessions on a remote box with tmux feel just as instant as when I'm working on my local Fedora/KDE h/w PC in Konsole.
- MichaelGG 10y agoMobaXterm is awesome. Except the performance is just crap. It's noticeably laggy doing basic things like opening tabs and stuff. Anytime it has to redraw/relayout it's just slow. And if you use RDP, the CPU just burns even when idle. It's so promising though, I paid for it.
- teh_klev 10y agoI paid for it as well :) I pretty much use it mostly for ssh and have never noticed any lag. There are one or two oddities, but I can live with them. It's miles better than plain old PuTTY. If I'm doing RDP I use RoyalTS, another thing I paid for because it does RDP management so well: https://www.royalapplications.com/ts/win/features https://www.royalapplications.com/ts/win/features
- snarfy 10y agoBut a third party must create an entire console just for tabs, due to /subsystem:console https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/fcc1zstk.aspx https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/fcc1zstk.aspx
- Svenskunganka 10y agoMintty is what I'm using for it. You don't have to install the entirety of Cygwin and its unix-like tools to use it, there's smaller bundles specifically made for WSL like this one: https://github.com/mintty/wsltty https://github.com/mintty/wsltty I personally don't want a terminal with built-in tabs or windows since I use tmux for that. On my Mac I use iTerm2 where tabs/windowing is integrated with tmux. Try it and see if you like it! :)
- nostoc 10y agoTmux solves your tab needs!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nailer 10y agoEdit for folks having trouble understanding: the post you're replying to literally mentions two of the best tabbed terminals for Windows. That's not the problem. A fast, inbuilt, 2017-era terminal is. - ConEmu has a UI that's a shotgun blast of shit. - Hyper still fails at basic shortcuts. - ConEmu plus other software still has a UI that's a shotgun blast of shit. - Some person's half maintained fork of putty is some person's half maintained fork of putty and we already have Windows openssh for SSH purposes. - A proprietary app you need to pay for is a proprietary app you need to pay for. - tmux is not a tabbed terminal. - Something that uses cygwin is something using cygwin. The post is requesting a clean tabbed terminal, included in Windows, and maintained full time by Microsoft employees (whether Open Source or proprietary). Edit: removed 'fully featured' as someone below thinks that means I want all the bullshit the other terminals add, rather than tabs, working escape sequences, and other terminal features.
- tjoff 10y agoConEmu has the best UI I've ever seen in a terminal. Way better than anything I've seen in *nix.
- nailer 10y agoI use ConEmu for 5 hours a day. it's the best terminal on Windows, but its UI is absolutely awful https://conemu.github.io/img/ConEmu-Maximus5.png https://conemu.github.io/img/ConEmu-Maximus5.png https://conemu.github.io/img/Settings-Main.png https://conemu.github.io/img/Settings-Main.png - Minimal contrast in active tabs - can't be fixed due to Windows XP support. - Flashes it's hidden console proxy on screen continually - Settings menu with around 5000 options and no sense of heirarchy - something that's rare is just as prominent as something that's common - Giant colorful icons and wasted space in the title bar. I can't throw my mouse to the top and pick a tab when it's maximised. - Freaks out when your console is too large - Does a bunch of things better done elsewhere: my profile bash/powershell profile sets environment variables, I don't need my terminal to do this.
- tjoff 10y ago
- marcoperaza 10y agoYou can run gnome-terminal with WSL and VcXSrv. You might need to run unity-settings-daemon once per session to get font smoothing working correctly.
- Analemma_ 10y agoIt's on their backlog: https://wpdev.uservoice.com/forums/266908-command-prompt-console-bash-on-ubuntu-on-windo/suggestions/6509358-support-tabbed-interface https://wpdev.uservoice.com/forums/266908-command-prompt-con... You can upvote it to signal this is important for you, they use UserVoice as one signal to prioritize feature work.
- ivanbakel 10y agoI really support ConsoleZ. The UI is sadly still a little bulky, but you can do a good bit of configuration for hotkeys. The tabbing is nice, and it also to my memory has panes, without ConEmu's weird hidden tab system for them. It has the added benefit of you being able to pick the terminal to spin up, and whether you want Administrator mode or not, on every new tab, so you can be working in a bash tab and pop a new Admin cmd tab to update packages using your Windows manager.
- hotsauceror 10y agoI second this. I use ConsoleZ daily as my main shell for cmd and for powershell. It does everything I need it to do, I can dial down the UI to the absolute bare minimum, it's fast and responsive, and it's highly customizable.
- e12e 10y agoIs that?: https://github.com/cbucher/console https://github.com/cbucher/console
- ivanbakel 10y agoIt is, yeah. Chocolatey has a package for it, which is how I found it.
- internet2000 10y agoThis is the biggest blocker, in my opinion. WSL is nice and all, but as long as cmd.exe/conhost.exe is the only official terminal, it'll never feel just right. If only they had an API so you could run Mintty without the wslbridge kludge.
- zadjii 10y agoBasically every release we look at if it's possible to get us to tabs in that release window. If it's not, then usually we'll do some architectural work to get us closer to that goal. Part of the problem is that most of the codebase is from 1993, so there's a LOT of architectural work between where we were when Windows 10 first launched, and proper tab support. We're working hard on that architecture stuff now, because we want tabs just as bad as the community.
- Analemma_ 10y agoI'm curious: could you explain briefly why tabs are so difficult? I would think that every tab could have its own process space for its own shell, but obviously there's something big I'm missing here. If this is more than could be enumerated in an HN comment, I'd love to have a blog post about it. This stuff is fascinating.
- nailer 10y agoHi Zadjii I really appreciate you answering. If it's a 25 year old code base, wouldn't a rewrite be easier? What's the process of taking something like that and trying to modernize it?
- bitcrazed 10y agoThis XKCD is equally applicable to this problem - just replace "standard" with "Console" (or any other app for that matter) ;) https://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/ And, no, simply rewriting the Console is not an option: Entire businesses' core systems depend on the Console, its specific behaviors, and even its bugs. If we break existing behaviors we get to hear about who we've broken very, VERY quickly ;)
- nailer 10y agoI get that, but there's the Paint/Paint3D option: keep existing codebase and app, for people who need exact behaviour, and rewrite a new cleaner app.
- pcwalton 10y agoI just use the XFCE terminal connected to VcXsrv in WSL. :)
- vithlani 10y agoWhat is wrong with ConsoleZ?
- bitcrazed 10y agoHi - PM for Windows Console & Bash on Windows here. YES ... one day ;) We're keen to figure out a decent tab story for the console, and the feature ask is on our backlog, but we're currently fully booked completing some important internal re-factoring, after which we'll be able to return to working on important asks like this. FWIW, we're currently giving the Windows Console its biggest overhaul in > 30 years!! We're re-factoring and modernizing many of the Console's core internals. We'll be writing-up the why's and wherefores of what we're up to in a couple of months. Stay tuned on our blog (https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/commandline https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/commandline) and follow me on Twitter (https://twitter.com/richturn_ms https://twitter.com/richturn_ms) for news, udpates, and info.