6 ms·
> I have the right to render your bits and bytes however I wish. Legally I have no idea. But ethically/morally, I'd argue you don't. By visiting the site, you'
by paulcole 10y ago
> I have the right to render your bits and bytes however I wish.
Legally I have no idea. But ethically/morally, I'd argue you don't. By visiting the site, you're entering into an agreement to exchange your ad views for content and you're breaking that agreement.
Doesn't feel right to me.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rootusrootus 10y agoI agree. It's just like any other kind of piracy. If the content isn't valuable enough to see with ads enabled, then the ethical answer is to not view the content at all.
- dheera 10y agoI read newspapers without looking at the ads. I use highways and public transportation without looking at the billboards. I don't see how it's any different. I would say it should be arguably illegal to resell content with ads removed, but how something is rendered in my brain or inside the confines of my home is upto me to decide. There's nothing illegal about ripping out the ad pages before reading a magazine at home.
- paulcole 10y ago>There's nothing illegal about ripping out the ad pages before reading a magazine at home. Nope but hanging around the printing press and cutting out the ads in all your friends' papers seems unethical.
- huehehue 10y ago>I would say it should be arguably illegal to resell content with ads removed And it sounds like he agrees with you.
- Canada 10y agoUnless your friend asks you to cut ads out of their newspaper. Ad blockers operate with explicit permission, so it's not as if anyone who wants to view ads is being deprived.
- zoul 10y agoThere is a big difference between print and web: by the time you rip the ads out of the newspaper you have already made it to the ad statistics (“our newspaper sells X copies daily”). On the other hand, with an ad blocker an ad load is never recorded. In the first case, the publisher still makes money, in the second he doesn’t.
- fwn 10y agoIn the first case you are also screwing the advertising entity for the gain of the publisher, in the second case you are not pretending to see ads to profit for someone in the ecosystem on the expense of someone else. I can hardly see any moral advancement there.
- oneeyedpigeon 10y agoAlong with several other factors, this is what makes advertising online more valuable, as far as I can tell. Online ads can be far better quantified, in terms of impact, can appeal more to their target audience, can more easily provide a service alongside their advertising content, etc. Advertisers were given a magic wand, but decided to break it over their collective knee and carrying on waving their empty hands about instead.
- petre 10y agoArrr! Let's block those ads to Davey Jones, savy.
- JKCalhoun 10y agoSucks when you actually buy the content (DVD) and then still have to sit through ads (previews).
- jancsika 10y agoIt turns out to be the other way around: the site owner claims that the ads Google served up were of such low quality that they "polluted" the content of the site: "For about R20,000 a year, it isn’t worth it to pollute our content with get-rich-quick adverts featuring Patrice Motsepe, Richard Branson and Oprah Winfrey (see image at top of article)." Moreover, the author states in the comments that their non-profit is sustained by donations, not by ads. If someone had visited this site with an ad-blocker turned on before the author stopped using Google ads, it would have improved the content (by the author's own stated standards) without endangering the site's source of funding. Granted this may be a special case. But I think special cases are often worth the read, or at least not "just like any other kind."
- mikestew 10y agoBy visiting the site, you're entering into an agreement to exchange your ad views for content and you're breaking that agreement. C'mon, you know better. What agreement? If your answer contains the word "unspoken", I'll let you in on the real definition of that word in this context: "non-existent". I didn't sign anything, no notice was posted. The only agreement I have is that I ask for data, and should your server deem me worthy, it will send me some. That's what I signed up for low those many years ago. If you and advertisers would like to change the "agreement" after the fact, well, good luck with that upstream swim.
- lobster_johnson 10y agoThe parent poster did say "ethically/morally". There's no legal agreement, obviously.
- paulcole 10y agoSociety has many unwritten agreements. You don't like ads, I get it. You take without compensating because you want to. Don't just shrug and say, "no notice was posted." Own it. Say, "I felt like taking this so I took it."
- mikestew 10y agoTwist it however you like, but just saying things like they're a fact does not an argument make. Making your case without accusations would be a good place to start.
- shawkinaw 10y agoI used to feel that way, and still have absolutely no problem with ads in and of themselves. But they are the ones who breached ethics and morals by tracking me around the web, tracking my search queries, running all sorts of terrible JavaScript, and generally being dicks. So I don't feel bad anymore.
- x0x0 10y agoDoesn't stop you from consuming their content though?
- kaishiro 10y agoWhy would it?
- MaulingMonkey 10y agoIt does if they bother to stop me.
- visarga 10y agoIt used to be the case that all content was Hollywood or newspaper created. But now, 99% of the content I am using is discussion threads such as this one, Wiki articles, arXiv papers and blogs. From the people, to the people! I don't even need movies and articles - well, I still keep a 1% interest in them, but that's all. I am sorry about them but they are so derivative and dishonest at times that I can't watch them any more. How many times did you find more value in YC comments than the linked article?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- metafunctor 10y agoExactly. On HN, I click to view the comments to see if it's even worth reading the linked article. It seems to be about 50/50, which is as good is it gets I think.
- TheAceOfHearts 10y agoConsider the following: If you pick up a newspaper or magazine, is it wrong to skip the ads? What about changing the TV channel or radio station while commercials play?
- paulcole 10y agoI think it'd be wrong to hire a dude to clip out all the ads before I open the paper in the morning. I think it'd be wrong to mod my TV and car radio to change the channel when an ad starts playing.
- kaishiro 10y agoDo you also think it's wrong to change the channel when an ad starts playing on TV, or to turn the volume down when an ad starts playing on the radio?
- paulcole 10y agoNo. I also don't think it's wrong to navigate away from a website when it loads an ad I don't like.
- kaishiro 10y agoBut you eventually go back to the TV show, or turn the volume back up, having skipped the ads, no?
- fmueller 10y agoAccording to your logic you are obliged to watch the ads on TV. Because by watching a film you made an agreement that watching the film is only free because you watch the ads.
- Crito 10y ago>it'd be wrong to hire a dude to clip out all the ads >hire Well I'm not paying for my adblocker. What if this dude volunteers? What if I'm doing it for my family members? This isn't a hypothetical.
- RodericDay 10y agoAre advertisements themselves moral? How can you debate the finer points of whether accessing a website and rejecting ads is moral or not, when you haven't built a moral case for urging and tricking people into buying stuff that they don't need?
- paulcole 10y ago> tricking people into buying stuff that they don't need This tells me all I need to know. If this is your stance on advertising, I don't know what to tell you.
- RodericDay 10y agoYour inability to grapple with the question tells me all I need to know, too.
- Symbiote 10y agoWhat do you think the purpose of advertising is?
- oh_sigh 10y agoWhat if you just wget the html, just read the body of the page, and don't load any of the external ad scripts?
- MaulingMonkey 10y ago> By visiting the site, you're entering into an agreement No. By replying to my browser, they're entering into an agreement to not waste my time, and give me lots of money. Oh, not that either? Hmm. Several sites detect that I'm using a malware blocker. I make no effort to obfuscate this. Some websites will ask me to turn it off, others will block me if I do not. That's fine - I've no obligation to them, they have no obligation to me. Neither of us entered into any kind of agreement. Keep in mind - I'm even happy to unblock and click ads relevant to my interests and follow relevant affiliate links - to stuff I'm actually interested in. Webcomics in particular are my jam. So I would likely not even bother with ad blockers if site owners were not routinely acting as a proxy for criminals in (attempting to) serve me malware, extortion-ware, pyramid schemes, and other scams - or peddling horrifically low quality untargeted advertizing that doesn't respect my time (think "same 30 second unskippable ad plays 5 times in a row" utter and other absolute garbage.) > Legally I have no idea. But ethically/morally, I'd argue you don't If you want to talk ethics and morals, just how ethical and moral is it to leave your computer open to joining a botnet - imposing so many externalities onto other parties not privy to your "agreement" in the form of DDoS attacks and proxying to obfuscate the origins of such criminals? I think these concerns far weightier than the ethical or moral concerns of depriving a website owner a few cents for selling my time, my attention, my browsing history, etc. (even if they've outsourced that messy work to an ad company who does so on their behalf.)
- bad_user 10y agoYou can't block ads in Facebook's native mobile app. Their communications are probably encrypted and their ads are probably served on the same connection as everything else. Which means that either now or in the future you won't be able to modify your /etc/hosts to solve this problem either (assuming you have a rooted phone or tablet of course). The only option you'll have will be to crack Facebook's client and modify its behavior, which will be copyright infringement. So how long do you think it will take for either (1) everybody moving to native apps where ads can't be blocked or (2) courts starting to rule ad blocking in browsers as being copyright infringement. After all, isn't opening a website just like installing an app? I don't see a difference really. Don't get me wrong, I now have ad-blockers installed everywhere I can. But let's not kid ourselves, you didn't have an implicit right for that content to begin with, by blocking ads you won't reward the good actors (i.e. GroundUp, featured in this article) and the future isn't bright.
- nebabyte 10y ago> By visiting the site, you're entering into an agreement If that were true, it'd be built into the protocol. "HTTP GET" would require an acknowledgement of the agreement you purport exists. Instead, it just serves the page to any requestee who comes by it, even if automated. Doesn't exactly sound like an agreement to me. Hell, a javascript popup would be a valid test for agreement compared to that.
- JKCalhoun 10y agoI'm more frustrated they're wasting my bandwidth, slowing down load times. If their ads were text-only and not running trackers to follow me on the internet I wouldn't bother with ad-blockers/tracker-blockers.
- zoul 10y agoThey have to waste your bandwidth in order to pay for the content you came to read. If you’re not happy with that, don’t read it.
- quickben 10y agoThey don't have to. There are plethora of monetizing options and content gating possible (subscriptions , apps, etc). When one chooses the cheapest to implement approach, one can't really complain that the cheapest ad blocking technique counters it.
- zoul 10y agoAgain: if they choose one you’re not happy with, you’re free to decide not to read the content. Otherwise I don’t see how the situation is different from not paying for a meal in a restaurant if you’re not happy with the payment methods offered.
- NLips 10y agoActually, if the restaurant only accepts payment by credit card, you are free to not pay. That's the concept of legal tender - if they want to demand payment of a debt (i.e. after you finish the meal) from you with backing by law, they _must_ accept legal tender. If they only accept credit card payments, they can't use the law to make you pay.
- coldpie 10y agoI would be surprised if this is true.
- fmueller 10y agoThe good thing about morale is that it doesn't have to be the same for different people. It's not an absolute value. You can live up to your high morale standards and watch ads (which sounds a bit odd). Other people think differently. Other people like me think we are morally bound to ignore ads as much as possible because we think they destroy a healthy capitalism and are misused to track people and distribute malware. Therefore I use an ad-blocker. But that's only a side note. In the internet your argument is invalid because I don't know in advance whether a website uses ads or not. To discover that I would have to visit that site without an ad-blocker and let them serve ads without warning. And that would be unacceptable. The solution for that problem is the various websites either use paywalls or detect ad-blockers and don't provide content when one is in use. In this case we really have an agreement. If I turn off my ad-blocker I'm allowed to watch the content, otherwise I'm not. But I never ever had the desire to see content which has been hidden behind an ad-blocker blocker.
- watwut 10y agoNo. You can not force "agreement" on me that easily. By visiting the site, I am visiting the site. There is no agreement between us whatsoever about anything.
- pmontra 10y agoSometimes when I click a link I get to a site I never visited before and I don't know that before having got there. They could have ads, they could not have ad. They could use JS to display even text content, they could not use any JS at all. They could serve malware, they could fingerprint me, they could run some bitcoin miner in the JS they serve. They could be totally honest. I really don't know. In some cases they don't know too. That's why I'm adblocking everything and I visit sites with NoScript, Self Destructing Cookies, DisableWebRTC among the others. Better safe than sorry. And about the right to render bits and bytes however I wish, I use Stylish for those few sites that do really wierd things with their layout. By the way, a browser renders bit and bytes as it wishes, starting from the html file and maybe stopping there or going as far as precaching linked pages.
- flukus 10y ago> By visiting the site, you're entering into an agreement to exchange your ad views for content and you're breaking that agreement. If that's your attitude then you should publish PDF's or create an app. On the web it's always been up to browsers to render a site how they wish.
- metafunctor 10y agoYou say "visiting a site" should be enough to "enter into an agreement" with a site to agree to view their ads. Surely the same should extend to the site, such that "visiting a site" is enough to "enter into an agreement" with the visitor to agree to show only ads that are relevant, non-intrusive, and do not contain malware. The main short-term incentive for ad networks is to show more ads, make them more intrusive, and sell them to whomever pays the most. It's simply not in the long-term interests of a website, or a website visitor, to be part of an ad network.
- jacquesm 10y ago> Legally I have no idea. Duly noted. > But ethically/morally, I'd argue you don't. That has to be a first: arguing for the morality of the advertising eco system. I've seen quite a bit of it from the inside and let's just say that if there is an argument for morality it lies with the consumers, emphatically not with publishers (who have conditioned their audience first that everything should be free) or with advertisers (and that's even before we get into the content of the ads, see TFA). > By visiting the site, you're entering into an agreement to exchange your ad views for content and you're breaking that agreement. That sounds like a legal argument to me, about which you earlier said you have no idea. Let me summarize my answer: you're wrong. By visiting a site you do not 'enter into an agreement to exchange your adviews for content'. > Doesn't feel right to me. That's ok, you are entitled to your own feelings. So you don't get to install an adblocker. Have fun with spyware, malware and being tracked from here to kingdom come. If it was just ads, on the page itself and without any further trickery the ads would work just fine.
- corford 10y ago>If it was just ads, on the page itself and without any further trickery the ads would work just fine. I really want this to be true but the elephant in the room is auditing. Without the ad network performing tracking, advertisers have no way to independently verify ad performance and corresponding payment to publishers for CPC ads. For CPA ads, the publisher has no way to independently verify the advertiser is paying out correctly for sales conversions. You need a third party in the middle to arbitrate. AFAIK, the only way to do that at scale is with cookies from an ad network dropped in and tracked via a beacon. I guess the only solution is for a new, non-commercial advertising network to spring up (sort of like an NGO) with a strong enough charter and ethical approach that end users (or browsers themselves?) trust limited tracking from ads served through that network. The problem is, who funds it? Not the advertisers or publishers as that would destroy the impartiality of the network. Edit: and problem two is if such an ad network came in to existence and was successful, it would end up a de-facto monopoly for on-line ad distribution. Apart from the headwinds it would attract from Google, there are obvious issues around free-speech, mono-culture etc. Edit 2: or maybe the "internet" agrees what an ethical ad network should look like and then any one is free to set one up but must submit to regular auditing by a new internet body to make sure they are sticking to the agreed "charter". That way the ad network could be operationally funded by publishers/advertisiers but still retain user's trust. A little like the CA market for SSL certs. If an ad network started misbehaving, browsers themselves could block/de-list them (like they do when they revoke root certs from rogue CAs)
- davidgerard 10y agoI didn't enter into an agreement to play Russian roulette with malware. Are you accepting actual legal liability for malware served to me via ads on your site?