19 ms·
Twitter allegedly deleting negative tweets about United Airlines incident
- 67726e 10y agoWould not at all surprise me. Twitter regularly censors popular right-of-center Twitter accounts.
- dev_head_up 10y agoWas sceptical of this myself until I experienced it. Scott Adams completely disappeared from my feed for, well I'd like to say months but can't pinpoint when it started. I assumed he had just given up his account/been banned. Until one day I searched for him, and there he was still posting. He had actively tweeted while I was logged on yet it was no-where on my timeline! I scrolled back a bit collarating tweets that appeared for me on the homepage versus times that he had posted, he was no-where to be seen and presumably under some sort of shadow block by Twitter itself. Before someone comes in and says it was due to preferences etc, I don't follow a huge bunch of accounts, I don't like/retweet or even tweet.
- cheath 10y agoBeware the filter bubble
- andoon 10y agoThe entire point of Twitter was that there was no such filter, it would just show the tweets of everybody you followed in a chronological order. That's why we are all pissed.
- cheath 10y agoJust to be clear--I too am pissed.
- kristiandupont 10y agoI don't know if that was the "entire point" of Twitter. I am certainly glad that there is a bit of filtering. I recall the old days where most of my feed consisted of noise, today I actually get some value out of it.
- andoon 10y agoIf there was too much noise in your feed it was because you followed the wrong people, simply.
- kristiandupont 10y agoSure. But my Twitter feed is not important enough for me to do something about that. As it is, it's somewhat entertaining (I check it perhaps once a week) whereas if it was unfiltered I never would. So I am at least one person for whom it makes business sense for Twitter to filter in order to keep me engaged.
- toyg 10y agoThat changed a long time ago, I'm surprised people are only noticing now. The change was not borne out of malice: like Facebook, they try to filter out accounts with too much noise or which you don't really interact with, to show you only stuff you're really interested in. In the past you'd see all @-replies and a single noisy account could basically flood your timeline, that's hardly the case nowadays. In the case of Scott Adams mentioned above, it happens to me regularly with tons of people who are absolutely unthreatening. There is certainly real censorship going on inside all these centralized platforms (like deleting content), but Occam suggests this is just Twitter trying too hard.
- andoon 10y agoThe shadowbanning and bubbling only started like two years ago. That thing about seeing all replies was changed... I don't know, eight years ago? And that made all the sense in the world and it's in no way censoring or anything... My friends talking to people I don't know is not something I care about. But my friends talking to me and me not seeing it because they are shadowbanned? That's a new low.
- Spooky23 10y agoThen a variety of trolls and other scum showed up and started ruining people's lives.
- dev_head_up 10y agoHmm. I'd say Scott is the only vaguely political account I follow. Next up would be one BBC News and a local newspaper account. Apart from that I follow mainly sports teams (my main use for it is scores and fantasy football) and some selected ones for tv shows. Less than 40 accounts in total. If anyone can explain how Twitter uses that information to decide to hide Scott Adams from my timeline, I'd love to know. It seems to me that there's one obvious explanation.
- cheath 10y agoIn short, because they think you'd engage less with Scott Adams' content. Filter bubbles are an algorithmic attempt to give you the content that you want the most. For example, Twitter might have identified at some level that you like and retweet sports related content more often than political content. Or even further, that you like left-leaning content more than right. So, they'll do everything they can to serve you what they think you want. If it keeps you scrolling, then they make more ad dollars. All of these nuanced inputs impact what you see on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, etc. The problem is, there IS a difference between what you want to see and what you should see. Just because you love cat photos, doesn't mean that the NY Times should be filled with them. If you haven't watched it, I highly recommend this (9 min) ted talk on the topic: https://www.ted.com/talks/eli_pariser_beware_online_filter_bubbles https://www.ted.com/talks/eli_pariser_beware_online_filter_b...
- dev_head_up 10y agoI've seen that and I'm sorry, but I really don't accept your explanation. I've never retweeted/liked/replied or tweeted, ever. I'm a passive consumer. I don't follow political accounts, or search out political views there. If anything, I reckon I was clicking a lot on his blog links via tweets, so (presumably) he should have been showing up more... rather than not at all. I don't mean to sound like I'm holding you accountable for this! It's just, well this kinda thing is well dodgy and I want to assure people I'm not just cribbing about this without a basis.
- cheath 10y ago
- tnones 10y agoYou can also see this in action with replies. Certain shadowbanned accounts will only show up in threads if you follow them. If you open the thread in an incognito window, certain people disappear. "Trust and Safety" is just Orwellian newspeak for controlling who gets to hear which opinions.
- fennecfoxen 10y agoScott Adams has blogged that he thinks it's about his politics and trollishly pro-Trump tweeting/blogging, and I've never been certain whether or not to believe it was true at all (he needn't even be lying for it to be false: it's possible to get quite confused going through these things with many followers, doubly so with any reason to be suspicious or paranoid). But in light of an incident like this it seems far more plausible to me that they have a more general-purpose algorithm at work that, in a few cases like United and @ScottAdamsSays, misbehaves radically. At a guess, some anti-spam thing gone terribly wrong. (A missing tweet identified in this incident is basically "United training video as Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade blimp scene". Do viral-joke tweets like this have similar enough dynamics to Scott Adams tweets and spam that they'd trigger similar filters?) (But hey, maybe I'm not paranoid enough :b) postscript: hey, why the downvotes? am i being too speculative? too paranoid? not paranoid enough? it's okay to downvote but do help me out here.
- ufmace 10y agoHe's blogged about it several times. According to his blog posts, he can track which posts get "shadowbanned" by blog analytics. Apparently, his posts regarding Trump or climate science aren't showing up in a lot of his followers' feeds. Even more remarkably, he seems to have gotten around it for now with code words - tweeting that the post is about kittens when it's really about a supposedly shadowbanned subject, which has supposedly restored his normal blog traffic rates from Twitter. See http://blog.dilbert.com/post/156806516721/the-social-media-hive-mind http://blog.dilbert.com/post/156806516721/the-social-media-h... and http://blog.dilbert.com/post/157904840851/dopamine-puppets http://blog.dilbert.com/post/157904840851/dopamine-puppets Sure looks like Twitter is in the business of censoring content that doesn't fit their political views. If they'll do that, there's no telling what else they'll censor.
- mrdrozdov 10y agoI follow this account: @gerfingerpoken Has not been censored at all on my newsfeed! That is the same account covered by this article: https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/as-a-conservative-twitter-user-sleeps-his-account-is-hard-at-work/2017/02/05/18d5a532-df31-11e6-918c-99ede3c8cafa_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/as-a-conserv... Tweets on average more than 400x per day.
- koolba 10y agoAssuming this is true (which I don't believe it is), why would they do this? I doubt UAL is paying them enough in advertising dollars to justify something like this. This isn't like silencing/promoting selective political speech where the personal ideals of the heads of the company are being pushed forward. Unless Dorsey really likes flying United.
- mtgx 10y agoEven if it's not intentional, they may have some algorithms that "throw the baby out with the bathwater" as the saying goes. We're already seeing Google's recent "extremism curation" hit a lot of youtubers that shouldn't be anywhere close to being impacted by it, and yet they still are. If Google's DeepMind/Brain AI can't properly curate this sort of stuff, I can't imagine Twitter is any better at it. After governments keep pushing them to "deal with extremism" I wouldn't be surprised if they took overly aggressive actions to be on the "safe side." I also think they're wrong to do that, but in Google's case they are obviously concerned about more advertisers dumping them.
- mrdrozdov 10y agoI am curious about DeepMind/Brain's role in the curating search results. Would you mind explaining more? Also, I am not sure I understand your reference to Youtube. Is this specifically about Youtube recommended videos in the sidebar?
- vultour 10y agoNot sure if it's only about the sidebar, but many youtubers were apparently deemed 'unsafe' by google and their videos stopped appearing all over youtube.
- caseysoftware 10y agoI think United is paying them a ton and has become a top partner: "We are constantly working to create industry-leading experiences for our customers. Twitter is a place where our customers engage with us 24/7 about a variety of aspects of travel. The new features that Twitter released have enabled us to create real-time engagements with customers to offer an array of services, from discovering where to go on their next trip, to answering common travel questions faster and easier. We’re excited to use these features to deliver additional experiences that connect people and unite the world through travel." KC Geen, Director of Digital Marketing and Customer Acquisition at United Airlines https://blog.twitter.com/2017/new-apis-to-power-the-future-of-customer-engagement-in-direct-messages https://blog.twitter.com/2017/new-apis-to-power-the-future-o...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mrdrozdov 10y agoI'm pretty skeptical this is true. I don't think this has to do with Twitter censoring left or right wing accounts.
- Mendenhall 10y agoI did not think this was about politics. I am not sure this is true either but I thought twitter was trying to curb abusive tweets lately. Perhaps the tweets towards United were trollish/abusive etc?
- cmdrfred 10y agoYou can see a great many tweets calling for the death of Trump as well as white people in general if this is a algorithm problem it seems someone's bias slipped in.
- Bahamut 10y agoHuh, kinda surprised - looks like they deleted my tweet asking United about this incident.
- jankotek 10y agoThis is ok, what we need is transparency. Twitter should publish price list and list of its clients...
- hammock 10y agoThe main threads on Reddit were deleted also: https://www.reddit.com/r/undelete/comments/64jbfq/1458098779_doctor_violently_dragged_from/ https://www.reddit.com/r/undelete/comments/64jbfq/1458098779... Many more: https://www.reddit.com/r/undelete/ https://www.reddit.com/r/undelete/
- nkkollaw 10y agoJesus Christ, what's going on? How can we counteract this? They absolutely deserve the bad publicity they're (or would be) getting!
- ythn 10y agoThere's "bad publicity", and then there's lynch mob Streisand Effect bandwagoning.
- nkkollaw 10y agoStill deserved, also for the comments they made afterwards. At least pretend, and say something like "this will not happen again".
- ythn 10y ago> Still deserved, also for the comments they made afterwards. Maybe, maybe not. We don't have all the facts yet. We still don't even know the identity of the victim - only hearsay from other passengers. This type of viral emotional response makes me weary. I see it happen so often - Michael Brown, Ahmed Mohammed, TSA Cancer Girl, etc. The lynch mob gets bloodlust and calls for complete destruction of the alleged perpetrators (St. Louis Police, School Administration, TSA, etc). Later more facts come out and we empathize with the perpetrators a bit more, but it's too late - careers and such have already been ruined.
- drakonandor 10y agoExcept we have tons of video, witness statements, responses from UA PR, and the CEO doing the old public "very sorry!, trying to contact the victim now and make ammends"/private "this guy is immature and beligerant!" positions.
- GiorgioG 10y agoCan Twitter just die already?
- diogenescynic 10y agoI'll definitely not be flying United or Delta ever again after this incident. Over-selling spaces on a plane is a scummy practice and shokldn't be allowed. When someone needs to cancel they still pocket the change fee or keep tne entire fee if they miss the flight. Seems like borderline fraud.
- casenjo 10y agoDelta? How come Delta? The flights I've taken in the past couple of months have been with Delta and their service was fantastic.
- diogenescynic 10y agoD'oh! Never mind, I thought United had acquired Delta. I got them mixed up with Continental. My point was that the United brand will never get another dollar from me.
- brightball 10y agoWait wait wait....what's wrong with Delta?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nommm-nommm 10y agoApparently they had something similar (?) happen. http://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/wayne-county/2017/02/06/detroit-metro-passenger-taken-plane/97552370/ http://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/wayne-county/201...
- diogenescynic 10y agoI got them mixed up. I thought United bought Delta, but that was Continental.
- scrollaway 10y agoOverbooking is an extremely common practice. In fact, I don't know of a single airline that doesn't overbook. On a plane with hundreds of seats you almost always get cancellations; the small amount of times you don't, you almost always get people volunteering to be pushed to the next flight in exchange for money (I've done it myself a few times as I don't mind working in airports). Cases like these are exceedingly rare. There's a million fucked up things with how they handled the situation, starting with assaulting the passenger. Overbooking itself is the last thing you should be worried about.
- bitL 10y agoWonderful, so Twitter is now a tool for corporate propaganda, Google is providing Censorship-as-a-Service API, Facebook is removing links classified as "Fake News(tm)", Reddit is deleting whatever mods don't agree with etc. Seems like we are going full steam into a dystopian society. I think I should start reading Solzhenitsyn to prepare for what is coming...
- rublev 10y agoCan you recommend something by Solzhenitsyn?
- rangibaby 10y agoGulag Archipelago
- kemoly 10y agoOne Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich
- oskarth 10y agoOne Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich is a slightly lighter (fiction, but reality-based) version of Gulag Archipelago, also by Solzhenitsyn. Might be a good entry if the length of Gulag Archipelago scares you away.
- heliumcraft 10y agoIn the long term we can at least attempt to counteract this by contributing to decentralized platforms such as Ethereum & Maidsafe, which create transparent decentralized systems in which this sort of censorship is not possible.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- c4n4rd 10y agoTweeter and all others you mentioned are private corporations. Their goal is to turn profit to their shareholders - NOTHING MORE. He who believes these companies exist as a way for the mass population to voice their opinion and as a way to exercise democracy should rethink what these companies are all about. Note: I do not necessarily agree with that they do, just pointing out what they are all about.
- radnam 10y agoDo not ascribe to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity or in this case probably engineering oversight. No affiliation or affection to twitter.
- rorykoehler 10y agoThis gets thrown around a lot on hn and I don't buy it as a healthy way to think. Leaves the door wide open
- wccrawford 10y agoThere's a huge difference between question something and believing it. The saying suggests that you shouldn't just jump to believing it, which is what happens all too often.
- siegecraft 10y agoIs it stupidity to think that twitter wouldn't try to monetize itelf by selling "reputation management services" to corporate customers? I guess one can get away with a lot of malice if they just affect the outward appearance of stupidity.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- radnam 10y agoDo you know for a fact that Twitter monetizes using "reputation management systems"? I am just suggesting keeping an open mind.
- bshimmin 10y ago* unpresidented
- bshimmin 10y ago(I'm not actually bad at spelling, it was a reference to http://www.snopes.com/trump-sends-unpresidented-tweet/ http://www.snopes.com/trump-sends-unpresidented-tweet/ - but I should probably know by now that cheap one-liners don't go down well on HackerNews...)
- dopamean 10y agoPeople here can be rather humorless.
- mod 10y agoI think we all understand the humor, but the comments that are appreciated here are insightful comments that enhance the conversation and add to the article. Jokes are not appreciated, but not because they are not understood.
- chc 10y agoWanting a place where every thread isn't derailed by low-effort jokes doesn't mean you're humorless. I mean, I like chocolate, but I don't want to only eat chocolate, and I'd be upset to find my computer screen smeared with chocolate.
- xname2 10y agoDoes twitter shadow ban also?
- tptacek 10y agoThis seems extraordinarily unlikely.
- privateprofile 10y agoCare to explain why?
- tptacek 10y agoAnd argue with people who badly want it to be true? No, thanks.
- golergka 10y agoThat's what happens when yoy decide to censor "hate speech" or "fake news".
- wccrawford 10y agoThat's a lesson that's been a while in coming, and I'm not under any illusion that people are going to learn it any time soon.
- yoran 10y agoI wonder why Twitter is doing this? What is their incentive for deleting negative tweets about another unrelated corporation? It's not like Twitter has a stake in United. And would they do it just for money? I know they are turning at a loss but this does not seem like a scalable business model...
- ino 10y agoMaybe somebody high up on twitter has a stake in united
- ryanmarsh 10y agoWhy was this downvoted?
- 67726e 10y agoBecause Hacker News skews heavily left, and if you point out anything that does not please them you will get brigaded. Happens routinely nowadays.
- sctb 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14087236 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14087236 and marked it off-topic since the guidelines ask us not to do this.
- tibbon 10y agoLet's say that Twitter isn't doing this; I do know a lot of companies however that will bend to clients $$$, which is really unfortunate. The reason we're willing to believe that Twitter is doing this, is because so many other companies would absolutely delete a few posts in order to appease a paying client. Money wins.
- matt4077 10y agoThis may serve as an example of a lot of the things wrong in society. First, as a show of how good faith has broken down. Then, to demonstrate the logical contortions performed by people who are otherwise perfectly capable of critical thinking, but really want to see their mistrust in every institution, or human, be true. This alleged conspiracy would involve (a) some rather rapid negotiations for a sum that wouldn't be much below the market value of Twitter, (b) the believe that now, 24h+ after it broke on Twitter, it has not made the jump to many other distribution channels already, and (c) the complete idiocy of United and Twitter in thinking such a scheme would not be noticed or, if noticed, would not result in coverage orders-of-magnitudes worse than what they deleted. Oh, and (d) apparently they forgot to delete the original tweets, which were the one actually being shared. All that is quite implausible, even though it may be possible. Here's an alternative theory: Twitter has, in an attempt to combat spam, implemented a filter that registers a sudden rise in certain keywords, maybe within a negative context. Once triggered, it throttles new tweets that match automatically, until someone overrides it manually. This system just failed spectacularly, because it had never before seen such an amount of tweets with such an imbalance of sentiment. I'm not saying that the latter theory is true. I just believe it's much more plausible than Twitter just throwing its business away. And while I don't care much about this specific company, I believe something larger is amiss when every single event is always interpreted in the worst (barely) possible way. If everyone and everything is assumed to be corrupt, pretty soon that's how it's going to be–either because it doesn't make a difference for the pitchfork-people if I'm really corrupt (or just incompetent/unlucky) so why bother? Or because those with pitchforks don't see problem with becoming corrupted themselves. Everyone is doing it, after all. So, in an attempt to stem the tide of corruption, people scream for transparency, and everyone is accused, everyone is a subject, everyone is under investigation. That, however, cannot work: a liberal democracy does not have the means to audit and control everyone. A free society, and an advanced economy, is sustained by 98%+ doing the right thing even when nobody is looking. That, and the trust it brings, and the institutions it makes possible, is basically the difference between Canada and Somalia. So I'll delay my scorn for a day and see what Twitter has to offer, and I'll needle the guy I know there with jokes and watch him turn red, and I'll know that moment of shame is (for him) more of an incentive to do better than a million hateful tweets would ever be.
- 10y ago
- goodmachine 10y agoTwitter presumably just 're-accomodating' these tweets, nothing to worry about.
- jasonlfunk 10y agoI'm also a little skeptical of this. It seems too random. If it were an algorithm, it's hard to know what the parameters were that it was looking for. And if it as a person, it's hard to know why it was so sporadic and limited. I wonder if it can just be explained by user error? Do we /know/ these tweets were actually ever on twitter? Perhaps the tweet about united failed to post. (It's happened to me). And if that happens to a few people who posted about United, you then get a conspiracy. But if the same thing happens to the cat picture you tweeted, it's chalked up to a bug and forgotten. Though given Twitter's recent track record with "ghost-deleting" and "shadow-banning", this sort of thing - if true - wouldn't be surprising.
- codeinstyle 10y agoTwitter is already in a bad state as is - I wonder why they decided to turn it's back on the public now.
- mmjaa 10y agoTools such as Akasha[1] and IPFS[2] and ZeroNet[3] can't arrive on the scene soon enough, imho. I think we're on the cusp of seeing these corporate-tools lose their grip on the populace, once Akasha becomes usable by the common man. [1] https://akasha.world https://akasha.world [2] http://ipfs.io/ http://ipfs.io/ [3] http://zeronet.io/en http://zeronet.io/en
- Dylan16807 10y agoHooking it onto blockchains provides what advantage over pure IPFS?
- mmjaa 10y agoThink: ownership.
- chambo622 10y agoTwitter had a moment filled with negative tweets about United at the top of its curated Moments tab for the entire day yesterday. Even now I see a trending hashtag and moments about the incident. If their goal was to suppress this story, they couldn't have done a worse job. These accusations sound like paranoia to me.
- error-code 10y ago1) Twitter is a company that owes you, and the public, nothing. The same goes for Facebook and Google. There is no law I know of that prevents them from running their platform however they like. So what if they sensor or take sides? It is their right. If you don't like it, use or build a competing service (as long as Net Neutrality exists). 2) Negative tweets about United could be considered "Fake News" in my opinion. Not because I am some "shill" for United. But because the facts are it was Chicago airport police that escalated the situation to excessive force. The United employees were not involved in that part at all whatsoever. In fact they will probably hesitate to call the authorities for help ever again.
- error-code 10y ago1) Twitter is a company that owes you, and the public, nothing. The same goes for Facebook and Google. There is no law I know of that prevents them from running their platform however they like. So what if they sensor or take sides? It is their right. If you don't like it, use or build a competing service (as long as Net Neutrality exists). 2) Negative tweets about United could be considered "Fake News" in my opinion. Not because I am some "shill" for United. But because the facts are it was Chicago airport police that escalated the situation to excessive force. The United employees were not involved in that part at all whatsoever. In fact they will probably hesitate to call the authorities for help ever again.
- error-code 10y ago1) Twitter is a company that owes you, and the public, nothing. The same goes for Facebook and Google. There is no law I know of that prevents them from running their platform however they like. So what if they sensor or take sides? It is their right. If you don't like it, use or build a competing service (as long as Net Neutrality exists). 2) Negative tweets about United could be considered "Fake News" in my opinion. Not because I am some "shill" for United. But because the facts are it was Chicago airport police that escalated the situation to excessive force. The United employees were not involved in that part at all whatsoever. In fact they will probably hesitate to call the authorities for help ever again.
- error-code 10y ago1) Twitter is a company that owes you, and the public, nothing. The same goes for Facebook and Google. There is no law I know of that prevents them from running their platform however they like. So what if they sensor or take sides? It is their right. If you don't like it, use or build a competing service (as long as Net Neutrality exists). 2) Negative tweets about United could be considered "Fake News" in my opinion. Not because I am some "shill" for United. But because the facts are it was Chicago airport police that escalated the situation to excessive force. The United employees were not involved in that part at all whatsoever. In fact they will probably hesitate to call the authorities for help ever again.
- jacquesm 10y agoWhat's really bad is that technically this flight wasn't overbooked at all. United decided to fly one of their crews when the plane was already booked to capacity and had paying passengers 'voluntarily' (what a funny way to use that word) give up their seats so they could move their employees around. It's a totally ridiculous situation and their media messaging doesn't help at all.
- maxerickson 10y agoAre you sure it wasn't also overbooked? They pulled passengers to fly crew, but that doesn't mean it wasn't overbooked.
- jacquesm 10y agoThey claimed it was overbooked but that has not been substantiated with any evidence other than the company making that claim and using it to pre-empt those passengers in favor of their dead-headers. The proof that they are bullshitting is that the passengers were already on board when suddenly the plane was declared overbooked. Which to me sounds like UA using an excuse to bump passengers off a flight they are already confirmed on in order to fix some kind of crew scheduling issue.
- maxerickson 10y agoSure I agree it is just a claim. But they overbook most flights, so it isn't really hard to believe. They could have paid some other passengers already to not board, prior to deciding that they wanted to fly the crew and needing to pull more passengers. That leaves the overbooking claim as misdirection, which isn't any better than a lie that they were overbooked, but it's a different situation. (sorry about the edit crosstalk)
- jacquesm 10y agoOverbooking does not include non-paying passengers that were not confirmed before the flight. Those passengers had confirmed seats and boarding passes and were in fact already on the plane (as was their luggage). In my experience - which is limited, but I've flown quite a bit over the years - overbooking always involved other paying passengers, never crew.
- gdulli 10y agoWithout the strictly chronological timeline anymore they can do whatever the hell they want with your timeline and chalk it up to "the algorithm".
- anotherturn 10y agoGiven twitters track record upholding user privacy in the face of lawsuits and the like [0] I'm somewhat skeptical that they'd play ball with United in this way. I'd suspect it's more likely that United and their twitter drone army are "reporting the tweet(s)" as "abusive or harmful" and if enough twitter users do that it would make sense that twitter would auto-remove / moderate said tweet. Of course, it's strange that the originators of the tweet don't get notified or see their tweet after moderation - so I'm likely wrong. [0]:http://time.com/4731403/twitter-donald-trump-alt-uscis-lawsuit/ http://time.com/4731403/twitter-donald-trump-alt-uscis-lawsu...
- juliangoldsmith 10y agoI'm not sure I'd take Twitter's refusal to unmask an anti-Trump account as purely upholding privacy. I'd consider Twitter to be pretty anti-Trump, so politics likely play a part there.
- arca_vorago 10y agoThe real outrage in the airline industry is the fact that we allowed security theatre in the form of TSA to get so damn powerful in the first place. There is no reason to be allowing naked x-ray vision scans, pat downs that border on or actually are assault, etc. As Bruce Schneier said, the one thing they did right after 9/11 was to make the cock-pit doors reinforced and locked from the inside. Do you think rich people on their own jets get TSA patdowns the same way? No. What we are creating is a state of freedom for the rich, and compliant abuse for the majority of the citizens. Since the new TSA regulations, I have only flown twice, for these very reasons. The first time I was so outraged at the scanners I was going to protest, but they just sent me through an old school metal detector and I was on my way. The second time, I only got the scanner leaving London, and being in a different country I knew I didn't have the same rights of protest as in the US. I once called in to NPR while in D.C. when they had a TSA guy on the air. I asked if it wasn't an obvious conflict of interest for the guy at TSA who approved the scanner purchase to immediately go to work for that scanner company, and referenced the above Bruce Schneier quote. I got some deft wiggling out of an answer and my number was blocked the next time I tried to call into an NPR show. (not calling too much, had called in maybe 4 times in the past six months) It's like someone somewhere said, "the terrorists can't take our freedoms if we take them away first!" (Of course, the real terrorists are the bankers and financiers) We need to rethink the patriot act, the TSA, homeland security, NDAA, AUMF, and every other peice of legislation the corrupt and/or blackmailed congress allowed to pass (in violation of their oaths) in the clamor post 9/11.
- ManlyBread 10y agoWhy is everyone so outraged about this, I mean twitter is a private company...
- CaptSpify 10y agoSure, private companies can do what they want with their own platform, blah blah blah. But there's no law against being outraged at a private company. Just because something is legal doesn't mean I forfeit all rights to be mad about it.
- ManlyBread 10y agoMy previous comment was supposed to be sarcastic, guess I failed.
- CaptSpify 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe's_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe's_law strikes again
- danso 10y agoSurprised that people here are taking this at face value. Why would Twitter remove these tweets from random users while leaving the vast majority of negative tweets in place? No proof has been given. Indeed, this Jay Beecher's allegedly deleted tweet is visible as far as I can tell: https://mobile.twitter.com/dancow/status/851808188567388161 https://mobile.twitter.com/dancow/status/851808188567388161 edit: To be fair, Beecher says that my tweet refers to tweets he sent out after the original tweet was deleted. Indeed, his screenshot shows a different timestamp for the original tweet. Not knowing him at all, I have no reason to accuse him of deliberately making this up. But burden of evidence is still on him, and hard to accept claims of random Tweet deleting when, as I write, #NewUnitedAirlinesMottos is a top trend (as it has been all morning), and we have much more definitive evidence that Twitter manually shuts down controversial trending hashtags. On a sidenote, how is it possible for a user to have a screenshot of an old tweet unless they took it before it was deleted? Other than a caching issue, I thought all Twitter clients (especially the official one) removed tweets marked for deletion? http://stackoverflow.com/questions/5955021/detect-tweet-deletion-with-twitter-streaming-api http://stackoverflow.com/questions/5955021/detect-tweet-dele...
- maxerickson 10y agoSurprised that people here are taking this at face value. Really?
- danso 10y agoYes. Many people here have had IT experiences where laypersons swear their computer spontaneously did something ridiculous as if the computer was out to commit personal malice. And HN users generally are skeptical of the Internet media's ability to understand and write about technical concepts, especially when click bait is on the line. And there are more than a few users who understand how Twitter's massive data output would make such an alleged Tweet culling to be hilariously insignificant, given the investment of engineering time to execute such a pathetic conspiracy. Sure, there's a lot of hate for Twitter and for large companies in general. But this kind of claim, without actual evidence (nevermind motive), is a pretty Wilde one, even for HN. Guess it can't be flagged off the front page now without confirming fears of a massive coverup.
- TorKlingberg 10y agoI would like to see more proof before I believe anything. People on the internet (especially Reddit) love to invent conspiracies. Is it likely that both Twitter and Reddit admins are somehow in cahoots with United Airlines?
- artursapek 10y ago> Do you think rich people on their own jets get TSA patdowns the same way? No. What we are creating is a state of freedom for the rich, and compliant abuse for the majority of the citizens. Rich people aren't going to hijack their own jet and kill themselves in the name of Allah.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cmiles74 10y agoPretty much no one is. You're talking about something astronomically rare.
- artursapek 10y agoIt's rare because it's hard. Look at Europe and see how easy it is to do it with a truck.
- cmiles74 10y agoIt's really hard to get a truck on a passenger airplane, I agree.
- artursapek 10y agoThis response is the online equivalent of plugging your ears and saying "LA LA LA I can't hear you!"
- jostmey 10y agoNeither am I going to commit a terrorist act. What is your point? That it is okay for the rich get to live under a different set of rules?
- artursapek 10y agoYeah, if someone owns their own jet they should fly under their own rules. You can fly a Cessna without going through the TSA too, so it's not exclusive to rich people.
- hdhsbshs 10y agoThis is true. I just checked mine from last night and it's gone. I have posted a new one. Let's see if it stays.
- jacquesm 10y agoWithout a link to your new tweet this coming from an account that was made just to post this comment does not carry a lot of weight.
- nl 10y agoA link to your account would be useful. Previously "deleted" posts seem to be reappearing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14089243 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14089243
- diegorbaquero 10y agoMy tweet got "re-accommodated" , just confirmed. What's going on???
- mizzao 10y agoIf this is Twitter's new "PR management" service, I guess they're in for a whole new level of Streisand effect.
- sagebird 10y agoIf overbooking ever happens, here is what they should do: Ask a representative of each atomic passenger group to write down a number of dollars on a napkin, and the number of tickets they represent. An individual flying alone might write down $1000-1. A mother of 2 kids might write down $2500-3. Collect the bids, and sort them. Then if you need to swap 4 seats, select the four lowest bids, and give them cash. Overbooking probably makes sense in general - it should lower costs for everyone in theory. If they used this bid system that I proposed, they would be less afraid of overbooking, and do more of it - until an equilibrium of opportunity lost to empty seats equals the expected payout to napkin bidders. Even if there is no economic benefit to this system, the voluntary aspect will save some heartache.
- Pigo 10y agoThis system they have in place is the reason you can find flights for extremely low fares that were once unheard of. Obviously this could have been handled better, but I think people should bear in mind that these inconveniences are the very reason they're saving so much money. This is a rough instance of it, but if you buy a first class ticket you can bet this won't be happening to you. All that said, everyone has the right to show disapproval and take their money elsewhere.
- verulito 10y agoI think there's a few tragedies here that people seem to be missing. 1. A man not clearly identified as a man of authority was empowered to physically remove a passenger from an airplane. I've seen 3 videos so far and while it's not obvious that the passenger questioned his authority, he should have. Given how things unfolded, I wouldn't be surprised to hear next that the man who removed the passenger was actually a nearby manager who was not trained or experienced in removing passengers from airplanes. 2. I think people are actually repulsed by the revocation of permission to fly. Compliance of a passenger denied boarding simply implies that the passenger continues to be in his present location. Here compliance required the passenger to perform work on behalf of the airline. While it's a pretty minor amount of work, I think people are more accustomed to restrictions of their actions. They are understandably more sensitive to giving control to others over what actions they must perform, particularly since it was unexpected in this scenario and the man in question had no frame of reference for determining if his actions were reasonable or not. 3. The execution by the "office" in question was abysmal at best. He showed no patience or sensitivity and the doctor showed no sign of aggression. The force used to remove the man was unquestionably extreme. Someone like that probably would have responded very well to a uniformed police officer. The other two men had uniforms but they didn't look that official and they weren't the ones removing the man. Simply bringing out your handcuffs is likely enough to get compliance. The "officer" should be fired here for performing poorly.
- pmarreck 10y ago1) Tweets should be immutable (since they are in essence immutable anyway as soon as a single Internet copy is made) 2) The evidence here is slim
- nl 10y agoThere's an update on the page: Update 2, April 11, 11:15ET: Some readers have suggested that the allegedly deleted tweets might have initially appeared as replies to now-deleted tweets, which would explain why they are missing. However, numerous users contacted by TNW rejected this premise, claiming the missing posts were standard tweets. I'm betting it is something like this, or a related "Twitter did some weird UI change which no one understands again". If it's not, then it's going to be a bug, and Twitter will apologize and attempt to restore the tweets. Deleting these tweets isn't in Twitter's interest, no matter how much United pays for ads. Edit: looking into this a bit more, it looks like it only affects Tweets which have @united mentioned. I suspect it's triggering Twitter's anti-Troll flooding measures, which is clearly wrong. It'll be interesting to see how Twitter responds, given how slowly they ship any changes.
- notahacker 10y agoPretty obvious this is either an algorithmic response to flooding or an algorithmic response to United mass-reporting tweets that @mention them in response to this... If Twitter wanted to actively work with United on damage limitation they'd start by not running Twitter moments about the event for the whole day and suppressing the circulation of the video, not deleting a percentage of sarcastic @mentions the following day. And probably delete that United CEO response too...
- nl 10y agoReplying to myself. A number of the accounts listed by thenextweb do have Tweets to @united visible (now?) prior to them complaining about Tweets being deleted. Eg: complaining about Tweet being deleted: https://twitter.com/iknowimbitter/status/851640007500718081 https://twitter.com/iknowimbitter/status/851640007500718081 Original(?) tweet, 7 hours prior: https://twitter.com/iknowimbitter/status/851544321564323841 https://twitter.com/iknowimbitter/status/851544321564323841 Complaint: https://twitter.com/TalkIBC/status/851604796113129476 https://twitter.com/TalkIBC/status/851604796113129476 Original, 1 hour prior: https://twitter.com/TalkIBC/status/851581587967934464 https://twitter.com/TalkIBC/status/851581587967934464 Complaint: https://twitter.com/MickFerry/status/851564908915437568 https://twitter.com/MickFerry/status/851564908915437568 Original, 6 hours prior: https://twitter.com/MickFerry/status/851474942789079040 https://twitter.com/MickFerry/status/851474942789079040 I tend to think my theory about spam/troll filtering might be close to correct, but I look forward to finding out exactly what happened.
- daveloyall 10y agoI'm with fennecfoxen and matt4077 on this one: it's a bug in a spam filter. Or maybe a hate speech or terrorism filter. Does Twitter have those? Meanwhile, it's a good time for Mastodon (and secure scuttlebutt).
- Zorlag 10y agoWho were these employers of United that have been more important than a customer at that cost? Maybe Trump chartered out Air America to United Airlines in order to save money and those employers really were CIA Agents?
- pklausler 10y agoTwitter's not deleting the tweets, they're just "reaccommodating" them.
- iambateman 10y agoIf there was a large-scale quiet-down campaign in force at Twitter, it would almost certainly be a shadow ban. Offending tweets would still be visible to everyone, they would just simply not show up in feeds. Considering Twitter Moments ran a wildly negative story for the whole day yesterday about this, I think we can safely rule out collusion. Someone else mentioned an army of flaggers marking these tweets as offensive and automatically get pulled, which makes more sense to me.
- oblib 10y agoFacebook deleted my post with a link to the post the man's wife made that had a video of it, also deleted were the comments I and my friends made about it. I posted the video again from YouTube as soon as I found out.
- deletia 10y agoInteresting sidenote: Last Thursday, after Trump illegally bombed Syria, #HandsOffSyria was becoming reasonably popular on Twitter. I remember making a few offhand tweets with the hashtag and the app on my phone suggesting it. Last Saturday, I happened to be photographing the #HandsOffSyria protest which was going on in Toronto. I made a tweet about it and noticed that, oddly enough, the Twitter app was no longer suggesting the tag. Seems to be working again now fwiw ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Perhaps the (presumed human) moderators at hasty (or unpopular) decision makers?